Ulairi, dear, if I didn't know any better, I'd say that you
miss some of these people. Interesting.
Your perceptiveness is astounding as always Fir.
True, Ulairi, but just because you like it that way does not mean it is the ONLY way to be.
And again I never purported this concept. It's simply a matter of personal taste. I am not, nor have I ever forced upon anyone on this board where, how and when they should post. To even believe that I have such power is profoundly egotistical. Do you all think that I'm just some egomaniacal megalomaniac who wishes to establish an esoterically intellectual oligarchy? WM can flick me off this board with his little finger if he so wishes. I have no delusions of grandeur; I simply expressing the opinion that I consider this place to be far more rewarding and worthwhile when it is populated by people who have great wisdom which they apply to the knowledge derived from the works of
Tolkien. It is The
Tolkien Forum, after all... although it sure as hell doesn't feel like it anymore (and this may be why Alcuin is no longer present

). Other than that I'm just a simple-minded plebian.
And you would certainly have no grounds to say (not saying that you have said) that your way is the best way.
Thanks Captain Obvious.

I am of the opinion that my way is the best way only because it is how I feel about the particular matter. My personal view, a contention, an ideal, a belief inimated etc... I will not concede however, from the position that this forum is better populated by n
oobs unless from n
ewbs (and I used the different variation here for obvious reasons) we see the development of a particular few that can generate brilliant discussion. Quality arises from quantity and quantity from quality. A self-perpetuating cycle. We can get certain random brilliant threads from time to time like
Finding God in The Lord of the Rings from newbs but those discussions are maintained and much more deeply explored by more adept minds.
Life is not about proving you are the best.
Well, it is a fundamental tenet of capitalism upon which the financial aspects of our lives are founded upon, but I agree with you nonetheless. There is no point
preaching to me here on this point as I have not made this contention previously, and more to the point I agree with this wholeheartedly. If I have an opinion I feel strongly about I will simply defend it to the best of my ability. If I come out the victor in the end then all I have been is successful in my endeavour to defend that belief, nothing more, nothing less.
Everyone has strengths, and everyone has weaknesses. That why we need relationships - so that we can pull others up in thier weaknesses, and so that they can pull us up in ours. It's a delicate balance that is extreamly good for us, as human beings.
I have no weaknesses...
I'm invincible!
You're a looney.
And by the way, please get off Starflower about pointing out the facts of real life, because like it or not, you do exist outside of cyberspace, as do the rest of us, and real life is a valid point in any discussion.
I don't need the facts of life pointed out to me when I come here to get away from them, it simply defeats the entire purpose of coming on here in the first place. Real life is certainly a valid point as I can't make a point without having one. I just simply get bored of having the same point reiterated to me as I don't listen to broken records.
I am not about to argue with you,
Úlairi, and i apologize if you felt in any way singled out by my post, as that was not my intent.
I wasn't spoiling for a fight Voronwen. I don't understand why everyone on this board contorts into a twisted ball everytime someone expresses an opinion contrary to the accepted norm or majority view. You have an opinion on the matter and so do I. We can leave it at that. I have no plans to pursue it further as not only has this argument become stale... it just goes around in circles. It may not have been your intent Voronwen to single me out but the placement in relation to threads made it quite obvious. You can call me arrogant, I have absolutely no problem with this whatsoever. "There's nothing you can't throw at me that I haven't already heard." If you call me arrogant a need will arise to defend myself and I will do so. Once I have done so I will leave it at that. What I am saying and I have repeatedly said to this forum is that I will not instigate personal attacks from now on. The first bullet fired will not come from my gun, but the second one most definitely will be.
I learned years ago that arguing and getting upset over posts on an internet forum was not good for my (or anyone's) health. I hope one day you find the experience you seek. Until then, i hope that you and i can at the very least enjoy a peaceable acquaintance.
We can enjoy more than that Voronwen. I often find the people I have the greatest repoire with are the people I initially experience dissension with; just ask Fir and Illuin. Just because I avidly defend my position it does not mean that I have personal dislike for you; quite the opposite actually. Being a law student requires that I have to maintain a level of objectivity in any argument.
Your "peaceable acquaintance",
Úlairi.