But heat doesn't have to come just from an eruption.eruption
Why?Well, no one said it yet,
so I guess I "must".
African or European?
You're joking, right?I am physically incapable of understanding the concept of mph so I'm not going to participate.
Well, at least the anglophone world has managed to get distances and areas harmonized.You're joking, right?
I understand the metric system just fine... can do a lot of imperial to metric conversions in my head, if not in my sleep.
I had to do it in my job (for 34 years) because at least one third of the equipment I used or worked on was made to Metric specs, but a lot of the tools I used were made to imperial specs.
So your are "imperiaIly challenged"? 😄
We have? We did? When did that happen? 😮Well, at least the anglophone world has managed to get distances and areas harmonized.
So why can't you get your act together for volume?????
The gallon is either about 3.8 (US) or about 4.5 (imperial) liters.
Have you ever tried to get those quarts (and / or pints) sorted at a beer festival after a couple of liter mugs (the "standard displacement" for Bavarian beer festivals)????? 🙄🥴🤢
Well, a short superficial scan of Wikipedia might give a "metrician" that possibly faulty impression for the mile and its subsidiaries (furlong, yard, inch) and the acre and its relatives (I did have to deal with this stuff that in metrical notation has no end to the right of the decimal point for nine years).We have? We did? When did that happen? 😮
(I guess I didn't get that memo 🙄...)
Why did they have to do it in only 30 minutes?What about at the Black Gate? Its about 100 miles from Dagorlad to Orodruin, and the Eagles had to have flown the distance in around 30 minutes. This would mean that they had to be doing about 200 mph.
I just picked 30 minutes as the maximum time. Now that I think about it, it would have to be closer to 10 minutes or less.Why did they have to do it in only 30 minutes?
Zuzu! Let's go somewhere!"Scotty, Beam Me Outta Here">
just picked 30 minutes as the maximum time. Now that I think about it, it would have to be closer to 10 minutes or less.
It would seem that for once, Lestrade is on the right track.It took the Eagles at least an hour to get to Sam and Frodo.
So the eagles flew a little faster than 100 mph (161-162 kmh), which is a reasonable "giant eagle speed" in a fantasy setting... 200 mph would beggar disbelief even in ME (imo). Despite ME being "the land of faerie" within his subcreation Tolkien still strove to maintain plausibility.
And how did I arrive at these numbers? (asks @Aethelwulf in utter confusion, dismay and indignation).
Right away dismiss all images in your head from the movie scene; Sam and Frodo did not dash from the Sammath Naur (S-N) and leap onto the ash hill right across from it. That makes for good action drama but, again, go ad fontem (read the book!) for the real story.
The ash hill was a good ways distant from the S-N doorway.
N.B.: I'm using Fonstad's ME Atlas for all distances and locations.
1) The Nazgul did not immediately fly off to Mount Doom when Frodo "put on the Ring and claimed it for his own".
"At his [Sauron's] summons, wheeling with a rending cry, in a last desperate race there flew, faster than the winds, the Nazgûl....southwards to Mount Doom."
Also: "But the Nazgûl turned and fled,...hearing a sudden terrible call out of the Dark Tower."
(Mount Doom is a little over 100 miles---straight line-- from where the Forces of the West stood on the two slag heaps)
2) At the same time (1) was happening Sam "got up, dazed" from being clobbered with a rock by Gollum.
There now ensues the fight between the unseen Frodo and Gollum: to and fro, falling to ground, rising again, teetering on the brink of Crack. finally Gollum biting off Frodo's finger and doing his "happy dance", losing his balance, falling and being consumed by the fires.
(3) The Eagles had already arrived by the time of (1) because they "bore down" on the Nazgûl even as they were were wheeling away at Sauron's call.
(4) Meanwhile, back at the ranch, Sam picks up Frodo, carries him outside and stands there and watches the fall of Barad-dûr which, big as it is, takes some time to occur; it didn't just collapse like a house of cards. Right after that, Frodo and Sam have a convo about Frodo's hand, the Ring, Gollum's part etc.
(5) At Sam's (imminently sensible) suggestion, they leave the dangerous S-N and "went slowly down the winding road... and passed toward the Mountain's quaking feet....[and] reached a low ashen hill at the Mountain's foot."
If you look at Fonstad's map you'll see the Ashen Hill is at least 2 miles, if not closer to 3 miles (on foot) from the S-N doorway.
Add that to the Mountain quaking, there is debris falling from the skies, rock and shale slides, and they are now off the road (which was tumbled rock even when they first climbed it), Sam and Frodo would be lucky to traverse that distance at even 2 mph; by way of comparison 2mph is a leisurely strolling pace.
Also, Mount Doom didn't suddenly explode like Mount St Helens; it erupted, extremely violently to be sure, but it didn't "blow up".
And all that, "rending and vomiting" Tolkien describes took some time.
(For a great simulation of what it was like for the Pompeii-nians when Mt Vesuvias erupted in 79AD.....Destruction of Pompeii)
So from the time Frodo put on the Ring, to the time the Three Eagles arrived to rescue them, was at least an hour if not longer.
Therefore they flew at no more than 100 mph, probably slower. The Nazgûl would be slower still.
(And Watson, I hope you are duly chastened at having made an ill considered estimate 🙄... I expected so much better of you 😉)
ooooo ... that's a low blow, that is.It would seem that for once, Lestrade is on the right track.
I will read this carefully again...1) The Nazgul did not immediately fly off to Mount Doom when Frodo "put on the Ring and claimed it for his own".
"At his [Sauron's] summons, wheeling with a rending cry, in a last desperate race there flew, faster than the winds, the Nazgûl....southwards to Mount Doom."
Also: "But the Nazgûl turned and fled,...hearing a sudden terrible call out of the Dark Tower."
(Mount Doom is a little over 100 miles---straight line-- from where the Forces of the West stood on the two slag heaps)
What about the 2+ mile trek to the Ashen Hill? No way they did that any faster than 2mph.I will read this carefully again...
As I read it, Sauron's "summons" comes... the 'sudden terrible cry'... when Frodo puts on the ring and 'claims it for his own.'
It's not until that moment Sauron realizes his peril and huge mistakes.
Thus the 'sudden, terrible call' to try to save his bacon.
Thus, the need for 'teleportation' to achieve the timeline of the Canon of Tolkien.
There is only time for the struggle with Gollum, during which the mountain is already responding, etc. and when gollum hits the pit, the walls are melting, and somehow Frodo and Sam are not baked. This is no hour.. it's meres minutes, at best.
HOWEVER... I may not be understanding some other event eliciting this 'sudden, terrible cry' from Sauron... though I recall none other in the text.
Anyway, review is always refreshing.
I dunno. That's why I'm going to review the full scope of things.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?