• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Durin VII - "The Decline of TTF" and Moria

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ulairi, notice what I've changed my "subtitle" to. :p;)

I'm in a rush though, but I will be back to post responses tomorrow.

Happy Easter people!
 
LOL. Suits you. :p

Yes, Happy Easter everyone!

Cheers,

Úlairi.
 
Wow...reading this thread was like the old days: arguing and attacking! It makes me nostalgic.:(
Good to see Ancalagon back! Actually, it was great to see a bunch of you from 6 years and before hashing it out! (see original comment).

Who are my Durin VII?
ReadWryt: that wonderful, grumpy curmudgeon. I appreciated his wit and well versed arguments against the movies. I wish he'd come back.

Greymantle: We banded together many times in the early years against those who defended the movies at all costs.

Mrs. Maggot: Probably one of the most logical, rational and well spoken purists I've had the pleasure of joining up with.

Harad, Markrob and Foe-Hammer: The Morgoth,Sauron and Witch King of film adaptation defenders. With their grossly ignorant and insulting posts 90% of the time, getting more infractions and warnings than anybody else on this forum put together, how much fun we had shaking Arda in our battles.

I also have to agree with some of you about Cian. Cian was a Tolkien loremaster no doubt. Also on the forum waaaaay back before this forum in it's present state existed, there was a person named Delia. She could very well have been Cian for the amount of Tolkien knowledge she had.
 
Last edited:
Think I've found myself a kindred spirit here! Let's commune Thorin! :p

Cheers,

Úlairi.
 
Mrs. Maggot: Probably one of the most logical, rational and well spoken purists I've had the pleasure of joining up with.

Yeah, wonder we she went off to. Anyone know?

Now back to my late reply:

That was beautifully said, Firawyn, and i cannot agree more.
Thank you kindly, Lady V. :)


Now Ulairi,

Your perceptiveness is astounding as always Fir.

Yes, it's a gift.:p

And again I never purported this concept. It's simply a matter of personal taste. I am not, nor have I ever forced upon anyone on this board where, how and when they should post.
Indeed this is the case. However, one would wonder as to why you are so bound and determined to voice your opinion so loudly. A whisper may change history, you know.

To even believe that I have such power is profoundly egotistical. Do you all think that I'm just some egomaniacal megalomaniac who wishes to establish an esoterically intellectual oligarchy?

Um, I think that it's best if I refrain from answering this, though I did want to point out that I read, and understood it. :p

I am of the opinion that my way is the best way only because it is how I feel about the particular matter. My personal view, a contention, an ideal, a belief inimated etc...

Yet you seem to bear contempt towards people who hold their own beliefs just as highly. One would think that if you want to be respected, and want your beliefs to be respected, that you would (can't resist the quote) "do unto others as you would have them do unto you."

Quality arises from quantity and quantity from quality. A self-perpetuating cycle.

I disagree. Quality arises from people with a desire to be better than they are, and from those who want to learn more. Quantity arises from people who believe that they are more important to any given discussion that the subject being discusses. The only cycle in this is that by human nature, we each give some quality, and some quantity, and I'd call that more of a rhythm that a cycle.

We can get *certain random brilliant threads from time to time like Finding God in The Lord of the Rings from newbs but those discussions are maintained and much more deeply explored by more adept minds.

I think that "more adept minds" is very condescending. Some people have simple minds, and others complex, but ironically it's often the simple minds (not simpleminded, just meaning minds that think in sentences rather than paragraphs), that will say the most profound things, and the complex minds will speak much, and say nothing at all.

The problem with the forum several years old with the same basic members is that the discussions to be had, have been had. That's why we welcome new members with open arms, because those who were young and less knowledgeable a few years ago can now contribute to these threads you speak of in the way that their seniors contributed before. If you want to revive old topics with new members, you don't give the entire answer to the question they ask in one post. You suggest lines of thinking that will allow them to explore with their own minds - not write a post that they could copy and paste and call a term paper for their English Lit class.

*Did you use enough adjectives in that sentence?;)

I have no weaknesses...

I'm invincible!
Yeah, sure you are. :rolleyes:

You're a looney.
You have no idea just how true that is... *eyes glaze over* Ohhh!!! Hi little voices in my head! How's it going? ;)

I don't need the facts of life pointed out to me when I come here to get away from them, it simply defeats the entire purpose of coming on here in the first place. Real life is certainly a valid point as I can't make a point without having one.
This place (or any place or thing) shouldn't be an escape. It's recreation of the mind. And in the mind, 'real life' still very much exists.

I just simply get bored of having the same point reiterated to me as I don't listen to broken records.
Well we're so, so sorry we're boring you, but if you would listen we wouldn't have to say it again.

I often find the people I have the greatest repoire with are the people I initially experience dissension with; just ask Fir and Illuin.
Yeah I about killed him the first week he was back here. :rolleyes: Now we get on so much better. :rolleyes::p
 
Yes, it's a gift.:p

Well, hold onto it, it's just about the only one you have. :p

Indeed this is the case. However, one would wonder as to why you are so bound and determined to voice your opinion so loudly. A whisper may change history, you know.

Yes, I wouldn't disagree with this. But exasperatingly no one can whisper on an internet board Fir... :rolleyes:

Um, I think that it's best if I refrain from answering this, though I did want to point out that I read, and understood it. :p

Yeah, it's a crying shame you can't use this to launch a personal attack. I wouldn't have had a problem with it, but the powers that be would be on it like a fat kid on a piece of cake. :D

Yet you seem to bear contempt towards people who hold their own beliefs just as highly. One would think that if you want to be respected, and want your beliefs to be respected, that you would (can't resist the quote) "do unto others as you would have them do unto you."

I never asked for any respect and any respect that I may gain on this forum, according to this whole real life theory, is completely devoid of any tangible substance anyway. Isn't it you that has continually stated that there is real life outside the forum walls? Logically the respect out there must also be real and thus the respect here must not be. Resultantly, whether I'm respected here or not is something that I can take or leave. The aphorism you've quoted applies directly to me as I generally expect people to vociferate their opinions as loudly as I do. If that were not the case, I would never have returned to TTF. I don't bear contempt for opinions that I disagree with usually, just apathy. If the opinion is quite cogent and poignant than I will not bear contempt for it at all, but rather that opinion will force a reconsideration of my own and as such I do respect those opinions - respect for people comes later.

I disagree. Quality arises from people with a desire to be better than they are, and from those who want to learn more. Quantity arises from people who believe that they are more important to any given discussion that the subject being discusses. The only cycle in this is that by human nature, we each give some quality, and some quantity, and I'd call that more of a rhythm that a cycle.

I'm going to have to explain this, aren't I? Every person that resides within this forum brings their own inherent quality (shocking :eek:). Thus with a greater quantity of people here there must be more inherent quality. As the level of quality increases more people will be drawn to a place where the quality is of such a high standard thus increasing the quantity. Simple really. Your statements about quality are quite puissant and I couldn't agree more. If you'd read a few posts back of mine this is exactly what I had said about quality on this board. So I'm to understand that Úlairi = quantity, right? *sigh* I guess there's really no point of even bothering anymore. One cannot continually stand alone in the face of such opposition. I may as well just stop posting here as it's not really even the same Tolkien Forum that it used to be, even Big Blue acknowledges this point.

I think that "more adept minds" is very condescending. Some people have simple minds, and others complex, but ironically it's often the simple minds (not simpleminded, just meaning minds that think in sentences rather than paragraphs), that will say the most profound things, and the complex minds will speak much, and say nothing at all.

I completely and wholeheartedly agree with that, Fir. *everyone gasps*

However we are definitionally in dissent with one another with regard to the word adept. Simple minds can still be quite "adept". But I'm kinda drunk right now so I don't even know why I'm actually posting. I know I'm just fulla sh*t, right?

The problem with the forum several years old with the same basic members is that the discussions to be had, have been had. That's why we welcome new members with open arms, because those who were young and less knowledgeable a few years ago can now contribute to these threads you speak of in the way that their seniors contributed before. If you want to revive old topics with new members, you don't give the entire answer to the question they ask in one post. You suggest lines of thinking that will allow them to explore with their own minds - not write a post that they could copy and paste and call a term paper for their English Lit class.

Must we go through this... again?!?! What did I say about repitition? This just keeps going on and the sound of smashing cymbals is just getting deafening... sorry Fir.

You have no idea just how true that is... *eyes glaze over* Ohhh!!! Hi little voices in my head! How's it going? ;)

Actually, that was a quote from Monty Python and the Holy Grail where King Arthur does battle with the Black Knight. Guess I'm as "normal" as everyone else here, Fir.

This place (or any place or thing) shouldn't be an escape. It's recreation of the mind. And in the mind, 'real life' still very much exists.

Well with all the "issues" of real life that you and I have discussed previously Fir, I'm sure you of all people understand why this place is an escape for me. I'm sorry that I'm just not up to the standard of everyone else on the board whose real-lives are so wonderful that this place is just simply their minds' playground.

Well we're so, so sorry we're boring you, but if you would listen we wouldn't have to say it again.

Actually, I think it is I who am boring you by the looks of things. Maybe we do need newbs around here. I've always enjoyed hunting. :D Just jokes, people, just jokes!

Yeah I about killed him the first week he was back here. :rolleyes: Now we get on so much better.

No, you attacked me and I was the one that was eventually penalized by the double-standards rife within this forum. You didn't even come close to killing me. The posts are still there if you want to have a look. ;)

*yawn*,

Úlairi.
 
I think I'll take my leave of TTF for a while. The place has become... unprofitable. It's also beginning to consume a little too much of my time again.

Adios Amigos!

Úlairi.
 
In that case, I consider this thread pretty much moot (in the sense of "without significance," rather than in the Entmoot definition) since it has indeed strayed far from any purpose other than debating each other's methods and personalities. If anyone sees any useful posts in this thread which could start profitable discussions elsewhere, let me know and I'll split them out of thread and start a new one. Until then, this thread is closed.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top