Just another thought.
The great medieval European monarchies, whether Catholic or Orthodox, were fine if you were of the nobility. They were tolerable if you were free, whether of the yeomanry (free peasants), artisans (craftsmen: experts, journeymen, and perhaps even apprentices, many of whom further enjoyed membership in a guild; besides such activities as bakers, cooks, and so on who were not enserfed), or professionals (lawyers, physicians).
For
serfs and slaves, however, I think life was pretty difficult, if not outright miserable.
To make the distinction: a
serf is a person
tied to the land. He is not a
slave in that he does not
belong to someone else: He isn’t the property of another person. However, a serf is
not free: He is not at liberty to move permanently to another location or to stop farming the land on which he lives. Part of his produce from farming or fishing must be given over to whomever owns the land on which he lives and works, and of course he is furthermore subject to taxation by the king. A serf might purchase the land on which he resided and on which he was required to stay and work, thus obtaining his freedom (and becoming a yeoman, a free peasant (commoner)), but of course the owner of that plot of land might find it more profitable to retain ownership and thus his allocation of the serf’s agricultural produce. Serfdom lasted in Russia until Tsar Alexander II abolished it in 1861.
Slavery is another matter altogether. Pope Eugene IV outlawed slavery in 1435 in the papal bull
Sicut Dudum and ordered the immediate release of all slaves. This was based upon his discovery that black Canary Islanders had been enslaved.
Until at least that time, slavery also existed in England. This I know from my research into a book I published a few years ago: various census records from early fifteenth century England described people by their occupations and status, among which both “serf” and “slave” were listed. (I have recently seen assertions by accredited academics that no slavery existed in England at this time. In my opinion, these “accredited academics” are poorly accredited, deliberate liars, or both. If that seems strong language, so be it: there is no excuse for such an error by people presumed professionals: documents to contrary exist: even I, a knowledgeable amateur, stumbled across several.) (By the way, Abraham Lincoln’s Emancipation Proclamation in 1862 was
inspired by and informed by Tsar Alexander’s emancipation of the Russian serfs.)
Serfs and slaves in England escaped to
cities and market towns whenever they could. If they could live out their lives without being caught, they not only obtained their freedom, but that of their descendants, who would otherwise be condemned to the fate of unfreedom.
There were regular revolts of slaves, serfs, and peasants in England. The largest and most dangerous (from the point of view of the nobility) was the
Peasants’ Revolt of 1381, also known as the Great Rising or Wat Tyler’s Rebellion (for the man who became leader and spokesman of the peasants). The revolt was triggered by a
poll tax or “head tax”, a flat tax levied on every adult (sometimes even on children)
regardless of their ability to pay. (
Article I Section 9 Paragraph 4 of the US Constitution originally outlawed “Capitation
[i.e., head taxes] or other direct Tax” except against the States in proportion to their populations; in other words, the Federal government could not generally directly tax citizens, but could only assess taxes against the
States in proportion to their populations. This was superseded in 1909 by the
XVI Amendment, which allowed the Federal government to directly tax the incomes of US citizens.) This was in addition to the Ordinance of Labourers decreed by King Edward III and the Statute of Labourers passed by Parliament in light of
dramatic increases in wages and demands for better working conditions by commoners in the wake of the Black Death, which killed between 25% and 60% of the population of England, vitiating the working population. (It never pays to outlaw economics: those Laws come from a Source no mere mortals can successfully contest.)
Richard II, then but fourteen years old, first seemed to accede to the complaints of his subjects, then viciously repressed the uprising. In the War of the Roses that followed Richard’s deposition from the throne, however, memories of the Peasants’ Revolt tempered over-taxation of peasants by the weakened Houses of Lancaster and York, and the poll tax was rescinded. In 1989, Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher attempted to institute a poll tax in Britain,
which directly resulted in her fall from power. Poll taxes are immensely unpopular.
At any rate,
slavery and
serfdom ended in England sometime in the fifteenth century, to the great benefit of the people and the country: free people are happier and more productive than slaves or serfs. Note, however, that
individuals might still be condemned to slavery as punishment. I have an ancestor who along with his father and elder brother served as an officer under
Bonnie Prince Charlie in the 1745
Jacobite Rising in which Scotland invaded England, then ruled by George II, in an attempt to place Charles Stuart (“Bonnie Prince Charlie”), grandson of the deposed
King James II, on the throne in London and restore the House of Stuart. (King George II, like his father, George I of Britain, was also Elector of Hanover: The rumor was that
George I never learned to speak English, and while that might at first have been true, clearly he did later in life. This dual monarchy continued until Queen Victoria: Hanover did not allow ruling
queens, so
Ernest Augustus, youngest son of George III, became King of Hanover.) I don’t recall whether the father was killed in battle or the older brother, but the survivor was
hanged, drawn, and quartered – a most gruesome way to die. (Hence the US Constitution’s prohibition on “
cruel and unusual punishments.”) My ancestor, due to his young age (he was twenty at the time) was sentenced to “lifetime servitude” and shipped in chains to Virginia, where the royal governor commuted the sentence to twelve years’ indenture. (Virginia was a long way from London: I doubt King George or his son the
Duke of Cumberland, victorious commander of England’s army who apparently imposed the sentence, ever found out about it.)