1stvermont
Active Member
- Joined
- Jul 4, 2017
- Messages
- 894
So I take it that with the European Renaissance, in your opinion, the feudal monarchies you so idealize went into decline. This is my interpretation of your above statement, so if I'm wrong, correct me. The Renaissance seems to be seen as having taken place in the 15th and 16th centuries by "orthodox" consensus, though some extend it forward into the 17th century, and backwards into the 14th. The latter had a massive paradigm shift in form of the Great Plague, peaking in Europe between 1347 and 1351.
To put it bluntly, whatever intrinsic positive values the Catholic feudal monarchies may have had for the population as a whole, which I'm willing to accept at least for the sake of argument, before history they were failures, ending up on history's garbage dump.
For European-internal reasons, too, the monarchs becoming - to steal the quote from Alcuin's above post:
"(See also Tolkien’s description of Aragorn’s descendants in Letter 244: “the dynasts descended from Aragorn would become just kings and governors – like Denethor or worse.”)"
But "Southrons" and "Easterlings" certainly also played a role, and that JRRT cast them in his tales as he did is simply European experience with whatever appeared out of the blue out of these directions. At least for 1500 years if you take the Huns, or if you take the Roman view of Carthage, at least 2200 years.
(There was a "homegrown" European scourge that JRRT did not take up: The "Northrons" or Vikings. Perhaps to do with his liking for the Norse Sagas etc.)
But there is a huge gap between the demise of the feudal monarchies and anything I would call a democracy. Greece never was, nor the US for the longest time. These were plutocracies, with the vote given to a very small minority of the population. France's experiment ended with the military dictator Napoleon Bonaparte (as did the nominal Roman Republic with Julius Caesar).
The beggings of the transformation from feudal to absolute began at various times in the west. But the origins of various Roman and renaissance influences can be seen as early as the late 13th century. I would say the normal renaissance time period of say 15-17th century was more the full implementation of absolute monarchies.
I agree the Catholic monarchies are done away with, but does might make right? Sorry for the bold but C.S lewis wrote
We all want progress. But progress means getting nearer to the place where you want to be. And if you have taken a wrong turning then to go forward does not get you any nearer. If you are on the wrong road progress means doing an about-turn and walking back to the right road and in that case the man who turns back soonest is the most progressive man. There is nothing progressive about being pig-headed and refusing to admit a mistake. And I think if you look at the present state of the world it's pretty plain that humanity has been making some big mistake. We're on the wrong road. And if that is so we must go back. Going back is the quickest way on
Speaking of playing nice, the OP and some of the discussion is interesting, and germane to the forum, but I think it might be time to remind everyone that politics and religion generally are both considered OT here.
Let's try to keep it to Tolkien and Middle-earth, shall we?
Agreed and I apologize for my part.
