• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Durin VII - "The Decline of TTF" and Moria

Status
Not open for further replies.

There was a certain member here a few years ago by the alias of Cían (and I most certainly would like to put him on my list and even on the Durin VII list!) who I personally believe made Grond, Ancalagon and Harad look like third grade English students (and me look like I was in pre-school). He (or was it a she???) would post significantly less than even you L_o_G but (s)he would occasionally meander into one of my threads and post something so incredibly and perplexingly complex that (s)he was often ignored in the very next post. I was terrified of Cían (more than anyone else) as (s)he was a cool, calm, calculated and complex cat. I know exactly how it felt to be treated like I was being interviewed by the FBI... but I'll come back to this point later.

For good measure I have not read HoME either; just parts of it that I consider important. I haven't read The Books of Lost Tales, HoME III-IX and The War of the Jewels. I have only read minor parts of The Peoples of Middle-earth and about half of Morgoth's Ring. I've read The Silmarillion once and Unfinished Tales once. I promise you that.


Then I pray that you don't continue to think that L_o_G as I thought your contributions in LOTR as a Metaphor for Our Lives thread were excellent and conveyed not an academic understanding of acquired knowledge but the far more important literary understanding of the text through the eyes of the author himself (who is often forgotten in the process). I hope that I haven't made you feel over your head as I actually think the contrary. You've found somewhere where you're right on par.


Follow you completely L_o_G. I don't think I'll ever read HoME either!


The only reason I find them unwelcome is because they erode the quality of discussion available to those who may have a greater understanding of The Legendarium. You're all quite concerned how those new to The Tolkien Experience should be catered to without acknowledging those who are the ones remembered for making the forum what it was (and still is to a degree). These people should also be taken into consideration and should also be catered to (and I know Illuin's in the shadows waiting to jump in with The Annals of the Eldanyárë but face facts mate - there are 3 people active in there). I acknowledge these posts have their place and are actually necessary in the development of future loremasters - and this is where I'll bring Cían back into the discussion.


I think I'd have to be a little naïve to believe that TTF is going to be full of noob loremasters in the next few years. They will dilute the quality of discussion; that is inexorable. However, as aforementioned, I realize that it is a necessary evil. We need discussions such as those as they will eventually generate some wonderful new members. What upsets me (and this is why the quote above wasn't directed at Illuin but at all of you) is that you are waiting for the next generation to come so you can join in the dilution process when you should be (if you're serious about being here) attempting to gain a higher understanding not just of Tolkien - but of literary analysis in general. I personally believe in self-improvement in all aspects of life and Cían (unknowingly) forced me to do this. Instead of complaining that TTF was full of noob-hungry lore-wolves I sat down and progressively ensured that my posts were of higher quality. I too know what it's like to be post-burned - it sucks! But I'm not going to lie there sucking my thumb wishing I was someplace else. I'm going to fight back with more coherent, ordered and (quasi-relative, Illuin ) logical responses. I don't want everyone to be interested, I'll just settle for more than 3 or 4.

Now, it was stated that this thread was meant to reminisce about the great members who are now gone. And that's a wonderful idea! However, I think that you have to continue to accept the Forum as it is.

I already have. That's why I'm a member of forums and communities elsewhere. I accept (and still love) TTF for what it is. When you love something you want to see it transcend and become greater than itself in every way. There is nothing wrong about having such aspirations as I'm sure it was these concepts that put dapence infront of his computer one fateful night, and typed those three first words: The Tolkien Forum.


A Golden Age may come to an end; but there's no reason why another can't take its place...

I can see there may be some attempts to bring this thread to a premature end but I am not attempting to discredit TTF or its current members in anyway; I'm just a voice crying in the wilderness... We know that this next generation is coming and that it should bring back some golden oldies with it. So let's talk about who of those we wish to see return without sinking into the mediocre concepts of it is what it is - as such concepts are complaisance's ugly cousin. Accept the status quo but don't embrace it.

Cheers,

Úlairi.
 
"The Decline of TTF"

I'm a relatively new member so I cannot speak to whether or not this wonderful forum has "declined".

I must say that since I became a member - I have found it to be one of the most fascinating sites on the Internet that I have ever gone on or become involved with.

I love virtually all of the postings that I have read thus far and the fact that they have greatly increased my knowledge of Professor Tolkien's wonderful works. I only wish that I had the money right now to buy the H.O.M.E. and to buy a compilation of Professor Tolkien's letters so that I could read them and contribute more effectively.

I agree that once The Hobbit movies come out - there will be a great influx of new members. But for those who are still here - please DON'T leave - I can definitely say that as a newbie - I love this website and would greatly miss reading some of the fabulous postings of individuals like Illuin, Ulari, RangerStryder and many others (whose names escape me at the moment) if they departed...

(Ps. this website is far superior than theonering.com !!)
 
Out of the mouth of newbies...

Fantastic! Thank you for such a wonderful post Itnjmy! I think I can happily rest my case here. If a new member like Itnjmy isn't petrified by lore-wolves then I see no reason why others should be.

Cheers Itnjmy,

Úlairi.
 
It is not a matter of being petrified of the 'lore-wolves'. It is simply how one sees the purpose of The Tolkien Forum. Clearly, Ulairi, you are going to want the Forum to maintain a high level of academic integrity. And I have to say that TTF is one of the few web message boards I've been on where this has been possible. I also would not want suggest that people should post at a lower level than they want to.

However, we have to think about the medium of web message boards in general and what they represent. To me, it seems that most message boards are places for casual (not to say ignorant) discussions of topics that interest a certain group of people. Perhaps I am overlooking something, but when I first joined TTF, it seemed that this site was no different. In any case, I never found a mission statement claiming that the objective of the web-site was in-depth literary analysis.

I also would agree that all members should do their best to post meaningfully and intelligently. But, Ulairi, you claim that some of your posts took weeks to compose with the background knowledge you put into them, and then you complain that only two people will respond. Not to sound harsh, but most people don't have that kind of time. People don't come onto web forums to produce highly-polished academic works; they come on to cultivate ideas by tossing them back and forth.

I know what it is like to feel like you put a lot of work into something and to come up shorthanded when nobody responds. So I looked at one of the threads you started (one of the ones with the Elvish titles), and there were a lot of ideas in it, so many that you had to put your questions in two separate posts. Responding to a thread like that requires more than wit and background knowledge; it requires time and patience.

I don't want to insult your intentions, Ulairi, because you seem like an incredibly smart person, but it seems like you expect an awful lot of the members of TTF, considering it is a web forum. I'm not saying that gives people permission to make completely inane and stupid posts. But it is important to understand the media you are working with, and a web forum is, in most cases, a place for the casual exchange of ideas.
 
I think it is important that younger and less-experienced or widely-read (in Tolkien material, at any rate) members of the forum are comfortable participating. By that I mean that an eighth-grader who’s just finished reading The Hobbit and then The Lord of the Rings should not be dismayed at the prospect of asking a question or putting forth an opinion, and so fail to post. Nor should an older poster who has loved Tolkien for many decades but never had the time to read History of Middle-earth believe that he has nothing to contribute, or that the more vigorous members of the forum will tear him into tiny little shreds just for fun, or because they disagree with the opinions he presents.

None of us enjoys being ripped to shreds in an internet forum. (Well, almost none of us: I’ve run across some folks who seem to seek it out, but that’s another matter…)

The contrapositive of a true statement is also true. The Golden Rule is, “As you want others to deal with you, you deal with them.” Alfred the Great made the contrapositive of the Golden Rule the foundation of English Common Law, and it remains the foundation of our legal system to this day, which is what makes English Common Law (and its sometimes wayward child, American common law) unique among legal systems and beloved by its people, despite the many failings of humans in jurisprudence: “What you don’t want done to you, don’t do to others.”
 
I cannot speak for others than myself, but my personal reasons for not participating as much as I used to are multiple and intertwined. And they all come down to the hardships of that horrible thing called "real life."
I do have time to drop by here every now and then, but I do not have the time to study JRR Tolkien's works as I once did.
And so perhaps the suggestion from Lady_of_Gondor a bit further up in this thread is rather on the spot: I really don't have anymore to contribute at the moment.

I do however have a suggestion for Durin VII: jallan
 
MEMBERS WHOSE CURRENT WHEREABOUTS ARE UNKNOWN​

Alcuin
YayGollum
Firawyn​

Checking in! Been busy in grown-up-land. Was also re-reading LotR again, so my Tolkien "fix" was thus taken care of. Missed you guys!


Úlairi, we are not fish. We are people. That makes us equals to engage yourself with, not underlings to catch and turn to what you desire.

However, I'm happy to know that I was among those you did not mark as lost causes.
 
Although I'm sure I've not been missed at all I realise that what this forum really needs is about three of four Tolkien newcomers to come along and ask a shed load of questions. All this stuff about TTF veterans is a load of rubbish... get over yourselves.

The greatest Tolkien question that will ever be asked is something along the lines of: Why are trolls purses the mischief?
 
Last edited:

It looks as though someone's nursing a little inferiority complex there...


Perhaps you should get over yourself too, Turgon. The TTF "vets" are the ones that keep this board active and alive without whimpering whiners like you...

Cheers,

Úlairi.
 
Turgon, Úlairi, both of you can just cut it out. Last I checked the two of you were mature young men. Stop acting like five year olds.

Both of you, along with all the TTF veterans and the newbes, and everyone else in between are valuable members to TTF.

This is not a contest.

This is not about who knows more about Tolkien and his works.

This is about a group of people from all over the world who love Tolkien and want to learn more about him and his works.

Group.


As in team effort.

Have I made my point clear?
 




Post number 666. I couldn't resist .


It’s Mr. Barlow from Salem’s Lot (1979 - Stephen King). It looks exactly like a certain Orc from TTT to me; and we know PJ loved his horror movies. Hmmm.
 

I'm glad that you believe that people shouldn't post at a lower level but not so much about the addition: "than they want to". This board should at the very least be aiming to enrich the quality of discussion which (as I've already mentioned) often requires that others do the same.


I was simply vociferating that we, as the members, can constantly evolve the objective, purpose and mission statement of this board and that one of these objectives should be to increase the quantity of quality...


The study took weeks but the composition not so long. I also often draw on more sources than just Tolkien as I find it to be more conducive to my understanding. However, I do expect that more people respond as despite the analysis in the original post people can often answer such questions in a few sentences - and sometime the greatest and most poignant of epiphanies and revelations derive from that which is short, sweet and perplexingly simple.


Wit, knowledge and patience can be improved through the participation in such topics. They are not intended to ward off those who have not even read the text as most of my threads have a potent philosophical construct upon which they are based. Concepts such as free will, choice and evil are intelligible to most people and thus the topic is not beyond their intellectual reach. It's just that they do not wish to deliberate over such matters as it often requires too much thought and analysis. It is this overwhelming sense of apathy that doesn't just exist here on TTF that exasperates me. I understand the problematic nature of time however. But one cannot say that they do not have any time whatsoever.


Fëanor forged the Silmarils from different media into something lustrous and beautiful to the point that they were coveted. Re-forging TTF into something of a similar nature is not beyond our ability; it is simply beyond collective desire and that to me, is ridiculously disappointing. I'm not writing my thesis - but there is no reason why the casual exchange of ideas cannot become a furnace of colloquium where ideas are melted and broken down into one another to forge threads more imaginative, thought-provoking and poignant. Why can't we forge TTF into something more incredible? We deliberate over the works of one man who invented a spectacular world for us to explore - but aren't two heads still better than one? Can't the works of Tolkien become more beautiful through a greater understanding of them?


Yes, which is why the fora have been separated as such. I have already addressed this aspect of the discussion above. However, as already stated, shouldn't the wants of those who desire deeper exploration of Tolkien also be catered to? Is there anything truly wrong in correcting those who misunderstand certain elements to increase their knowledge and thus empower them to engage in and invent topics that require the enhancement of thought and move beyond themselves and, God forbid, what they're comfortable with?

None of us enjoys being ripped to shreds in an internet forum. (Well, almost none of us: I’ve run across some folks who seem to seek it out, but that’s another matter…)

I'll admit I get kicks out of being ripped to shreds; because if I'm wrong I'll go back to my books, lick my wounds and understand why and where I misunderstood certain concepts and ideas and this enhances not just knowledge; but far more importantly: wisdom.

Firawyn said:
Úlairi, we are not fish. We are people. That makes us equals to engage yourself with, not underlings to catch and turn to what you desire.

However, I'm happy to know that I was among those you did not mark as lost causes.

No, you are far from a lost cause, Firawyn.

Matthew 4:19 said:
... I will make you fishers of men.

Nothing wrong with a little fishing from time to time, Firawyn.

Turgon, Úlairi, both of you can just cut it out. Last I checked the two of you were mature young men. Stop acting like five year olds.

Yes, Mum!

Both of you, along with all the TTF veterans and the newbes, and everyone else in between are valuable members to TTF.

I don't consider someone who meanders into a thread and personally attacks people without justification to feel better about their own mediocrity, especially when they also complain of it, to be a valuable member of anything whatsoever.

This is not a contest.

This is not about who knows more about Tolkien and his works.

I wouldn't need to contest anyone with such an opinion of others; it would be an incredibly easy victory.

This is about a group of people from all over the world who love Tolkien and want to learn more about him and his works.

Group.

As in team effort.

Have I made my point clear?

And this, Firawyn, if you haven't noticed, is exactly what I was discussing above before Turgon whinged about how no one missed him and how pothetic we all were. Turgon deviated from this concept of a collective mentality of propogation of this forum to further splendour and had to make it all about his insignificant self. That... is just too damn low without having to comment about it. Fortunately in life, you often get to choose who is in your team. Shame you can't do it here...
Illuin, that was hilarious and congrats and your 666th post.


Arvedui, excellent suggestion about jallan - from memory (s)he made great contributions to the forum.

Cheers,

Úlairi.
 

Awesome, Turgon - I totally agree

And YES what's with those mischievous purses?
 
Turgon may have gone on the defensive a bit in his post, but his point was still valid, which is (as I understand it, along with what Firawyn and myself have been saying as well) that it is a little bit arrogant and kind of pointless to complain on this forum about how it isn't meeting your standards because not everybody has the desire to post the way you do (or the elusive missing veterans did), Ulairi. And that is what I meant with my addendum, 'lower than they want to'.

This is, after all a public forum. And you would probably accuse me and others of laziness or apathy because we have a different style of posting than you do, which you apparently deem inferior with your assertion that we should "strive to forge anew the Tolkien Forum as Fëanor forged anew the Silmarils" (paraphrase). It's unfortunate for you, Ulairi, that the majority of the current posters do not meet your standards. But if the 'Annals' forum has seen less activity of late, it might just be that most people are happy to continue posting more casually in other places on the forum.

You are faced with a dilemma of sorts - that of acceptance. You can stand there and whine on about how people just don't try hard enough or you can accept that this is a message board where people are happy to pose questions on a whim, talk about silly matters, make comparisons with Middle Earth and real life, and often enough with many of the members still active (yourself, Alcuin, Firawyn, HLGStrider to name a few that I have noticed in my recent return here) debate deep and philosophical concepts that require more time and energy.

Time and energy spent toward better understanding is always well-spent. That is something you and I would most definately agree on, Ulairi. However, where I differ here is that you cannot expect a whole forum to change (reforge itself) because of that. The people who aren't putting time and energy into TTF might be spending it elsewhere (raising a family, working, practicing a sport, or in my case, planning lessons and doing freelance translations on the side), and that includes your worthy veterans. It is not apathetic to say that we must accept that. It is realistic. The people who want to post in the Annals already do. As for me, and that eigth-grader Alcuin made reference to, we might stick to the simpler forums for a while! Personally, I don't feel guilty.
 
I'm simply awestruck at the fact that one can now receive an infraction for such a mild comment. This forum needs to remove the stick from its a$$. Gonna give me another infraction, Ithrynluin? For a "Forum Insult"? Or was it enough to constitute an infraction for insulting you as I put your name in this post? I hope this isn't taken out of context either!

All the best TTF,

Úlairi.
 
Oh come now, surely an agent of chaos, here to incite rebellion, isn't awestruck but prepared to face the consequences for taking upon himself such a noble cause.
 
Whilst there are various aspects of this board that are noble; there certainly is no cause fighting for here, whatsoever.

You could charm the paint off a wall, Ithrynluin. Careful you don't smile too hard through clenched teeth; you might get a jaw-ache...

P.S. You should try translating the Quenya quote below to contextualize the Heath Ledger quote above it; as you seem so interested in my signature it might give you a better insight before you jump to conclusions...

Cheers,

Úlairi.
 
What’s the problem with posting anything you want (in good taste)? Aren't forums supposed to be "fun". So what if it’s serious, trivial, funny, light, heavy, and even outright stupid. Take Mr. Barlow for instance. He didn’t lighten things up like I had hoped, but it was impulsive, and I just felt like doing it (though I don’t understand how anyone can resist such a cute face; I was expecting a resounding awww!). I really don’t care what the post is about; as long as there is a post. Sure beats an empty forum. There is room for all; and if someone wanted to post something like:

On a lipstick kleenex hung on a pointed forked twig, above one red beak stuck in the bottom of a small tin pail, is injust injest infeast infest incest in specks in speckled cans of shish-kabob mouse flexing their magic mustaches upon the straw hill

Who cares!!! Go for it. Lots of people and diversity are what we need here. I come here to have some fun.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…