Úlairi
Crying in the Wilderness
- Joined
- Jan 13, 2002
- Messages
- 1,947
I think you may be missing the point of the problem. For me, how I have always seen the Tolkien Forum (and the reason for which I have only a measly 85 posts in however many years I've been on this forum) is that there is a small group of people who have an incredibly vast knowledge of Tolkien on here, having read Unfinished Tales and The Histories of Middle Earth several times. They contribute a lot, and they put a lot of valuable Tolkien scholarship into the web-sphere.
There was a certain member here a few years ago by the alias of Cían (and I most certainly would like to put him on my list and even on the Durin VII list!) who I personally believe made Grond, Ancalagon and Harad look like third grade English students (and me look like I was in pre-school). He (or was it a she???) would post significantly less than even you L_o_G but (s)he would occasionally meander into one of my threads and post something so incredibly and perplexingly complex that (s)he was often ignored in the very next post. I was terrified of Cían (more than anyone else) as (s)he was a cool, calm, calculated and complex cat. I know exactly how it felt to be treated like I was being interviewed by the FBI... but I'll come back to this point later.
For good measure I have not read HoME either; just parts of it that I consider important. I haven't read The Books of Lost Tales, HoME III-IX and The War of the Jewels. I have only read minor parts of The Peoples of Middle-earth and about half of Morgoth's Ring. I've read The Silmarillion once and Unfinished Tales once. I promise you that.
And then, there are the rest of us, who may or may not feel completely at ease here, but don't want to leave entirely because it is a great place to discuss Tolkien. Illuin put it nicely when he said,
A lot of people are passionate about Tolkien, but they don’t know the material as well as others, and are probably nervous about posting something for fear they’ll look like an idiot.
I am going to give myself as an example, since I know nobody's experience but my own. Illuin's point is basically how I have felt, and I am generally not afraid of public speaking or web-forum posting. I go through periods of activity here. I joined just before the release of the films and enjoyed discussing on here for a little while until posts all the 'loremasters' made me self-conscience. Then when the films came out, I hung out here a bit more because the atmosphere became more laid-back. But now! Now I think the forum has gotten more complicated than I ever could have imagined - and I have gotten A LOT smarter and become a more sensitive reader after four years of college!. After having spent only a few days back here, I am starting to think that I am over my head.
Then I pray that you don't continue to think that L_o_G as I thought your contributions in LOTR as a Metaphor for Our Lives thread were excellent and conveyed not an academic understanding of acquired knowledge but the far more important literary understanding of the text through the eyes of the author himself (who is often forgotten in the process). I hope that I haven't made you feel over your head as I actually think the contrary. You've found somewhere where you're right on par.
To be quite honest, I am not sure I will ever read The History of Middle Earth (and I KNOW I am not alone on that one), and maybe that makes me less of a fan of Tolkien than some members on this forum, but it does not mean that I am not a fan of Tolkien, if you follow me.
Follow you completely L_o_G. I don't think I'll ever read HoME either!
But on some level, a person with my interest level might feel unwelcome here. Consider the following statement by Ulairi:
However, I think this is an incredibly poor excuse not to engage in intellectual discussion and simply just sit on your hands instead and wait for the next generation to post and dilute the quality of this forum.
I realize this was primarily aimed at Illuin, so I may seem out of line, but it seems that you are trying to suggest that posts of a lower quality than what you or other 'loremasters' contribute are unwelcome.
The only reason I find them unwelcome is because they erode the quality of discussion available to those who may have a greater understanding of The Legendarium. You're all quite concerned how those new to The Tolkien Experience should be catered to without acknowledging those who are the ones remembered for making the forum what it was (and still is to a degree). These people should also be taken into consideration and should also be catered to (and I know Illuin's in the shadows waiting to jump in with The Annals of the Eldanyárë but face facts mate - there are 3 people active in there). I acknowledge these posts have their place and are actually necessary in the development of future loremasters - and this is where I'll bring Cían back into the discussion.
Who is to say that posts that are not quite so intellectually stimulating would 'dilute the quality of the forum'? You are welcome to continue posting threads that resemble the beginnings of a dissertation if you like, and there are a few people on here who will take the bite and give you the intellectual satisfaction that you crave, but if you are hoping that everybody on the Tolkien Forum is going to be interested in that type of discussion, you are probably mistaken.
I think I'd have to be a little naïve to believe that TTF is going to be full of noob loremasters in the next few years.
Now, it was stated that this thread was meant to reminisce about the great members who are now gone. And that's a wonderful idea! However, I think that you have to continue to accept the Forum as it is.
I already have. That's why I'm a member of forums and communities elsewhere. I accept (and still love) TTF for what it is. When you love something you want to see it transcend and become greater than itself in every way. There is nothing wrong about having such aspirations as I'm sure it was these concepts that put dapence infront of his computer one fateful night, and typed those three first words: The Tolkien Forum.
If the forum once included many members capable of analyzing Tolkien to the level that some do here, that must have really been a 'Golden Age' (doubtless, one I chose to absent myself from). But, as with every golden age, it must come to an end. And so some members have moved on. Maybe they will come back. Let's hope so. But let's also let the forum be what it will be.
A Golden Age may come to an end; but there's no reason why another can't take its place...
I can see there may be some attempts to bring this thread to a premature end but I am not attempting to discredit TTF or its current members in anyway; I'm just a voice crying in the wilderness...
Cheers,
Úlairi.

