• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Did Ringwraiths Botch Murder in Bree?

Was the scene of Ringwraiths stabbing empty beds in Bree loyal to the book?

  • Yes, it went something like that.

    Votes: 12 60.0%
  • No, some thugs from town did it in the book

    Votes: 3 15.0%
  • I never really thought about it

    Votes: 3 15.0%
  • Book, what book?

    Votes: 2 10.0%

  • Total voters
    20
  • Poll closed .
In view to blindness, THEY ARE IN THE SHADOW WORLD and cannot see well in daylight. The Nazgul see as Frodo saw with the Ring on and through this would have been able to see at night.

I disagree with this. The Ringwraiths were unable to see Frodo until he put the Ring on. The Wraiths are in the Wraith world and cannot see well at anytime. In the daylight men cast shadows in their minds, and in the dark I do not think this is any different. The Wraiths are able to sense many signs and forms that are hidden from others in the dark, which is why they are to be most feared at night. They do not see the same as Frodo saw with the Ring on, for to Frodo's eyes nothing changed when he put the Ring on but the Nazgul.
 
And when Frodo puts the Ring on the Nazguls heads snap to him, focusing on him as they can see him. By da way Nenya when the Rider chases Frodo to the Brandywine his horse can most probobly see for him
 
Well, by that time Frodo is already on the edge of the Wraith world so the Wraiths don't need their horses to help them see him anymore. But yeah, the horses do help the Wraiths see things.
 
Re: It WASN'T the Ringwraiths!!!

But likewise, nowhere in the books does it say that it was Bill Ferny or anyone else either. Its just speculation. 99 out of a hundred people would assume that it was the Nazgul. They found their way all the way to Bree, they didnt need anyone else to do their killing for them and they would have wanted to close in on the ring as soon as they were able. I cant see them steppig back while Bill Ferny and his mates went in after the ring to murder a room full of Hobbits.

I'm happy with it being the Nazgul.
 
For the last **** years I've taken it for granted it was the wraiths who attacked the bolsters, but now it's quite clear it couldn't have been them. I can see Pale King's point of view, but the book does confirm the opposite view, however indirectly.
 
I was gonna quote someone from the first page but I forget who....
Anyways, I think that the Nazgul attacked the room because they might have thought Frodo hid the ring there......(I know thats wrong though, because they can sence the ring, at all times.)
But....if they can sence the ring at all times, and Sauron can sence it even more...then why couldnt Sauron sence it when Samwise put it on in his own land!?!?

Anyway, I think that the Nazgul would be able to dectect the ring if it was in Bree, even if Frodo was hiding somewhere, or whatever.
They could search hire people to search the town and get the ring from Frodo. Maybe even some of them could wait outside of the town for Frodo and co. to come out of the town and they could wait a little bit and ambush them a few miles outside of the town's watch.

Besides, even the heir of Elendil the Tall couldnt destroy a Ringwraith. And a few hobbits could do nothing at all.(At that time)

As for sight, they cant see, but they can feel everything....or thats what I think anyway. They can feel each other and they can feel the ring, at all times...but if they can feel the ring, as they are servents of it, why couldnt they sence it when they were 50 or less meters away from it?

And further more....accautly....I need to shut up.
 
Welcome to the forum, Anarion!

I'm still of the opinion that the Nazgul did not attack the room in Bree. Here's why:

From "The Fellowship of the Ring":



But....if they can sence the ring at all times, and Sauron can sence it even more...then why couldnt Sauron sence it when Samwise put it on in his own land!?!?
 
Oh....that clears things up a lot....
But....did the Ringwraiths tell Ferny or whoever that they are searching for this huge ring of power that is really really powerful???

And also, why did you say welcome to the forums?
Is it because you have never seen me here before?
 
Originally posted by Nenya Evenstar
I'm still of the opinion that the Nazgul did not attack the room in Bree.
I'm pretty sure it's a "fact" now that it wasn't them.
The film makes the idea particularly odd by the way the wraiths come storming into Bree one moment, and the next are stealthily making their way through the inn to the hobbits' room. Everything that happens in Bree is pretty confusing, and it's probably just as well that the scene shifts so abruptly to the five of them well on their way away from there!
 
Anarion:
But....did the Ringwraiths tell Ferny or whoever that they are searching for this huge ring of power that is really really powerful???
I don't think they would have told Ferny (or anyone else for that matter) what they were searching for. They could get a hold of people by fear and control those people by that fear. There was no need for them to mention the ring - just hobbits.

I welcomed you to the forum because you were registered in October, and it is still quite early in that month. Also, I haven't had the privilege of seeing you very often before.


joxy:
I'm pretty sure it's a "fact" now that it wasn't them.
I know, but there may still be people who don't agree with me, and I'd like to respect those people.
 
Just going slightly off topic for a minute, I was wondering how the hell could the hobbits and Aragorn fight the Ringwraiths at Amon Sul? Aren't people meant to have the whole dark shadow of despair and what have you desend on their arrival. Was it just because Sauron's power wasn't at his strongest so they weren't as potent as at Pellanor.
Sorry I'll stop rambling now
 

Oh, ok, LOL.
Well, I am welcomed, and although I have already been yelled at 4 times by different people it is quite a nice site.
Back on topic, I think that Ferny and co. DID ransack the place because the Ringwraiths were lazy.
 
Anarion, well, you are welcomed by me, and you won't ever catch me yelling at you. Glad you like the site.

Galadhwen, thanks for the post! I don't mind it that you drifted off topic at all. I've thought about your question and here's what I've come up with:

Some people were known to overcome their fear of the Wraiths as witnessed by Eowyn and Merry during the Battle of the Pellenor. Aragorn, I'm sure, would have had very little problem overcoming such a fear. After all, it was his will that led all those people through the Paths of the Dead. The hobbits were terrified of the Ringwraiths, but I'm sure that Aragorn would have been strong enough to overcome his fear.
 
Actually the southerner in Bree was in league with the Witch-king and the other Ring-wraiths, although not of his own choosing. This quote (which I had forgotten about) also explains how the wights came to be in the barrows... they were sent there by the Witch-king.
 
He is never called Angmar in any of the works that I know of. He is referred to as the Witch-king of Angmar or the Lord of the Ring-wraiths for the most part.
 
Thanks for the quote Grond! Wow! I didn't even know stuff like that existed. I must read that stuff soon or go insane!
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…