I'm going to keep this short and sweet.
People on this forum are a sensitive bunch. But arguing with them is a fruitless effort since they are also stubborn as mules.
Pfft... Walter was using a wheel chair five years ago - I'm sure he's moved on to a bathchair by now...
No, a walking stick it is by now...Most likely a luxury, floating commode
And you're getting this idea from one personal insult? Honestly, if you want to switch me off then tell me to go away. I can guarantee you if there is enough of you that want me to do so I'll be more than happy to oblige. I can take personal attacks; they often precipitate more animated and interesting discussions in threads. Everyone seems far to damn apathetic these days and complain when such an incredibly weak comment is made about another member.
I personally would not see someone who ignores another person as a jerk, rather as someone who acknowledges an impasse. It takes a certain amount of detachment because you know that if you stop arguing a point the other person will assume that they've won, but the trick is not to care, and from experience in debates you don't have to acknowledge every poster in a thread, only the ones you consider to be injecting valuable content at that point.
Presumably if you have someone on ignore, you won't even know they are posting in your thread, which can lead to some confusing gaps (As I know from my habit of ignoring people in WoW chat. I don't believe I currently have anyone on the forum ignored, though I have ignored one or two people in the past for personal reasons) but it is extremely doable. Just pretend that everything the ignored individual is saying relates only to how hot Elijah Wood is, it'll make you feel better.
Now, as I said, this is only referring to the extreme case where this individual is making your forum experience so bad that you want to leave or feel as if you can't rest until they leave. If you can't be at peace as long as the other individual is posting, edit them off your personal forum experience.
Just remember, there is only so much power we mods have. In response to a person being rude or divisive, we have only a few weapons the wet noodle slap of "infractions" or the blunt instrument of "banishment." There really isn't a good middle ground at this point. So if you don't like what a person is saying but don't feel as if they should be banned from the forum, the mods really can't help you. If you feel things have escalated to the point where we should whip out the ban stick, that's another issue entirely, but I still think the ignore button is a good middle ground.
I know if I were on a forum and felt no one was listening to what I was saying any more I might change the method with which I was communicating. Or, if I didn't feel the opinion of those who I was in debate with mattered, I'd have to ask myself, why am I bothering to debate them in the first place?
Honestly, I'm not getting this from any particular post/insult/comment. I'm getting this from the attitude of some people who have made it known in private that they are upset with things you have said.
In the case of noobs, you may as well click the ignore button if they're not worth response for their lack of contribution. People accuse me of chasing them away and preventing them from posting in my threads - but if you in your own threads purport to be noob-friendly and then just simply ignore their existence you're practically shunning them to an even further extent!
Perhaps the feeling that you are not wanted comes from the fact that even when someone is sort of on your side and would rather not see you banned, you turn around and attack them by misinterpreting things they say in posts? Just maybe?
Noobs I don't mind. I never would ignore someone for being unaware/uninformed but I would ignore someone for being constantly on the attack, for turning everything I say into a rant about my personality, for choosing to read everything I say in the wrong spirit . . .
there is simply no way to argue meaningfully if someone hijacks the thread where I simply said, "If you personally find someone to be rude and can't handle their posts, ignore them" into "Let's all call HLG a hypocrit because she would ignore people who are wanting to know if Tom Bombadil was Gandalf's cousin!"
Honestly, if I wanted to read into your posts I would say that you panicked because you thought too many people would ignore you personally and so your relavence would be threatened, but that would be an assumption, and Firawyn can tell you what they say about people who assume.
Noob. What does that actually mean? Someone who is new to Tolkien; or someone who has read Tolkien’s work for say, thirty years, but is new to the forum? Anyway, I think it’s ironic that Barley was concerned his "Decline of the Tolkien Forum" thread would die out with a thud many moons ago; yet it was so huge it actually spawned a satellite thread that is presently on fire. Maybe the Innkeeper should not be too hasty when selling out to Dunkin' Donuts.
You mean newb (or newbie) not noob. Newb is someone new, doesn't know much and makes mistakes. Noob is someone who has been around for a while claims to know stuff yet still makes the same mistakes as a newb. Newb is not offensive where noob is.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?