Talimon- If my sarcastometer is right in this matter, than jallan may not actually think that movie-Aragorn is perfect.
Let's take a look at Elrond's quote, "He chose exile long ago."
If that is the case, then we can safely conclude that Aragorn's decision to so vehemently reject the kingship is simply because he doesn't want it, not because he's afraid of Isildur's weakness in him. To me, this whole "weakness" thing is a secondary reason once the ring pops up.
And Aragorn's whole "dumping" of Arwen is also a confusion. Why? Because it is made quite plain in both mediums that Aragorn CANNOT claim Arwen unless he is king.
My quotation from Appendix A relates to events after the disappearance and presumed death of Eärnur, and therefore disproves your contention that no-one pressed a claim after Eärnur's death. There were some who did, but none of the claim garnered sufficient support from all parties.Is there a pertinent difference between these two that I am missing?
If Tolkien had included a description of the Northerners trying to claim the throne and failing, then I'd be completely satisfied. It is with those who never tried that I have a problem.
The Appendices were published in the first edition of The Lord of the Rings. Even without the Appendices, the main narrative gives a reasonable account of the decline and disappearance of Arnor and the continued existance of the Dúnedain of the North under chieftains descended from Isildur, Aragorn being the current chieftain.In fact, there weren't any histories around when LotR was published in the first place. As such, how can we blame PJ for details that even Tolkien himself did not cover?
Stupid worthless sarcastometer.Originally posted by jallan
Yes, Jackson makes Aragorn more perfect.
I'd say this is intentionally so. I've been guessing all along that we'll get the Aragorn backstory in RotK. Elrond's "He chose exile" and Boromir's "This is Isildur's heir" are far too leading of comments not to have further explanation, IMO. I think that when Aragorn does finally decide to take the throne, we'll become privy to whatever other demons have been holding him back. Of course, I could be wrong, but it does seem to be Jackson's style of story-telling. In FotR we never understood Aragorn's glance to Arwen when the Fellowship left Rivendell- now (after TT) we have a little more insight.Originally posted by jallan
So far Jackson has given no answer.
I don't think this disproves my contention- I acknowledged that claims were made by those who didn't have either the full support of the people or who weren't of pure blood. However, nothing in Tolkien's description makes me think that he's referring to Aranath and the Northern Line. Again:Originally posted by jallan
My quotation from Appendix A relates to events after the disappearance and presumed death of Eärnur, and therefore disproves your contention that no-one pressed a claim after Eärnur's death. There were some who did, but none of the claim garnered sufficient support from all parties.
Tolkien gives no details about these claims, whether Aranarth was or was not one of those who made a claim at that time, or whether or not the previous claim of the northern line by Arvedui came up on occasion in the debates.
Tolkien describes heirs who either flee to Umbar or who have married non-Numenoreans. Both of these seem to imply that he is talking about the Southern line, since, as far as I know, neither of these were practices in the North.from Appendix A
Now the descendants of the kings had become few. Their numbers had been greatly diminished in the Kin-strife; whereas since that time the kings had become jealous and watchful of those near akin. Often those on whom suspicion fell had fled to Umbar and there joined the rebels; while others had renounced their lineage and taken wives not of Númenorean blood. So it was that no claimant to the crown could be found who was of pure blood, or whose claim all would allow; and all feared the memory of the Kin-strife, knowing that if any such dissension arose again, then Gondor would perish.
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
[Jackson wanted to make his Aragorn far more "female driven" than Tolkien's character. He wanted the man's strength to originate not from his own personality, training and heritage, but from Arwen who seemed to be constantly cajoling and canoodling him along that he wasn't bad old Isildur at all, but sweet, wonderful Aragorn. I'm sorry. As a woman of a different era, I don't feel it necessary to build up my sex by knocking down the fellas. I much prefer a man who is a man and not some fellow who needs his "better half" to encourage him and boost his spirits so he can get on with his life. I realize that this is simply my preference, but there it is! [/B]
I don't see this as being too much of a problem, as we've already been given tastes of "Elf magic" capable of communicating over distances. The way I see it, we have two options:Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
Narsil will certainly be the indication that Aragorn has changed his mind and decided to go for the gold. However, what I am interested in learning is how Jackson is going to bring the news "back to Rivendell" so that the sword can be re-forged. Remember, this isn't just a matter of picking the thing up and transporting it somewhere. First it has to be re-forged and what reason would Elrond have to do that if he still believes that Aragorn remains in his "self imposed exile". On the other hand, how is Jackson going to reveal Aragorn's change of heart and mind without blowing the tension?
I respect that you have a different opinion on this, but is book Aragorn really that independent? I have the utmost respect for the guy, but even in the book he acknowledges that others had a great (if not the greater) part in him becoming King, which is why he has Frodo bring him the crown and Gandalf place it on his head. I think that movie-Aragorn can also stand on his own two feet, but expecting him to accomplish everything that needs to be accomplished in order for him to be king without any outside help is a bit much. Personally, whether Arwen is weavinng a banner to help him become King, or simply encouraging him during one of his dark moments, the difference just ain't that big. Remember, there is the quote from the books:Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
Jackson wanted to make his Aragorn far more "female driven" than Tolkien's character. He wanted the man's strength to originate not from his own personality, training and heritage, but from Arwen who seemed to be constantly cajoling and canoodling him along that he wasn't bad old Isildur at all, but sweet, wonderful Aragorn. I'm sorry. As a woman of a different era, I don't feel it necessary to build up my sex by knocking down the fellas. I much prefer a man who is a man and not some fellow who needs his "better half" to encourage him and boost his spirits so he can get on with his life. I realize that this is simply my preference, but there it is!
Is this pep-talk substantially different than in the movie where Arwen says "You will face the same evil, and defeat it"?from Appendix A, the Tale of Aragorn and Arwen
'And Arwen said: "Dark is the Shadow, and yet my heart rejoices; for you, Estel, shall be among the great whose valour will destroy it."
' But Aragorn answered: "Alas! I cannot foresee it, and how lit may come to pass is hidden from me. Yet with your hope I will hope. And the Shadow I utterly reject."
Originally posted by aragil
I don't see this as being too much of a problem, as we've already been given tastes of "Elf magic" capable of communicating over distances. The way I see it, we have two options:
1) Elrond- Elrond either learns of Aragorn's decision (ala the Galadriel-Elrond conversation re. Faramir), or intuits it. The second could certainly be the case, especially with that long look he gave the Isildur-Sauron painting in TT.
2) Arwen- I think Arwen has more credibility for intuiting Aragorn's intentions. First of all, we have the scene where she is 'present' for Aragorn's 'reviving' in TT. Also, we have scenes from some of the trailers which weren't in the movie, scenes of Arwen running to the Narsil shrine. Perhaps she is going to retrieve the sword and bring it to Aragorn? After all, in the books she seemed to intuit Aragorn's need for the banner, and there is no evidence that her weaving of the banner was initiated by anyone other than her own self.
With either of the above, the re-forging can be accomplished without a messenger running to Rivendell. Some may call this use of Elf Magic cheating, but even the good professor was guilty of such plot devices, so I think we needn't boggle too much. Then again, perhaps MM's scenario will play out- I must admit I really have no idea.
I respect that you have a different opinion on this, but is book Aragorn really that independent? I have the utmost respect for the guy, but even in the book he acknowledges that others had a great (if not the greater) part in him becoming King, which is why he has Frodo bring him the crown and Gandalf place it on his head. I think that movie-Aragorn can also stand on his own two feet, but expecting him to accomplish everything that needs to be accomplished in order for him to be king without any outside help is a bit much. Personally, whether Arwen is weavinng a banner to help him become King, or simply encouraging him during one of his dark moments, the difference just ain't that big. Remember, there is the quote from the books: Is this pep-talk substantially different than in the movie where Arwen says "You will face the same evil, and defeat it"?
Movie-Aragorn will come to Minas Tirith for altruistic reasons undefiled by any political desire whatsover, but of course, everyone, as in the book, will just insist he must remain and rule them, and since they all want it so badly, and he is the rightful heir after all, movie-Aragorn will humbly agree.
Movie-Aragorn will never hold the Ring, will never possess it, never be in a position himself to cast it away.
He will never be seriously tempted to take it either, though he obviously has many opportunites. Movie-Aragorn will instead face probable death alone against fifty Orcs to allow the chosen Ring-bearer to escape.
Even without the Appendices, the main narrative gives a reasonable account of the decline and disappearance of Arnor and the continued existance of the Dúnedain of the North under chieftains descended from Isildur, Aragorn being the current chieftain.
If movie-Aragorn is the rightful king of Gondor but another now rules the land, the question of why this is so obviously arises.
So far Jackson has given no answer.
I think it has been shown that the book Aragorn was in fact conflicted. He could not marry his beloved without being king of both kingdoms, but he could not do that while Sauron remained the most powerful force in Middle-earth. In fact, it appeared to be all over for the Ranger until the Ring appeared. Only then was there any hope (slim to none) of the Dark Lord being ultimately defeated and his chance come to get both the throne and the lady.
I don't see why reforging the sword and giving it to Aragorn should have anything whatever to do with him deciding to accept or reject kingship, a kingship, which, as in the book, will be almost forced upon him.
Of course he will accept the throne, as in the book, when everyone pushes it at him. My point is that book-Aragorn, in the end, doesn't seek for the kingship because he is practially acclaimed by everyone he meets. Jackson has realized that the seeking was a motif that could be eliminated. So Jackson substitutes a contrasting counter-motif of someone who does not seek power at all. It won't matter in the end.I'm suspecting that by the time Aragorn reaches Minas Tirith he will fully acknowledge that he is the rightful king. He will be wielding Narsil, and will be prepared to accept the throne.
What different character? Have his beliefs changed, his manner of speech, his ability to fight, his devotion to duty, his motives, his understanding? I see nothing changed about him.Indeed, if you look at Aragorn at the end of TTT he is a very different charachter from Aragorn in the beginning of FotR.
Yes, and I said so.I believe the whole point of that scene at Amon Hen was to show how Aragorn was tempted there for a moment. If you listen closely you can hear the ring whispering, "Aragorn...Aragorn..." That whole scene was meant to fulfill Arwens prophecy that Aragorn will "face the same evil, and you will defeat it." That evil is the temptation of power. He faced that temptation.
Tolkien has Gandalf tell the story of Isildur and the One Ring very briefly to Frodo, Elrond repeats it briefly at the Council, and Gandalf tells of Isildur's experience with the One Ring more fully at the same Council. We are told again and again that Aragorn is Isildur's Heir.We hear just a little of Isildur at the Council of Elrond, but just exactly who he is is never made perfectly clear. I credit PJ for making it perfectly clear who Isildur is, and how Aragorn is his descendant.
The information is in the chapter "The Council of Elrond", where one should expect to find it. Read particularly Elrond's description of the Last Alliance, Boromir's summary of the history of Gondor, Aragorn's speech about the part played by the Dúnedain of the North, and Gandalf's account of Isildur and the Ring.
Fair enough. A reader can easily miss some of this, as you apparently did. But the details are indeed explained clearly in the main story as one would expect them to be in any story about a lost heir or exiled heir. They are also more completely spelled out in Appendix A.One of the most common questions by new readers involve Aragorn, and why he is the rightful king.
Possibly also true of movie-Aragorn. Movie-Aragorn has already won Gandalf's high respect and Arwen's love.We meet him at the peak of his character arc.
Originally posted by jallan
Mrs. Maggott posted:I don't see why reforging the sword and giving it to Aragorn should have anything whatever to do with him deciding to accept or reject kingship...In the book it seems it is reforged because of the dream told to the Council by book-Boromir combined with an ancient prophecy, not because of any decision by book-Aragorn to seek the kingship. Book-Aragorn has long been ready to seek it, and the dream only gives him his chance to do so. Here the dream is the link between the two.....Rather oddly, the broken sword in the book is almost a blind motif.
No. It was reforged particularly because of the dream, indicating the time had come for the reforging.It was reforged for book Aragorn to finally claim his throne.
The sword may be a symbol of resistance to Sauron, and of resistance to evil and oppression in general. But how is this sword a symbol of kingship?
I've heard this before.No, the sword is definitely a sign of Kingship ....
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?