• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Best 🧌Orc Pentathlete

Choose the best Orc Pentathlete

  • Gorbag

    Votes: 6 7.2%
  • Grishnakh

    Votes: 27 32.5%
  • Shagrat

    Votes: 15 18.1%
  • Ugluk

    Votes: 35 42.2%

  • Total voters
    83
Instead of a Left! Right! Left! Right! marching cadence, it would have been Skewer! Shriek! Skewer! Shriek! :)
 
Maybe Grishnakh's strategy of avoiding the enemy would have worked better than Ugluk's "strategy" of attacking their swords with his neck. Crook-legs are excellent for stealth btw.
 
I'm afraid that Grishnakh's strategy of avoision was all too often compromised by his habit of skewering himself on horse-boy spears. And shrieking.
 
Grishnakh had to make the best of a SNAFU-ed situation, compliments of Ugluk-the-Size-1-Brain-in-a-Size-9-Skull. At least Grishnakh was trying to escape. His shriek was a badge of honor compared with the dull thud as Ugluk's head was lopped off.

Now if only Grishnakh had the backup earlier that he deserved. No pointless march across Rohan, no unmarked bonfire for the lads. Instead feasting and fun at Lugburz whilst the Prisoners beg to tell all they know and more.
 
Ah, the big 'if'

The problem here is that Grishnakh had every opportunity to get the Hobbits to Mordor. If he had been able to face up to Ugluk in the first place, then the whole troop would have been off Eastwards to Mordor. But when push came to shove, Grishnakh ran away from confrontation and had to ask the Nazgul for help. Ugluk was his own Orcs.
1) Grishnakh cheated in the Death March, Ugluk took the longer route and still was traveling faster when Grishnakh ran across them.
2) Ugluk made Threats and followed them up with lopping off heads. Grishnakh made Threats and then ran for it.
3) Ugluk was not a brilliant Insulter, but he was proficient with statements about the 'mountain maggots', 'filthy horse-boys', and the 'apes of Lugburz'. Grishnakh was so often bested physically that he had much more practice at spinning off insults. Yet it seems to me that for all his practice, Grishnakh did not come up with anything brilliant either.
4) Ugluk is a run-away victor in the Brute Strength category, lopping off heads of mounted horse-boys and Orcs alike. Grishnakh apparently tried to use his 'terrifying strength' to wrench a spear out of a horse-boy's hand after having been skewered with it.
5) Low Cunning was never Ugluk's greatest asset, yet he does very well in leadership and tactical decision-making. He is able to hold a heterogenous mixture of Orcs together with a minimum of bloodshed, a feat which is beyond all the scheming of Grishnakh. He is also able to make the best of a bad situation- holding a small band together during the morning route and nearly fighting his way out of the Rohirrim. After all, he was only being stopped by the personal heroism of the King of Rohan. In comparison Grishnakh's plan is undone by his own action- foolishly drawing his sword in the presence of a horseman. Finally, I notice that the Hobbits were not quite able to play with Ugluk's head, like they were with Grishnakh. When dealing with the halflings Ugluk seemed cool and collected, Grishnakh seemed to be trembling.
Clearly Ugluk is the leader in categories 1, 2, and 4. In categories 3 and 5 Ugluk is competitive. The Pentathlon considers all 5 categories equally, so I must say that Ugluk appears to be the best pentorclete.
 
Re: Ah, the big 'if'

Originally posted by aragil

1) Grishnakh cheated in the Death March, Ugluk took the longer route

Can there be any clearer endorsement of Grishnakh! He cheated! Bonus points!

2) Ugluk made Threats and followed them up with lopping off heads. Grishnakh made Threats and then ran for it.

Threats are easy to make when backed up by a troop of lads. Grishnakh made threats a capella . A win.

3) Ugluk was not a brilliant Insulter,

Ugluk would have to pool the entire brain power of his Isengard trash, and still couldnt match Grishnakh's "Swollen Head" jibe. Clear win!

4) Ugluk is a run-away victor in the Brute Strength category, lopping off heads of mounted horse-boys and Orcs alike.

Grishnakh concedes that for brute strength without reason, Ugluk is your Orc. Even stronger than Ugluk and equally intelligent would be a falling rock.

5) Low Cunning was never Ugluk's greatest asset,

Hmmmm...no argument here.

Grishnakh was both a doer and a thinker, low cunning, his specialty. Meetings with the Nazgul and Sauron would find a sober and reflective Grishnakh in a business suit with a briefcase full of position papers. Then, after spitballing with the bosses, he would change back into his Red Eye duds, go back into the field and mix it up with the Lads. An Orc-for-all-Reasons, your Pentathlete Champion, Grishnakh.
 
Re: Re: Ah, the big 'if'

Originally posted by Harad
Grishnakh was both a doer and a thinker, low cunning, his specialty. Meetings with the Nazgul and Sauron would find a sober and reflective Grishnakh in a business suit with a briefcase full of position papers.

Strange that Grishnakh could deal so calmly with the Nazgul, and then be so put out by simple Hobbits. I think that if the Hobbits could play with Grishnakh's head, then the Nazgul were really wacking him out. This is reinforced by how he seems to remember meetings with the Nazgul as painful. I think that the likely scenario is that Grishnakh was wetting his orc-mail while speaking to the Nazgul, and then getting some sort of sick thrill out of the encounter. As so often happens in campaigning, Grishnakh is not turning out to be the way you've portrayed him. He's terrified by the Nazgul, and is likely looking to get the ring for himself in preparation for payback (not looking to get the ring for Sauron to further the cause of evil). The ME-ORC folk don't look kindly on this sort of behavior, nor do I think that they'll give bonus-points to cheaters.
Ugluk, in contrast, really is just as cool and collect as I have always maintained. He gently reprimands wayward Orcs with the sharp end of his sword, much as a wise father will reproach a child who has misbehaved. He is level-headed in the heat of battle, and his leadership is an inspiration to the Uruk-hai who serve him. He has 'cunningly' arranged for Mauhar to meet with the Rohirrim, unfortunately the moment is ruined by Grishnakh. Yes, there is more than one way to exhibit cunning. There is the scheming of Grishnakh the Kinky, and then there is the noble cunning and tactical intelligence of Ugluk the Magnificent, second on our current ballot, but forever first in our hearts.
 
Last edited:
Nazgul, Nazgul, - said Grishnákh, shivering and licking his lips, as if the word had a foul taste that he savoured painfully. - You speak of what is deep beyond the reach of your muddy dreams, Uglúk, - he said. - Nazgul! Ah! All that they make out! One day you'll wish that you had not said that. Ape! - he snarled fiercely. - You ought to know that theyre the apple of the Great Eye. But the winged Nazgul: not yet,not yet. He won't let them show themselves across the Great River yet, not too soon. Theyre for the War-and other purposes.

Grishnakh knows Evil. Grishnakh knows pain. Grishnakh savors foul tastes. On the other side:

I Grishnákh say this: Saruman is a fool. and a dirty treacherous fool. But the Great Eye is on him.

Trouble speaking with Halflings? Here's trouble:

My dear tender little fools, - hissed Grishnákh, - everything you have, and everything you know, will be got out of you in due time: everything! You'll wish there was more that you could tell to satisfy the Questioner, indeed you will: quite soon. We shan't hurry the enquiry.
 
Ahh, excellent. I see that with that last vote for Shagrat team Shagrat and Ugluk have at last cought back up to the total of that crook-legged shrieker Grishnakh. Death Marching and Brutishness over Cunning, that is what made Orcs great!
 
Hate to jump into this political debate (but as usual I will), but I agree with Harad, re: Shagrat would not team up with Ugluk. Shagrat is like Grish, anorcoftheeye.

Let me introduce myself, the campaign manager for Shagrat. Shagrat is running on the dungybrown party ticket, and expects to force the Grishnak party to make concessions in order to win one for Mordor. Without the great Shagrat, limp-armed champion, who more so than Grish or Ugluk, fought in a dirty way, so dirty and filthy, only Sam could provide us our campaign slogan "Curse the filth!", without him, hairy armed Grish with the yellow teeth can't win!

With a simple knife wetted by Shag's spit, and a horrible squeeze move that made Radbug look like a bad child's playdoe experiment, Shagrat hopes to come from behind, or force the ticket of Grish to give in to its demands. You'll vote for Shagrat or you'll have a belly full of maggot-holes!

Only Shagrat, captain of the Orcs of the tower, true to the Eye! ran straight to Barad-dur and delivered the goods just like the orders. If Sam hadn't been in the tower, and Gorbag hadn't been the filthy rebel he was, Frodo would have been a nice package for Lugburz too. He finished off Gorbag with a stomp and trample that rivaled Bombadil.

Vote for Shagrat if it ain't too late!
 
Shagrat of course being an Orc of Mordor is more deserving than that rebel scum Ugluk. And in the Grishnakh regime, Shagrat will be given nudgenudgewinkwink flesh.

But even shirley knows that Shagrat was inferior to Grishnakh. Shagrat was left guarding an empty tower while Grishnakh was out in the fields serving his Eye and country. Shagrat could not even handle one Halfing, while Grishnakh had one in each paw.

Give Shagrat his due. Give Ugluk your scorn.

But for Pentathlete Champion, Give Grishnakh your vote!
 
Slowly but slowly the gap closes, as Grishnakh's campaign promises of 'The Lowliest Cunning' and 'nudgenudgewinkwink flesh for all' turn out to be so much empty shrieking in the ears of the voters. The electorate can feel the need for another candidate. A candidate who will lead them in a Death March across the open fields of Rohan in the bright light of the sun; who will Threaten them with the prospect of a head removed from shoulders; who will Insultingly call them the maggots and apes of Lugburz yet still show them that he cares; who will Brutishly display his strength on the uncommited voters; and finally a candidate cunning enough to not let Hobbits play with his mind. Truly, the voters desire a Magnificent candidate.

Take heart, for there is one Orc who fits the bill: The Condottiere of Nan Curunir, the Meatpacker from the slopes of Methadras, the Hannibal of the Uruk-hai- Ugluk the Magnificent!
 
I've heard of the Endless Campaign. I've heard of protests. I've even heard of 5-4 Supreme Orc Decisions. But its time to prepare for the next Games. Is Ugluk going to add "Sore-Loser" to "Rebel-Scum" and "Swollen-Head"?

They felt the Orc's arms trembling violently. 'Curse you, you filthy little vermin!' he hissed. 'Untie your legs? I'll untie every string in your bodies. Do you think I can't search you to the bones? Search you! I'll cut you both to quivering shreds. I don't need the help of your legs to get you away-and have you all to myself!'
Suddenly he seized them. The strength in his long arms and shoulders was terrifying

The efficiency of Grishnakh is just stunning. This short passage highlights his insults, threats, and brute strength. Remarkable.
 
Why were Grishnakh's arms trembling. It appears that the Hobbits have gotten in to his head, and he lacks the cunning to get them back out.
And, I might ask, is Grishnakh going to add cries of 'foul' to his already long list of shrill shriekings?
Honestly people, you know Ugluk the Magnificent is superior. All I ask is for six more votes. If any of you have learned the error of your ways, I could always find out if the Webmaster will allow you to change your vote. Also, I'm looking in to what is to be done with the myriad dimpled chad votes which have not yet been posted. I think that the 'poster intent' of those voting for Gorbag was quite clearly to vote for Ugluk. I'll stretch this thing out until inauguration day, if I have to.
 
If Ugluk wishes to ally with Gorbag, then that is his right. I'd like to point out that as Shagrat was Gorbag's mortal enemy, that will just go to confirm Shagrat as Grishnakh's running mate (or should that be Death Marching mate?). Grishnakh's position is therefore unassailable.
 
The Magnificence for Office Alliance does not look to add Gorbag to the ticket! He is far to schemy and mutinous, like a certain long-armed crook-legged creature I know of. I was just reiterating the fact that the two lost souls who voted for Gorbag were mistaken, and probably had intended to vote for Ugluk. As I said before, some of these Web Browsers display the ballot in a confusing manner, so that the dot for Gorbag is very close to the name of Ugluk. If I'm any judge of cyber-voter intent (and I'm not), I'd say that the Gorbag voters were definitely trying to vote for Ugluk but were confused by the balloting system. Need I remind everybody that the ballot was put together in this confusing manner by a Scheming Grishnakh man?
Remember folks, the polls aren't closed yet. The later time zones in the West have always been Isengard-friendly, and Isengard needs your support now more than ever. Keep the Apes of Lugburz away from the Laurels! 6 more votes for Ugluk the magnificent!
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top