• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Fanfic Ill Chances and Strange Fates

Maedhros_Nelyafinwë

CPA of Himring
Staff member
Administrator
Joined
Nov 28, 2022
Messages
3,734
~Table of Contents~


“Marriage, save for rare ill chances and strange fates, was the natural course of life for all the Eldar.” ~J.R.R. Tolkien, Morgoth’s Ring, The Laws and Customs Among the Eldar

Prologue

Gentle flurries of snow grew to a raging blizzard in the mountain kingdom of Himring. And with every falling flake, Raiwen’s worry grew.

Her mind was not with the herbs she ground or the poultices she stirred. She could barely focus on the prayers she uttered to Estë, ritualistic prayers of blessing over these medicines she prepared. All she could think about was the fact that the watchmen would have no choice but to close the gates soon, due to the snow rapidly piling up. Her love was still out there in this weather.

She worked quietly in a tower overlooking the gates, gazing intently over each warrior who walked through the area. One head of black hair after another… none of them red.

He had promised her he would return with his warriors before nightfall on the seventh day. She had trusted him, for he was not one to break his word. But the sky had already grown from a light gray to a much darker hue, and it was the seventh day. She did not doubt he had remembered his promise and done his best to abide by it, but no one could foresee the arrival of a blizzard like this.

But in addition to her restless feeling of anxiety and her rapidly beating heart, she also battled frustration in her mind. She understood his need to patrol the lands; Morgoth would not use the foul weather as an excuse to rest, so neither should the warriors of Himring. But she didn’t understand why they couldn’t relax their efforts just a little during the dead of winter.

The bitterly cold wind brushed in through the window and nipped at her fingers. The white healer’s veil covering her dark hair fluttered under the draft. If she could feel the unpleasant sting of the wind from the safety and warmth of this tower, how much worse it must have been for those who were still out there. The guards who remained on patrol outside huddled together in tight clusters. The temperature outside was well below freezing and the roaring wind made it feel even colder. Naturally, Raiwen worried about anyone unfortunate enough to be out in such elements, but especially her love. He couldn’t afford to suffer frostbite in his only hand.

The mighty steel gates wavered and trembled under a particularly strong gust. The wind howled and the steel rattled. Raiwen could only watch as the guards gathered around it, seeming to discuss something amongst themselves. Then, they took shovels and cleared the snowdrifts around the gate as best they could… and slowly began to push the gate shut.

Raiwen closed her eyes, shuddering. A sick feeling of dread settled in her stomach. Her love had miraculously survived horrors beyond imagination, but cold like this could kill anyone, no matter how strong.

Faint noises of commotion caused her to reopen her eyes. The guards, having paused their closing of the gate, pointed and shouted at something beyond the gate. Then they scrambled to open the gates to their widest again.

A few dozen horses trudged their way through the snowdrifts outside the gate and burst into the courtyard. The guards erupted into cheers and applause.

At the front of the group rode a tall, broad-shouldered figure, his red braid visible under his helmet. Raiwen exhaled in relief. Her tense muscles relaxed, but her heart wouldn't slow down just yet.

Maedhros, and all his warriors and their horses, were coated in snow and likely drenched. But they seemed in good spirits as they dismounted and greeted each other, clapping each other on the back and laughing. Stable boys ran to the courtyard and led the horses away.

This didn’t mean Raiwen’s worries were completely dismissed, however. She knew better than most how stubborn Maitimo could be in pretending he was fine when he really wasn’t.

For some time, she could do nothing but watch and wait. If it were up to her, she would have rushed down to the courtyard to meet him herself. But as a mere healer, she could not appear to a lord unsummoned. And that was all they were, officially: a lord and a healer.

The ellyn outside didn’t remain talking for long; they all dispersed, the guards returning to their watchtowers where they could at least be sheltered from the wind and start a fire. And Maedhros and the warriors he had brought all went inside.

Raiwen gathered up her supplies and hurried back to the healing halls, where she could be available to respond if summoned. This was a large room full of many beds, separated from each other with thin curtains. As always, the healing halls were crowded, full of warriors with all kinds of injuries, ranging from arrow wounds to broken bones to frostbite. The familiar sounds of clanking tools, hushed murmurs, and groans of pain filled the halls. A few minutes after Raiwen arrived, a pair of snow-drenched warriors hobbled in, one limping heavily and leaning on the other. Another healer, who had been sitting by the bedside of a sleeping patient, rushed over to help them.

Raiwen’s heart ached with guilt as she watched her fellow healers bustling around tending to the many patients. Normally, she’d be here helping them, and she had been doing just that for most of this week. But she had to make sure she was available when—not if, but when—Maitimo needed her. All the other healers here understood that, because it was the entire reason why she left the House of Fingolfin and came here to Himring. She had a hand in stitching up every single wound he had incurred during his torment in Angband and Thangorodrim. Only she knew the precise spot on his right shoulder which would give him some relief if massaged. She hardly trusted another healer with him at this point.

She had only to wait a few minutes before a servant arrived to tell her Lord Maedhros was asking for her. A few of the other white-clad healers glanced up from their work and watched her knowingly as she hurried off.

Raiwen found Maedhros in his chamber, which was a spacious room with a scarlet canopied bed, a great oak desk piled with books and parchments, and a cabinet filled with all sorts of bandages and herbs. Torchlight gave the stone walls a warm glow. Gold-framed portraits of all his six brothers, and his parents and nephew, hung on the walls. He himself was bent over his work desk and intently writing something. He shivered despite the fire roaring in the nearby fireplace, which might have been because there were still some chunks of snow in his damp auburn curls. He had managed to unbraid his hair but not get the rest of it sorted out, apparently.

Raiwen glanced at the parchment Maedhros was working on. “Confirmation of Trade Proposal,” it was titled, written in Dwarvish runes. Raiwen was not as fluent in the Khuzdûl tongue as Maedhros was, but he had taught her the basics, mostly so she could help proofread his letters. Neither of them should have known the tongue, since the Dwarves didn’t normally teach it to outsiders. But thanks to the friendship Maedhros had struck up with the dwarf king Azaghâl, he had gained proficiency in the language.

“You’re trying to work right now?” Raiwen said, amused yet concerned and slightly irritated.

He jumped at the sound of her voice, but relaxed and smiled tiredly when he saw her. “Good evening, Aranya,” he said, switching to their native tongue of Quenya and calling her by her true name. “I figured there’s no reason I couldn’t draft this letter tonight. It is a mere response to a trade proposal from Azaghâl, which I had already decided to accept.”

“May I see it?”

Maitimo nodded, put his quill pen down and handed her the parchment. She frowned slightly as she read it, took the pen and circled a few words, and handed it back to him.

He stared blankly at it and then winced. Simple spelling mistakes.

“I dearly hope you don’t plan on sending that to Azaghâl,” she said, and added gently, “We both know you’re too weary to write your best, especially in Khuzdûl. Try it again in the morning.”

His shoulders sagged, a defeated look in his eyes. “It’s just a simple response… I should have been able to write it quickly and easily.”

“You’re only made of the stuff of the earth. Don’t be so hard on yourself." Before he could protest, she returned his pen to the inkwell and neatly stacked his papers and books. "Now, what seems to be the trouble?”

He blinked in confusion at her. “The trouble?”

“What did you summon me here for?”

“Come now, Aranya… do you think I only summon you when I need your help? I haven’t seen you in over a week, and I’ve missed you.”

Aranya couldn’t help but smile, and she pulled up the other velvet-cushioned chair by his desk and sat beside him. “I’ve missed you too, Maitimo. And I was very worried about you getting caught in this storm. I’m relieved you all made it back safely. And yet I know you, and you look strained. Are you sure there’s nothing I can help with?”

Knowing Maitimo, he hated asking for help as often as he truly needed. It was hard for him to accept that his torment in Angband and Thangorodrim had changed him forever, in more ways than one. He apparently liked to think it wasn’t worth it to bother someone else over the aches and pains he thought of as minor. So Aranya, knowing this, tried to help him by pretending she might as well offer her services while she was there, as if it were a casual matter of convenience. As if she couldn’t read the pain in his eyes.

And sure enough, he hesitated and then nodded. “Well… I guess I am a little sore. And I can’t seem to warm up, even with the fire.”

“This would be part of the reason,” Aranya commented, brushing some of the half-melted snow out of his hair. “We need to make sure your hair fully dries. While it’s wet, it will sap away a great deal of heat. And how’s your hand?”

Maitimo held out his hand to her, and she was relieved to see no signs of frostbite such as paleness and blistering. His fingertips were red, though. “It’s somewhat tingling and burning,” he told her.

She took his hand between hers, flinching at how cold it felt, though her own hands were a little cold as well. “And you were trying to write with this?” she gently scolded him, rubbing his hand between hers.

He shrugged, and she glanced up to meet his intent stare. His soft gray eyes lingered on her dark brown ones for a moment… too long a moment.

Aranya forced her gaze away. Maitimo himself had told her decades ago not to wait for him, that he wasn’t free because of the Oath he had sworn in his youth, and fulfilling it only looked increasingly hopeless as the years wore on.

Yet how could she not wait? Who else did she possibly have to wait for?



Notes:

Ellyn - Sindarin word for male Elves.
 
Last edited:
Return to top

Chapter 1: Cracks and Blunders

“Give it back, Tyelko, it’s not yours!”

“Come on, Finno, I’m just borrowing it!”

“Well, I want it back!”

“I’m just making some… improvements!”

“You’re gonna break it!”

Maitimo sighed deeply and dared to glance away from his careful watch over his little twin brothers, and towards his bickering brother and cousin. Just when he had thought Tyelkormo old enough to manage for himself in some playtime in the forest with Findekáno, so Maitimo could have some time to concentrate and make sure the little twins didn’t get into trouble, well… he was proven wrong. It was especially disappointing given their age. They were nearly adolescents. And since Tyelko was quite tall for his age, as Maitimo had always been, he desperately needed to learn how to wield his increasing strength with gentleness.

Birds chattered happily and golden light beamed in through the rich green foliage of the forest, as though nature itself were happily ignoring the squabbling children. At least the Ambarussar were happy enough for the moment digging in the dirt and playing with bugs. Maitimo decided he would have to accept their consumption of some bugs and dirt in his absence while he broke up the fight.

Tyelkormo and Findekáno were both tugging on Findekáno’s brand new bow, one his father had just made for him. Tyelko’s fluffy silver-blond hair and Finno’s black braids whipped back and forth as they struggled to take the bow. It was a finely carved bow, tightly strung, with a fairly heavy draw weight. This was the first real one Findekáno had ever gotten, and his father had obviously intended it to be something he would grow into. Right now, he could hardly bend the string. And if Maitimo knew Tyelko, he must have been more than a little jealous of such a gift. Though he was plenty strong enough to handle something bigger than the small bow he’d had throughout his childhood, their father Fëanáro told him he wasn’t responsible enough to handle a real bow yet.

Maitimo stood and approached them, leaving the little redheads alone for a moment. He’d be able to hear if they got into trouble. “Both of you, stop it,” he scolded Tyelko and Finno… and he immediately cleared his throat. The high-pitched crack of his voice made him sound less authoritative than he had hoped. He’d been suffering from a great deal of those lately as his voice was falling deeper… and deeper… and deeper. Kind of like how he just kept growing taller… and taller… and taller.

“Stop it,” Tyelko echoed, mocking Maitimo by imitating his voice crack.

Maitimo rolled his eyes, but otherwise ignored it. “You really are going to break that bow if you keep playing tug-of-war with it, and then Uncle Nolo will be furious. Tyelko, that bow doesn’t belong to you. You’re not going to get one of your own anytime soon if you keep behaving like this.”

Young Finno’s chest puffed up and a vindictive grin lit his features. Tyelko’s pouty scowl deepened. “How come you always side with your half-cousin rather than your own brother?” he whined. His grip on the bow was tightly clenched still. And even though he was about the same age as Finno, he was much bigger and stronger than him. He would eventually win the tug-of-war and likely damage the bow in the process, unless Maitimo could talk him down from it.

And Maitimo winced at Tyelko’s derogatory reference to their relationship with the Nolofinwians. “That’s very rude of you to refer to Finno that way. And I’m not siding with him. I’ve asked both of you to stop the bickering, and so far, neither of you have. Tyelko, if you want a bow like that of your own, you need to be respectful of what belongs to you and what doesn’t. What would Oromë say if he saw you trying to take a weapon that wasn’t yours?”

Tyelko paused and his gaze dropped, his grip seeming to loosen as he fell silent to think. He practically idolized the Vala of hunting, having gone with him on some adventures. And of course, Oromë was the one who had gifted Tyelko his giant, intelligent hound.

“And Finno,” Maitimo added gently, “there’s no need to rub it in Tyelko’s face, either. You know how much he’s been wanting a bow like that.”

Now Finno’s cheerful grin faded, and he nervously fidgeted with one of his braids. But before either of the elflings could respond, there was a loud crack and a sudden burst of crying. Maitimo turned to see little Pityo standing on a rock and holding a stick, and Telvo was sprawled in the dirt, crying and… bleeding.

Maitimo gasped and rushed towards the twins. Even Tyelko and Finno forgot their argument, dropped the bow and ran after him.

Telvo was beginning to sit up and right himself, but he cried loudly, and there was a bloody scrape across his cheek where Pityo had apparently struck him. The latter, still standing on the rock, watched him with wide-eyed curiosity and confusion.

“What happened, Telvo? Are you alright?” Maitimo asked, kneeling down and setting the toddler on his lap. Telvo only screamed all the louder.

“Use your words,” Maitimo gently told him.

“Pityo—hit me—” Telvo whined between incoherent babbles.

“Are you sad?” Pityo asked, his faint red brows creasing in confusion.

“Of course he’s sad! You made him sad when you hit him!” Tyelko snapped, and his harsh tone caused Pityo to burst into tears.

Maitimo opened his mouth to scold Tyelko, but Pityo managed to squeak out, “It was… accident…”

A change took over Tyelko’s features, rapidly as a startled bird taking off in flight. His anger cooled, and a softer look came to his eyes. “Oh… you didn’t… realize that would happen, did you?”

Pityo shook his head, and the entire forest clearing echoed with the sounds of both the twins blubbering and screaming.

“Young Elflings don’t often know what the consequences of their actions will be,” Maitimo said quietly to Tyelko, patting Telvo on the back and holding him closely. “He probably just learned for the first time what happens when you hit someone with a stick.”

“I’m sorry!” Pityo wailed. And to Maitimo’s great surprise, Tyelko picked up Pityo and snuggled him tightly. The little one’s cries quieted to sporadic whimpering and sniffling.

“Should I go fetch a healer?” Finno offered, smiling, clearly trying to be helpful and diffuse the stress.

“You can take us inside and show us where they are. Thank you,” Maitimo said. Then, with him carrying Telvo and Tyelko carrying Pityo, they left the woods and returned to the House of Nolofinwë.

The healing halls were in the first floor of the grand House, thankfully. Finno led the group down several marble corridors before they arrived at a large room, with glistening floors, clean white walls, and several beds separated by floating gauze curtains. A hush fell over the visitors as they entered, since the place was noticeably quieter than the lively outdoors or bustling halls of the palace. A few healers wandered around, preparing herbal mixtures or practicing embroidery.

Finno approached a pair of healers sitting nearby. One appeared to be around their parents’ age or older, based on the maturity of her face and the wisdom in her gray eyes. Beside her sat a young nís who appeared to be around Finno and Tyelko’s age. Both had dark hair covered with sheer, pale blue healers’ veils, and they were clad in simple blue robes with pristine white aprons. They sat with embroidery hoops, and the elder pointed at the younger’s work, seeming to give her instruction.

“Good afternoon, Arcamë and Aranya,” Finno said cheerfully. “We’ve got a little Elfling here who took a pretty good nick to the face.”

Both the níssi stood, put their embroidery hoops down, and curtsied. “Oh dear, that’s no fun at all,” the elder healer said with a kindly smile. “Let’s have a look, shall we?”

Maitimo held out Telvo to them, though he was inclined to hide his face in Maitimo’s shirt, and Maitimo had to gently coax him to look at the elder healer so she could examine the cut.

“That will be an easy enough fix,” the healer said. “I think Aranya is more than capable of handling this one. Would you like to treat this, dear?”

“I’d be glad to,” said Aranya, the younger healer. She stared intently at Telvo for a moment before inviting them to follow her to one of the beds.

“I’m glad we got Aranya,” Finno whispered in Maitimo’s ear, stretching up to reach him, grinning with excitement. “She’s really fun and nice. You’ll like her.”

Maitimo nodded and smiled, slightly amused by the serious, almost grim look on Aranya’s face as she gathered up some medicines and bandages. She was no older than a child, shorter even than Finno, and yet she was acting like she was performing her sacred duty in the middle of a heated war in ancient times. Her cheeks were a rosy pink, and she had darker eyes than Maitimo had ever seen in a Noldo.

“Sit him down here, please,” she said, her posture poised and her voice formal. Maitimo tried not to laugh as he sat Telvo down on the bed—and struggled to extract the clingy toddler from his arms. Aranya then poured a clear, strong-smelling liquid onto a cloth and gently dabbed it on Telvo’s face. The latter squirmed and yelped, but Maitimo held his soft little hand, reassuring him it would be all right.

“Does that hurt too?” Pityo blurted out from where he stood next to Tyelko.

“Shh,” Tyelko shushed him, though his tone lacked its usual bite. “Generally, when people flinch and yell, it means they’re in pain.”

Pityo nodded sagely, looking as though some fascinating new knowledge had been revealed to him. Maitimo noticed Aranya’s lips twitch slightly as though she were trying to suppress a smile.

“You’re doing very well. The worst part is over,” she said gently to Telvo. She dipped her finger in a green poultice and rubbed it gently on his cut. “This should feel nice and cool, much more pleasant.”

The more she spoke, the more confused Maitimo became. She looked like a child, yet she spoke with the maturity and dignity of someone much older.

Before he could stop himself, he blurted out, “Excuse me, but, how is it that you are old enough to work in the healing halls?”

Aranya’s head snapped up and she regarded him with a scathing gaze, her eyes narrow and her jaw clenched.

“I am older than you, Your Highness,” she said coldly. “I would appreciate it if you would refrain from making comments about my height or my apparent youth. How would you like it if I commented about your height?”

Maitimo’s face burned all the way to his ears, and Tyelko burst out in loud laughter. Even Finno giggled too.

“Now you’ve done it, Russandol,” Tyelko wheezed between his gasps of laughter.

Ignoring them, Maitimo tried to stammer out an apology. “Forgive me, lady.” His voice chose this time to give him the most severe crack he’d had all day. He coughed and tried again. “I mean, forgive me, lady. I did not know, and I meant no offense. I was a brutish idiot to make such an assumption about you.”

“Truest thing Nelyo’s said all day,” Tyelko sniggered.

Aranya stared at him long and hard, that midnight-dark gaze seeming to bore straight into him. For a moment, Maitimo feared he had offended her beyond reparation, and he could never again show his face in the healing halls of Nolofinwë. But after far too long a moment, her grave expression cracked, and she smiled broadly. She had very soft and pink lips, Maitimo noticed.

“It’s all right, Your Highness. I… I guess I overreacted. Forgive me too, for bringing your height into it. It’s just that people mistake me for a child all the time, and they underestimate my abilities because of it. I get rather tired of it, so I reacted defensively.”

Maitimo nodded, his heart finally slowing down as relief flooded him. “I understand. It’s amazing how presumptuous and rude people can be, and I always thought I was above that, but… apparently not. You’ve taught me to never make assumptions like that again, though. But I can only imagine how much work you’ve put into your studies, and to have people think you incapable must be maddening.”

Aranya nodded slowly, and she seemed to study him for a long moment. “Yes… it is.”

She paused for another long moment, and, unbeknownst to Maitimo, Tyelko’s eyes were widening and he was elbowing Finno, trying to suppress another snicker.

But Aranya quickly turned around to face Telvo after that, and she applied some small strips of wet bandages to his face, where they would dry and stick until they were ready to be removed.

“I do have a question, though,” Maitimo said. “How do you know you’re older than me? Did you make an assumption about my age, too?”

“Of course not,” she snapped. Her voice grew cold and she scowled again, and Maitimo internally cursed himself. “All of Tirion celebrates your and your brothers’ begetting days every year. Do you think me incapable of basic arithmetic?”

Both Finno and Tyelko burst out laughing again, and as Maitimo stumbled over his words, Aranya continued, “You should go outside sometimes, Your Highness.”

Maitimo recovered his train of thought and his voice just in time to deliver a retort. “Believe me, I’d like to get out of the House sometimes, but these little rascals—” he ruffled Tyelko’s hair— “and my tyrant father with his expectations of my studies forbid it.”

Unfortunately, his retort didn’t have the humorous effect he intended. Rather than laughing, Aranya’s dark brows creased with… was that concern?

“Your father doesn’t let you go out?” she said incredulously. “And why do you have to take care of your brothers?”

“My Atar and Ammë are very busy with their own crafts. Somebody’s got to do it,” Maitimo said with a shrug. “And don’t misunderstand. My father is not saying, ‘Nelyafinwë, you are not allowed to leave this House.’ But he has taught me to prioritize my studies first and wasting time for fun later.”

“Having fun is not a waste of time. I’d like to have a word with your father,” Aranya said indignantly.

“Do you have any idea who my father is?”

“All of Valinorë knows Crown Prince Fëanáro Curufinwë, Your Highness. I’d still like to have a word with him.”

Here, it was Maitimo’s turn to laugh out loud. Aranya gave a satisfied smile and finished applying the bandage to Telvo’s face. And Telvo, apparently returning to his old self after the accident, squirmed and fidgeted impatiently. “Nelyo, can we go now?” he whined.

“Yes, I suppose so. But we will do quiet activities indoors so we don’t disturb your bandage,” Maitimo told him, scooping him up in his arms.

As they all turned to leave, he faced Aranya one more time and nodded deeply and respectfully to her. “It was a pleasure to meet you, my lady. Thank you for reminding me not to let my manners slip. I hope this won’t be the last I see of you.”

Aranya nodded, but said nothing, and she curtsied deeply. Was Maitimo imagining things, or had her cheeks flushed even pinker than before?

Little did he know that her heart was ready to hammer its way out of her ribcage. That her mind was reeling because he had called her lady. That she had not been staring at Telvo earlier, but at him.

* * *​

After a long day of socializing with the Nolofinwians and attempting to keep his brothers under control, Maitimo practically stumbled into his guest room, ready to collapse into bed. His arms and legs were sore and stiff, not just from the day’s activities, but because his bones were growing faster than his muscles.

But he noticed something slipped under his door: a carefully folded note, with no seal or any other indicator as to who it had come from.

Frowning in curiosity, he opened it to discover a note written in precise, delicate, and beautifully styled writing.

Your Highness, Prince Nelyafinwë Maitimo:

Please forgive me if this is too bold a request. If you don’t want anything to do with me because of my status, I understand. But I may regret it forever if I don’t ask.

It seems to me as though there is a sad lack of fun in your life. I imagine it must be difficult for you to get away from your brothers and your studies. But as a healer, I can assure you that never taking any breaks to have fun is Very Bad for Your Health.

One way I take breaks is by going to the woods during midday mealtime. The servants’ dining halls are usually too crowded for my taste, and full of tiresome people I don’t wish to see. I don’t know if you know of the great pond about halfway between here and your House, the one with all the water lilies and the wisteria trees. If you would ever like to join me for some peace and quiet, and possibly some fun, the invitation is open. I can’t say I know how to entertain a prince, but I should like to try.

Please burn this letter and disregard it if it offends you. You’re the one who said you’d like to see me again, after all. Did you mean it? If not, my solitude at the pond tomorrow shall be my answer.

Respectfully,

Aranya Estiel.



Notes:
Nís/níssi—singular and plural Quenya words for female Elves.
Atar—Quenya word for father.
Ammë—Quenya word for mother.
 
Last edited:
Return to top

Chapter 2: A Broken Promise

“Laurë, can I ask you a favor? It’s important.”

Makalaurë, the second oldest son of Fëanáro and the one closest in age with Maitimo, glanced up and blinked, bleary-eyed. He typically stayed up composing his songs all through the night, and Maitimo knew how he hated to get up in the mornings like everyone else. Maitimo only hoped he would have the presence of mind to remember that he had agreed to such a favor. Perhaps Maitimo should have approached him about it last night, when his mind would have been more alert.

“Of course, brother,” Laurë said, stifling a yawn.

“Will you watch the little ones, just for an hour, during midday meal, this afternoon? Hopefully there won’t be much to do, since everyone will be together in the Great Hall. But you know how they are prone to running off.”

“I know very well,” Laurë said dully. “We wouldn’t have this problem, however, if Atar and Ammë actually paid attention to us instead of arguing with each other and Uncle Nolo.”

Maitimo nodded and sighed. Their parents and uncle seemed to have argued increasingly often as of late. What exactly these arguments were about, Maitimo didn’t know for certain. He knew Fëanáro had never held great fondness for his half-siblings, the children of his father’s second wife. But Maitimo didn’t care to know the exact words passed between his parents or between his father and uncle. At home, whenever he heard the raised voices of his parents, he invited some of his little brothers into his room to play, and shut the door.

“I know,” he said to Laurë. “It’s not fair, but it is what it is. But I promise I will be available for our brothers and cousins all throughout the rest of the day, and I just need this one hour free. Then, I will ensure no one will bother you and your music.”

Laurë regarded him with a skeptical, studious gaze, surely sensing Maitimo’s desperation. “What is so important about you being gone for this one hour specifically, and missing midday meal, where everyone will notice your absence? Surely I’ll have to make up some excuse for you, won’t I?”

Maitimo shifted uncomfortably. “Tell them I needed to go home and get something.”

“During midday meal? When everyone knows you’re growing like a weed and you can’t afford to skip meals?” Laurë’s smoky gray eyes twinkled with amusement as he added, “Have some faith in me, brother. I can come up with a much cleverer excuse than the lame one you offered me. I am a writer, after all. But I feel I need some… inspiration… first.”

So, Laurë was on to him. Maitimo should have known better than to think he could hide his feelings from his closest brother. And now, his face chose to betray him by flushing red as he thought about how to explain his situation.

“Aha! There’s a nís involved, isn’t there?” Laurë smiled vindictively. “Why, Nelyo, I thought I’d never see the day when you would fall for somebody! I know the sight of any pretty nís reduces you to an awkward puddle, but to see you seek one out on purpose—”

“Keep your voice down!” Maitimo hissed, glancing anxiously at the door of Laurë’s guest room to make sure it was fully closed. But even when the Strong-Voiced of Finwë wasn’t trying to be loud, his voice often carried to every nook and cranny of the house. And who knew which little brothers or cousins might have been eavesdropping at the door?

Laurë fell silent, but his smirk remained, and he looked expectantly at Maitimo. The latter sighed and said quietly, “Don’t get too excited. There’s nothing really happening at the moment. I’m just… curious about this young lady I met yesterday. I’m afraid we didn’t get off on the right foot at first, as I insulted her by accident—”

Nelyafinwë the diplomat insulted a lady? I can hardly believe my ears! You must be hopelessly smitten with her!”

“I mistook her for being much younger than she was!” Maitimo retorted, feeling his face burn all the way to his ears. “I made the mistake of commenting on it. She’s rather sensitive to the issue and she was indignant with me for bringing it up. I want to crawl in a hole and fade from existence when I think about it. To make things worse, I was having a great deal of trouble with my voice at that moment too.”

“Oh, Timo… you poor dear.” Laurë shook his head, his mouth twitching as he struggled to suppress a smile. “Someday you’ve got to let me teach you how to properly interact with níssi.”

“I wouldn’t call your behavior towards níssi proper. You flirt with them and make them think you’re very interested in them, only to leave and never speak to them again.”

“I just like to use any available opportunity to see if my poetry has the effect I’m intending.”

“You use them for it. That’s the problem. These are real people, Kano, not playthings.”

Laurë’s gaze dropped with a faint twinge of guilt, and he was quick to change the subject. “So if you utterly humiliated yourself in front of this lady, why does she want to see you again? Why do you want to see her again?”

Maitimo shrugged, unable to come up with a rational answer to either question. “I… I don’t know. I managed to apologize appropriately to her, and she accepted it. Then, last night, I found… a note under my door. It was from her. Since I said I hoped to see her again at some point, she asked me to prove it. She says she normally takes her midday meal alone in the woods, and she invited me to join her. She also seems to think I have no fun in my life and she’d like to show me some amusement.”

Makalaurë coughed and nearly choked. His eyes widened enormously, and he struggled to catch his breath.

“I stand corrected in my earlier assessment that you are hopelessly smitten with her. I mean, you are, but she’s smitten with you too! She seems to cherish her alone time, and she invited you into it? However did you do it, Russandol? You somehow seduced her with your insults, your awkward mannerisms, your frizzy hair and your voice cracks. Forget what I said. You need to teach me how to properly interact with níssi.”

“Firstly, don’t use words like ‘seduce.’ That is crude language and I don’t appreciate it,” Maitimo said irritably. “Secondly, you’re reading into things too much. Who said she regards me that way or I regard her that way? I barely know her. I just… I truly meant it when I said I’d like to see her again, and I don’t wish her to think me flippant or insincere. She seems like… an interesting person. Maybe she’s right that I work too hard and don’t take enough breaks. I don’t have much of a social life outside of our family. What she has asked me to do sounds… nice. I would like a break from being a student and babysitter once in a while.”

Laurë gave a thoughtful hum and stared at Maitimo for a long moment. Thankfully, he didn’t try to argue the point any further.

“There’s something else you should know,” Maitimo said. “I think you will understand the need to keep this a secret from the Nolofinwians, and certainly Ammë and Atar. She’s… one of the healers who works here.”

Laurë’s eyes widened again. A mixture of emotions flashed across his face: shock, sympathy, dread. He and Maitimo were thinking the same thing: their parents would never accept Maitimo’s association with someone of such low birth.

“Maitimo,” he said softly, “you are doomed.”

* * *​

The trickiest part of sneaking out that afternoon was attempting to procure a decent amount of food without being noticed. If Maitimo were at home, he could have just gone down to the kitchen himself and packed a picnic basket, and no one would have thought anything of it. Here, though, he was not in his own House. And who knew what servants would be in the kitchen right now? Aranya herself could have been down there, for all he knew, and that would defeat the entire purpose.

And for most of the morning, he was preoccupied with his brothers and cousins, playing games with them and trying to sort out their arguments. Laurë would take no part in it, since he was strictly assigned to midday mealtime and that was all. So it was hard for Maitimo to find a moment to break away. But finally, all the brothers and cousins got distracted enough with a game that Maitimo managed to sneak away for a few minutes and summon a servant. He told her he was going home for a few hours rather than joining his family, and that he would need a meal packed. He warned her not to tell anyone of his business, which caused her to regard him with a strange look, but she did as he asked. Thankfully, the game went on long enough that Maitimo had enough time to intercept the food and sneak out to the woods without being noticed.

His heart pounded all the way as he walked to the pond Aranya had described. But what specifically he was nervous about, he wasn’t sure. Was he worried about getting caught? That he might make a fool of himself again while conversing with Aranya?

At least he was familiar with this pond, being the landmark that indicated the halfway point between the House of Fëanáro and the House of Nolofinwë. But in a way it made him worry more that someone might travel between the two Houses for some reason and see him and Aranya.

Adding to his anxiety, no one was there when he arrived.

He called Aranya’s name a few times and received no response.

He sat by the pond for a while, tossing pebbles into it, worrying that the white wine was growing too warm, or that he had been lied to or stood up. What if there was some miscommunication and he had gone to the wrong spot? Or maybe Aranya had forgotten. What if he went through all this trouble, and got Laurë all worked up, for nothing? The impossibly beautiful wisteria tree here seemed to taunt him as it dropped petals into the pond and its water lilies.

Just when he was debating whether or not he should leave, there was a rustling in the bushes, and Aranya stumbled into the clearing. She was panting and her face was flushed, and she was scowling.

Aside from the angry scowl, there was something about her that looked different from yesterday too. It took Maitimo a minute to figure out what that was, but he eventually realized it was because she was no longer covering her hair with that silvery-blue veil. It fell in bouncy waves, and even some ringlets, all the way past her hips.

“Um… hello?” Maitimo’s voice cracked, and he winced and tried again. “Hello, is everything alright?”

Aranya stared blankly at him for a second, and then the enraged look on her face faded, replaced by a look of shock. “You came,” she muttered.

“Of… course… I came,” Maitimo said, befuddled. “You asked me to.”

“Yes, and it was wishful thinking, and I didn’t actually… expect…” Aranya’s voice trailed off as she continued to stare at him. “You’re a prince. You command me. Not the other way around!”

“Did you not want me to come, then?” Maitimo couldn’t help but find himself confused and even a little irritated. Had Aranya sent him a meaningless invitation she didn’t actually want?

“Oh, no, my lord! That’s not what I mean at all. I’m so sorry. I’m shocked, that’s all. Pleasantly shocked.” Aranya’s face flushed a deep pink, and Maitimo was sure his was flushed too. She changed the subject: “It’s very good of you to come. I know how busy you are, and I’m deeply honored that you would even want to see a humble servant like me. Truthfully, I regretted putting that note under your door, and I couldn’t sleep at all last night because I was so embarrassed, and worried you might tell Arcamë I had stepped out of my place, and—”

“It’s all right,” Maitimo interrupted. “Don’t be embarrassed. I was just glad you don’t hate me for what I said yesterday, and thinking about that conversation will be what wakes me up in the middle of the night and makes me cringe.”

Aranya smiled and giggled, seemingly relieved as well. “Well, then. Enough of that, I think. I hope I didn’t keep you too long. One of the other healers—he’s one of the main reasons I don’t usually go to the servant’s dining hall—he was especially curious why I took two portions of everything today. I told him it was because of feminine reasons, hoping this would disgust him enough to make him leave. But he knows no shame, and he asked me all sorts of questions about my symptoms and my timing and—” Her eyes widened with horror. “—And I picked the absolute worst topic of conversation to have with a prince, of all people! I seemingly have no sense of shame either! I apologize, Your Highness. I promise I’m not normally like this. I suppose this conversation will keep me up and cringing tonight.”

Maitimo laughed, more relieved to discover he was not the only awkward, flustered one here than he was embarrassed by her story. “Don’t worry about it. It sounds like it was all that other healer’s fault anyway.”

“You know what? You’re right.” Aranya nodded vehemently, her eyes glinting with defiant rage. “If he had just left me alone, I wouldn’t have such a bad story to tell you. Anyway, I suppose you must be hungry. I certainly am. Let’s sit down and eat, shall we?”

Maitimo nodded, and Aranya withdrew a red and green blanket from her pack. It had a rustic look to it, being woven out of coarse strands, but it had a complex geometric design. She spread it on the ground and invited him to sit with her on it.

“I wish you’d known you didn’t need to take a double portion from the servant’s halls,” he told her, opening up his own bag. “I didn’t want to burden you, so I brought some things too.”

“Really, you didn’t have to…” Her voice trailed off as he pulled out the grapes and the flask of white wine. “Is that royal wine?”

Maitimo nodded. “I love the Nolofinwians’ white wine. It’s very light, mild and refreshing in taste. You’re welcome to it. There’s plenty enough for us both.”

Aranya sipped at it, and a smile lit her face. “Oh, I’d better be careful with that… I could drink the whole flask if I let myself. Our wine isn’t bad, but it’s more on the bitter side.”

They ended up sharing the things they had each brought, comparing their quality and taste. Maitimo was glad to see the servants’ food was all good quality, if a bit simpler and more bland than royal food. But in fact, he ended up liking the servants’ bread better than his own bread. It was heartier, with more grains, rather than the finely ground flour of the royal bread. Aranya, though, was enamored with the novelty and luxury of the royal food, and she told Maitimo she would gladly eat it all the time if she could.

And throughout their meal, their earlier awkwardness was forgotten as they chatted about the food, the weather, the landscape, and the House of Nolofinwë. As it turned out, Aranya knew the children of Nolofinwë quite well and almost saw them like her little brothers and sister.

“Perhaps I’m too familiar with my lord’s children,” she told Maitimo. “But see, I have no siblings of my own, and Finno and his siblings have always been so warm and friendly to me whenever I’ve helped them. At first, I tried to keep myself more properly mannered, not engaging with them in any games or play. But little Íri, especially… she gets lonely sometimes, being the only girl. I can understand her, too, because I wanted to be a huntress when I was her age. My parents loathe hunting, though, and they put me into healing training at a very young age so I would never be able to hunt.”

“Really?” Maitimo studied Aranya’s face, perceiving a sorrow somewhere deep in her eyes despite her attempts to keep her tone light and pleasant. “I’m sorry. I hope this hasn’t destroyed your enthusiasm for healing, because from what I can see, you are good at it.”

“Thank you… I must admit I hated healing at first for that very reason. I used to chop the limbs off my healing dolls, or etch strange designs into their skin, or rip out their hair, out of sheer spite. My parents were horrified, needless to say! They thought I was irredeemable, possibly even possessed by some sort of evil spirit. They used to bring priests and Maiar to try to cast… whatever it was out of me. But they all said the same thing. There was no dark spirit in me. Only anger. And I had a right to be angry. My parents made me take an oath I didn’t want, and this took away my one dream.”

She turned her face away suddenly. When she hastily wiped away a tear with her sleeve, he then realized she was crying.

He fidgeted uncomfortably, feeling horribly awkward and useless. Should he try to comfort her? But how?

She continued before he could respond. “A Maia of Estë came to talk to them, and this finally put some sense into… all three of us. The Maia said I didn’t have to be a healer. That I could go down a different path if I so wished. She asked my parents if they would agree to release me, and since they’re devoted followers of Estë, of course they agreed. But at the same time, the Maia asked me to give it one sincere try before giving up. I hadn’t really been trying, after all. She told me there will one day be a great deal of action, adventure and violence in the life of a healer, though today is not that day, and I have just the right fearless heart for it. So, I agreed, thinking this was my only way out.

“And… ironically enough, once I started studying under my mother’s friend Arcamë, and I got to help a young servant boy who was trampled by a horse… I realized the Maia was right. I came to love it. I was shocked by the horror of seeing broken bones and blood for the first time, but it was exciting. And watching that boy transform from pale and unconscious to lively and healthy once again… I realized that’s what I want to do. I don’t want to harm living things; I want to heal them.”

Maitimo nodded slowly, listening, fascinated by her every word. It was noble of her, he thought, to continue on this healer’s path despite having every reason not to.

“Healing and harming,” he murmured, thinking out loud. “They’re opposites, yet quite nearly the same. After all, sometimes if you want to help someone, you have to cut them open and stitch them up, which is painful.”

“Yes, exactly!” Aranya stared intently at him, smiling, her eyes wide. “You… you understand.”

Before he could figure out how to respond to that, she changed the subject. “I think I’ve done far too much rambling. What about you? What’s it like having Crown Prince Fëanáro as your father? And six little brothers? One brother would be too much for me!”

“Oh, it’s not all bad,” Maitimo said, laughing. “It just means a lot of sleep deprivation and next to no free time. I stay up well after the mingling of the lights, since it’s my only real chance to get any studying done. And then Tyelko, the blond one—you met him yesterday—and the twins, whom you met as well—the three of them like to get up before the morning mingling, and they jump on my bed till I’m awake.”

Aranya stared at him incredulously. “That… that is not enough sleep! You must be a saint, because if I were you, I’d have killed them already.”

“I don’t think you could do it. They’re just so cute. I’m always annoyed about it at first, but when I see their big round eyes and their fluffy hair and round little cheeks, I can’t bring myself to hold a grudge. Though, Tyelko’s looking more and more grown up every day, so he doesn’t really have the round little cheeks anymore. But he’ll always have the fluffy hair and big eyes, I think.”

“Hmm. Maybe.” Aranya plucked some wildflowers from the ground and twisted their stems together. “Is this a regular occurrence for you? You don’t normally get a good night’s sleep?”

“I…” Maitimo’s voice faltered. He hadn’t thought of it that way before. “I guess not. I’ve fallen asleep at the dinner table sometimes and woken up to find my brothers smashing food into my hair, or drawing designs onto my face with sauce. I guess that’s the closest I ever get to wanting to kill them.”

“If it weren’t for my oath as a healer, I’d do it for you. No matter how cute your brothers are.” Aranya smirked, and Maitimo watched in terror and fascination as her chain of flowers grew in her hands. “Next time you come out here, we won’t talk so much. We’ll eat, and then you’ll take a nap. It’s not healthy to be sleep deprived all the time, and you can tell your brothers I say that as a healer.”

“My brothers aren’t the problem, though.” Maitimo cut himself off before he could finish his thought, not really wanting to bring Fëanáro into this discussion.

Yet Aranya nodded, seeming to understand his unspoken words. “I’ve only seen a little of your father, and I can tell he’s… intense.”

“Intense,” Maitimo agreed, “and not present to manage the day-to-day operations. He seems to think we’re all grown up enough to manage without him being around much, so he’s usually in the forge or traveling.”

“And he expects you to take care of all your brothers?”

“Apparently. I remember he and Ammë were always around when Kano and I—he’s the second oldest—were small. The four of us did everything together. Atar taught us his Tengwar, and he and Ammë would take us on rides, showing us sights all over Valinorë. But I think Tyelko wore them out with his energy and rebellious temper. Moryo is stubborn, too, as is Curvo, though those two at least aren’t as active and energetic as Tyelko. But the three of them when put together are known to cause trouble. Then by the time the twins came along, I think our parents got wearied.”

Aranya hummed in sympathy, and Maitimo added quietly, “But now I’m the one who’s wearied.”

“Hence why you need a nap,” Aranya said gravely, causing Maitimo to burst out laughing. She smiled slightly, but continued, “I’m not… entirely joking. Sleep is important, especially when you’re growing as much as you are. Maybe you should lock your door so your brothers can’t wake you up before Laurelin’s first light.”

Maitimo shook his head. “No… They get nightmares sometimes, or they just feel lonely and need some cuddles during the night. Even Tyelko’s not fully outgrown that yet. I can’t… lock them out of my life. There’s just not enough hours in the day for me to take care of all six of them and myself too.”

“I’m sorry, I…” Aranya avoided his gaze, seemingly flustered again. “I guess I don’t understand what it’s like to have brothers. I didn’t mean to be insensitive. But, I’m worried about you. I wish there was something I could do to help.”

Maitimo found himself at a loss for words. He’d only ever had two conversations with this girl, and she cared about his problems that much?

But then again, he couldn’t say he didn’t feel the same way. He’d found himself thoroughly invested in her earlier woes about becoming a healer, worrying that she was forcing herself to walk a path she hated.

Before he could articulate any of these thoughts, Aranya’s eyes suddenly lit up. “Actually, there is something I can do! It can’t solve any of these big problems, but it can solve a little one.” Opening her pack, she pulled out a small vial with a thick, greenish-yellow liquid. “Oh dear, I’m worried I’m going to embarrass myself again, but… bear with me,” she said with a sigh, her cheeks reddening. “If this offends you, you can tell me to stop. But I couldn’t help but notice… you don’t seem to be properly caring for your curls.”

“Caring for my—what are you talking about?” Maitimo blinked in confusion and stared at her, while self-consciously reaching for his frizzy locks. His brothers certainly didn’t spare their teasing about how he had inherited their mother’s unruly hair. He always rolled his eyes at the comments and ignored them, though they stung a little, mainly because he had no idea how to tame all that frizz. And he was one of very, very few Noldor cursed with such a problem. The typical Noldo’s hair was black, sleek, and straight.

“I mean,” Aranya tried to explain, “you can’t just brush your hair the way most Noldor can. That breaks up the curls and makes the hair frizz up. Curly hair also needs more moisture than straight hair, and thus, you need to use some oil. That will help get rid of most of the frizz, and help the curls come out.”

Maitimo nodded slowly, very confused by this information. But it seemed to explain why his mother Nerdanel’s hair, though wild, still seemed to look better than his. He had always thought he was unlucky enough to inherit just the frizz, without the curls. But perhaps she actually had some technique for caring for it which he didn't know about.

“Can I try something?” Aranya asked, tilting her head.

“Sure…?”

Aranya seemed to hesitate for a moment before taking one of his coppery locks, rubbing a drop of oil into it, and twirling it around her finger. A sweet floral aroma filled the air as she worked with the oil. Maitimo’s heart pounded so hard, he thought it might shatter his ribcage. A nís was touching him! What was he supposed to do now?

But as Aranya finished her work, the lock of hair, no longer a limp and frizzy strand, now fell into a shining, bouncing ringlet.

“See?” she said, smiling. “I do this on my own hair. It’s not as curly as yours, but it’s not straight either. It goes limp and frizzy if I don’t.”

“That’s… how did you do that?”

She then showed him how he could do it himself, and it took him a few tries, but eventually he was able to yield a similar result. Since Aranya was faster at it, they agreed that she should treat the rest of his hair that way.

“This is really nice and all,” he told her as she finished the last section of his hair, “but practically speaking, I don’t have time for this.”

“Even if you just work a little oil into your hair without curling it around your finger, your hair still benefits from the moisture, and it’s less frizzy, and some waves and curls will form on their own,” she told him. Then, she handed him the bottle of oil. “You can keep this. I have plenty, since my mother makes it herself.”

“Thank you… I… I don’t know what to say.” Maitimo wasn’t sure how he felt about accepting a gift from someone without much wealth, especially not knowing how expensive such an oil might have been for Aranya and her family. But she had freely offered it, and Nerdanel had always told Maitimo it was rude to reject freely offered gifts. “This is very kind of you,” he added. “I hope I can do you a favor too at some point.”

“You already did by coming here when I know how busy you are, by providing me with such lovely food and conversation, and by listening to me…” Aranya smiled broadly, her dark eyes seeming to twinkle under the golden light of Laurelin. “No offense, but I didn’t know a Fëanorian could be so nice. Though I guess I should have, given how highly Finno speaks of you. And Prince Nolofinwë, too.”

Maitimo could feel his face flushing and his heart pounding. He tried to think of something decent to say in return, but all he noticed was how bright the golden tree of Laurelin was shining all of a sudden. He gasped, realizing with dread how late the hour was. “Kano’s going to kill me. I promised him he’d only have to watch the little ones for an hour, but I think it’s been much longer.”

Aranya winced too. “Arcamë must be wondering where I am… though, thankfully, the healing halls have been very quiet lately. Still, we should return. Next time we do this—if there is a next time—we should keep better track of time.”

“I would like to do this again. That is, if you would as well. Do you come here at this same time every day?”

Aranya nodded, folding up the blanket and packing away what remained of the food and dishes.

“I can’t necessarily come tomorrow. I don’t know if I can make another excuse so soon or convince poor Makalaurë to take over for me again, especially since I broke my word that I’d only be gone an hour,” Maitimo told her. “But I will come the next time I can manage it.”

Aranya’s soft pink lips turned up in a smile. “Whenever you can, I eagerly await it.” She stood and curtsied deeply. “It was a pleasure to meet you properly, Your Highness. It was very kind of you to grace me with your company.”

Something about that formal farewell didn’t sit right with Maitimo, though. Before he could stop himself, he blurted, “Please, I’d consider us friends at this point. I’m going to feel so awkward if you keep curtsying and calling me ‘Your Highness.’ Just Maitimo is fine.”

“Alright… Maitimo…” Her smile broadened. Turning back towards the woods, she muttered under her breath, “The name suits you.”

“What did you say?” Maitimo asked, having only heard indistinct muttering.

“Nothing!” Aranya’s gait turned to a skip as she disappeared into the woods. “Until next time, my prince!”

* * *​

Maitimo nearly collided with Írissë upon returning to the House.

She cut him off mid-apology. “Are you feeling better?”

Feeling better? Maitimo blinked in confusion before remembering that Laurë had to make an excuse for him. “Oh, yes, thank you,” he stammered.

“Good.” Íri’s dark stare grew confused and incredulous. “No offense, but I thought you were smart enough to know what kind of mushrooms in the forest you can eat and what you can’t.”

Maitimo sighed deeply. What a picture his brother had painted! Curse you, Kano.
 
Last edited:
Return to top

Chapter 3: Fëanorian Dodgeball

Írissë led Maitimo to the gardens, to the entrance of a complex hedge maze, marked with a carved stone archway. Maitimo was only grateful everyone was outside the maze rather than inside it; finding missing children in there was quite the puzzle, though Maitimo’s height allowed him to cheat his way through by looking over the hedges.

Laurë stood guard in front of this archway, apparently blocking anyone from going in. He looked frazzled as he supervised the children playing a battle game, with his normally sleek black hair falling in his face. His dark-circled eyes were wide and haunted. As Maitimo joined them, Laurë’s expression was flooded with relief, but it quickly turned to anger.

As Írissë ran to join Tyelko’s team, Laurë came up to Maitimo and whispered through gritted teeth, “That was most decidedly longer than an hour.”

“I know, I’m sorry. I lost track of time… But Kano, really? Mushrooms?”

Laurë’s lips twitched in a suppressed smirk. “I felt guilty about it at first, but with you taking forever to get back, I no longer feel that way.”

“No one will believe you. Everyone knows I’m competent in foraging and hunting and camping.”

“They’ve believed me so far.”

Maitimo rolled his eyes, but decided to ignore Laurë and instead begin a mental head-count of all the children. “The twins are missing,” he said flatly. That was just great; had they wandered into the maze?

Laurë ignored him and started to walk past him, but as he did so, he took one of Maitimo’s shiny new curls and fingered it with fascination. “Positively smitten, brother,” he whispered. “My time here is well past up. Have fun finding the twins and keeping everyone else together.”

Makalaurë was wonderfully sweet and sensitive until he got burned out. And he got burned out rather quickly.

As it turned out, the twins weren’t hard to find as soon as Maitimo noticed the mysteriously shaking bush, which decorated the entrance to the maze. He crawled down to try to pull them out from where they sat under the branches, but they both immediately burst into tears.

“Nelyo,” Telvo whined, “this is our safe spot.”

“We need to keep Telvo’s face safe,” Pityo added. “Everyone else is throwing rocks.”

“They’re what?” Maitimo jumped up, and ducked his head just in time to avoid getting hit in the face with a rock. Sure enough, the young ones were all hurling rocks at each other. The group seemed to be divided into Fëanorians versus Nolofinwians, with one notable exception… Írissë had turned coat and joined the Fëanorians. Though she was even younger than Curvo and just a few years older than the twins, she already had a strength and a ferocity, hurling rocks as though her life depended on it. This meant the Nolofinwians were heavily outnumbered and overpowered, since they only had Finno and his younger brother Turukáno. The two of them couldn’t stand up under the combined might of Tyelko and Íri, especially aided by Moryo and Curvo.

“Maitimo!” Finno cried, dodging rocks and shielding Turno with his body, even though Turno was nearly as tall as Finno already. “Tell Íri to come back and help us!”

Íri grinned mischievously and shook her head, hiding behind Tyelko. “Nah. I want to be on the side that wins.”

“Everyone—” Maitimo’s voice cracked, and he cleared his throat— “Everyone, put your rocks down right this second!”

Nobody listened to him, and the Fëanorian side hurled another barrage of rocks at Finno and Turukáno. Maitimo quickly realized this was going to get dangerous and out of control, so he jumped in front of Finno and urged him to move backwards. The Fëanorian team and Íri dropped their rocks in shock, since none of them wanted to hit him. “I said stop,” he said severely. Thankfully, rather than cracking, his voice dropped to a lower register, carrying an authoritative resonance with it.

All the children were silent. Then, Íri giggled, kissed Tyelko on the cheek, and ran away from him to Maitimo’s side.

“Hey! Íri!” Tyelko yelled, his pale blue eyes widening with hurt. “Where are you going?”

“To the winning side,” she said, winking at him.

“Tyelko—” Maitimo tried to find some words to explain himself, but the Hasty-Riser’s eyes hardened with anger as he stared coldly at him.

“You always side with Finno and not me!” Tyelko snapped, throwing a rock fiercely to the ground. “You said yesterday that you don’t but you were lying! Either that, or you wanted one of us to hit you with a rock so you’d have to see a certain healer.”

“Well, maybe if you would stop acting like a little brat and provoking your cousins on purpose, I wouldn’t have need to side with him over you!”

The words tumbled freely out of Maitimo’s mouth before he could think any better of them. As he realized what he said, his face paled and he clamped a hand over his mouth.

This was a more shameful thing to him than any of the voice cracks he had suffered or embarrassing blunders he had made in front of Aranya.

All the children fell into shocked silence, unused to seeing Maitimo’s anger. Tyelko stared at Maitimo calmly. Too calmly. Then, he burst into tears and ran off.

Mentally cursing himself, Maitimo turned to all the other children, who stared at him with varying degrees of shock and confusion. “Go inside and find Uncle Nolo or someone. All of you. Now. And don’t forget the twins.”

His voice came out colder than he had hoped, and his heart stung with guilt as they all scrambled to extract the twins from the bush and hurried inside. He wished he hadn’t been so harsh with them, but he needed to get them inside quickly so he could go after Tyelko.

At first, Maitimo worried Tyelko might have gone into the maze, but, knowing him, that didn’t seem likely. Tyelko didn’t have the patience for such a puzzle, and he preferred the open air anyway. So Maitimo ran around the outer edge of the maze until he spotted the little blond figure running towards the woods. He was fast for his age, and he’d had a head start, but Maitimo’s legs were much longer. It wasn’t long before he caught up with him. “Tyelko, wait,” he pleaded. “I’m deeply sorry I said that. It was wrong of me.”

Tyelko shook his head and fiercely wiped a tear from his face, and he continued to run. “You don’t mean it. You’re just trying to make me feel better so you don’t have to feel bad anymore. But I know you think I’m just an annoying brat!”

He began to pant from the effort of running, but he didn’t slow his pace, and Maitimo kept up.

“I can run longer than you,” Maitimo said calmly. “You’ll tire out before I do. Will you stop so we can talk?”

Tyelko seemed to clench his jaw, and he kept running. He held out for a surprisingly long time, until even Maitimo was starting to get a little tired. But finally, he stopped and doubled over, gasping for breath, and practically collapsed on a log. Maitimo sat carefully beside him, but not too close.

“You’re not a brat, Tyelko. I know I’ve always told you not to call people names, so it’s unfair of me to call you a name. And it’s not true, anyway.”

“Isn’t it, though?” Tyelko glared fiercely at Maitimo with reddened, tear-streaked eyes. “You’re right. I am a brat. I’m nothing but a brat to the Nolofinwians and Kano and Moryo and even Curvo. And to you. I know you must be sick of me.”

He buried his face in his hands and his body shook as he sobbed. Maitimo couldn’t think of a single good thing to say, and a knot formed in his stomach. Had he really led Tyelko to believe this about himself?

“You’re not a brat and I’m not sick of you,” he finally said. “You’re my brother, and I’ll always love you no matter what you do. I might get annoyed sometimes, truthfully. And today, I let my anger get out of control, which was the wrong thing to do. But, let me ask you something. Have Moryo and Curvo ever gotten on your nerves?”

Tyelko paused his crying long enough to think about it for a moment, and then he nodded.

“When? What did they do to annoy you?”

“Well… Moryo called Huan a big, stupid mutt when he licked his face. That’s just a kiss from Huan. It’s an honor, and Moryo called it gross. Besides, he’s not a mutt. He’s a hound of Oromë.” Tyelko’s lips curled in a pout as he recalled the memory.

“And do you still love Moryo anyway?”

“Well… yes, I suppose.”

“Why?”

Tyelko’s pale brows scrunched up as he thought about it. “I don’t really know. He and I both make a lot of mistakes, so he understands me.” He gazed at the ground and kicked a rock as he muttered, “Not like you. Everyone thinks you’re so perfect.”

“Well… I’m not perfect, am I? I failed you just now, didn’t I? I guess I can understand you a little better because of that.”

“Maybe. But that was just one time for you. It’s all the time for me.”

Maitimo paused, unsure how to respond to that, because he couldn’t exactly deny it. But he smiled as a thought came to him. “But you know what I saw in you yesterday that impressed me? Once you realized Pityo didn’t know what would happen when he hit Telvo, you were quick to understand him. You hugged him, carried him, made him feel better. I was proud of you for that.”

“Really? I think you’re just saying that. It was nothing,” Tyelko huffed. But a hint at a smile played at his lips.

“I’m not just saying that. Any time you can make someone else feel better, it’s not just nothing. I think you have a good heart, Tyelkormo. But other people can make you angry sometimes, and that happens to all of us. None of us can ever be perfect. So, can you try a little harder to be nice to our cousins? And will you forgive me for losing my temper too?”

“All right,” Tyelko said begrudgingly, and Maitimo smiled and threw his arms around him. No matter how mad Tyelko was, he could never resist a good snuggle. And sure enough, his pouty façade faded, and he grinned and hugged Maitimo in return.

And as they walked to the House, Maitimo hoisted up Tyelko on his back. Even though Tyelko staunchly declared he was getting too old for such things, he could never resist when Maitimo offered him the opportunity. And these days wouldn’t last much longer anyway. Tyelko was already getting too heavy for Maitimo to be able to do it for very long.

“You look different today, Timo. I’ve been trying to figure out what it is.” Tyelko suddenly yanked on one of Maitimo’s curls, and he yelped. Tyelko watched with satisfaction as the curl sprang back into its shape. “Your hair looks nice!”

Maitimo snorted, trying to ignore the backhanded nature of the compliment. “Thanks, Tyelko.”

* * *​

Curufinwë and Carnistir silently emerged out of the shadows of a great hallway, creeping alongside Tyelko as he trailed some distance behind Maitimo. “Well?” Curvo probed, his voice quiet and patient, yet far too mature and dignified for his age.

“Well what?” Tyelko asked.

“What was Nelyo doing earlier?” Carnistir pressed.

Tyelko muttered a curse and internally kicked himself. Then he kicked himself again, because if Maitimo had heard that, he would have forced him to make a contribution to the Swear Jar. “I uh, forgot to ask him about it.”

Carnistir groaned, his ruddy complexion seeming even deeper as his eyes narrowed. “Come on, Tyelko, you had him to yourself for a long time!”

“I was distracted. I wasn’t even thinking about why he was gone.”

Carnistir opened his mouth, but Curvo spoke before he got a chance to say anything. “That doesn’t matter anymore. Now the only logical step is to move forward. I guess we have no choice but to do this… the hard way. Are you both ready to do as we discussed?”

Tyelko and Moryo nodded somberly. Tyelko felt a bit guilty over this, in light of the moment he had just shared with Maitimo… but only a tiny bit guilty.

* * *​

After Maitimo brought Tyelko back to the House, they entered one of Nolofinwë’s sitting rooms, which was a large space with plenty of plush velvet sofas and elegant little tables intended for serving tea. Now, though, the place had pillows and toys strewn all over the floor. Tyelko ran off with Curvo and Moryo, but Maitimo was immediately greeted by Finno.

“Welcome back, Maitimo!” Finno said cheerfully. “My Atya wants to see you.”

Maitimo’s heart picked up its pace. “Am I in trouble?”

“I don’t know.” Finno shrugged, his nonchalant tone indicating he was hardly bothered by the prospect. “I told him what happened earlier. Don’t worry, he didn’t seem mad. Not to me, at least. Though, in all fairness, it can be hard to tell with him—”

“Alright, alright, I’ll go see him,” Maitimo said, unable to help being irritated with Finno for bringing up the incident to his father. Great, now he was a bother to Uncle Nolo as a result of lashing out at the children. Would he—and consequently Fëanáro and Nerdanel—think Maitimo irresponsible and immature because of this?

A sick feeling settled in his stomach as he approached Nolofinwë, who was standing in a corner of the room, folding his arms and gazing calmly over the playing children. Uncle Nolo was a tall, imposing figure, with dark hair and the same strong jawline as Fëanáro. Yet Maitimo was already close to his height.

“Ah, Nelyafinwë,” he said, his stern look softening to a warm smile. “Come with me to my study, if you would. A governess is here to watch the young ones, so you needn’t worry about that.” He nodded towards the young nís bouncing the twins on her lap, scolding Moryo as he shouted angrily at Turno. Maitimo only hoped this governess was up to the task, but he had little choice but to follow Uncle Nolo out of the room.

His heart pounded as he followed Nolofinwë down the hallways, full of massive portraits of his children and ancestors. Passing by a picture of Fëanáro, Maitimo now felt like his eyes were on him as well as Nolofinwë’s. “Am I in trouble?” he couldn’t help but blurt out after the silence drew on for an uncomfortable time.

“No, not at all, son. But what Findekáno told me had me concerned, so I thought we should talk.”

This did not completely reassure Maitimo. His nerves remained on edge even as they arrived in the study, and his uncle offered him a cup of chamomile tea. He glanced uneasily at the pristine study with books and parchment sorted neatly onto their respective shelves. Nolofinwë’s chair was exactly centered at his great oak desk. The great window lighting the room overlooked Anairë’s meticulously tended rose garden.

“Findekáno tells me you had a moment of stress and frustration with everyone earlier,” Nolofinwë said coolly as Maitimo sipped the tea. “Is this true? Can you tell me in your own words what happened?”

Maitimo, carefully avoiding the reason why he had been out, started explaining the story from the moment he arrived and met a frazzled Makalaurë. How he walked into a dangerous rock war, how Tyelko and Íri instigated conflict, and then finally how Maitimo snapped at Tyelko. He also explained how he had managed to mend the wound in his relationship with Tyelko, for now at least. Nolofinwë didn’t say a word, simply nodding, humming, and staring intently at Maitimo. For a few moments after Maitimo finished, he didn’t speak, which caused Maitimo’s heart to pound all the harder.

“It was good of you to admit your wrong to your brother,” he finally said. “Many parents, myself included, struggle to admit their wrong to someone much younger, especially their own children. When you are a father one day, I believe your humble heart will keep your children close to you.”

Maitimo tried to smile, but his heart was still not at ease, as he still expected a rebuke at some point.

“It is not lost on me,” Nolofinwë continued, “how you have selflessly risen to the challenge of caring for all these children, even my own children. This has been invaluable to me, as it has afforded me the chance to connect with your father. Or try to, anyway.” He paused, frowning slightly and gazing into the distance, but the moment quickly passed and he shook his head. “Anyway. I suppose it didn’t occur to me that you have not had a moment’s rest from it, and I apologize for my thoughtlessness there. See, you are only the stuff of the earth, Nelyafinwë, and such a burden would cause anyone to eventually lose their temper, no matter how patient and enduring their temperament. Enduring tempers are often asked to endure much. Too much.”

Maitimo stared intensely at his teacup, hoping Nolofinwë wouldn’t see the tears welling up in his eyes.

“Is this common for you at home?” Nolofinwë asked quietly. “I noticed none of us gave you the order to watch the children. You just did it, as though it is everyone’s expectation of you, and your expectation of yourself.”

Maitimo nodded, still avoiding his uncle’s gaze. He managed to hold the tears back enough to speak. “Yes, Uncle. My parents are so frequently absent, and my brothers do not respect nurses or governesses. Perhaps I enable my parents by taking responsibility for the children upon myself, but what else am I supposed to do? I can’t let them run around unfed, unbathed, and uneducated. And if I dare raise a complaint to my parents… I don’t even want to find out how Atar would react.”

Given the way Fëanáro would lash out at a servant for simply bringing him the wrong type of wine, Maitimo would never dare to bring up such a sensitive topic as a complaint about Fëanáro’s absence as a father.

Nolofinwë nodded in understanding. “You should not have to initiate such a conversation with your father and lord. I would like to speak up on your behalf about this, though I’ll warn you, he doesn’t listen much to me either. But at least I am more like a peer to him. Really, we ought to get your mother or grandfather to see your plight. They are the only ones who have any influence over your father’s heart.”

“And Ammë’s influence is dwindling,” Maitimo sighed. “I hear her and Atar fight so often now… My bond with her is close. Or, it used to be, anyway. She would see my heart on this, but she is burdened herself, and I can’t bring myself to add this to her troubles.”

“Still, she has a greater responsibility than you do to care for these children.” Nolofinwë paused for a moment, seeming to think. “I will personally ensure you will have a break tomorrow for the entire day. If I have to watch all the children myself, so be it. But I will try to involve your parents as well.”

Maitimo blinked at him, barely able to believe what he had just heard. Was Uncle Nolofinwë really offering something so generous?

“I… I don’t know what to say. Thank you, Uncle. I love my brothers and your children, and I don’t begrudge my duties to them. But it would be nice to have a day off, I will admit.”

He immediately thought of Aranya. She wasn’t exactly busy at the healing halls, so maybe she could take a longer break than usual… If only he had some way of talking to her in private before then, or at least sending a note. But she would have slept in the communal servant’s quarters, so any note he would have sent her would potentially be seen by all the servants.

Nolofinwë nodded, smiling slightly. “One last thing, Nelyafinwë. I notice you did not tell me the reason for your earlier absence, and I don’t believe it was mushroom poisoning. That is fine. Your business is your business. But I’m fairly certain you would like to have more free time for whatever it was, or whomever it was, yes?”

Maitimo’s entire face blushed bright red, and Nolofinwë chuckled heartily and clapped him on the shoulder.

“Go have your fun, nephew,” he said, his eyes twinkling. “You’re only young once.”

* * *​

Maitimo and Nolofinwë returned to find the poor governess completely overwhelmed by the nine children, scrambling to break up a fight between Tyelko and Finno, while the twins giggled and tugged on her skirt. Curvo and Íri looked all too interested in some high shelves with delicate glassware, and they were piling some books up on a couch. Maitimo and Nolofinwë worked together to sort out those potential disasters, and before they knew it, it was time to round everybody up for supper.

Maitimo found it interesting how much easier it was to manage all the children with just one other competent person around.

If only Atar and Ammë would work together to take care of everyone, like they used to, he thought. But somewhere deep down, he knew this was a vain hope.

After supper, everyone else took to some card games and word games. Maitimo didn’t entirely feel like watching Fëanáro practically tear out Uncle Nolo’s throat for the sake of his fierce competition over these things—especially since Fëanáro had invented most of these word games—and besides, Maitimo’s weariness was catching up with him after several short nights of sleep. Since his brothers especially needed some extra cuddles while staying at an unfamiliar house, Maitimo certainly wasn’t about to lock them out, so he anticipated his usual wake-up ceremony from Tyelko and the twins before Laurelin’s first light. This way, at least he had a chance of catching up on some sleep.

Lost in his own thoughts, he stumbled into his dark guest room… and then he yelped as something heavy knocked him to the floor. A pair of warm hands closed around his wrists and pulled them behind his back, and somebody slipped a black cloth around his eyes. Three pairs of arms then hoisted him up and onto a chair, and then bound his wrists with rope.

Maitimo sighed. Another interrogation.

“Nelyafinwë,” said the cool voice of Curufinwë, “your behavior as of late has been suspicious. It is not typical for you to disappear during midday meal, since it is the most active time of day for the household. And we know you didn’t really get mushroom poisoning. We have determined you were up to something, and we find Kanafinwë’s excuse for you to be logically unsound.”

“Right,” Tyelko piped up. “First of all, there’s no mushroom I know of that causes sickness for exactly two hours. Second of all, you’re the one who taught me this, and you even stop me from trying the hallucinatory ones when we’re out camping.”

Curvo gave a hum of agreement. “We find it insulting to our intelligence to believe you could be so stupid all of a sudden.”

“So, what do you have to say for yourself?” Carnistir demanded. Maitimo could vaguely make out the orange glow of a lantern behind the blackness of the blindfold.

Curvo sighed in annoyance. “You were supposed to whip off the blindfold first and then shine the lantern in his face, Moryo.”

“Oh. Right,” Moryo said softly and sheepishly. “Should I do it now?”

“No! Not now that he knows the tactic! Just forget it.”

Though Curufinwë was the youngest of the three, a mere child nowhere near adolescence, he was the most calculated of the bunch and formed most of their plans.

“I’m very impressed with your intimidation tactics,” Maitimo told them. “Much improved since last time. But I will never talk.”

There was a long, drawn out silence before Carnistir growled, “Wrong answer.”

Maitimo heard some more shuffling movement before a cupful of ice-cold water splatted onto his lap, and he yelped.

“Feel that?” said Tyelko. “There’s a lot more where that came from. How would you like it if one of your pretty new curls took that?”

Maitimo cringed, but gritted his teeth and said nothing. Joke’s on you, he thought. Aranya can do my hair like that again tomorrow, suckers. The most unpleasant part would be enduring the icy temperature of the water, but he’d endure it for the sake of protecting the lady’s identity.

“You rascals are going to ruin Uncle Nolo’s furniture, and he’s not going to be happy about it,” he said dully.

“You really think we’re going to dump a bucket on you or something?” Curvo huffed in annoyance. “Come on, Nelyo, we’re not stupid. No. All we have to do is dip your hair in the bucket, one curly lock at a time, if and until you talk.”

“Which I won’t, so you might as well not waste your time.”

There was another tense silence before Curufinwë said coldly, “So be it.”

At least the brothers spoke the truth in that they didn’t dump their bucket of cold water right on Maitimo’s head. Maitimo felt them grab one of the locks, and then he felt a couple of cold droplets on his shoulder and chest. Tyelko took off the blindfold long enough for Maitimo to see the sad, limp lock, and then he replaced the blindfold.

“Any change of heart?” Tyelko asked.

Maitimo shook his head, refusing to say another word.

So the brothers continued to soak his hair in the cold water one lock at a time, continually probing him with questions, but he refused to answer any of them. It wasn’t long before he began to shiver as the wet hair clung to his chest and back, and by the time the brothers were done, his teeth were chattering. But his lips remained sealed.

The three brothers exchanged an unnerved glance. Normally, Maitimo readily told them whatever he was up to, sometimes even spoiling surprises he planned for their begetting days. And their ruining his hairstyle was perhaps the meanest and most unpleasant thing they’d done so far, yet he still wouldn’t talk.

“Clearly I’m not going to tell you anything,” Maitimo said between shivers. “Can you leave me alone now and let me clean up? And warm up?”

The brothers whispered to each other before Curvo muttered, “I suppose.”

Was it just Maitimo’s imagination, or was that a twinge of guilt in his voice?

The brothers removed his blindfold and untied his wrists. Tyelko, avoiding Maitimo’s gaze, handed him a dry towel. Maitimo sighed with annoyance, squeezing the water out of his hair as his brothers all silently filed out of the room.

“What was that?” Moryo whispered as they walked down the hallway. “Normally he lets us practice our tactics at first, and he puts on a stubborn show of resistance before eventually talking. Why didn’t he talk this time? It must be serious.”

“I think… I think it’s a girl,” Tyelko said, his voice and eyes somber.

Moryo and Curvo scoffed at him, but he continued, “Think about it! We all know he acts strangely around níssi. It has to be the only explanation. Besides,” he lowered his voice and grinned widely, “I think I know who it is. I saw him, yesterday, become an absolute awkward wreck in front of somebody.”

“Well then,” said Curvo, “there’s only one way to find out for sure.”
 
Last edited:
Return to top

Chapter 4: Everything and Nothing

“Nelyo! Nelyo! Wake up, sleepyhead!”

Maitimo awoke the next morning to the familiar sound of the Ambarussar and Tyelko giggling, and the sensation of his mattress jostling as all three of them jumped on his bed. Then, the twins bumped into Tyelko, who irritably shoved them away—and they both fell on top of Maitimo.

“It’s too early for this,” Maitimo groaned, gently pushing the twins to his side and pulling a blanket over his face. The silver light of Telperion still shone through the cracks between the curtains, and only a few faint traces of Laurelin’s gold dotted the walls.

“That’s what you say every morning,” Tyelko huffed, yanking the blanket away from Maitimo’s face. “You would sleep all day if you could. Come on, we just need to wake up Finno and then we can go hunting. Don’t take forever to do your hair or whatever! We still have some nocturnal prey to catch! And can we leave the twins here this time? They’re so noisy.”

“We’re not noisy,” Telvo yelled.

Maitimo eagerly awaited the day when Tyelko was old enough to go hunting by himself. If he could just prove his worthiness to Fëanáro and get that bow, Maitimo wouldn’t have a problem sending him out alone with Huan.

“Tyelko, I’m sorry, but today’s my day off. Uncle Nolo promised me he or Atar and Ammë would take care of you all today. Go find one of them and ask them to take you hunting.”

A thick silence drew out for a painfully long moment. Maitimo forced his heavy eyelids to crack open, and he looked on Tyelko with his blue eyes enormous and welling up with tears. The twins stared at Maitimo with confusion and curiosity.

“Do you not like me anymore?” Tyelko whimpered.

“Of course I like you, hannacë.” Maitimo rubbed his eyes and tried to smile. “But sometimes, I need a break to do some things by myself.”

“Like what?” Tyelko huffed. “Seeing a certain healer? I bet you like her better than me.”

“Like sleeping,” Maitimo said bluntly. “Right now, we want different things. You want to hunt, and I want to sleep. And Uncle Nolo promised me I’d have a day off. It doesn’t mean I don’t like hunting with you. I promise I’ll do it tomorrow. But for now, you can either go find our parents or Uncle Nolo, or you can stay here with me if you cuddle gently and quietly.”

“Yay! Cuddle with Timo!” the twins cheered. They promptly burrowed themselves under the blankets next to Maitimo, and remained surprisingly still and quiet, save for the occasional giggle.

Tyelko, though, clearly disgruntled, huffed loudly and left the room, slamming the door behind him.

Maitimo didn’t respond and closed his eyes. As much as he tried to shower the needy Tyelko with love and attention, there were also times when the Elfling needed to learn to be a little less self-absorbed. Maitimo did not feel guilty about this interaction.

Besides, the little twins snuggling up on either side of him filled his heart with warmth. It wasn’t long before he fell back asleep.

* * *​

By the time Maitimo woke up, the twins were gone. And the golden light of Laurelin streamed through his curtains at full strength.

He bolted upright. It was almost midday! And his hair was a disaster!

Aranya would be able to fix it later, but he couldn’t show his face in front of her with his hair matted, frizzy, and swept up in all directions. He hastily got dressed and tried to sort out some of the worst tangles, but he didn’t have time to detangle all of it, so he wrestled it into a braid. He just barely remembered to send for some bread, cheese and wine from the kitchen before hurrying out.

Unfortunately, he was a little late getting to the spot. Aranya sat by the pond, eating her meal, looking thoughtful yet vaguely disappointed as she gazed into the distance. Some of the petals from the wisteria tree fell into her hair, and her reflection in the glassy pond rippled gently under the slight breeze.

She didn’t seem to notice Maitimo as he stepped into the clearing. Not wanting to startle her, he cleared his throat.

Aranya screamed, jumped up, dropped her piece of bread into the pond, and cursed. Then she glanced up at Maitimo and smiled awkwardly.

“I’m so sorry,” Maitimo stammered, blushing to the tips of his ears. “I was trying not to startle you, but I was unsuccessful—”

“It’s—it’s all right.” Aranya’s face flushed too as she hastily swept breadcrumbs off her skirt. “It’s my fault. I was lost in my own thoughts instead of paying attention to my surroundings.”

“No, it’s not your fault. You had no way of knowing I would come. And I’m sorry about your food. I brought plenty, so you’re welcome to it.”

Aranya smiled as he opened up his bag and wine flask. “You brought that white wine and bread again? Oh, Maitimo, you’d better be careful. You’re going to spoil me. I’ll soon grow to hate the bread and wine in the servant’s hall.”

“Well then, we can trade. Next time, assuming I don’t make you drop your food into the pond, that is. I rather like the bread they give you.”

“You’re just making that up,” Aranya said, scrunching up her nose in distaste. “I hate the texture. It’s so grainy.”

“That’s actually what I like about it. It’s healthier, I think, than this white flour where all the nutrients are ground to oblivion.”

Aranya’s skeptical eyes told Maitimo she wasn’t convinced. Then, her smirk faded and her eyes widened. “What happened to your hair?”

“My brothers ruined it.”

“I will kill your brothers,” Aranya said solemnly, fingering the fraying, frizzy tail of his braid as tenderly as though she were mourning a friend. “If I had siblings who ruined my hair, I’d kill them, at least. No matter, I can fix it again now. But don’t you remember the way I showed you to do it?”

“Yes, but I didn’t have time. Speaking of which, I understand if you can’t stay here very long, since I came late.”

Aranya motioned for him to sit on the grass, and he pulled the bottle of oil out of his pocket and handed it to her. “Don’t worry about it. The healing halls have been quiet today, save for a certain nér talking my ear off. It’s amazing how he manages to say nothing of substance with so many words. So I’m not eager to return, and I can assure you, I will only really be missed by people I don’t much care to talk to.”

She began to rub the oil into his hair and shape the curls, and before he knew it, he was telling her all about the events since their last meeting: from the rock war to the interrogation to the way he managed to secure himself a chance to sleep in.

“You slept in? Maitimo, I’m so proud of you!” Where most people might have meant such words in a sarcastic or joking manner, Maitimo could detect no insincerity in Aranya’s voice or countenance. “I didn’t think you would take my advice,” she continued. “Most people don’t. Most people dismiss my thoughts as overly passionate or unimportant. Or else they think I’m a child and they don’t take me seriously.”

“I’m still very sorry and embarrassed I made that mistake,” Maitimo mumbled.

“Oh, it’s all right. You learned your lesson, which, like I said, most people don’t.”

“Well, I wish I could heed your advice all the time,” Maitimo sighed. “It certainly felt nice to sleep in, but it won’t become a regular thing. I’m lucky because the adults are taking care of the children today and working hard to give me a day off.”

His voice trailed off as he wondered what had happened to Tyelko and the twins after they had tried to wake him up. And was it Fëanáro and Nerdanel, or Uncle Nolofinwë and possibly Aunt Anairë, taking care of the children? Whoever it was, Maitimo only hoped they were up to the challenge.

* * *​

“Ambarussar, this is a midday meal, not a food fight!” Nolofinwë stood from his chair at the head of the table and hurried to break up the twins, who were scattering peas and shoving mashed potatoes into each other’s faces. They both giggled hysterically, with the creamy bits of mashed potato sticking all over their faces and clinging to their copper hair. And when Nolofinwë wet a cloth and tried to wipe away the mess, both the twins burst into tears.

“Where’s Timo?” one of the twins whined, flinching away from Nolofinwë’s touch. In all honesty, Nolofinwë still could not tell the twins apart. Maitimo seemed able to do it, but how he distinguished them, Nolofinwë had no idea. Maybe he should have asked him yesterday when he offered to watch the children, because now, the other sons of Fëanáro seemed to know he couldn’t tell them apart, and they scoffed and snickered at him when they thought he wasn’t watching. But alas, Nolofinwë had never been responsible for so many children at once before, and so he’d had no idea he needed to plan for such things ahead of time.

Nelyafinwë is taking some time for himself today,” Nolofinwë said calmly, though he wasn’t sure how much of those words the twins would process. “In the meantime, let me help you.”

A yelp from Írissë startled him, and he turned to see Turukáno yanking on her raven-black locks. “Íri started it!” Turno cried, paling under his father’s stern glare. “She was yelling at me!”

Nolofinwë sighed. If this was what his eldest nephew put up with every day, no wonder he was consistently stressed and exhausted.

“Atar,” Findekáno said quietly, gently tugging on the flowy blue sleeve of Nolofinwë’s robe.

“What is it?” Nolofinwë’s voice came out a little testier than he intended.

Finno dropped his gaze, seemingly with guilt. “Have you seen Tyelko, Moryo and Curvo lately? I haven’t seen them since before midday meal.”

Nolofinwë gazed around the room and sighed again. The middle three children of Fëanáro were indeed missing. But what could he do? Leave the room to Kanafinwë’s care and go out and look for them? The quiet poet had already cared for the younger children in Maitimo’s stead yesterday, and he was not very well suited for the task.

“We will look for them after everyone has finished eating. I’m sure they’ll turn up,” Nolofinwë said, returning to his work in wiping the mashed potatoes off the twins’ faces.

* * *​

Maitimo shook himself out of his thoughts, telling himself the children were not his responsibility today, for once in his life. “I’m afraid my life will go back to normal from tomorrow onwards,” he explained to Aranya, “and I can’t promise I’ll be able to get away and see you again anytime soon. Though I will certainly try my hardest.”

“Your hardest?” Aranya paused her work, and moved over to face Maitimo. She had a strange, wide-eyed look on her face, somewhere between incredulous and perhaps moved. “You would... try your hardest, in light of your brothers and your studies and everything else, to come see me, a random healer you’ve only known for two days?”

Maitimo’s mind blanked. Was this some sort of a trick question? Girls were good at that sort of thing. “Yes...?” he hesitantly answered.

“Why?”

Maitimo’s heart took off. How was he supposed to put all his thoughts and feelings into words? And worse, what if he somehow offended or scared Aranya in trying to explain it?

As he sorted through his thoughts in a panic, Aranya must have noticed his terrified expression because she blushed and added, “I’m sorry. I didn’t mean to put you on the spot. I’m just a little shocked and confused that someone as important as you, with such important things to do, would bother spending your time around someone like me. I’m curious why, that’s all. But maybe I shouldn’t have asked. I’m sorry, Your Highness.”

“No, no,” Maitimo said quickly. “Don’t be sorry. The thing is... just because you’re a healer, it doesn’t mean you’re less important than anyone else. Truthfully, I’ve never... felt about anyone else the way I feel about you.”

Aranya raised her dark eyebrows, and Maitimo’s heart pounded, but he forced himself to keep going. “Yesterday’s picnic was... like a breath of fresh air for me. I rarely get a chance to just relax and talk to somebody who cares about my life, as you know. And you’re very interesting to talk to. You’re knowledgeable about many subjects. And I don’t understand people who think you’re too passionate because I think that’s wonderful. And you’re... kind. Genuinely kind. Though you do scare me a little with your threats towards my brothers. It makes me dearly hope I won’t fall out of your good graces.”

As he spoke, Aranya’s smile widened more and more. At Maitimo’s last few words, she burst out giggling. And her cheeks were deeply flushed.

“That’s—” she twirled a lock of her own hair around her finger, seemingly nervously, but then her gaze grew serious— “That’s one of the nicest things anyone’s said to me.”

“Are people very unkind to you?” Maitimo asked, alarmed. “I only said what is true.”

“No, no… I didn’t mean it like that. But,” she sighed and gazed off into the distance, “that nér I’ve told you about who always follows me around in the healing halls, he doesn’t know about any of my passions. If I told him about them, he wouldn’t understand them. And sometimes… I don’t think I’m particularly kind. I’m often told I judge people too harshly and my anger is too fierce. Perhaps once you get to know me better, if you would like to, anyway, you will come to agree.”

The suddenly sorrowful look in Aranya’s deep eyes, and the way her posture sagged slightly, made Maitimo yearn to throw his arms around her and tell her everything would be all right. Maybe he would have if he thought she would appreciate it, and it wouldn’t scare her off.

So instead, he resorted to mere words, hoping they would soothe her heart at least a little. “I’d like to prove them wrong, then. Because if you were unkind, you’d have no reason to be concerned with my life and problems any more than your duties command. You have no obligation to offer me your only time of solitude during the day, yet you do it anyway. Besides, I think it’s good and healthy to have some skepticism of the motives and character of others. My Atar says I like too many people who don’t deserve to be liked. I disagree with him, because I believe he is referring to people who have only ever been good and kind to me. But still, perhaps he has a point. Not everybody deserves to be liked.”

“Not everybody deserves to be liked… That, I do agree with.” Aranya’s eyes took on a fierce glare as she added, “Though I don’t like hearing your father tell you you’re too kind. He’s taking your strength and acting as though it is a weakness. I wish I could like everybody the way you seem to, because to be perfectly honest, your father and brothers would drive me insane after a few minutes, by the sound of it. But please, don’t allow him to harden your heart. I… I rather like your heart.”

She lightly touched his chest, and they both blushed furiously.

“But since you say you will try your hardest to see me,” Aranya said quickly, as though trying to cover up that brief awkwardness, “I promise the same in return. I will do my best to come to this same spot every day, at this precise time, and be vigilant in watching for you. If my work day is light, I’ll tarry here a little longer in case you’re late. Because… I want to keep seeing you, and getting to know you, too.”

Maitimo realized at that moment he had been tense ever since Aranya asked him why he wanted to make an effort to see her, and only now did he feel his muscles relax. Though he hadn’t consciously realized it, his heart had longed to hear Aranya express desire to see him in return.

* * *​

Maitimo and Aranya talked for well over an hour after that, staying well past the time she was normally allowed to take for her break. But eventually, she admitted Arcamë would get worried if she didn’t return soon, and they parted ways.

Maitimo lingered by the pond for a while after she left, so he wouldn’t be seen returning with her. Besides, he couldn’t even remember the last time he had been alone in nature with nothing to do except think.

And as he blankly watched the soothing, repetitive motion of the rippling pond, he realized he was already counting down the hours until he could see Aranya again.

If it couldn’t be tomorrow, it had to be the day after. He wasn’t sure he could bear it otherwise. Perhaps it was healthy, anyway, that he had just one hour a day built into his schedule where everyone knew he was not to be disturbed. Every other hour of his day, he gave to his family or his studies. Why not have just one for himself and Aranya?

He took his time in returning to the House, absorbing the sight of every moss-coated stone and rustling tree he passed. Normally he was in such a frantic hurry all the time, trying to keep track of six children, so he almost never got a chance to simply enjoy the beauty of these Blessed Lands.

But after taking this leisurely time alone, he realized he didn’t want to spend the rest of his day like this; that sounded too lonely. So upon re-entering the House, he followed the noise until it led him upstairs to the guest rooms, where his brothers were hurrying around, stuffing clothes and toys into their bags.

Maitimo blinked in confusion. They were supposed to stay at the House of Nolofinwë another three days, at least.

“What’s going on?” he asked Laurë, who was carefully unstringing his lyre and trying to shoo off Curvo, who seemed all too interested in the mechanics of the instrument.

Laurë sighed. “Atar just came and told us we’re leaving tonight. I’m not sure what happened, but I think he and Uncle Nolo must have had a fight.”

Maitimo shook his head in disgust. “I wonder who started that one,” he said dryly. Laurë nodded in agreement and rolled his eyes.

Why must Fëanáro be such an embarrassment? Why must he scorn the hospitality of the good Nolofinwians? Yes, Fëanáro had some real, legitimate hurt in his heart from the way his father had doomed his mother to an eternity in Mandos by marrying Indis. But for the Valar’s sake, Nolofinwë had not chosen the means of his conception and birth, and he’d had unimaginable patience and tolerance his whole life for the outbursts of Fëanáro. All he had ever wanted was for his older brother to love him, and Fëanáro had shown him nothing but contempt.

“You two always side with Uncle Nolo,” Curvo griped, scowling as Laurë shoved away his hand yet again from the lyre. “We don’t know what happened, as Kano said. Why assume it’s Atar’s fault, then? That’s illogical.”

Laurë looked faintly annoyed, but Maitimo couldn’t help but chuckle. “You’ve got a very clever brain in your head, Curvo. You raise a good point. It would be wiser for us to withhold our judgment until we know the full story.”

Curvo did not visibly react to the praise, and he changed the subject. “Speaking of stories… come to my room, quickly, before everyone else sees you. We have some urgent matters to discuss.”

Maitimo laughed again, but Curvo’s scowl darkened, and he grabbed Maitimo’s wrist and led him away. “Don’t laugh. This is serious.”

“Am I being interrogated again?” Maitimo asked, trying to put on an air of grave somberness.

“Well… technically, no. But you’d do well to think of it as such.” Curvo hurried with Maitimo across the hall and into his guest room, before anyone else had a chance to see them. As Curvo slammed the door shut and locked it, Tyelko and Moryo jumped out from behind the bed.

“I’m not going to continue our conversation from last night, if this is what you’re after,” Maitimo said dryly.

“Oh, no… we don’t need to!” Moryo grinned broadly. “We saw you… with her.”

Tyelko and Curvo both snickered, and Maitimo’s eyes widened.

“With whom?” he asked innocently, just in case there was some misunderstanding and they hadn’t seen him with Aranya, but rather with someone else. Even though that wasn't logical, because Aranya was the only female he'd seen today.

“With that really pretty healer girl,” Tyelko said. “Aranya. The one you thought was younger than me, but she’s actually older than you.”

Maitimo winced. “Keep your voices down! Don’t you understand, people can’t know about this? After all, I don’t care what anyone thinks of me, but she could get in trouble. You teasing me is one thing, but to put a poor innocent lady out of her job for no reason is unforgivably cruel.”

“Nelyo, Nelyo. We’re not stupid.” Curvo rolled his eyes and huffed dramatically, as though he were explaining a simple concept to a toddler. “We won’t tell anyone, not even Atar and Ammë… but we have some conditions for our secrecy. I think you’ll find them quite reasonable.”

“I want your desserts for a week,” Tyelko piped up. Then, his face scrunched up as he seemed to think for a moment. “Actually, no. A month.”

“Tyelko,” groaned Moryo, “what did we say about keeping our demands reasonable? He won’t agree if it’s too ridiculous.”

“Okay, fine,” Tyelko muttered. “Just a week, then.”

Maitimo shook his head. “Tyelko, that is far too much sugar for one little Elfling. It’s not healthy. Besides, you will never go to sleep at a reasonable hour if you get a double portion of dessert, so that makes my life all the harder.”

Tyelko pouted and looked ready to throw a fit, but Curvo leaned over and whispered something in his ear. Then, his bright blue eyes lit up. “Fine, then… how about you give me a full-sized bow to practice with? And let me go hunting by myself without the twins?”

Maitimo nodded slowly, considering this. “I can’t do that without Atar’s permission, but I’ll make you a deal. I’ll talk to him about it, and I’ll do my very best to persuade him that you’re getting big and responsible enough for this.”

At first, Tyelko looked disappointed, but Curvo nodded in approval. “Nelyo’s good at persuading people, Tyelko. This is a good deal. You should accept it.”

“Alright. Deal,” Tyelko said begrudgingly.

Moryo, who had been looking impatient throughout all this negotiation, burst out, “My demands are simple. I just want ten gold coins.”

Maitimo nodded reluctantly. Ten gold coins was a sizable amount of money for any Elfling to have, but Moryo was surprisingly clever, often using whatever money he could scrounge up to start a trade system or some sort of deal. One time, he had given a gold coin to Curvo for him to buy metals with, and told him whatever he made, he was to sell and give Moryo the proceeds. Maitimo figured this would be a good way for him to refine his skills even further.

“Deal,” Maitimo said.

“Why was that so easy for you, Moryo?” Tyelko whined. “Giving me his desserts would have cost him nothing. He doesn’t even finish his desserts most of the time!”

“Because it’s about more than just money most of the time,” Moryo replied. “There are other factors such as time and convenience. Nelyo did say giving you his desserts would be inconvenient for him because you’d be bouncing off the walls all night, and he thinks it’s bad for you. Whereas for me, he just gives me the money and he’s done. And he knows me having more money is not bad or unhealthy for me.”

Curvo cleared his throat and spoke up. “And I wish to read the last five essays you wrote for Atar.”

Maitimo blinked in confusion. What were those last five essays even about? With his life constantly being a hectic blur of stress, he could barely recall writing any essays lately. He vaguely remembered one of them evaluating a law designed to ensure fair trade in commerce between Tirion and Alqualondë. Another was a brief history of the linguistic development of Quenya. None of it was particularly thrilling stuff, especially not to someone so young as Curvo.

“Why in all Arda do you want to read my schoolwork?” he asked, befuddled. “Those essays are not exactly on very exciting topics. I barely even remember writing them.”

Curvo bristled and folded his arms, his eyebrows scrunching in a faint scowl, seemingly offended by the question. “Because it’s information, Nelyo. I figure there’s a reason why Atar asked you to write all those things. And you are a good researcher, the best of all of us, and a skilled writer too. I trust the information you present will be thorough, objective, and clearly articulated.”

Maitimo tried not to smile at the praise embedded within the request. “Alright, fair enough. If you’re that interested in my essays, you can read whichever five you choose. But in addition to your secrecy, there is one other thing I ask of all of you. I will not give you these things unless you agree to it.”

The three brothers exchanged a glance, and reluctantly nodded.

“How did you find out about me and Aranya? Did you follow us or something? If that’s the case, don’t do it again. It’s our private time, and I want to be able to talk to her in peace without worrying if I’m being spied upon.”

Tyelko snorted. “Oh, I get it. You just want to be able to say mean things about us in secret.”

“In all fairness, that was Aranya, not Nelyo,” Curvo coolly pointed out. “She’s the one who wants to kill us for messing up Nelyo’s hair, which is honestly fair. Nelyo actually defended us to her, when he didn’t have to.”

“I don’t want to watch you and her together again anyway,” Moryo added. “You two are so boring. Doing nothing but talking while she does your hair… it was making me sick.” He made a gagging noise, and Curvo snorted with laughter, and even Tyelko cracked a smile.

“So it’s safe to say, we’ve seen what we need to see, and we don’t have interest in watching any more of it,” said Curvo with a confident nod. “As long as you hold up your end of the deal.”

“Oh, I will,” Maitimo said, relieved that this was resolved with such apparent ease. Still, he’d have to be extra watchful for any signs of sneaky little brothers next time.

* * *​

The rest of the evening was a hassle as Maitimo helped his brothers pack their things, and he barely had enough time to pack his own things as a result, but thankfully, Laurë helped him finish that up. Then, it was time for them to meet their parents at the front gate and say goodbye to the Nolofinwians.

Finno looked melancholy as he hugged Maitimo goodbye. “I wish you didn’t have to leave so early.”

“I know, Finno,” Maitimo sighed. “I wish things didn’t have to be this way. But hopefully, I’ll see you again sometime soon.”

After all, if he was going to regularly sneak halfway out to the Nolofinwians’ house, maybe he could go all the way and visit the family on occasion, without the stress of all the brothers or Fëanáro.

“I know there were a lot of us at once, and it’s kind of unfair that you had to be in charge of everybody all the time,” Finno said. “But for what it’s worth, I still had a great time with you, especially when we went hunting with Tyelko. Maybe when I’m old enough, and your brothers are old enough that you don’t have to watch them all the time, just the two of us can go hunting.”

Maitimo smiled at his little cousin’s sincere eagerness. “I would like that. In the meantime, keep practicing with your bow and arrow, alright?”

Then, he glanced up and noticed Nolofinwë motioning for him to come over, so he did so. Nolofinwë whispered in his ear, “I’m sorry, Nelyafinwë, but I didn’t get a chance to speak to your father about the matters we discussed. An argument came up between us regarding an unrelated issue, so I figured if I brought this up, it would only backfire.”

Maitimo’s heart sank a little, but he agreed with his uncle’s reasoning. “I understand. And I’m sorry about him.”

Nolofinwë smiled faintly and shook his head. “No need to apologize to me for something you did not do, and besides, we both had a hand in the fight. I’m sorry for my own part in it, and that the situation escalated the way it did. But I hope to see you again soon, nephew. And if you get a chance to see your grandfather, he may be much more helpful to you than I am.”

Maitimo nodded, conflicted. His grandfather Finwë was one of the kindest Eldar he knew, but should he really burden the King of the Noldor with his little troubles with his father and brothers? Besides, Fëanáro could do no wrong in Finwë’s eyes. Maitimo was reluctant to bring up anything even slightly negative about him.

But Nolofinwë embraced him firmly. And after everyone in both the families had completed their farewells, the House of Fëanáro all mounted their horses and rode off.

Fëanáro looked like a king himself as he led the group, mounted on his sleek black stallion. His cloak of scarlet velvet draped over the stallion’s flank, his chiseled chin was lifted high, and his ice blue eyes gazed keenly over the road ahead. Glancing backwards, he caught Maitimo’s eye. “Nelyafinwë. Come here and speak to me.”

Maitimo trotted his horse up to Fëanáro’s side, his heart beating a little faster, as it often did when Fëanáro wanted to speak to him.

“All your other brothers have heard the news, but you were absent when I delivered it.” Fëanáro’s tone was cool and detached, making Maitimo wonder if he was angry about his absence. “We are all of us to go to Formenos, and see how the construction is going. Except for your mother, who shall stay home with the twins. We shall stay however long we need, until we are certain that the builders continue to execute my instructions with competence.”

Maitimo’s heart seemed to crash into the pit of his stomach.

This would likely not be a quick visit. For whatever reason, Fëanáro had deemed their great house in Tirion not quite safe enough for the hoard of treasures Fëanáro was crafting. He insisted he had not achieved a particular vision in his mind yet, but when he someday did, he needed a safe place to keep that treasure. In the meantime, he insisted he didn’t want all his wealth to be lost should their house in Tirion be robbed.

And who, exactly, did he think was going to rob the house in Tirion? Nolofinwë?

So, Fëanáro had taken to constructing a mighty fortress in the far north of Valinorë, and he hated to leave it to his hired builders for very long. And when he was there, he liked to question every worker and observe every step in their process, and he liked to make his sons help.

Which meant, they would be stuck there a long time. Maitimo might not see Aranya again for weeks.

Yet he could not betray his secret or defy the wishes of his father and lord.

“Yes, Atar,” he mumbled.

So that night, Maitimo sacrificed some hours of sleep, and rode as fast as he could to the pond in the forest. There, he folded up a parchment, which explained the situation to Aranya, and he used a heavy rock to keep it firmly secured to the ground. Despite his profuse apologies, he feared the letter would not be good enough. He feared Aranya would think him insincere, or think she wasn’t important enough to attract his attention after all. But he promised he would come back to her as soon as he could.

Very little changed in the life of Nelyafinwë Maitimo those three days. He was still responsible for his brothers, his father and half-uncle still fought bitterly, and he still bowed like a sapling under the will of his father. But meeting Aranya was a big enough change in his life to cause him to suddenly hate the way he had been living all these years. Where he had once accepted his burdens as inevitable, he now grew anxious to come of age and assert his own independence. Where he had yielded to the will of his parents for his entire life, he sought now to resist.

And resist he would, slowly and quietly, until the day came where he could create a life of his own.



Notes:
Hannacë: Quenya diminutive word for little brother.
Nér: Quenya word for a male Elf.
 
Last edited:
Return to top

Interlude

Many years later, none of Maitimo’s brothers thought twice about his taking his midday meal alone. Or officially “alone,” if anybody asked them, anyway. This was his routine now.

He went out to the stables and asked for Morirámo, a young black stallion who had recently been attacked by wolves. A servant had found him one day and brought him to the stables of Fëanáro as an act of charity, to restore the wounded beast back to health. Based on his fear of being touched, the stable hands figured Morirámo would never be ridden again, and they would soon release him back to the wild.

But if they did that, Maitimo realized Morirámo might get attacked again. So in his scarce spare time, mostly in conjunction with his visits to Aranya, he gently worked with the horse, hoping to get him used to riding again. Tyelko had spoken to the beast in his own tongue, reassuring him that he was in a safe place now and had no need to fear the Eldar. But Morirámo was still viscerally afraid, bucking and rearing at the slightest of sounds, and Tyelko grew bored of trying to help. This was where Maitimo hoped he might succeed. He didn’t have the incredible gift of animal speech like Tyelko did, but he had something else: patience.

So, the short ride to his meeting spot with Aranya was the perfect opportunity to get the horse used to being ridden and encountering terrifying sounds like rustling leaves or snapping twigs. Over time, Maitimo’s patience paid off. At first, he could only lead Morirámo down the path. But the horse’s trust in him gradually grew until he eventually accepted Maitimo as a rider. And interestingly, Morirámo seemed completely unafraid of Aranya, where he still didn’t fully trust Maitimo or Tyelko.

Aranya smiled broadly as Maitimo trotted the horse into the clearing. And in fact, Morirámo ignored Maitimo’s gentle tug on the reins and headed straight towards Aranya. Even though it was a bit of a windy day, Morirámo’s excitement to see the lady must have outweighed his fear of the blowing leaves and rustling trees.

“Hello, handsome boy,” Aranya called out. “Oh, and you too, Maitimo.”

“Thanks a lot,” he said, rolling his eyes in feigned offense as he carefully dismounted. Aranya then reached into her pail and pulled out a carrot, which she offered to Morirámo. The horse crunched down eagerly on the carrot, orange bits flying out of the corners of his mouth. Aranya giggled and petted the stallion’s velvet muzzle.

“Why didn’t you bring me a carrot?” Maitimo asked, folding his arms, still feigning offense.

“Because your head is already full of carrots.” Aranya didn’t glance up from the black stallion. Maitimo, unable to keep up his charade any longer, nearly doubled over in laughter. Aranya’s lips twitched, but she couldn’t feign seriousness much longer either, and she erupted in laughter as well.

By the time their laughter died down and they caught their breath enough to speak, Maitimo’s smile faded as he said, “I can’t stay very long today, unfortunately.”

“You can never stay long these days,” Aranya huffed, watching with a slight pout as Maitimo tethered Morirámo to a nearby tree. “I curse the City Council of Tirion.”

“Now, Aranya, don’t curse them too harshly. They are the reason why I’ve managed to escape so many trips to Formenos, after all.”

“Yes, I know. If it weren’t for them, you’d be riding home today along with the rest of your brothers, after having spent many weeks there, and I wouldn’t have seen you today, or hardly at all… And I know how you hate Formenos, as much as you miss your brothers.” She gave the stallion one last pat before she and Maitimo sat by the pond and opened up their bags. And as they pulled out the various bread, cheeses and fruits and arranged them on plates, Aranya tilted her head slightly and smiled. “I still can’t believe it. My Maitimo, the youngest Elda ever on the city council…”

He laughed softly and the slightest hint of a blush came to his cheeks. “Well, I can hardly believe my parents agreed on something for once in their lives.”

Few things were as terrifying to him as the combined might of Fëanáro and Nerdanel. As soon as they had discovered his growing talents in his studies of law and history and diplomacy, both had been eager to do something with it. Fëanáro because he wanted the honor of having an eldest son with some important title, and Nerdanel because she, too, was passionate about politics and wanted to see her son who was so like to herself do something with it.

Maitimo remembered well the day they had introduced him to the city council. His heart had pounded the whole time as he had conversed with the councilors, hoping his polite smile and rehearsed topics of conversation were enough to disguise his nerves. And many of the councilors had responded to him quite well, complimenting both him and his parents, saying how eager they were to have such a bright young Elda serve as a shining example to the upcoming generation. Others… though they tried to hide it, Maitimo could clearly read their disdain. Their smiles were thin and forced, and they whispered and scoffed to each other when they thought he wasn’t looking. And a unanimous vote was required to put him on the council.

Maitimo had thought nothing would come of his parents’ ambition. But… something had changed.

No matter how much he asked them for details, they wouldn’t explain why just a few days later, the entire council had agreed to add him as a member. Maitimo could only suspect that Nerdanel managed to persuade some of them with her warm, soothing words. And for those who would not be persuaded, she likely left to Fëanáro to deal with in his own way. Given how both of them were so tight-lipped about it, Maitimo was certain they must have collaborated.

If only they would cooperate with each other in such a way more often. They might have accomplished so much good that way.

But as much as Maitimo was grateful for their help, so he could finally have a real way to practice his speaking and debating skills, he had to wonder how much the position was granted to him based on his own merits rather than his parents’ influence.

“You’re too modest,” Aranya told him, breaking him out of his thoughts. “After you spent so many years slaving away in your studies, you deserve this. My only regret is it keeps you away from me—and from getting enough sleep.”

Maitimo blinked in surprise. How did Aranya seem to know what he was thinking about? And this wasn’t an uncommon occurrence. Often, if he tried to conceal his true thoughts or feelings from her, she accurately named them anyway, and then got offended because he didn’t tell her about it on his own. She told him his face was too easy to read, and he bared his heart for everyone to see.

Yet there was one secret he had successfully managed to keep from her so far. Now that he had recently turned one hundred and come of age, Nerdanel immediately set off to look for a wife for him. A perfect wife, one of high noble or preferably royal blood, worthy of Finwë’s heir. Someone from another family or tribe would be ideal for the purposes of forging an alliance. In fact, she was on her way back at this very moment from a trip to Valimar for this very purpose.

Whenever Nerdanel brought this up, Maitimo tried to stall the discussions. At first, he wasn’t sure why. He yearned to get married and have a family just as much as anybody else, so why did he hate this idea so much? Finally, he realized: it was because of Aranya. He hated the idea of marrying somebody who was not her.

But it was out of the question to even think about bringing this up to his parents. Nerdanel’s political ambition and Fëanáro’s fierce temper were too great. But Maitimo knew he would run out of excuses at some point, and then what would he do? Nerdanel was thankfully nowhere close to satisfied with her search yet, but what about the day when she finally brought home the pristine Vanyarin lady she imagined? How could Maitimo possibly voice his true objection?

Looking into Aranya’s deep brown eyes as she chatted about her day in the healing halls, Maitimo wondered if she had any idea of these thoughts. If she knew he was thinking of her that way. If she thought in such a way about him. But while his situation was so uncertain, he couldn’t afford to get her hopes up.

Even though he was of age, his life was not his own yet. The freedom and independence he had yearned for after he first met Aranya had not arrived yet.

But he would not stop pursuing those ideals in whatever small way he could. Someday, he would create for himself a life suitable to be shared with Aranya Estiel.
 
Return to top

Chapter 5: Unfortunate Accident Leads to Sleepy Flirting

Mittanyissë, a senior healer in the House of Finwë, could sense something about this Aranya girl, and she wasn’t sure how she felt about it. The young nís seemed a little too enthusiastic in volunteering to keep ice on the prince’s ribs. And now, the hour was growing late and Aranya’s duties were complete, yet she insisted on staying just a little longer.

“You’ve been working hard all day, and the light of Laurelin has faded,” Mittanyissë told her, gently but sternly. “You mustn’t wear yourself out. Resting is just as much an important part of being a healer as working. We’re no good to our patients when we’re dead on our feet.”

“Oh, please, I’m not tired,” Aranya practically begged. “I’d be content to simply wait in here and watch the rest of you, if you’re worried about me wearing myself out.”

You’d be content watching him, more like, Mittanyissë thought. She was fairly certain she could sense what was going on. After all, she had once been young too, though those days were long ago. It was only natural for any young lady to take an interest in Prince Maitimo.

But, needless to say, using the sacred duties of a healer as an opportunity to gawk at a handsome prince was not appropriate in the slightest.

Mittanyissë didn’t want to shame the bright-eyed girl, or dampen her enthusiasm for healing, which indeed seemed genuine. Aranya didn’t seem solely motivated by her interest in the prince, from what Mittanyissë had seen. But the House of Finwë needed to uphold the highest standards of purity. As a student visiting from the House of Nolofinwë, perhaps Aranya didn’t know or understand these principles, and now was the time to educate her.

So, Mittanyissë put her hand on Aranya’s shoulder and gently guided her away from the others, to a quiet corner by a small desk stocked with healing herbs and surgical tools. Thankfully, the healing halls in the House of Finwë had private rooms for more seriously injured patients, so there was no distracting activity other than the other two healers tending to the prince a short distance away. Though this room was small, it was fitting for royalty, with its bed frame of gold sculpted in a design of vines and leaves, and its great window with a stained glass motif of the House of Finwë. The room was illuminated in a soft glow of silver light, since the evening mingling was well past.

“I believe I can understand how you’re feeling,” Mittanyissë whispered to Aranya. “I’ve been there myself, long ago. I can’t say I blame you in the slightest, either. But the sacred duties of a healer are not to be tarnished by our personal feelings.”

Aranya’s dark brown eyes widened, and the rosy flush of her cheeks deepened.

“Mittanyissë, it’s not like that,” she protested. “I mean, well, it’s not that I claim to feel nothing at all. But, I suppose I might as well say it, if you can keep a secret.” She glanced around for any eavesdroppers before whispering, “I’ve been trying to keep this to myself. But… I am no stranger to him. And he doesn’t know any of the rest of you, so I just thought… he’d like to see a familiar face when he wakes up.”

Mittanyissë fell silent, thinking over her words. Was there any validity to making sure a familiar person was around to keep him calm, in case he woke up distressed?

She opened her mouth to point out his family was nearby, and the healers were not by any means frightening people. But before she could say anything, Aranya gasped. “He’s waking up!”

She rushed to the prince’s bedside. Mittanyissë sighed, not seeing any movement from the prince, and thinking perhaps Aranya was simply trying to get out of this conversation. The other healers were still much closer to the prince, after all, and they would have noticed if he was starting to awaken.

But then, much to Mittanyissë’s amazement, Prince Maitimo indeed began to stir. His eyes blinked slowly open.

What was Mittanyissë to make of this? Had the young Aranya noticed something the rest of them had missed? Had she simply been lucky?

Aranya tensely watched Maitimo stir, her heart pounding for some reason. She wasn’t sure exactly what she was nervous about. His gray eyes fluttered open, but seemed to focus on nothing at first, gazing dazedly into the distance.

“Maitimo,” Aranya whispered, hoping the sound would not reach the ears of the other healers. They wouldn’t be pleased if they heard her call him directly by his mother-name. “Maitimo, it’s me.”

His gaze then drifted towards her, and a faint smile came to his lips. “Aranya,” he whispered. But then he inhaled sharply and his hand moved towards his ribs.

Aranya, though, stopped him by gently taking his wrist. “No, don’t touch it, and try not to move much. You’ve broken some ribs, and you have some cuts around there too.”

“That… explains a lot…” He grimaced and asked, “What happened?”

She didn’t get a chance to answer him, though, because the other healers realized he was awake and talking, and they hurried over to question him, trying to determine his pain level and whether or not he had a concussion. They motioned for Aranya to get out of their way, and she obeyed begrudgingly.

She gave a small sigh. Though the other healers were obviously much more experienced than her, she wished they could have just let her have a moment or two to talk to Maitimo. He was no longer in immediate danger, and he was going to get overwhelmed with all these strangers talking to him at once.

Sure enough, even though Aranya stood a short distance away, she could still see his eyes grow wide. He blurted out, without answering their questions, “Who are you? And where is Aranya?”

“We are healers in the House of Finwë. Aranya is right here, and she is studying with us today,” Mittanyissë spoke up. “Now, Your Highness, if you would please answer a few questions for us—”

“Please, can you bring her back?” Maitimo uncharacteristically interrupted her.

If Aranya said she weren’t feeling a bit proud and validated, she’d be lying. But her feeling vanished when all the other healers turned to look at her, their gazes indicating varying degrees of bewilderment and suspicion.

The one who surprisingly came to her defense, though, was Mittanyissë.

“I think you were right,” she whispered. “We needn’t all gather here around him, and you should ask him the questions. You know what to ask, don’t you?”

Aranya nodded eagerly, somewhat shocked with how this had turned out in her favor. The other healers quietly dispersed, but they were still watching her every move, though from a distance.

So even though Maitimo seemed to visibly relax as the other healers left, Aranya couldn’t bring herself to.

“What is your name?” she asked him.

He looked at her strangely. “Nelyafinwë Maitimo.”

Good, that was one test passed, at least. Aranya had once heard of a hunter who hit his head so hard that he entirely forgot who he was.

“Where are we right now?” she asked.

“The House of Finwë.”

Aranya nodded, relieved his short-term memory was working as well. “Now, can you list all your brothers’ names, in reverse order of their births?”

“Ambarussar, Telvo and Pityo, I mean. Carnistir—no wait, Curufinwë’s next—” Maitimo paused for a long moment, and Aranya’s heart sank a little. His eyes widened anxiously and his silence drew on longer and longer. He clenched the linen bedsheets in his fists, and the muscles of his arms visibly tensed. “I haven’t forgotten who my brothers are! I have six!” he cried, his voice pleading and despairing. “Ambarussar, Curufinwë, Carnistir…”

“It’s all right. Tyelko and Kano are the only ones missing. I know you haven’t forgotten them,” Aranya tried to reassure him, her heart panging with guilt over his distress. “It’s not your fault, Maitimo. You hit your head very hard, and it may be difficult for you to remember long lists of things in an unusual order. It doesn’t mean you’ve forgotten your brothers.”

“Tyelko and Kano. I swear, I didn’t forget them. They’re the oldest ones besides me,” Maitimo said, his eyes wide and voice frantic. His breath quickened to choppy, panicked gasps.

Aranya was quickly regretting choosing such a personal list to have Maitimo recite. She should have chosen something less personal, like numbers or letters of the Tengwar. But then again, the latter might have been a bad idea too, since Maitimo’s father had invented the Tengwar and Maitimo might have grown distressed if he made a mistake in reciting his father’s alphabet.

“Don’t worry. I can tell you remember who all your brothers are,” Aranya reassured him. Then she quickly changed the subject, asking him the other questions she was required to ask to determine his pain level. It was a lot, unsurprisingly, even though they had already given him some medicines. But this meant they were free to give him some more.

“We can give you something else, but it will put you to sleep for hours,” she said. “Before we do that, your family is here, and they would like to see you. May we invite them in?”

Maitimo hesitated, and an uncertain look came to his eyes. “Well… I don’t want to offend any of them, but, all of them in here at once… they’re loud.”

Aranya smiled and tried not to giggle. Maitimo looked as serious as though he were proposing a new law to the councilmen of Tirion. He had done exactly that before, multiple times, and some of those laws had even been passed.

“It won’t be all of them,” Aranya explained. “Your parents, and perhaps one or two of your brothers. I know Tyelko is particularly eager to see you. He’s the one who saved you, you know.”

Maitimo blinked in surprise. “Saved me? From what?”

“I guess you’ll have to let him tell you.”

He nodded in agreement. “Alright, then, you can send for my parents and Kano and Tyelko, please. It seems fair to invite the brothers in by order of their age. And if you don’t mind, could you tell them to keep their voices down?”

Aranya couldn’t manage to fully contain her laughter this time; a suppressed giggle escaped through her lips. Even when concussed, Maitimo was so polite.

“Of course. It’s no trouble,” she told him. Mittanyissë, having heard the conversation, turned and left the room, pushing aside the heavy curtains of silver velvet in the arched doorway. She returned a moment later with Fëanáro, Nerdanel, Makalaurë and Tyelkormo. Aranya stepped aside to let them all talk to each other.

“Please, may I stay until he’s been put to sleep?” Aranya whispered to Mittanyissë as they walked towards a different corner of the room to give the family some privacy. “He may worry if I leave suddenly.”

Mittanyissë nodded, but her pale gray gaze boring into Aranya made her fidget uncomfortably. With her dark hair neatly tied into a flawless bun under her silver veil, and her ivory robes unblemished even from all the mess of blood earlier, Mittanyissë seemed a picture of impossible perfection. “You may, and only because if you were to leave suddenly, I agree it may cause him distress. But truthfully, had I known of your… history… with him, I would have never let you help with this case in the first place. A healer should not have personal emotional entanglements with a patient. Especially when said patient is a prince, and a direct heir of the High King, no less.”

Aranya fell silent and avoided the elder healer’s gaze. She couldn’t deny these points, and yet the criticism made her feel like a stupid schoolgirl.

“I was just trying to help my friend,” she protested, her cheeks burning.

“And you did help him, though I’d say you were lucky there,” Mittanyissë said coolly. “But remember, we cannot risk subjecting the House of the High King to the slightest bit of scandal. We cannot violate the purity of our profession. And all that aside, you must guard your heart for your own sake.”

Laying a gentle hand on Aranya’s shoulder, she added softly, “You know how his family is. It can never be.”

But Aranya flinched away from Mittanyissë’s touch and abruptly turned her back, trying to hide her burning tears of shame and rage. First of all, how presumptuous it was to assume Aranya was trying to marry Maitimo just because of this one limited interaction! They were friends, and she happened to think he was very attractive. That was the extent of it.

Besides, she wasn’t naïve enough to think his family would ever allow him to marry her. Both his parents wanted him to find a “suitable match,” and by that they meant someone who could provide sufficient political power to the House of Finwë.

But for now, she was just happy to have picnics with him in the woods. He provided interesting conversation and patiently listened to her speak her mind. And she liked looking at his face. Why in all Arda did Mittanyissë feel the need to practically accuse her of bringing a scandalous downfall to the House of Finwë, and remind her of the impossibility of a match between her and Maitimo?

Meanwhile, the Fëanorians were blissfully unaware of this conversation.

Fëanáro and Nerdanel had been to visit Maitimo while he was still unconscious, so it wasn’t a shock to them to see all his bruises and bandages. But Kano and Tyelko hadn’t seen him yet, so they were both silent and anxious, staring at their brother with wide eyes.

Nerdanel approached him first, bending down and planting a soft kiss on his cheek. “Maitimo, dear, we’re glad to see you awake. How are you feeling?”

Maitimo tried to smile up at her, taking comfort in the familiar sight of his mother’s warm smile. “Not so great. But it could be worse, I suppose.”

“It could have been, and you were lucky it wasn’t worse,” Fëanáro agreed. Though his voice was barely above a whisper, it still carried a resonance and sternness. Maitimo subconsciously tensed up a little, unsure if his Atar was scolding him somehow.

Sensing Maitimo’s unease, Makalaurë drew closer to him and gently patted his hand. His soft gray gaze seemed even sadder and moodier than usual, and that was saying something. The two eldest sons shared the same gentleness and sensitivity of temperament, and both often felt uncomfortable or upset when Fëanáro’s words or tone felt harsh, even if unintentionally so. Maitimo smiled gratefully, recognizing his brother’s wordless gesture as his way of showing comfort.

Tyelko, though, stood awkwardly behind their parents, unable to meet Maitimo’s gaze. His silver hair fell in front of his face, concealing much of it.

“What happened, anyway?” Maitimo asked, breaking the silence, and wondering why Tyelko would not come near him, especially if he had saved Maitimo as Aranya had said. “I don’t remember anything. I mean, I remember departing for a ride this morning, and then… nothing.”

“According to your brothers, you all went on a hunting trip this morning, and you rode that horse who had been rescued from the wolf attack,” Fëanáro explained. Maitimo wasn’t sure if he was imagining a subtle hint of accusation in Fëanáro’s tone, as though he were blaming the accident on Maitimo’s foolish choice of mount. “The horse spooked at a sudden gust of wind as you were riding along the edge of a short but rocky slope. It threw you and took off running.”

“That stupid, cowardly beast,” Tyelko muttered, scowling. He glanced up slightly, and Maitimo noticed a dark look in his ice blue eyes.

Laurë turned abruptly towards Tyelko, now scowling himself. “Why can’t you keep your negativity to yourself, for once in your life, during a time like this?”

“Boys, both of you. Your brother does not need this,” Nerdanel scolded them, placing a strong hand on each of them and guiding them away from Maitimo. “I’m sorry, Maitimo. They’re tired and they’ve been worrying about you all day. Perhaps we should try this again in the morning.”

“Wait,” Maitimo said as Nerdanel turned with them to leave. “Don’t go. I need to know how Tyelko saved me.”

The three of them stopped, and to Maitimo’s surprise, Fëanáro nodded in agreement. “Let Turcafinwë tell the tale himself, for he deserves that honor.”

Tyelko’s scowl softened, and Laurë huffed but didn’t say anything more. However, even as Fëanáro motioned for Tyelko to approach again, he still kept his gaze to the ground.

“I don’t know if I deserve the honor at all,” he mumbled. “Look what good I did. I should’ve… noticed… the horse…”

His eyes turned red and glassy, and he tried to turn again, but Fëanáro stopped him by placing a gentle but firm hand on his shoulder. “Nelyafinwë has asked to hear the story. Tell him of your deed.”

Tyelko shrugged. “It wasn’t much. And if it weren’t for Curvo helping me figure out the knots, it would have never worked anyway. I just used a rope to climb down the slope and bring you back up. I had to do it, because there wasn’t time to… get help.”

“Why, Tyelko… that’s no small feat at all,” Maitimo said, his eyes widening as he struggled to picture how that must have worked. “How… how did you do that? I mean, it must have been a steep slope if you needed a rope to get up and down. You must have needed your hands free for climbing, so how…”

His voice trailed off and he shook his head. Trying to imagine it and logically understand it was making his head hurt. Well, his head hurt regardless.

Tyelko, though, seemed to perceive Maitimo’s sincere admiration. His deflated posture righted itself, his chest puffed up, and his lips twitched as though he were trying not to smile.

“I brought some additional rope with me and basically tied you to my back,” he explained. “And I guess my adrenaline gave me some extra strength, but still, it was… a mess… you were bleeding all over me…” Here his voice faltered and his lip quivered. “You ruined my clothes!” he added vehemently. “Don’t ever do that to me again, Nelyo! You shouldn’t have picked such a stupid horse!”

He burst into tears and looked like he was starting to collapse, but Nerdanel swiftly caught him and pulled him away, glancing apologetically at Maitimo as she did so. “Tyelkormo, that’s enough for now,” she said quietly. “Let’s get you to bed. It’s been a long day.”

He nodded and went along with her, proving how tired he really must have been. Normally Tyelko resisted anyone else’s efforts to get him to go to bed at a reasonable hour, though he usually gave in eventually since he habitually got up so early.

So the four of them began to leave, bidding Maitimo a good night as they did so.

But then, Tyelko stopped in his tracks. Before either Fëanáro or Nerdanel could stop him, he broke away from their grasp and rushed towards Maitimo. He reached for his older brother, but then froze in place, as though he wanted to throw his arms around him but suddenly remembered his injuries.

Maitimo gave him a reassuring nod and opened up his arms. Tyelko hugged him around his shoulders, carefully avoiding his ribs. And Maitimo could feel a few wet tears landing on his shoulder, and Tyelko sniffled and shuddered.

“Shhh,” Maitimo whispered, gently rubbing his brother’s back, concerned and slightly unnerved. Just how bad was this accident, to traumatize Tyelko in such a way? Maitimo had awakened already cleaned up and bandaged, with no memory of the accident itself. But his condition must have been so severe that his brothers feared to delay long enough to send for help. No one Tyelko’s age should have had to bear such a frightening situation. And how were the brothers even younger than him coping with this?

It only intensified Maitimo’s guilt. He had just been trying to give that horse a chance at a normal life by reintroducing him to a safe ride in the woods. But now, because of that, he had put himself and his family through this ordeal.

“It’s alright, Tyelko,” he reassured him. “I know you’re just overwhelmed. Anyone would be in your situation. I’m sorry I took Morirámo on our trip today. I thought he was ready, but he wasn’t. But thanks to you, everything will be alright soon.”

“I didn’t… mean to make you feel bad about it,” said Tyelko, pulling away to reveal a reddened, tear-streaked face. “I’m the one who should have known about Morirámo’s fear… I can’t seem to say what I mean, and I’m messing everything up! I’m sorry, Timo… so sorry.”

“It’s really alright.” Maitimo squeezed Tyelko’s hand. He wished he had something wise and comforting to say, but his head ached too much to come up with anything better, and talking was growing painful. Even the small movements he had made left him dizzy, too. “I think you ought to get some rest now. We both need it.”

Tyelko nodded in agreement, and he and Laurë left with their parents for real this time. Maitimo was grateful no one had stopped Tyelko from running to him, since it seemed like they needed this moment in order for him to go to bed calmly.

Aranya, having ended her conversation with Mittanyissë several minutes ago, approached Maitimo after his family left. Secretly, she was grateful to see them go. They were a volatile bunch. And why in all Arda did Maitimo have to be the one calming and soothing his riled up younger brother in his condition?

“Would you like that medicine now?” she asked. He nodded, and Aranya got up to fetch the small cup of draught. Mittanyissë carefully helped him sit up while Aranya held the cup to his lips.

Never before had she been so close to Maitimo’s lips. Interesting.

As Mittanyissë helped him lay back down, Aranya told him the medicine would work very quickly, within minutes, really.

“Will you… stay… till it does?” he asked, already drowsy and blinking slowly.

“Of course.” Aranya couldn’t help but smile as Mittanyissë left.

“Thank you.” Maitimo smiled slightly. “Poor Tyelko. He’s so upset about this. Everyone thinks he’s a brat, but really, he just wants to cuddle all the time. He’s so cute.”

He sighed and closed his eyes. Aranya tried not to giggle at his rambling speech, no doubt brought on by the strong draught quickly affecting him.

Then, she wasn’t sure exactly why she said what she said next. Was it out of spite towards Mittanyissë? Had she always secretly wanted to say such things but been too nervous before? Or maybe she felt so much bolder knowing Maitimo would remember nothing of this conversation?

“You know who’s cuter than Tyelko?” she blurted out, not sure if he was awake enough to hear.

No matter. Even if he wasn’t, she would tell him anyway.

His brows creased, though he did not open his eyes. “Impossible,” he mumbled. “No one’s cuter than Tyelko.”

You are, Maitimo.”

“Me? No…” He raised his eyebrows and his eyes cracked open. “I don’t believe it.”

“You’d better believe it, because it’s just true.” Aranya reached for one of his soft auburn curls and twirled it around her finger.

His gaze followed her hand for a brief moment before he smiled and closed his eyes. His hand briefly brushed against hers… and then it promptly fell limp. His breathing grew deep and rhythmic. The faint light of Telperion filling the room illuminated his sharp features in a soft glow.

Aranya couldn’t believe herself. Had the other healers heard that? Seen that?

Glancing over, she saw all their backs turned as they busied themselves cleaning their tools and putting away herbs.

Good.

Aranya regretted nothing.
 
Return to top

Chapter 6: Much to Learn

Aranya tossed and turned in the bed in her guest room for many hours, too giddy to fall asleep. In her mind she scolded herself for feeling so elated when Maitimo was seriously injured and in pain, but she didn’t listen to her own scoldings.

Yes, her first reaction upon seeing Tyelko and Moryo carrying Maitimo’s bloodied, unconscious form had been one of horror. Her stomach had knotted and her lungs had felt tight, and she’d had half a mind to flee from the room upon seeing her dear Maitimo in such a state. At first, she had done nothing but stand there, idle and frozen, as Mittanyissë and the others had rushed to put him on a bed and take his tunic off. His tunic had been swamped with blood, which was oozing from some gashes near his ribs. Seeing all that blood made Aranya’s head spin and her knees weak. At first, she was worried she might faint herself.

“Aranya, girl!” Mittanyissë had called out, snapping her out of her frozen terror. “Get a clean cloth and push it down as hard as you can on his cuts, until we come back with a needle and herbs.”

Aranya had numbly complied, not sure if she was going to be able to handle this or not, but she realized she had to, for Maitimo’s sake. So she had fetched the cloth and pushed it down as hard as she could on those cuts.

There had been a horrible grating sound. Maitimo had let out a hoarse gasp, but he did not wake. Aranya’s heart had dropped to the pit of her stomach.

“Was that too hard?” she had asked, her voice thin and panicked. “Did I hurt him?”

Mittanyissë had frowned and carefully poked and prodded around Maitimo’s ribs. “I think a couple of these are broken. However, don’t let up the pressure on that cloth. We’ll be right back. We need to mix some cleaning herbs.”

She and the other healer had hurried to the cabinets full of herbs, leaving Aranya to keep the cloth on and watch as blood seeped up between her fingers. The liquid was hot to the touch.

Aranya had pried her gaze away from the horrible sight, and she had chosen instead to focus on Maitimo’s face. That… wasn’t much better. His complexion was whiter than Aranya had ever seen it, and blood trickled at the edge of his hairline.

But then she had realized: his tunic was off. She could see all the finely sculpted muscles of his figure. Well-formed one indeed…

When Aranya had first met Maitimo, he had been in the middle of growing too fast, resulting in his arms and legs appearing painfully long and thin. But eventually, a change took place, so slow and gradual that she hadn’t even noticed it until years later. His shoulders and chest had broadened, and his arms were contoured with muscle. When he pulled her in for an embrace and her head rested on his chest, and his arms closed in around her, she felt surrounded by a pleasant hardness and strength.

And now, he needed her to be strong too, though not quite in the same way. Aranya had taken a deep breath, forced herself to look at the blood staining the cloth and her hands, and resolved she would do everything she could to help make it better, no matter how gruesome and terrifying it was.

When the other healers had returned with their needles and herbs, Aranya had asked if she could help apply the poultice to his cuts. They had agreed, though they didn’t let her help stitch his wounds. She had forced herself to at least watch, though it made her shudder when they put needles and thread through her Maitimo’s skin. She had stitched up minor wounds before, but nothing as deep as this, and certainly not for her dear friend.

The other healers had also discussed keeping ice on his ribs as they dressed the wound on his head. Aranya had volunteered for the task without hesitation. And as they worked, Aranya had pretended they weren’t around. She had softly hummed the tune of a healing song her mother had taught her as a small Elfling. She caressed his hand, though he wasn’t aware she was doing it. And she let her eyes linger longer than they probably should have on the muscles of his figure.

These things, and her interactions with Maitimo after he woke up, bounced around happily in Aranya’s mind as she tried to sleep that night. The only things that made her squirm with embarrassment were Mittanyissë’s words. The sacred duties of a healer are not to be tarnished by our personal feelings.

Aranya tried to convince herself she wasn’t violating the purity of her profession. She did a perfectly fine job caring for Maitimo, didn’t she? She had kept him calm when no one else could. What did it matter if they happened to be friends and she happened to like looking at him? And healers were not forbidden from marriage. Aranya was not desecrating her profession by taking an interest in a nér.

Besides… the more Aranya thought about it, the angrier she became at Mittanyissë. Did Eru Ilúvatar not design the Eldar for marriage? Was marriage not intended to be pleasurable? And where exactly did desire for marriage come from—the sky? Did strict people like Mittanyissë expect young níssi to instantaneously transform from pure little children to married adults with children of their own? No, there had to be a healthy amount of attraction and romance between those two phases of life if there was to be any happiness in the marriage.

But then Aranya cut off her chain of thoughts in alarm. Was she actually… thinking of marrying Maitimo?

She’d be lying if she were to say the thought had never entered her mind before. But she had never thought it possible. He almost certainly didn’t see her that way, and even if he did, his family would never allow such an unequal union.

So, as she often did whenever the wishful fantasy entered her mind, she shoved it away. Better not to dwell on it and get her hopes up.

That didn’t mean she wouldn’t allow herself to carry a bit of a grudge towards Mittanyissë, though. Aranya was, in fact, a fully grown nís with normal, healthy desires, placed in her heart by Eru Himself, and if anyone tried to make her feel ashamed of having those desires, that was their problem, not hers.

* * *​

At the first sign of Laurelin’s light the next morning, Fëanáro summoned Mittanyissë, demanding to know how his son was doing. Crown Prince Fëanáro couldn’t simply ask things, after all. He could only demand.

“He fares much better, Your Highness,” she replied, hoping her fatigue wasn’t showing in her eyes. She had worked all night, and now her watch was nearly over. “He slept for some hours, and we managed to coax him to eat.”

That hadn’t been easy. It was understandable enough that the prince didn’t feel much like eating, given the nature of his injuries, and the strong medicines they had given him. But even when awake and rational enough to understand that he was hurting himself by refusing to eat, he still wouldn’t give in. And he wouldn’t stop asking after Aranya, who had gone to bed.

Mittanyissë had been so tired and frustrated at that point that she had done something she wasn’t proud of. Something she had never done before and did not plan on doing so again. She manipulated her patient.

“If you will not eat, I will tell Aranya,” she had said. “She will not be pleased, for she wishes you to heal.”

Maitimo had immediately complied at that point.

This left Mittanyissë with quite the dilemma. It wasn’t just the maiden that fancied the prince. The prince fancied the maiden. That meant Mittanyissë couldn’t easily remove Aranya from the case, now that Maitimo remembered she was around, and seemed to be constantly thinking of her.

Fëanáro’s deep voice snapped Mittanyissë out of her thoughts. “Well glad am I to hear this. I would like to see him now.”

“Of course, my lord.” Mittanyissë led him to Maitimo’s room, where he then asked to be alone with his son, and Mittanyissë quietly left.

When Fëanáro entered the room, Maitimo was staring dully at the ceiling, bored out of his mind yet not able to do much of anything. He wasn’t tired enough to sleep, but the healers had forbidden him from moving much at all for the sake of his healing ribs. His wounds ached faintly despite the strong medicines he had taken.

He glanced up hopefully—though a bit nervously—when his father entered the room.

Nelyafinwë, the healers say you are better.” Fëanáro’s bold tone made these words seem like a statement not to be challenged, rather than an inquiry. His face appeared stoic and unreadable.

Maitimo nodded carefully. “Better than last night, thank you, Atar.”

Fëanáro nodded and sat on the chair beside Maitimo’s bed. He frowned slightly and stroked his chin, as was his habit when he was deep in thought. “There is something I do not understand. How is it that you lost control of your steed? Have I not taught you how to respond when temperamental beasts act out?”

Maitimo’s heart plummeted. He had anticipated the conversation would go in this direction, yet hoped it wouldn’t.

“You have taught me well, Atar,” he said, trying to remain in control of his rising nerves, as though they were a spooked horse. “But I do not remember exactly what happened. I only remember setting out on the ride, and then some bits and pieces of being in the forest with my brothers, and then… nothing. I wish I could better explain what happened and why the horse threw me. I’m sure it was not caused by any negligence on your part.”

“Of course it wasn’t. That’s not what I’m asking,” Fëanáro said shortly. “I am seeking to understand what happened so it will not happen again. But seeing as how your brothers have no answers, and you have no answers, I suppose all I must do is restrict your riding until you prove yourself capable of handling unexpected things like this. You are to only ride steeds with an established history, steeds whom we know to be safe. No more of this training of the wild ones until I say otherwise.”

Maitimo dropped his gaze. It wasn’t an unreasonable command, but it certainly felt humiliating. “Yes, Atar.”

Fëanáro nodded and, seemingly satisfied with that discussion, changed the subject. “Now, the other thing I regret is that you will not be joining us at the council meeting tonight. You had quite the speech prepared, from what I remember. The lords of Tirion will be disappointed that you will not be joining us.”

Maitimo sighed. He had completely forgotten about that speech; he seemed to be forgetting a lot of things lately, thanks to this cursed injury. “I’m sorry, Atar. Convey my regret to them, won’t you?”

“The lords were looking forward to your speech. You will be missed.” Fëanáro paused for a moment, and then his frown deepened. “I do hope this injury will not impact your intellectual abilities over the long-term.”

Maitimo’s eyes widened a little. He had not thought of this as a possibility, but it was a valid concern. He couldn’t even recite all his brothers’ names last night. What if he forgot Tengwar, or some crucial fact during a debate with the lords? What if he forgot the knowledge he had worked so hard to earn in law, history, economics, linguistics and many other subjects?

“Atar, would you or someone else bring me some of my books from home?” he pleaded, his voice suddenly desperate. “Whichever ones are sitting on my desk, along with the last few papers I wrote. I don’t have anything else to do, and… and I can’t afford to fall behind.”

Fëanáro’s grim expression softened into a pleased smile, and he gently patted Maitimo’s shoulder. “That’s my bright, high-achieving son. I knew you wouldn’t let something like this deter you from making progress.”

Maitimo smiled faintly in return, only hoping this would prove true.

Fëanáro stood and left the room. It took Maitimo’s heart several minutes afterwards to stop pounding.

* * *​

Later that afternoon, Aranya was at work in the storeroom in the House of Finwë, helping to organize different types of herbs and supplies. Mittanyissë had assigned her here this morning even though there were a few other wounded people in the healing halls besides Maitimo. Mittanyissë insisted that Aranya had a long and wearisome day yesterday, and she needed a less strenuous task to do today.

It was a mildly interesting task to sort through the shelf, which stood from the floor to the ceiling, full of meticulously organized herb boxes. Yet Aranya was indignant. Was this punishment for her interaction with Maitimo? She only had a few precious days here at the House of Finwë. Why should she waste that scarce time doing mundane work in a storeroom, when she was capable of keeping a level head in front of injured, potentially aggressive patients?

A voice calling her name made her jump. She turned to see Cendë, one of the healers who was assigned to Maitimo during the day. She wore the same neat bun and pristine robes as Mittanyissë, but her eyes were gentler and softer. Though not as experienced as Mittanyissë, she was still considered one of the senior healers.

“We need your help with the prince,” said Cendë.

Aranya blinked in shock, nearly dropped her herb box, and caught it just before it could splatter all over the floor. “I thought Mittanyissë said I wasn’t to help with him anymore.”

“Well, I think you’re the only one who can help us in this moment.” Cendë glanced around before she lowered her voice. “Mittanyissë doesn’t need to know. Come with me.”

Aranya certainly wasn’t one to object to that, so she put the box aside and followed Cendë back towards Maitimo’s room.

“What’s the trouble?” Aranya whispered as they walked down the hall.

“He will not rest even though he clearly needs to,” Cendë explained. “He’s getting himself agitated and frustrated over some books, insisting he needs to study. He won’t tell us why.”

Oh, no.

Maitimo had always been passionate about his academics, but only one person drove him to near insanity about it.

“Was the crown prince with him today, by any chance?” Aranya asked.

Cendë looked at her sharply. “Indeed he was. He left just before I began my duties today. How did you guess?”

Aranya didn’t have time to reply, because they reached Maitimo’s room. She pushed aside the velvet curtains hanging from the arched doorway and entered.

Sure enough, Maitimo had a book on his lap, and a few others strewn across the bed. He was staring intently at the pages and muttering something under his breath.

“Maitimo?” Aranya said softly, slowly walking towards him.

He glanced up at her, revealing reddened, tear-stained eyes. “Aranya, I… I’m forgetting so much,” he said in a hoarse voice. “How many companions did Tata, the second Elf-father, take with him on his journey to Valinorë? This is basic information. I should know it.”

Frowning slightly, Aranya drew a little closer and gently closed the History of Arda book on his lap. “You shouldn’t be studying, Maitimo. You need lots of sleep if you want to heal from your concussion.”

Maitimo shook his head, but oddly enough, he didn’t try to stop Aranya as she gathered up his books and sorted them into a neat stack. “But,” he protested, “what if I forget more and more, and I’ll have so much to relearn after I’m recovered? I’ll lose months of work, if not years! So shouldn’t I start now? I’m not that tired, really…”

“I think it’s rather the opposite.” Aranya set the books aside, out of his sight. “Think of it this way. Your brain is hurt and trying to heal, and right now, you’re putting a great deal of stress and strain on it. It’s like trying to run on a broken leg. That won’t help all your memories return. But if you sleep, your mind will work subconsciously to repair your memories.”

Maitimo watched her intently as she spoke, and his posture sagged. “How long will that take?” he asked quietly.

“I don’t know. Weeks, perhaps, if you take proper care of yourself.”

Weeks? I don’t have weeks.” He reached towards the spot where his books had been, wincing with the movement, and then paused, seemingly confused. “That’s right. You moved them,” he said bitterly, almost under his breath. “But I don’t have weeks. It’s bad enough that I have to miss the city council meeting tonight.”

“Maitimo… was it your Atar who put these notions in your head?”

His eyes widened briefly, then his gaze fell. Though he didn’t directly answer, this response told Aranya everything she needed to know.

Aranya gently continued, “Why would anyone even speak to you of that council meeting? Everyone knows, or ought to know, you need plenty of time to heal. Any reasonable person would be very understanding of your situation.”

“Atar thinks I’m better.” Maitimo’s voice was barely above a whisper. “I don’t… I don’t want to prove him wrong.”

Aranya had to wonder how Curufinwë got that idea. And if he had talked to Maitimo earlier, how dense did he have to be to fail to realize that his son, though he had certainly improved since last night, was still in a very bad state?

Fëanáro Curufinwë was incredibly brilliant and incredibly stupid at the same time, it would seem.

And yes, Aranya was disrespecting her crown prince in her mind. But she hardly cared. He deserved it. Her mind was her own private place, anyway. She could think whatever she wanted there.

“Frankly, you’re not better,” she said bluntly. “Not well enough to do what he seems to be expecting of you, anyway.”

Noticing a few locks of copper hair clinging to his face and looking slightly damp, Aranya gently pushed them away. She frowned slightly when his forehead felt hot to her touch. Too much passion from the fëa could cause the body to burn like that. It was a good thing indeed that Cendë sent for her, especially if no one else had had any luck in calming him down.

“Perhaps I can speak with the other healers about making sure Fëanáro knows he can’t ask these things of you,” she said, half to herself.

His eyes widened and his face paled.

“Your funeral,” he said gravely. “If you do that, I wash my hands of it. He would blame all of you, think you’re not doing your job. I don’t wish to bring disgrace on any part of my good grandfather’s House, let alone you, Aranya. You who are least deserving of it. Let me deal with Fëanáro. I’ve been doing it my whole life.”

“Very well. You do that,” Aranya said.

She had no intention of letting Curufinwë run around unchecked, however. Not if she had something as good as a healer’s order to bestow upon him.

“You can endure Fëanáro as valiantly as you wish,” she went on. “But on one condition.”

Maitimo raised his eyebrows, clearly surprised and intrigued.

“You go to sleep.”

Maitimo sighed heavily and grumbled, “I knew you were going to say something like that.”

He paused, and added softly, “Will you stay with me for a little while, though?”

Aranya smiled. “Gladly.”

She then picked up his History of Arda book and began to read aloud the chapter about the journeys of the first Elf-fathers. Listening to it would be less taxing than reading it himself, and if it was the last thing on his mind before sleeping, it would hopefully help repair his memories.

He seemed to realize what she was up to, and he smiled. But in reality, his mind was barely on the material. He was distracted watching Aranya’s dark eyes skim across the words, her soft pink lips uttering the words, and her voice adding animated passion even to the academic text.

Maitimo was more tired than he thought, though, and Aranya didn’t read more than a few paragraphs before he fell asleep.

With a satisfied smile, Aranya closed the book, set it aside, and returned to Cendë, who seemed to be watching her with fascination.

“You... have a way with him,” Cendë said knowingly.

“We’ve been friends for years. I know him well.” Aranya shrugged, trying to suppress her smile from widening, and changed the subject. “Cendë, I believe it would be a good idea to tell the crown prince that he can’t demand his son study at a time like this.”

Cendë’s amused smile dissipated into a frown. “No, young one. That would be improper, and besides, inaccurate. The crown prince did not ask his son to study, after all. Nelyafinwë requested his books from home entirely of his own volition.”

“But he only did that because he felt Fëanáro was pressuring him,” Aranya argued. “He wouldn’t have even thought about it if not for that talk with his father. And now, Curufinwë will surely be expecting Maitimo to do something he cannot.”

“The private affairs between father and son are none of our business.” Cendë’s stare grew stern, and she placed a surprisingly strong hand on Aranya’s shoulder. “I’m pleased with what you have managed to do for Nelyafinwë. And unlike Mittanyissë, I believe your friendship with him is helpful, and not harmful, in this situation. However, you must watch your heart so that pride does not grow there. Just because you have found success with Prince Nelyafinwë where the rest of us have failed, it does not mean you have the right to command Crown Prince Fëanáro.”

“But I wasn’t—" Aranya protested.

“The crown prince has done nothing wrong, as far as we’re aware. All we can do is answer any of his questions honestly. Nelyafinwë studied a little, and you coaxed him into the sleep he needed, and I believe the crown prince will be pleased by that. We have done our duty and that is all that matters.”

Aranya longed to argue more, but based on the unrelenting sternness of Cendë’s gaze, that wasn’t a good idea.

Well, then. She’d have to take this matter into her own hands. At this point, it seemed as though she was the only one willing to speak up for Maitimo.

With a respectful nod, she left. But she wasn’t returning to her books or the herb closet. She was seeking out Fëanáro.

It didn’t take much to find him. She only had to roam the palace halls for a little while before she heard his resonant voice booming off the marble pillars and floors.

She waited for his conversation—or more accurately, his yelling at his children—to end. It sounded like the twins had asked too many questions for his taste and he had brusquely ordered them to silence. But after a few quiet murmured words from Nerdanel, Fëanáro emerged, storming down the hallway.

Was it a bad time to bring this up? Almost certainly. But Aranya figured it was her only chance.

She took a deep breath and summoned every bit of courage she could muster. She willed her voice to come out loud and clear.

“Your Highness? I must speak to you.”

At first, she thought he didn’t hear her. But then he stopped and spun around, his black hair flowing and his silk cloak swishing with the movement. His ice-blue eyes narrowed as he regarded her. “And just who might you be?”

His gaze flicked up and down as she opened her mouth, trying to stammer out a response. “A healer from the house of my half-brother? In my father’s house? I have to wonder what the likes of you would be doing here of all places. And at a time when my son is wounded, it seems suspicious to me. Speak quickly, then. What do you want?”

Aranya wished her hammering heart would settle down, and she shakily replied, “I am a student working under the fine healers of your father’s House today, Your Highness. I have been working with your son, under the supervision of Mittanyissë and Cendë. And I have something I must tell you about him.”

Fëanáro was silent, his piercing gaze scrutinizing her. Aranya forced herself to meet that gaze, though she yearned to squirm and wiggle and hide under a bush.

“He… he cannot study. Please, my lord, do not ask him to study.” Her voice came out as barely more than a squeak. “He frets over all the things he can’t remember, and it will not help him heal. It is my opinion, as a healer, that he should only rest for now, and resume his studies when he is better healed.”

Healer’s order, you idiot! Why didn’t you give him a healer’s order? Aranya internally scolded herself. The words she had prized as a weapon slipped from her tongue. And the argument she made for Maitimo, which had sounded so articulate in her head, now sounded feeble and incoherent tumbling out of her mouth.

Fëanáro stared at her for a moment, seemingly dumbfounded, before bursting out in laughter. The hard marble floors and walls echoed his laughter, making it seem like a hundred voices rather than one were laughing at her.

Aranya’s face burned. In that moment she would have liked nothing more than to gracefully and peacefully fade from existence.

“You said yourself that you are a student,” Fëanáro scoffed. “And the house of my half-brother is not known for their high achievement. Nelyafinwë, on the other hand, did not become the youngest member of the Council of Tirion because he rests and relaxes all the time. If you say he has lost memory, then I am gladdened that he has taken the initiative to recover it already. Perhaps if you healers had been doing your jobs rather than relishing in mediocrity, he wouldn’t have lost his memories in the first place.”

Aranya stumbled back, her knees suddenly feeling weak. If she weren’t so shocked, she might have cried or been sick.

“I suggest you return immediately to your own House where mediocrity is welcome,” Fëanáro concluded. “Or if my command is not good enough, I will gladly tell my father I wish you gone.”

Had Aranya heard that right? Now it was her turn to stare at him in dumbfounded shock.

“Your Highness, please,” she croaked. “I apologize, I meant no offense, I was just trying to help—”

“Well, clearly, you have much to learn and have no place learning under my father’s House at this time,” he said coldly. “You had no place to address me the way you did. Begone.”

Numbly, seeing no way out of this, Aranya bowed and turned to leave.

Thankfully, the guest quarters were empty, and she had few belongings to pack. She didn’t have the heart to tell Finwë’s healers, who had been gracious to her, what had happened. And she especially couldn’t bear to tell Maitimo.

Let them all wonder. She would depart quietly in shame and let everyone else figure out the truth once her absence was noticed.

As she walked through the woods, taking a winding path towards the House of Nolofinwë, the reality of this crashed in on her. She was handed an incredible opportunity to study under the best of the best, and she had squandered it like a fool.

Yet at the same time... somehow, seeing the harshness of Fëanáro for herself only hardened her resolve. Maitimo currently stood alone against that intense Elda, possibly in front of his brothers. Aranya had failed to stand with him this time, but it didn't mean she would give up.

I’m sorry, Maitimo, she wished she could say to him. I did my best to speak up for you. And I’d do it again with no regrets if I only thought it would do any good.
 
Return to top

Chapter 7: Nice Néri Don’t Get the Nís

The first thing Aranya did was sit in the spot where she and Maitimo normally had their picnics, and she cried for a long while.

How could she have been such a fool? The most basic responsibility of studying under elder healers was listening to their commands! They had warned her about Fëanáro, and she had ignored them.

And yet... if Fëanáro hadn’t laughed in her face, she didn’t think she’d regret anything she did.

Still, she disobeyed, and she paid the price. And now she wasn’t sure if she’d ever get the chance to study under the House of Finwë again.

How would her parents react when they found out? Oh, they’d be livid... especially Aranya’s mother, who had used her own personal connections to get Aranya the spot.

And then all the other healers she worked with would wonder why she came back early.

So, she resolved to hide as long as possible. For hours, she sat on a rock, staring at her reflection in the still pond and throwing pebbles at it.

If Maitimo were well, he’d be here at this time of day. And he would have listened and understood. He never judged her for making mistakes, unlike her parents or Finwë’s healers.

The only other person Aranya felt might understand was Arcamë. But even so, she wasn’t ready to face her just yet.

As the light of Laurelin began to fade to a dim orange-gold, her stomach growled, and she begrudgingly admitted it was time to return. So she walked down the path heading back to the House of Nolofinwë, though she took her time in doing so.

Everyone in the servants’ hall would likely be finishing their supper right about now. If Aranya was lucky, she would make it back just in time to get a meal for herself and avoid her fellow healers.

And thankfully, the servants’ dining hall, a large room in the basement with windowless stone walls, was empty. The room still smelled of venison stew and freshly-baked bread, and some of the simple wooden benches and chairs were slightly out of place. At the long table which held the food and drink, the soup and bread were still warm. Aranya served herself a bowl, took some slices of bread, and poured herself a taller glass of wine than she normally did.

She barely managed to suppress an audible groan of annoyance when a familiar voice called her name.

Tecno Lóremo, one of the healers she worked with, sidled up to her on the otherwise-empty bench and sat right next to her. She could feel his onion-scented breath on her neck. His breathing was very loud, too. His slick black hair looked somehow even greasier than usual today, which was saying something.

She scooted several inches away from him. He followed her.

“Aranya, you’re back!” he said cheerfully. His round eyes looked even wider than usual as he stared at her, as though he were some sort of creepy owl. “That’s good! You’ll be able to go with me to the village dance after all!”

Aranya took several big sips of her wine.

She had forgotten about that village dance. Since she was supposed to be working in the House of Finwë at the time, she had been very glad to have that excuse when Tecno had asked her to the dance. And with everything that had happened, she entirely forgot about it.

“Actually,” she said, “I’m very tired. I have a headache. I think I’d better not go.”

“Oh, really? That’s too bad.” He reached for her forehead, but she flinched away. His hands were perpetually sweaty.

“You know, I was thinking it didn’t sound like such a fun time myself,” he continued. “And if you’re not feeling well, I’ll stay with you till you’re better. I’ll get you a cold cloth, and brew some of the tea we always make for Lady Anairë—"

“I can manage it myself,” she said curtly, taking another swig of wine. It was already hitting her with a pleasant warmth and slight lightheadedness, but it wasn’t enough to rid her of Tecno.

“Well, for starters, you should stop drinking that wine,” he said with a self-righteous nod. “But if you’re not going to the dance, I’m not going either. You’re the only reason I wanted to go to it, you know. And I really want to make sure you’ll feel better.”

Aranya grimaced, reconsidering her options. All the other servants were indeed at this village dance, leaving only the royal family in the House. Néri were not allowed in the níssi’s sleeping quarters, but with no one else around to keep watch, she wasn’t so sure Tecno would respect the rules.

“It’s really not that bad. I’ll go,” she said begrudgingly. “But I will not be dancing at all.”

Tecno grinned and reached for her hand, but she jerked it away. “Oh, I’m glad! We can at least talk for a long while, if you don’t feel up to dancing.”

“I don’t feel much like talking either,” she snapped. Leaving about half of her food and drink unfinished, she returned her dishes to the washing bins and walked briskly out of the hall. She’d have to change into something besides her healing robes, as much as she didn’t want to make it look like she was presenting herself nicely for Tecno.

But at least at the dance, all the other servants would be there. Arcamë and the other female servants were sympathetic to Aranya’s plight with Tecno, and they would do their part to distract him. And if that were the case, she wouldn’t have much of a chance to talk about why she was back early. Yes, this was the better plan.

“I need to change,” she said coolly to Tecno as he followed her down the hallways.

“Oh... right.” He nodded knowingly and added with a wink, “I’ll wait while you change. Don’t want to invade your privacy, you know.”

Aranya shuddered, feeling as though beetles were crawling down her spine. Tecno followed her all the way to the female sleeping quarters. Aranya’s heart pounded with dread. She had half a mind to turn around and show up to the dance wearing her healing apron and all. But thankfully, he allowed her to enter her room and shut the door. She hastily changed into her plainest casual dress, silver in color and loosely fitted, belted at the waist.

She had much prettier dresses, made of fabrics embroidered with tiny flowers, and much more fitted at the bodice. But she refused to wear one for Tecno. They had become special to her ever since she started wearing them to her picnics with Maitimo.

Once she emerged from her room, Tecno’s eyes widened. “You look ravishing!” he gasped.

Aranya tried not to gag. Saying nothing, she walked as quickly as her short legs would allow down the halls and out on the road towards the village.

“Slow down,” Tecno said, panting, jogging to keep up with her.

She ignored him. She might have been short, but she had learned to take longer strides and become a faster walker after walking with Maitimo so much. He didn’t try to walk fast, but his strides were long.

They walked on, with Tecno feebly attempting to make small talk, and Aranya ignoring everything he said.

Eventually, even with his lack of social awareness, he seemed to realize she was ignoring him.

“Hey,” he said, waving a hand in front of her face. “I’m talking to you, you know.”

“Didn’t I tell you earlier that I don’t feel like talking?” she snapped back, spinning around in rage to face him. “There’s something else you should know. I’m not going to this dance with you. If you wish to dance with a nís, you should find another one besides me.”

Thankfully, the group of servants seemed to be not too far ahead, and Aranya and Tecno were catching up. They could see the servants’ torchlight and hear their chatter. So before Tecno could respond to her vehement words, she broke into a run and joined the group. She stayed in the back, hoping no one would notice her. But several people heard her footsteps and turned towards her.

Aranya wasn’t sure she could endure all the questions and general socializing, but mercifully, one of the servants near the back was Arcamë.

As the senior healer of the House of Nolofinwë, Arcamë was older than Aranya’s parents, but not quite as old as Mittanyissë. Her sleek black hair was always kept in the neatest of buns, and her soft grey eyes held a depth of wisdom.

“Aranya, child?” she said, surprised, yet her voice gentle. “What are you doing here?”

“It’s... it’s a long story.” Aranya tried to swallow back the tears welling up in her throat, but when Arcamë put her arm around her, they spilled down her cheeks anyway. “I don’t want to talk about it.”

Arcamë’s brow furrowed in concern, but Tecno came running up to them at that moment, huffing and puffing from the valiant effort of keeping up with Aranya.

“Aranya, it’s all right if you don’t want to talk or dance. I don’t feel much like talking or dancing myself,” he said, a note of desperation to his voice. He didn’t even seem to notice Aranya’s tears.

“Tecno Lóremo,” Arcamë said with gentle firmness, “she wishes to be left alone at the moment. I suggest you find something or someone else to amuse yourself with.”

Tecno’s eyes widened with shock, but he couldn’t refuse the wishes of their leader. So he nodded awkwardly and walked away.

Arcamë shook her head and rolled her eyes, and Aranya smiled gratefully at her. “Thank you... I didn’t want to come here at all, but otherwise, I would have been alone with him prowling around the House somewhere.”

“I don’t believe he is malicious, but he desperately needs to learn manners and respect,” Arcamë said. “I can sense something troubling your fëa, but if you’re not ready to tell me about it yet, that’s all right. I heard there will be pastries with berries and cream, and I was eager to try them, if you’re interested in joining me.”

Aranya agreed, and not long afterwards, they arrived in the village square. Flowering garlands hung over all the fences and rails, and small torches and candles twinkled everywhere, mingling with the silver light of Telperion. Several couples were already dancing around the fountain in the center of the village.

It was a pretty sight. Aranya only wished she had someone suitable to dance with.

It was ridiculous, but she wished Maitimo were here.

It was a distant fantasy, for he would never be allowed to show his face in a peasants’ village dance. But if it were up to him, he wouldn’t have minded it. He would have delighted in the candles and garlands just as much as Aranya did, even though he lived in a palace full of grandiose stonework of his mother’s crafting, and ornate stained glass windows of his father’s crafting.

But he had made her jaded to the unskilled dancing of village commoners. One time, he had requested her help in practicing a dance he had to do at an upcoming ball. It was complicated, and he had been nervous about it.

“I know all the steps,” he had told her. “But I haven’t internalized them all yet, so I just need to practice them again and again until I can do it without thinking about it. And it’s... not the same... practicing it by myself instead of with a partner. Would you mind if I practiced with you?” He had hastily added, blushing, “Unless you don’t feel comfortable, which is perfectly fine.”

“No, it’s fine,” she had told him, though her own heart had pounded, and her voice had shaken slightly. “I’d be glad to help, though I have no idea how to do it myself.”

“It’s all right. I’ll teach you. That will help me understand it better, anyway,” he had said.

And then he had guided her into the proper position, where she had one hand placed on his shoulder, and he had a hand on her waist. He had guided her through the waltzing steps and the twirls. He had even lifted her a few times. Her heart fluttered as he effortlessly lifted her high in the air, as though she weighed no more than a feather.

With all that dancing, he wasn’t even out of breath.

As they both got more comfortable, they got faster, and the movements felt less calculated and more fluid. Maitimo’s arms were strong yet gentle, skilled from years of training in dancing and archery. Whenever he took her hand, she didn’t feel he was grabbing it, nor did his grip feel limp. It was just... balanced.

And since then, whenever Aranya came to the village dances in the outskirts of Tirion, she was unimpressed with all the other néri she danced with. Some of them squeezed her hands and yanked her arms. Others felt as limp as wet grass. Tecno was somehow both at the same time, and his hands were always drenched with sweat.

Maitimo had told her she was a better dancer than many of the ladies at the court, and he wished she could have been his dance partner and not them.

“Aranya, dear?” Arcamë’s voice startled Aranya out of her thoughts.

“Hmm?” She glanced up, startled.

Arcamë smiled and handed her a pastry, made of a buttery, flaky dough and filled with cream and berries. “Would you like one?”

Aranya nodded gratefully and accepted it. She hadn’t finished her supper thanks to Tecno, and these pastries were a rare treat.

She and Arcamë ate in silence, but as they watched all the couples twirling, Arcamë glanced back at Aranya. “You know the person you wish to dance with, don’t you?”

Aranya nodded. Arcamë wasn’t blind to the way she interacted with Maitimo whenever he visited the House of his cousins, and Aranya had even told her about some of their picnics. Arcamë was the only person Aranya could trust to not gossip about it or judge her.

“Perhaps someday,” Arcamë said, “either he will leave his life or you will leave yours. I sense the bond between the two of you is strong. One day, it will happen.”

Aranya wasn’t sure if she was imagining the trace of sorrow appearing in her mentor’s eyes as she added quietly, “But it may not happen for a while. A long while.”

Aranya lowered her head, and tears came to her eyes once again. This she knew, somewhere deep down.

But she would wait.

After all, what was the alternative? Settling for someone like Tecno Lóremo? Arcamë wasn’t married, and she still lived a fulfilling and productive life. Aranya didn’t mind remaining in a similar state until the time came.

“Fëanáro sent me away from the House of Finwë,” she blurted before she could stop herself. “Because I tried to stand up for Maitimo.”

Arcamë nodded and gave a low hum, appearing completely unsurprised.

Before Aranya knew it, she had started from the very beginning, when Maitimo’s brothers were carrying his unconscious, bloodied form and screaming for help. Aranya poured out all the ways she had felt judged by Finwë’s healers, and how Fëanáro was unwittingly harming his eldest by putting such pressure on him.

Arcamë listened quietly, never saying a word except to ask a few questions to clarify her understanding. Then, after Aranya finished, she was silent for a while.

“If you’d like, I could write a letter to Mittanyissë, explaining our side of the story,” she finally said. “Is it accurate for me to say you’ve learned your lesson about heeding the advice of your elders?”

Aranya nodded eagerly. Arcamë had worked with Mittanyissë a long time ago, so her words might hold greater weight than Aranya’s.

“I cannot promise you will be granted another opportunity to study under the House of Finwë,” Arcamë added. “But it may help to smooth over the relationship so it doesn’t end with bitterness and misunderstanding.”

“Indeed. Thank you,” said Aranya. “I just… I only hope Fëanáro did not take his anger out on them as well. I wish I knew what happened after I left. Fëanáro thought I was incompetent, but he seemed to think all of us were as well. I hope… I hope he did not try to move Maitimo and take him home because of me.”

The one blessing with quick tempers like that of the Crown Prince is that they flare up quickly, but they often cool quickly as well,” Arcamë told her. “He may have forgotten his indignation as soon as one of his children came by and asked him a question. Do not fear too greatly.”

They sat in silence for a few minutes, listening to the lutists and pipers, and watching the couples dance. Then, Arcamë spoke once more. “You must learn to balance following your heart and following the rules. It seems to me as though you had the two in balance fairly well until you decided to confront Fëanáro.”

“And yet…” Aranya sighed. “I still don’t entirely regret it. I regret the way I went about it, and that I potentially brought disgrace on my fellow healers. But if I knew I would succeed in taking some pressure off Maitimo, I’d gladly do it again.”

“Your compassion for him is noble. However, be careful not to let your heart lead you too far astray. We Eldar are not Eru, and we cannot control each other. Curufinwë Fëanáro is the least likely out of all of us, I think, to be mastered or influenced by another. The only one who has ever been able to sway his will, I believe, is his wife. If you are set on altering his ways, you are only setting yourself up for disappointment.”

Aranya paused, turning this over in her mind. She didn’t want to believe it… but she couldn’t argue with it. It did sound proud and stupid, if she really thought about it, to believe she could somehow make Fëanáro into a gentler and kinder person.

But then again, that wasn’t what she had asked for. All she had wanted in this moment was for him to know it was unreasonable to expect Maitimo to do any productive studying.

Maitimo’s words to her echoed in her mind. Let me handle Fëanáro. I’ve been doing it my whole life.

Perhaps he was right. Aranya didn’t like to see him bend under his father’s unreasonable expectations, but it must have been the only way for him to safely get by and avoid unnecessary conflict. And now, seeing firsthand how awful it was to get into a fight with Fëanáro… Aranya couldn’t say she didn’t understand.

In her head, she knew this was another person’s family affairs, a royal family’s affairs, and none of it was any of her business. But in her heart, this was a person she cared deeply about. Of course she was going to find some way to help him in whatever way she could.

Next time, she’d simply be smarter about it. She wouldn’t give up.
 
Return to top

Chapter 8: Incompetence


Maitimo woke up feeling like his head and ribs were being pounded with one of Fëanáro’s hammers. Every breath felt like a stab from a knife, and every heartbeat made his head throb more. And it wouldn’t go away, no matter how still he lay or what movement he made.

These foreign, unrelenting sensations caused his heart to take off. What was this? He had never been in serious pain before. Of course he had occasionally fallen off his horse before or taken some solid whacks when his brothers got too rowdy in a play fight. But this… this was so bad, he could hardly think of anything else.

Why was he only feeling this now? Was he getting worse rather than better for some reason? This thought increased his panic, and his breath was reduced to short, choppy gasps.

Where were the healers? He didn’t see any around. Why was Aranya not here? He thought he remembered her being here earlier… reading to him…

A booming voice somewhere nearby made his head throb. Wincing, he glanced in the direction of the sound, which seemed to come from behind the silver velvet curtains in the doorway. He recognized the voices of Fëanáro and two of the healers who had been tending to him lately.

Every nerve in Maitimo’s body cautioned him not to speak, but it seemed he had no choice. He took a deep breath—wincing from the resulting pain in his ribs—and called out, “Healers?”

His world throbbed and spun, but his call was nowhere near loud enough. The sound likely only carried to the doorway. Maitimo waited a few seconds, and the arguing figures did not seem to hear. He tried not to anticipate the pain as he tried again. “Healers!

The voices outside fell silent, the curtain opened, and all three of them came in. Maitimo recognized the two healers, though he did not know their names. Fëanáro’s face was flushed, and the healers’ faces were pale and nervous.

Great work, Atar, Maitimo thought dully.

Fëanáro and one of the healers approached Maitimo, while the other immediately went to a table in the corner and started mixing herbs.

“What’s wrong?” Fëanáro was the first to speak, his voice demanding and his countenance scowling.

Fëanáro was the last person Maitimo wanted to explain his problem to, but he noticed the healer was listening, so he said carefully, “I feel… so much worse…”

He also burned with curiosity as to why Aranya was no longer among them, but even with his mind clouded and his senses overwhelmed, he knew better than to speak her name in front of Fëanáro.

“My apologies, Your Highness,” said the healer who stood close to his bed. “We are supposed to give you a draught every couple of hours to keep your pain under control. Due to unforeseen circumstances—” she subtly glanced in Fëanáro’s direction— “we are late.”

Maitimo’s gaze turned to glare at Fëanáro, and Fëanáro’s gaze turned to glare at the healers.

“The incompetence I have seen out of you lot today is astounding,” Fëanáro spat. “I will not stand idly around here and let my son suffer for it.” He glanced down at Maitimo before storming towards the door. “You would be better off with our healers at home. I will now send for a carriage and your brothers and mother.”

“Atar—”

“Do not question me! You lack the mental capacity!” Fëanáro thrust the curtain aside before leaving the room, and his footsteps faded to silence as he left the healing halls.

The two healers and Maitimo all breathed heavily, and the healers avoided Maitimo’s gaze as they prepared the draught.

“What happened?” he asked quietly. “I suppose he found some reason to be upset with you, forced you away from your duties, and then chastised you for your duties not being magically done?”

One of the healers cracked a faint smile, indicating Maitimo was not far from the truth.

But a sick feeling settled in his stomach as a new thought occurred to him. “Does this have something to do with Aranya?”

Had Fëanáro found out about her and Maitimo? Oh, Varda above, not now!

And the uneasy glance the healers shared told Maitimo he was once again close to the truth.

“Do not worry about it, Your Highness,” said one of them, bringing the cup to him and holding it to his lips. Almost immediately after he sipped the draught, a pleasant warmth came over him and his aches began to soften, and he sighed in relief. “There was a misunderstanding and some tempers flew. Just focus on preserving whatever strength you have for your ride home. You will need it,” she added with a dark look coming to her eyes.

“Please, I will worry a great deal if you don’t tell me anything. I’ll imagine all the ways it could have possibly gone wrong, and… please just tell me if Aranya’s all right. She’s—” he hesitated— “a friend of mine.”

The healer who had given him the draught sighed deeply. “Well, truthfully, we don’t know where she is. We only know the crown prince came to us complaining about her, saying she had stepped out of place. We don’t know the details or understand very well what happened, but he’s blaming us.”

Maitimo’s eyes widened and his heart sank. Had she done exactly what he had told her not to do? Just thinking about her approaching Fëanáro and telling him not to ask Maitimo to study made him squirm and cringe.

“He went on some tirade about mediocrity and competence, and said he expected more of his father’s healers, and so on. That is all we really understand about the situation,” the healer concluded. “I’m sorry, Your Highness. We will try to find Aranya and make sure she’s safe, but likely not till after you have gone home already.”

As the healers returned to their activities of preparing medicines to send home with him and writing down notes and instructions, Maitimo seethed silently. Whatever had gotten into Fëanáro’s head, to make him think his own healers were superior to those of the House of the King of the Noldor? The healers at the House of Fëanáro had never dealt with anything severe, whereas those of the House of Finwë had seen a wide variety of injuries from many of the subjects in Tirion. And didn’t Fëanáro adore his father above anyone else? Why did he think so low of his father’s healers?

And regardless of all that, Maitimo couldn’t imagine traveling home like this, short a distance as it was. The healers wouldn’t even let him sit up fully, and the mere idea of it made his head and ribs throb.

As he lay there, stewing in his bitter thoughts, the velvet curtains shifted, and a tall, dark-haired figure walked in: none other than King Finwë himself. His robe of silver velvet graced the floor with its long train, with edges finely embroidered in goldwork. A gold circlet, elaborately crafted of delicate twists and curls, crossed his brow.

“Ah, Nelyafinwë,” Finwë said with a kindly smile. He sat down beside Maitimo’s bed and took his hand. “How are you, indyo? Every time I’ve seen you, you’ve been asleep. It gladdens my heart to see you awake.”

Maitimo tried to smile at his grandfather’s warm, bright blue gaze. He’d have to conceal much, since complaining of Fëanáro’s misdeeds would only grieve Finwë. Still, Maitimo couldn’t bring himself to pretend everything was fine, and he blurted, “Not all is well, Haru.”

The strong, dark brows of Finwë creased in concern. “Are you in very much pain?”

“It’s not so bad thanks to the draughts of the healers.”

“Then what is troubling you?” At Maitimo’s long silence, Finwë pressed, “You can tell me.”

Against Maitimo’s better judgment, his words tumbled out of his mouth. “Atar wants to bring me home, as soon as he can possibly do it. At this very moment, he is sending for my mother and brothers, and a carriage.”

Finwë’s frown deepened, and Maitimo immediately regretted his words. The problem was, Finwë could easily read Maitimo and understand his feelings, nearly as well as Nerdanel or Laurë or Aranya could. But Fëanáro was the person Finwë loved more than anyone else in all Arda, and Maitimo was in near constant conflict with him.

“Why is that, indyo?” Finwë asked, giving Maitimo’s hand a gentle squeeze. “I’m sure your father must have a good reason. He only wants what’s best for you.”

Even with his mind muddied from lingering pain and the strong medicines, Maitimo realized it would be foolish business to try to explain his own understanding of Fëanáro’s motives to Finwë. “Ask him when he returns. I’m not sure I accurately understand his reasons. All I know, Haru, is I can’t imagine traveling home like this. I don’t want to go.”

Tears came to his eyes, which made his head ache harder, and he tried his hardest to swallow them back. Don’t weep before the King! he scolded himself, but to no avail.

Finwë’s expression looked like a mixture of concern and confusion, but before he could say another word, Fëanáro walked briskly in, followed closely by Nerdanel. Fëanáro blinked in surprise at the sight of his father.

“Atar,” he said, bowing. “It is good to see you. I wasn’t expecting you here.”

Finwë smiled warmly, stood, and embraced Fëanáro. “I’ve been trying to catch Nelyafinwë awake, without being in the way of you or the healers, but have not yet gotten a chance till now. Nelyafinwë tells me you plan on taking him home immediately, yondo. Why is this?”

To Maitimo’s great surprise, Fëanáro’s gaze dropped and he shifted uncomfortably. Was that guilt in his countenance? Perhaps Finwë could talk him out of his foolishness! Maitimo held his breath and resolved not to say a word, lest he ruin the moment.

“It’s nothing against you, Atar,” Fëanáro said. “I mean no offense to you or your judgment, but perhaps you are not aware of some of the shortcomings amongst your healers. Earlier today, I came upon a rather insolent young student from the House of my half-brother, who tried to give me orders as though she had authority over me, telling me I had no right to make my own son study. First of all, I did not make him study; he did so of his own volition, because he is bright and ambitious. Secondly, why does some servant girl think she can command me?”

Maitimo’s heart plummeted, and the sick feeling in his stomach intensified. Oh, Aranya… How he longed in that moment to be well, so he could jump on a horse and search for her! The healers said they didn’t know where she was, so perhaps she had fled in shame. Just imagining that conversation made Maitimo want to crawl in a hole and hide for an eternity, so he could only imagine Aranya’s mortification. And even though he probably should have thought she had brought this on herself through acting foolishly, he couldn’t bring himself to feel anything but sorrow and sympathy for her. If he could have ridden out and found her, he would have held her and told her not to think of this anymore, and perhaps they could go berry picking in the woods, or practice their braiding, or go on a long horseback ride.

“Oh, dear,” sighed Finwë, pinching the bridge of his nose, and sitting back down beside Maitimo. “I’m very sorry anyone had the audacity to disrespect you like that, yondo. You did not deserve such. I really don’t know what the younger generation is coming to sometimes.” Turning to the healers, he asked them, “Said student was sent home, I would hope?”

“We don’t know where she is, my lord,” said one of the healers with a bow. “It’s possible she returned home of her own will. But when we are finished here, we will send for somebody to find her.”

Finwë nodded, and Fëanáro continued, “This is my other grievance. When I came here to check on Nelyo, I discovered these healers here were late in giving him a draught for his pain, resulting in unnecessary suffering for him.”

The healers fidgeted and avoided his piercing gaze. Maitimo could feel his face flushing and his heart pounding with anger, and, forgetting his injuries, he struggled to sit up, but Finwë gently pushed him back down. It was a good thing he did, because even the slight movement caused another wave of dizziness to hit him, making the ceiling and all the people in the room tilt and spin. Maitimo closed his eyes, waiting for the sensation to pass.

“What is the meaning of this?” Finwë calmly asked the healers.

“We deeply apologize, Your Majesty. Prince Nelyafinwë was asleep, and we were about to wake him to give him the draught. But Crown Prince Fëanáro arrived to question us about the student, and so we did not get a chance to give him the draught in time.”

Fëanáro glared at the healers, but Nerdanel surprisingly spoke up. “My love, this is unfair to the healers. They had no chance to perform their duties.”

“Well, then there should have been more of them present besides the two!” Fëanáro shot back, spinning around to face her, his face reddened.

“To do what?” Nerdanel folded her arms and stared defiantly up at him. “Watch Maitimo sleep and give him a medicine? Could you not have simply pulled one of them aside for questioning? Had there been three, would you have demanded all three?”

Fëanáro fell silent, his jaw clenched. Maitimo always found it satisfying when, for all his self-proclaimed cleverness, Nerdanel managed to stump him.

“Enough of this.” Finwë calmly stood and motioned for silence. “Do not argue like this in front of Nelyafinwë, my children. He has been through enough. Now, I can see there are many misunderstandings. I do not believe it is fair to blame the healers of my House. They have done their duties to the best of their ability, from what I can understand. However, you also have fine healers in your House, Fëanáro, and if you believe it best to take your son home for the sake of peace, in light of these many conflicts, I understand. I trust your judgment.”

Don’t trust his judgment, Haru, Maitimo thought bitterly.

However, perhaps Finwë’s words were wiser than Maitimo’s would have been, because at having his ego flattered a little, Fëanáro relaxed visibly. His uptight posture loosened and the tightness in his jaw dissipated. His eyes, too, lost their fiery glint and appeared milder.

“Thank you, Atar,” Fëanáro said. “I do deem it best to bring Nelyo home. I believe he will heal better under my healers, under my direct supervision.”

Maitimo yearned to scream at everyone that his own opinion wasn’t even consulted, but he kept his mouth shut. Finwë had calmed the conflict for the time being, and Maitimo wasn’t stupid enough to ruin the momentary peace, even if it came at his expense. He was used to his own will and desires being of least importance in the family’s conflicts anyway.

Nerdanel must have been of the same mind. Maitimo thought he caught her glaring at Fëanáro and clenching her jaw a little. Then she caught Maitimo’s eye, and her expression softened to one of sorrow, and perhaps even some bitterness.

“It is settled, then,” said Finwë. “Do what you must, though I am sorry to see you go.”

“I am sorry to leave your fine House too, Atar.” Fëanáro took a few tentative steps towards Finwë, a trace of guilt lingering in his eyes. But once again, Finwë stood and embraced him.

“I understand it is what is best for your family, yondo. You are a good father. I’m sure Nelyo will heal swiftly under your diligent care.”

But Maitimo was fairly certain this was not going to be the case, if only because of his own anger and spite.

“Please, my love,” Nerdanel said quietly, “let’s take care with him. I fear to move him in such a state.”

“If we help him, I don’t see why he can’t walk to the carriage and sit down in it,” Fëanáro said. “His legs are not injured, after all.”

“Yes, but it was only yesterday when he lost so much blood—”

“That is why we will help him, Nerdanel. It’s a short distance. How dangerous can it be?”

Nerdanel fell silent, clearly not satisfied, but clearly not wanting to disturb the peace either. So she cast another glance at Maitimo, and they shared a long, sorrowful gaze.

“May I be alone with him for a moment?” she asked.

Fëanáro nodded. “I need to see how the boys are coming along with preparing the carriages anyway. I will be back.”

“Take your time, yeldë,” Finwë added, and he and Fëanáro left the room together.

Nerdanel sighed, perhaps with frustration or relief or both, and sat down beside Maitimo. “How are you feeling, dear? Not much up to going home, I’d imagine?”

Maitimo shook his head, trying to fight back the tears welling up in his throat. “I couldn’t even sit up a little without feeling faint, Ammë. I can’t imagine standing and walking out of here, even if I have you and Atar to lean on.”

“I know, Maitimo, I know.” Nerdanel leaned down and kissed him on the cheek, and he shuddered as his tears flowed freely. “But I fear your father is very upset. He’s worried for you more than you know, and I believe these issues with the healers, though insignificant in isolation, were just enough to provoke him far more than he normally would be. And if you and I were to defy him, even though I’m on your side and I don’t wish him to move you, we would provoke his wrath even more.”

Maitimo nodded. “I understand. That is why I have not spoken up against it.”

“If it’s any consolation, I believe he will calm down significantly after we arrive at home.” Nerdanel gently ran her fingers through Maitimo’s auburn curls, so much like her own. “Here, he is on guard, even if it is his own father’s House. He doesn’t know Finwë’s healers like he does ours. At home, he will believe the problem is resolved, and he will feel as though he has greater control, and this will calm him. He will likely become much easier for us to deal with. So, we simply need to get through this little trip home, and then everything will calm down and you can focus on getting better. I will make sure no one bothers you, especially not Tyelko and the twins.”

Maitimo cracked a smile. “I wouldn’t put it past them to think they could still jump on my bed.”

Nerdanel chuckled warmly, her gray eyes twinkling. “Those boys! I’d think they should have outgrown it years ago.”

Should have, yes. But they will never outgrow annoying me.”

“They will always be your brothers.” Nerdanel sighed and shook her head, and her smile faded. “Stay strong, Maitimo. You can lean on me and Atar as much as you need. And I hope us returning home will put an end to all this nonsense.”


Notes

Indyo: Quenya word for grandson

Haru: Quenya word for grandfather

Yondo: Quenya word for son

Yeldë: Quenya word for daughter
 
Last edited:
Return to top

Chapter 9: The Wrath of Makalaurë

The Fëanorians’ return home did not put an end to all the nonsense.

For one thing, Makalaurë was provoked to a rage, which was not a common sight in the household. Unlike Tyelkormo with his hasty anger, Makalaurë, for the most part, minded his own business and delighted in his poetry and music. He rarely spoke up in the typical family fights, usually only reacting when Tyelko pestered him beyond his ability to tolerate. And he was one of Maitimo’s precious few sources of quiet, soothing companionship. But that did not mean he did not possess his own Fëanorian fire.

Fëanáro found his sons in their assigned guest common room. When he asked the brothers to send for a carriage, Laurë thought nothing of it at first. Curvo was the first to obey, hurrying out to the stable yard, and Tyelko and the twins followed him. But Moryo lingered, and Laurë wasn’t in a hurry to follow the others either. “Are you sending us home, Atar?” Moryo asked Fëanáro, folding his arms as he stood from his seated position on a luxurious velvet sofa. “A carriage is frankly unnecessary. We all can ride competently, you know. Besides, we don’t mind staying here, waiting for a chance to see Nelyo.”

“We are all of us returning home,” Fëanáro said, seemingly unbothered by Moryo’s characteristic brashness. “The carriage is for Nelyo, your mother and myself. Not you.”

Laurë, whose mind had been halfway in another world for a time, suddenly snapped to reality. Maitimo, being brought home? Unless he had received some miracle from Estë, based on his condition yesterday, Laurë couldn’t fathom how that was possible. “You’re bringing Nelyo home?” he said incredulously to Fëanáro. “Is he that much better already?”

“Quite the opposite. I believe he is in incompetent hands here,” Fëanáro said, his ice-blue eyes narrowing as he regarded Makalaurë. “Now, am I your father and lord, or some lowly friend of yours that you should debate me? Do not question my command, and go help your brothers.”

Laurë grit his teeth. Never mind the fact that Moryo had questioned Fëanáro’s command too, and he spoke even more rudely than Laurë dared to. This was because everyone was used to Carnistir loudly blasting his every opinion for everyone to hear. How unfair that one of the rudest sons should run around unchecked, while the courteous ones had every move scrutinized! The burdens of being polite… Timo and Ammë were the only ones besides Laurë to understand this.

As for Maitimo being worse off than before, Laurë didn’t know what to think of that. The healers of Finwë were supposed to be the best of the land, so were they really doing a terrible enough job to warrant sending Maitimo home? And if he really was worse, wouldn’t that be an especially strong argument not to take him home? Would Fëanáro’s own healers, who only had experience with minor accidents, fare any better than those of Finwë?

As Fëanáro swept off, Laurë and Moryo glanced at each other, sharing a mutual look of concern and unease, before tentatively joining their brothers in the stable. There wasn’t much for either of them to do, as Tyelko was barking orders at the stable boys handling the horses, and Curvo was fiddling with the mechanics of the carriage, which was a wooden contraption on wheels, beautifully carved with designs of trees, intertwining vines, flowers and birds. Gauzy silk curtains hung in the windows.

Fëanáro returned briefly to check on their progress before disappearing into the house again. Then, the stable hands finished their work, and the carriage and horses were properly hitched up. The driver brought the carriage into the courtyard, and the brothers followed, bringing their own horses, standing in the courtyard and idly chattering as they waited. Laurë barely heard a word of it, though. His gaze was fixed on Finwë’s front gates.

The only time he started paying attention was when Pityo ran up and joined the group. No one seemed to have noticed he had gone missing.

“Where have you been?” Telvo asked him.

“Atar asked me to go with him to collect some notes from the healers,” Pityo said with a smug smile, holding up a handful of parchments.

“Why you?” Curvo asked, seemingly miffed. “I’d be worrying about you losing track of such important documents.”

“Me? Lose these? Have some faith in me, brother! These are… fascinating!” Pityo grinned widely as his eager gaze skimmed over the notes. “Did you know they can figure out how bad a concussion is just based on asking some questions? Apparently, Nelyo recited our names in the wrong order! And he forgot about Tyelko and Kano entirely! Until one of the healers reminded him, that is—”

“Pityafinwë,” Laurë said severely, “that is not a trivial matter. It means our brother is quite badly hurt.”

“How am I trivializing it?” Pityo asked, his faint red brows creasing in confusion. “I’m just fascinated that they can figure out how badly hurt the head is just by asking a few questions. That’s all. I was trying to ask one of the healers, Cendë, some questions about it. She tried to answer some of them, but Atar kept ordering her around. At one point she whispered to me that Atar even stopped them from giving Nelyo medicine at the right time, and then he blamed them for Nelyo’s worsened pain. That’s why he’s taking Nelyo home, I guess.”

All the brothers fell into stunned silence at the revelation of this information.

“Do at least attempt to get your facts straight before you tell such stories about our father,” Curvo said dully, a faint look of annoyance in his blue eyes. “We are surely missing some context. Atar has better judgment than that. Keep in mind, this was a biased account from one of the healers, whom Atar has judged incompetent, and even Haru Finwë hasn’t argued with him on the point. Do you really think both the King of the Noldor and our Crown Prince would make such a grievous error in judgment?”

“I don’t know. I’m just telling you what she told me,” Pityo said with a shrug. “And I’m sure Atar was doing what he thought was best, but I’m just saying, these healers aren’t stupid. These notes are extremely detailed. They wrote exactly what time they gave Nelyo each medicine, how he responded to each, whether or not he has blurry vision or dizziness, how much he’s been eating—not enough, by the way; we should see if we can make something good for him later.”

“Just because they know how to document what they’re doing, it doesn’t mean they’re doing the right thing,” Curvo said, his voice growing increasingly tense. “You just said yourself Nelyo’s not eating enough. Isn’t that negligence?”

“Based on the notes, I don’t think so. The notes say he feels too sick to eat much, and he keeps refusing what they try to give him. That’s not their fault. But you know how he loves the chicken soup Tyelko and I make. I think we should try that when we get home.”

“Well, maybe it’s their fault that he feels sick. Shouldn’t they be giving him better medicine, then?”

Laurë carefully and quietly listened to their exchange, wrestling with his own thoughts on the matter. It didn’t surprise him that Curvo would staunchly defend anything Fëanáro did, even without having all the facts himself, ironically enough. Fëanáro could do no wrong in Curufinwë’s eyes. If Pityo’s version of the story was correct, then Fëanáro must have gotten himself overly worked up about… something… and gotten the idea stuck in his head that the healers were incompetent. Which did sound all too much like Fëanáro. And if Laurë’s bad gut feeling was to be believed, Maitimo would suffer for it.

“What do the notes say at the very end?” Laurë asked Pityo. “Is there anything about Maitimo’s condition and whether or not it’s safe to move him?”

“Only a little…” Pityo turned to the last parchment. “It says the slightest movement, like sitting up, makes him dizzy. They don’t think all the blood he lost has been restored yet.”

“Brilliant, Fëanáro. Just brilliant,” Laurë said bitterly, under his breath.

The conversation was cut short as three figures hobbled out at a painfully slow pace. Maitimo seemed able to walk, but his posture was slumped and his gait staggered. He had an arm wrapped around each of his parents’ shoulders, but he seemed to be leaning more heavily on Fëanáro. His face was white and ashen, and he was grimacing.

A knot formed in Laurë’s stomach, but he dared not make any move or speak to the trio for fear of distracting them. He could only stand aside and watch awkwardly as Fëanáro and Nerdanel helped Maitimo get into the carriage. By the end of it, Maitimo was gasping, shuddering, closing his eyes, and pressing his fingers against his forehead.

Every muscle in Laurë’s body tensed and his mind froze in terror; he couldn’t move or think. He had a sudden urge to run away from the scene, but as he saw Nerdanel settling into one of the seats next to Maitimo and Fëanáro preparing to get in the other one, Laurë realized there was something he needed to do.

“Wait, Ammë, Atar,” he said. “Please, Atar, may I sit next to Maitimo? My presence will reassure him.”

“More so than the presence of his own father?” Fëanáro retorted.

Honestly, yes, Laurë thought, but didn’t say. After all, who did Maitimo complain to when he was overwhelmed, or tell of his visits with Aranya? Not Fëanáro.

Still, for the sake of not making things worse for Maitimo, Laurë again clenched his jaw and willed himself to keep silent. Fëanáro looked about ready to rebuke Laurë for his supposed insolence or something like that, and knowing Maitimo, such arguing would only exacerbate his stress.

Laurë managed to catch Maitimo’s eye, though, and the frustration and sorrow in his soft gray stare clearly indicated he would have preferred Laurë to be there instead of Fëanáro, but neither could speak up about it.

And so, the carriage drove off, and the brothers mounted their own horses and followed.

Maitimo hated every second of the walk to the carriage, but he hated the ride home with a burning passion. No one gave his dizziness a chance to subside before the carriage lurched off. Every bump and jostle was like a jab at his wounds. And Fëanáro was right there, trying to be a concerned father but in reality, seeming more to Maitimo like he was breathing down his neck.

Why did he have to dismiss Laurë the way he did? Why did he have to be so oblivious and arrogant as to think he was the best choice to be one of Maitimo’s close companions on the ride?

He kept his eyes closed as much as he could, with the moving scenery causing his head to spin and his stomach to churn. But he still felt every bump on the road, and Nerdanel and Fëanáro thought they were being helpful by offering him frequent words of encouragement, but the noise made his head throb and he really wished they would just be quiet.

After what felt like three ages, Nerdanel cheerfully announced they were home, and the carriage finally came to a stop. Maitimo carefully cracked his eyes open, only to find that everything was still spinning.

His parents didn’t hesitate to help him climb out of the carriage, when really, they should have hesitated. At the moment Maitimo stepped to the ground, the whole world seemed to tilt and fade to darkness.

Fëanáro and Nerdanel felt him go limp in their arms. Alarmed, they carefully laid him on the ground and spoke his name, gently shaking him and trying to revive him.

Makalaurë and the other brothers watched this in stunned silence. Images flashed through Laurë’s mind of Maitimo lying at the bottom of the cliff, in a rapidly growing pool of his own blood. And he didn’t doubt his brothers would have been troubled by the same images.

After a few attempts, Maitimo would not wake. So Fëanáro looked up and his voice thundered as he cried out, “Someone go fetch our healers!”

The Ambarussar were the swiftest to react, jumping off their horses and fleeing to the house like frightened rabbits. Though only in their early adolescence, they had some of the quickest reflexes and highest agility amongst all the brothers.

Laurë knew he would regret what he was about to do next. Or maybe he wouldn’t, but he’d get in trouble. So be it; he could no longer keep to himself his displeasure with Fëanáro’s misdeeds. In his heart he knew what was right and could no longer contain it.

“This could have all been avoided,” he said coldly, stepping closer to the group. His every word was icy, his every syllable sharply articulated. “If you’d let him stay in the House of Finwë, he would still be resting and healing right now. Or even if you’d let me ride with him, I’d have noticed he wasn’t feeling well enough to stand, because I know my brother!”

“Laurë, dear, this is not a good time—” Nerdanel said nervously, but Fëanáro’s face flushed with anger, and he cut her off.

“How dare you speak to me like that, over your brother’s wounded and unconscious form, no less! You have no place to question your father and lord, and I do not want to hear another word out of you unless it is an apology!”

Makalaurë laughed, loudly and bitterly, and the sound startled all the other brothers, who stared in horror at him. “A shame if you don’t want to hear it, Atar. You have harmed my brother, though indirectly, through your arrogance and unwillingness to see the truth. You have ignored the advice of your father’s healers and cast blame where it was not warranted. You moved Maitimo when he was not ready for it. This—” he gestured to Maitimo’s still form— “is your own doing.”

Gasps rippled throughout the group, and Fëanáro’s jaw visibly clenched, his eyes blazing with rage. “Get out of here,” he spat. “I do not wish to see your face again until you repent of your words.”

“Such a punishment,” Makalaurë said with a cold sneer, turning to walk away.

“I will not permit you to see Nelyafinwë until you repent.” Fëanáro’s words sent a cold chill down Makalaurë’s spine, but he continued to walk to the house and did not look back. “You have used your strong voice for ill, at an ill time. Begone!”

“I will! Gladly!” Laurë retorted, storming into the house, running up to his room and slamming the door.

Perhaps later, for Maitimo’s sake, he would lather up the most flattering, fake apology his creative writing abilities would allow. But he wasn’t sure his pride could endure such a thing, not even for Maitimo.
 
Return to top

Chapter 10: Vengeance


Content warning: This chapter depicts harsh treatment of an animal.

If Tyelko weren’t so frightened for Maitimo, he would have throttled Kano. And everyone thought Tyelko was the insensitive one who caused so much trouble for everyone else!

But looking at his brother’s unconscious form for the second time in two days, not even the Hasty Riser could find it within himself now to pick a fight with Kano. Besides, Fëanáro sent him off quickly and easily enough.

Instead, he approached his parents as they waited for the healers and continued to try to revive Maitimo. “I can help you bring him inside,” he told them. “I carried him all by myself yesterday.”

“No. Wait for the healers,” Fëanáro said, not glancing up from Maitimo, a look of fierce concentration on his face.

Oh, so now we’re not moving him? Tyelko huffed, walked some distance away and firmly kicked a large rock, sending it flying. The thud of the rock against the ground was satisfying enough to make up for the pain of kicking it. There was a certain satisfaction in the pain itself, too. Maitimo was in pain, so why shouldn’t Tyelko be? Especially since it was his fault Maitimo was in pain in the first place.

He watched numbly from a distance as the twins rushed forth with the healers. Tyelko was perhaps the most useless one here. He didn’t have Curvo’s smarts, the twins’ swiftness and eagerness for the healers’ notes, or Moryo’s grounding presence. Kano was the only one less useful than Tyelko here, but he was intentionally choosing to be a nuisance. He knew full well he could have used his voice to comfort the others, or he could have been a companion to Maitimo whenever he woke up, but he had chosen to reject all that in favor of his pride and anger. And here was Tyelko earnestly trying to help by offering his strength, but this was rejected. Fëanáro was the one to carefully carry Maitimo inside, guided by Nerdanel and the healers. So, Tyelko could not offer anything Fëanáro did not already have.

That wasn’t true, though. Tyelko had his gift of animal speech. But he had failed to use it when it truly mattered. Tyelko felt it was fair to blame himself for failing to communicate with the horse on time. But at the same time, it was the horse who had done the deed itself.

Where was that horse, anyway? Morirámo, his name was? It occurred to Tyelko that no one had seen him since he threw Maitimo and ran off. Nobody had cared to go after him.

Until now. That horse deserved to pay.

* * *​

As Maitimo returned to consciousness, he had no idea where he was at first. The empty, glistening white space, and drifting curtains of red gauze, appeared to him as blurry blobs of color.

There were four figures in front of him, too. Two of them he recognized as soon as his vision cleared a little: Fëanáro and Nerdanel. The other two… they were unfamiliar at first, but as he observed their red veils, he recognized them after all. Sívenettë, the senior healer in the House of Fëanáro, and her main assistant, Tyalindë. Maitimo knew those two healers well, not because he frequently got hurt himself, but because he was in charge of six rowdy brothers all the time. For the first time he could remember, now it was his turn to pay these healers a visit.

His wounds throbbed, unsurprisingly, and his entire body felt weak and shaky. But there was some sort of sweet aroma nearby which seemed to soothe him as he inhaled it. And he only vaguely remembered bits and pieces of the journey home, and how awful he had felt in the carriage. He didn’t care to work too hard to retrieve the rest of the memories.

Maitimo also vaguely made out the figures of his brothers crowded a short distance away from Fëanáro and Nerdanel. Every person here was gathered around and gawking at him. Not that he was unused to his brothers staring at him whenever he woke up, though.

“I’m glad I have delivered such a captivating performance,” he said dryly.

Most of them chuckled, and even Fëanáro cracked a smile.

“Excellent Maitimo, enchanting audiences even in sleep,” Curvo added from the back of the group, smirking. He was never one to turn down the opportunity for a joke or pun.

“I wish the journey home had not been so difficult,” Fëanáro said, his voice surprisingly quiet and subdued, and his normally proud gaze lowered to the floor. “But you are safe at home now, yondo, and there should be no more trouble. You can rest now, and Curufinwë made sure to bring your books home, for whenever you wish to have them.”

Maitimo tried to smile. There were some members of this family who could not utter the words “I’m sorry” to save their life. Tyelko, Moryo and Curvo were the main culprits, and they all inherited that trait, of course, from Fëanáro. However, each of these proud Eldar had their own way of indirectly apologizing or at least expressing guilt. Maitimo recognized these words from his father as one of those times.

“Thank you, Atar,” were the only words he could manage.

Besides, Fëanáro was right. As much as his decision to leave the House of Finwë frustrated Maitimo, it was in the past now, and it seemed like Fëanáro wasn’t going to rush the recovery process anymore. Perhaps it really required a disastrous journey to get him to understand the severity of the situation, but at least he understood now.

As Maitimo’s vision continued to clear, and he sipped at a draught Sívenettë offered him, he noticed the crowd of brothers seemed a little thinner than usual. After doing a head count, he realized Kano and Tyelko were missing.

“Where are Kano and Tyelko?” Maitimo asked.

The brothers all exchanged awkward glances, and Fëanáro opened his mouth to speak, but Nerdanel spoke up before he got a chance. “Don’t worry about them. They’ll be here to see you soon.” She gave her usual warm smile, and took Maitimo’s hand and gave it a gentle squeeze.

The tense air amongst the group didn’t fade, though, and it gave Maitimo an uneasy feeling. He wished somebody would just tell him what was going on, but he realized Nerdanel was likely just doing what Maitimo himself would do: being diplomatic, concealing some of the truth for the sake of his feelings.

Normally he might have pressed the point, but his head ached too much for him to give it much more thought. If there was some drama going on, maybe the family could sort it out without his help for once in their lives.

* * *​

“You missed Nelyo waking up,” Curufinwë said coolly to Tyelko as he arrived late to the Great Hall and reached for a few cuts of meat to put on his plate. One who didn’t know Curvo so well might have missed the subtle note of irritation in his voice. Tyelko noticed it, but elected to ignore it as he bit into a juicy chicken thigh.

“He was asking about you. Everyone was asking me where you were, as though it was my fault you weren’t around,” Curvo added, neatly folding up his napkin and placing it on the table, having finished his meal. “It was a bit embarrassing for me to not know something for once, especially information about you. It’s ruining my reputation. Or at least, everyone must have thought I was covering up for you. Where were you, anyway?”

“Hunting,” Tyelko said with his mouth full of food. It was technically true, after all.

Curvo rolled his eyes. “In the middle of the afternoon? You never do that.”

“Well, I did this time.”

“You’ve got to get better at making excuses one of these days, or else you’ll wind up sounding like Kano and his mushroom poisoning story.”

Normally, Tyelko would have laughed at such a joke, but today, his nerves had lost tolerance for any reminder of Kano, or of Maitimo being unwell. The fact that his closest brother didn’t believe his story stung, too. “I was telling you the truth,” he said severely to Curvo, and then he took his plate and goblet and stormed out of the dining hall, leaving Curvo all alone.

Curvo’s posture sagged as he watched Tyelko leave. “Well, I thought that was a good joke,” he muttered softly to himself.

* * *​

Maitimo had slept for some hours after his family left him earlier, mostly thanks to the strong draught from Sívenettë. He awakened sometime after the evening mingling, with his pain dulled, but his body still weak and dizzy.

For a few minutes he tried to ground himself by watching Sívenettë do her embroidery nearby. All healers studied the needle arts as a form of practice, and to keep their hands from idleness during slow moments, as Aranya had told him.

Thinking about her made his heart heavy. What had happened to her? Nobody had given him a clear answer.

Sívenettë noticed he was awake, and she stood, put her embroidery hoop down and approached him. She was somewhere around Nerdanel’s age, with pale gray eyes carrying a depth of wisdom, and lighter hair than was typical for a Noldo, being more of a dark brown than black.

“Is it strange for you to see me here rather than Tyelko or one of my other brothers?” Maitimo asked, with a strained attempt at a smile.

Sívenettë chuckled warmly. “You are such a responsible one, I never would have guessed I’d see you in such a predicament. But your family and the notes from the previous healers have detailed the entire incident to me, and it sounds to me like a terrible case of the wrong place and the wrong time.”

Her voice was quiet and soft, which Maitimo appreciated.

“And misjudgment,” he added. “I thought Morirámo was ready for a trail ride. He wasn’t, unfortunately.”

Sívenettë hummed lightly. “No one can know the mind of a horse save for perhaps Oromë himself, I suppose. Even the tame ones are wild.”

Maitimo nodded in agreement, and she asked him, “How are you feeling?”

“Dizzy. Otherwise, not terrible.”

“Well, you need to eat something. Speaking of which…” She glanced up and smiled towards the entrance of the healing halls, where Tyalindë stood with a wide smile, and she motioned with her hands for someone to come in. The Ambarussar hurried in, both grinning excitedly, and with Telvo carrying a covered dish on a platter.

“Nelyo, we made your favorite soup!” Pityo announced cheerily.

“Hush. Not so loud,” Sívenettë gently scolded him.

“We made your favorite soup,” Pityo repeated, this time in a whisper.

Telvo nodded proudly. “And without Tyelko’s help.”

“How very thoughtful of you,” Maitimo said with a smile, though he glanced uneasily at the healers, unsure if he should trust something the twins made unsupervised. As wild and ill-behaved as Tyelko could be, he at least knew how to cook meat safely, thanks to Fëanáro and Maitimo drilling it into his head at a young age. And with his big appetite and frequent hunts, Tyelko had plenty of practice in catching, skinning and cooking his own meat. The twins, however, didn’t have as many years of experience.

As though she could read Maitimo’s thoughts, Sívenettë leaned down and whispered in his ear, “I sent Tyalindë to ensure they were properly supervised by the cooks. I believe Tyalindë may have helped them herself, too, as she has been with them this whole time.”

“Oh, good,” Maitimo said with a slight laugh. The twins were getting old enough to take on some responsibility, but they were still flighty and easily distracted, so they still required some supervision for such a task as cooking chicken soup. And if Tyelko wasn’t around, there was no one better suited for the task than Tyalindë, who was the twins’ favorite out of all the servants, since she shared their playful temperament.

He didn’t object as Sívenettë helped him sit up and Tyalindë placed the platter on a raised tray over his lap. He still felt nauseous, but chicken soup sounded less objectionable than anything else. The twins watched him eagerly as he tasted it, and they both grinned when he smiled and hummed in approval. The flavor of the broth was rich and perfectly balanced with the right amounts of herbs and salt. The twins must have certainly had some skilled help, then.

“You did a good job,” he told them. “It’s even better than Tyelko’s, but don’t tell him I said that!”

The twins exchanged an excited look and raised their fists in a silent cheer.

“But yours is always the best, Timo,” said Pityo. “I don’t think we or Tyelko will be able to ever beat it.”

“That’s very sweet of you,” Maitimo said. He wouldn’t have admitted it, but he was grateful for the recognition. Though the House of Fëanáro had plenty of servants to cook at home, Fëanáro had taught all his sons to be able to live off the land and cook for themselves whenever they went on journeys. Maitimo had always been creative in finding the right types of herbs, and yes, mushrooms, to add to a soup, and his knowledge had grown thanks to Aranya.

“Where has Tyelko been, anyway?” he asked the twins. “Why wasn’t he with all of you earlier, and why didn’t he help you cook?”

The twins only shrugged, with Pityo looking blank, and Telvo looking slightly irritated. “We don’t know. Last we saw him was when we all got home. After you fainted, I think he took off somewhere,” said Telvo.

Maitimo’s heart beat a little faster with sudden worry. “So no one has seen him since then? What if he ran away somewhere? It’s not safe to be alone outside at this hour.”

“Oh, no,” Pityo piped up. “Curvo told us he saw Tyelko come in briefly to grab some supper after the rest of us were done. I guess Tyelko must be just sulking somewhere, probably in his room. He’s in a bad mood, I guess.”

Maitimo nodded, relaxing a little. That did indeed sound like Tyelko, especially since he seemed to be taking the incident harder than the rest. Maitimo wished Tyelko would just come talk to him and tell him how he felt, and allow Maitimo to reassure him that none of this was his fault. But, in all fairness, there hadn’t yet been an opportunity for that.

“If you see him, will you tell him I’d like to talk to him, just the two of us? Tell him he’s not in trouble,” he said, glancing at the twins and the healers. All four of them nodded.

Maitimo ended up being grateful he hadn’t refused the soup, because counterintuitively, he felt less nauseous and less dizzy after he had finished. But not long afterwards, he grew very drowsy again, and the healers sent the twins away so he could sleep. It was amazing how quickly he got tired even though he wasn’t doing much of anything.

He awoke with a start a few hours later, gasping for breath, feeling as though his ribs were being stabbed and his head was being pounded. It must have been late at night, since the only light shining through the red-veiled windows was the silver light of Telperion.

A sight nearby startled him enough that, for a brief second, he forgot the pain. Laurë was seated next to his bed, writing something on a parchment, using no light except a silver beam shining through the window. His raven-dark hair blended in with the shadows of the night. He quickly glanced over at Maitimo, though, hearing his labored breathing.

“What’s wrong, Timo?” he asked, clasping Maitimo’s hand. Maitimo found himself unintentionally gripping his favorite brother’s hand.

“Pain’s really bad,” was all he managed to gasp out.

Laurë seemed unsurprised, and he calmly nodded. “The healers said this might happen. Give me a moment, and I’ll go get them.” With a slight frown, he added, “If you release me from your iron grip first.”

Maitimo tried to smile, but it likely looked more like a grimace as he let go of Laurë’s hand. Laurë then got up and walked a short distance away to where the healers slept on some unused beds. He spoke a few soft words to them, and they quickly got up and approached Maitimo.

“We only use this draught in severe cases, since it is strong and can take a toll on the body if used too much,” Sívenettë told him as she held a cup to his lips. He barely choked the stuff down; it was thick and bitter. But it worked quickly, and within a few minutes, the pain dissipated to a dull throb. The healers returned to bed, but Laurë remained, looking calm and alert.

“What are you doing here at this hour, anyway?” Maitimo asked him.

“Brother, I thought you knew I rarely ever sleep at night,” Laurë said with a chuckle. “It only makes sense for me to watch over you so our healers can get some rest.”

“Well, yes…” Maitimo sighed. These medicines were messing with his ability to think. “I guess what I meant to ask was, why weren’t you with the others earlier?”

“I wasn’t allowed to be,” Laurë said flatly.

Maitimo blinked in stunned confusion. It made no sense that he would be deprived of the company of his favorite, even-tempered brother. Was this another idiotic executive decision from Fëanáro? “Why would you of all people be forbidden from seeing me?”

Laurë heaved a long, deep sigh. His sighs were nearly twice as long as anyone else’s due to his incredibly strong lungs. “Because I told our father dearest what he needed to hear, and what no one else would dare tell him. He didn’t like that much, as you might guess. He told me I would not be allowed to see you until and unless I apologize, and I swear I won’t till the end of time. Technically, I’m sure I’m not supposed to be with you right now, but Atar is surely either sleeping or in the forge, or in all likelihood, sleeping in the forge. What he doesn’t know can’t hurt him.”

Maitimo’s head spun as he tried to process all this information. Whatever had transpired when the family arrived home, it had clearly been enough to make even the patient Makalaurë snap, and this came as no surprise to Maitimo. Pretty much everyone had been driven to their breaking point over the course of these past two days. Still, if Maitimo were in Laurë’s place, he most certainly wouldn’t have chosen the time of Fëanáro dealing with an unconscious son to pick a fight with him.

But then again, Maitimo hadn’t, and would never, pick a fight with Fëanáro at all, simply because he knew such fights couldn’t be won.

“What exactly did you say to him?” he asked.

“I told him he is the one who worsened your injuries and brought you to unconsciousness with his foolhardiness.”

Maitimo winced and rubbed his forehead. “Kanafinwë…”

“Don’t Kanafinwë me!” he said indignantly, folding his arms. “Don’t tell me you’re on his side, Nelyafinwë! I was defending you!”

“I’m not on his side, and I appreciate that you would defend me, but… I believe that moment was enough to teach Fëanáro the error of his ways, and he would have come to that conclusion without stinging words from you. As blind and arrogant as Atar was, he’s not cruel, and he did what he did because, in his misguided way, he thought it was best for me. I would guess it grieved him when he finally realized his actions brought me ill, and your words truly must have hurt him.”

Makalaurë was silent for a long moment, seeming to brood in his thoughts. Then he finally said, his voice quiet and bitter, “And I did that on purpose. He hurt you, so he deserves to be hurt back.”

“Perhaps so. But vengeance is in the hands of Eru, not ours.”

A look of irritation crossed Laurë’s features, and he opened his mouth as though to retort, but seemed to think better of it and promptly closed it. “Forgive me for arguing with you at a time like this, brother,” he said, his expression cooling to a gentle smile. He uncrossed his arms and took Maitimo’s hand again. “None of that matters now. The most important thing is that you get back to sleep.”

“You’re sounding like Aranya,” Maitimo grumbled, but he couldn’t fight to keep his eyes open much longer.

* * *​

Fëanáro had been wrong about many things lately, but he was right about one thing: home was a calm, stable place for Maitimo to heal. Maitimo had assumed it would be the other way around, because he wasn’t sure anyone would manage the children enough to give him some peace and quiet. But his parents, now that they understood the severity of his injuries, were particularly diligent in taking care of the younger children and making sure none of them overwhelmed Maitimo. Even Laurë helped, though as he told Maitimo, helping Moryo and Curvo with their studies was the only thing he could stand to do, since they focused on their academics quietly and with discipline, unlike the other young brothers.

However, Laurë continued to only visit Maitimo in the secrecy of the night, since he still could not suffer his pride to apologize to Fëanáro.

The first full day home, Maitimo did very little other than sleep. He didn’t even study a tiny bit; the mere thought of looking at his books sounded exhausting. He fretted over this, wondering if he was getting worse rather than better, and if he would ever be able to recover his academic abilities. But his weariness surpassed his worry, and the healers along with Fëanáro and Nerdanel kept the healing halls quiet and empty.

The next day, Maitimo noticed a significant improvement. His pain was lessened and some of his energy had returned. He felt restless and eager to move around, so the healers allowed him to walk around the healing halls a little, though he still had to lean on somebody. Oddly enough, standing and walking was easier than trying to sit up on his own. And he asked to look at his books a little, though he couldn’t read for very long without tiring.

The third day, even more of his strength and energy had returned, and he joined the rest of his family for dinner. It was a little hard to tolerate at times, because the loud chatter from all his brothers hurt his head, and even Fëanáro and Nerdanel couldn’t keep everyone perfectly subdued. But Maitimo endured it with joy, because the family hadn’t been together like this since… he couldn’t remember when. The only thing dampening the mood was the iciness between Fëanáro and Makalaurë. The former hadn’t seemed to forget his vow, and he made Laurë sit opposite of Maitimo at the table, when normally they sat together. And similarly, Makalaurë’s pride and resolution remained unbroken.

Whenever Makalaurë had visited Maitimo lately, he had gently urged him to do the right thing and apologize, but Laurë not-so-subtly changed the subject every time.

At the end of the third day, Nerdanel helped Maitimo walk back to the healing halls, though he didn’t need that much support; she linked her arm in his, ready to help him regain his balance if he stumbled, but that was all.

“Perhaps tomorrow, we can try the stairs,” she told him. “If you can manage it, you can go back to your room.”

“That would be nice,” Maitimo agreed. Early on, he had been so exhausted that he didn’t care where he slept; any horizontal surface would do. But now, he was missing his own bed, as it was bigger than the ones in the healing halls, and his legs were getting a little cramped. Besides, the healing halls were sterile and empty, and he missed the comfort of his own room with the velvet blankets, his neatly organized bookshelf, and his great oak desk well-stocked with paper and ink.

“I have some news for you,” Nerdanel told him as he sat down on the bed. There was a faint smile on her lips, and her gentle gray eyes sparkled with excitement. “I’m sure you’re aware… things have been difficult between your father and me for some years now. I always tried to keep you and the others far from our arguing, and his leaving to Formenos all the time helped me succeed. Nonetheless, I know you are sensitive and perceptive to such things, so I’m sure our tension has not escaped your notice.”

Maitimo nodded in slight confusion, wondering where she was going with this. Somewhere deep down, he still wondered what all their fighting was about, since he always avoided them when they argued and neither of them spoke a word about it to him. And he had never asked about it, since his fear of stirring up more conflict was greater than his curiosity. This continued to be the case, as he did not ask Nerdanel for any more details now.

Now that Maitimo was involved in the politics of Tirion, he was starting to become more aware of Fëanáro’s reputation. He was widely regarded as a brilliant innovator, the most skilled amongst the Eldar. But he was also proud and refused help from anyone who was interested in his crafts. Since Nerdanel was so conscious of the family’s political reputation, Maitimo suspected her grudge may have related at least in part to that, but he couldn’t be certain.

Nerdanel continued, “If any small good has come out of your accident, it is this. Your father and I have been forced to work together to take care of all of you again, like we did many years ago. And this has made us realize… we miss each other. We regret all these petty arguments and years of distance.”

Maitimo, again, could only nod, not daring to probe any deeper, though the information was fascinating to him.

“There is something we have agreed on,” Nerdanel said. “We feel empty and run dry, and we need a time of rest and retreat with each other before we can continue to pour into all of you. In order to offer you our best, we need to care for each other first. Since you are doing so much better, we had hoped to depart as soon as possible, perhaps tomorrow.” At Maitimo’s wide-eyed glance, she added, “Makalaurë has agreed to watch over Carnistir and Atarinkë, and Tyelkormo the twins, so you needn’t worry about any of them. The healers told me you are in no danger anymore and should continue to improve with rest. But regardless, I wanted to find out how you feel about this. Will it make you anxious if Atar and I leave? We can wait if you feel you still need us.”

Maitimo nodded slowly as he considered the matter. Nerdanel was right, he realized; Laurë was nearly of age and perfectly capable of managing Moryo and Curvo, and he himself admitted they were tolerable to him. And Tyelko, wild as he could be, was older than Maitimo was when he had first started caring for his brothers. It made Maitimo a little uneasy to think what he and the twins might get themselves up to, but Sívenettë and Tyalindë were practically like additional mothers to them, and they would likely keep some level of awareness of their whereabouts.

Besides, it had been decades since Fëanáro and Nerdanel had last acted like they loved each other. Maitimo was not about to become the thing standing in the way of their love rekindling.

Part of him wondered if he would get another sibling out of this. Nerdanel insisted she was done with her childbearing years and that seven was more than enough, but… she had said the exact same thing after Curvo was born, too.

Smiling to himself and shaking the thought aside, he said, “Of course I don’t mind, Ammë. It gladdens my heart that you and Atar would find peace with each other again. I’ll be fine, as long as everyone continues to leave me alone.”

Nerdanel smiled warmly, pushed his copper curls aside and kissed his forehead. “You are such a sweet and loving son. I don’t know what I did to deserve you. And truly, I hate to leave you, even though you are doing better, but I also fear this moment of healing with your father will vanish like a mist in the morning if I do not act on it now.”

* * *​

Tyelkormo had been doing little other than hunt these three days. And now, on the morning of the fourth day, he found his target.

Morirámo, that cowardly idiot, had been nibbling on some grass in a forest clearing some leagues away from home. His ears had pricked up and he had prepared to bolt at the sound of Tyelko’s approach, though his giant hound’s pawsteps hardly made a sound.

“Halt,” Tyelko said severely in the horse tongue, dismounting Huan and approaching the horse. Morirámo froze in place, unable to move under Tyelkormo’s command.

Danger, Morirámo said. It was the word he uttered most often.

“That’s right, danger,” Tyelko said with a cold sneer. “You put my brother in danger, you coward. You broke his ribs and bashed his head for the sake of what? A snapping twig?”

Morirámo is sorry, the beast said. His eyes widened to the point of exposing the whites of his eyes, and he pranced in place, though unable to move anywhere else, still bound under Tyelkormo’s command. Morirámo did not mean to spook. The Tall One was always good to him. He did not wish to hurt him.

“Well, you did anyway!” Tyelko shot back, his face reddening with rage, and he stormed towards the dark horse. “Hold still. You are not to move until I release you.”

In the background, Huan whimpered softly at the ferocity of Tyelko’s words, but Tyelko ignored it.

Morirámo had no choice but to obey Tyelko, holding perfectly still, though his widened eyes watched the hunter’s every move. Tyelko then approached Morirámo’s side and delivered him a firm smack in the ribs. Morirámo squealed. The blow wasn’t enough to injure the horse, but it was enough to sting and give him a fright.

Master, do not hurt Morirámo! The horse protested. He said he is sorry!

“Lower your head,” Tyelkormo said coldly, ignoring Morirámo’s pleas. The horse again had no choice but to obey. Tyelkormo then smacked him on the forehead, and Morirámo squealed again.

“You deserve that and so much worse!” Tyelkormo cried. “You’re lucky my master Oromë forbids the slaying of horses! Now, get out of here! I never want to see you before my face again!”

Morirámo took off like a stone released from a slingshot, disappearing into the woods in the blink of an eye.

Tyelko breathed heavily, and his hands shook for some reason. He had thought it would be satisfying to hurt Morirámo in the same places where he had hurt Maitimo, but all Tyelko felt inside was a numbness and… fear.

A deep voice clearing his throat behind Tyelko startled him. He turned and faced… none other than Oromë, the Vala of hunting.

A mighty sight to behold, Oromë was clad in deerskin, which draped loosely over his shoulder and exposed his muscular chest and arms. He wore leather sandals with straps crossing up to his knees. His thick brown hair and beard framed his face in wild curls, and a quiver of arrows and bow were slung around his back. His leather belt housed a wide variety of knives, and in his right hand he held a spear.

“What do you want from me?” Tyelko said dully. “I obeyed your command. I didn’t slay him, though he deserved it.”

“You have no place to make such a judgment,” said Oromë, his face somehow even grimmer and sterner than usual. “Horses are the wildest of beasts, and cannot be blamed for acting on their instinct. And though you have followed the letter of my commands, you have broken the spirit by harming a creature which is not for us to kill or maim.”

“But I didn’t maim him!” Tyelko argued.

“Not in body, no.”

Tyelko was silent for a long moment, unable to come up with an argument in his own defense. Finally he said, “Well, Morirámo hurt my brother in body and scarred my heart and mind. Do you know what it’s like, Lord Oromë? No, of course you don’t, because you Valar are so perfect and have never suffered. I had to rescue my brother’s mangled, bloodied body from the bottom of a cliff and carry him to the house of my grandfather! All because of that cursed horse!”

Tyelko’s lip quivered as he tried to choke back tears. His knees buckled, and he collapsed to the ground and gave in to his sobs. His whole body trembled. It was the first time he had wept, really wept, since the incident.

“Rather than seeking vengeance, you should have sought help,” Oromë said gently, slowly taking a few steps towards Tyelko. “I am here to help you.”

He reached out and put a large, strong hand on Tyelko’s shoulder, but Tyelko flinched away and glanced up coldly at him.

“If you’re here to help, then why didn’t you stop this from happening? You could have appeared, like you did just now. You could have cast the fear out of Morirámo’s mind. Or at the very least, you could have told me to tell Maitimo never to touch that stupid horse!”

Oromë was silent and only gazed calmly at Tyelko, who shook his head and stood up.

“I told Morirámo I don’t want to see him again,” Tyelko said. “I don’t want to see you again either! Come on, Huan, let’s go!”

Huan looked dolefully at Tyelko, and then at Oromë, but had no choice but to yield as Tyelko mounted him and took off into the woods.

Tyelkormo wasn’t sure where he would go. He would not go home, or to the Woods of Oromë. Nor was he at all interested in returning to the hoarded wealth in Formenos. But he would figure it out, and he would stay for a long while, possibly forever.
 
Return to top

Chapter 11: I’m Home Alone, And I’m Singing

Fëanáro and Nerdanel left before breakfast the next morning. Maitimo was only aware of this because they woke him up sometime during the wee hours of the morning. He fell back asleep promptly, and he barely remembered their bidding him goodbye later.

But he felt well enough to join his brothers for breakfast. Laurë sat in his usual place next to Maitimo, since Fëanáro wasn’t around to tell him otherwise. And Laurë did a much better job than Fëanáro and Nerdanel in keeping the room quiet; he himself spoke in soft, melodious tones, which Moryo and Curvo tried to mimic. The twins, however, kept raising their voices, and whenever they did, Laurë promptly silenced them with a firm, resonant tone of voice.

“Where is Tyelko?” Laurë huffed after shushing the twins for the fifth time. “He’s supposed to be watching those two so I don’t have to deal with them.”

“He often hunts early in the morning,” Maitimo said. “Though I suppose normally he would be back by now.” Raising his voice as much as he was able, he asked the group, “When was the last time anyone saw Tyelko?”

The brothers all exchanged awkward glances and muttered quietly to each other.

“I think I heard him slam his door shut last night,” Pityo piped up, trying to be helpful. “I’ve barely seen him at all these past three days, though.”

Maitimo frowned. That wasn’t a good sign, since Tyelko had agreed to watch the twins, and Laurë would get overwhelmed if he had to do it. “When was the last time any of you actually saw him?”

Moryo and the twins reported a few brief Tyelko sightings yesterday and the day before, such as seeing him come to the dining hall for some leftover food or seeing him enter or leave his room, but none of it was very helpful to Maitimo in figuring out what was going on. He noticed Curvo was eerily silent and staring intently at his plate throughout the whole conversation.

“Curvo?” Maitimo asked gently. “Do you know anything?”

“Nothing more than anyone else,” Curvo muttered, keeping his gaze moodily fixed on his barely-touched eggs and ham.

“Are you sure?”

“I never say anything I’m less than sure of, Nelyo,” Curvo said with a deep scowl and a testy edge to his voice.

“I didn’t mean to imply that,” Maitimo said, trying to keep his voice level as the brothers’ glances and murmurs turned increasingly anxious. “I guess what I meant to say is, you’re more likely than any of us to know what Tyelko’s been up to, and we need your help.”

“I’d help if I had anything to offer. Tyelko’s hardly told me a thing lately. I’ve barely seen him. I’m no different to him than anyone else, apparently.”

Though Curvo was often difficult to read, Maitimo could clearly sense the hurt now in his strained voice and avoidant gaze. So then, Tyelko must have been shutting out Curvo too, rather than Curvo being an accomplice in Tyelko’s secrecy, which was normally the case.

A sick feeling settled in Maitimo’s stomach. This was worse than he thought.

“We need to get to the bottom of this, and quickly,” he said. Despite his lingering weariness, his voice managed to resonate across the room and silence the murmuring brothers. “In any normal case, I’d go out and look for him myself, but obviously…”

“Maitimo, this is ridiculous. You shouldn’t have to worry about it at all,” Laurë said with a cool smile, seeming to snap out of his quiet musings. “We’ll take care of it. Moryo, Curvo, you help me ride out to look for him. We’ll all split up and choose different areas to search. Ambarussar, you will stay with Moryo and follow his lead.”

“Hey!” Telvo snapped, his freckled face flushing red. “We can ride swifter than the rest of you, and we’re perfectly good hunters in our own right. We don’t need to be nannied like this. We would cover more ground if you let us go on our own.”

Even Pityo’s normally cheerful gaze darkened, and he nodded vehemently. “It’s not fair! Atar would let us ride by ourselves.”

“But you’re still too young and easily distracted to go out riding by yourselves,” Moryo said bluntly. “The rest of us are responsible.”

Maitimo winced and rubbed his forehead as the arguing escalated to a louder volume. “Brothers, Laurë is in charge of all of you for the time being. Don’t argue with him and do as he says.”

The twins pouted and muttered something to each other under their breath, but they didn’t object any further. All the brothers finished their meal in haste and then got up to leave.

“Be back by the mingling of the lights if you don’t find him,” Maitimo urged them. “You know how the night can be perilous with dangers of wolves for lone riders.”

“We’ll be fine, Nelyo, especially since we have to be a group of three,” Telvo said dully.

“Still, I agree with him,” Laurë said. “We should regroup by the evening mingling partly because of the danger, partly for reassuring Maitimo, and partly so we know if somebody found Tyelko, and if not, where they looked.”

Moryo and Curvo hummed in agreement, and with that, everyone departed, leaving Maitimo alone in the Great Hall.

The silence felt thick and oppressive compared to the typical rowdy ruckus of the brothers. The haphazardly placed plates and scattered crumbs made it feel like the brothers would come back any second. Unable to stand the strange stillness and silence, Maitimo got out of there as quickly as he could.

Immediately, he searched for something to occupy his mind with, knowing the alternative was to sit around and stress about his brothers. His first idea was to try the stairs. So he fetched Sívenettë and Tyalindë to go with him in case there was a problem, but as it turned out, he climbed the stairs without needing them at all. His side ached a little from the movement, but the satisfaction of his increased mobility and independence overcame the pain.

“I think I should be fine for a while,” he told the healers, upon reaching the top. “I’ll summon you if I need you.”

They nodded in agreement. “Just don’t get too excited about going up and down the stairs for the sake of it,” Sívenettë told him. “If you can, try to stay up here for a while. I’d hate for you to disturb your stitches.”

“I won’t,” Maitimo said with a smile, faintly amused by the idea of going up and down the stairs for the sake of mere amusement. Though, if he got bored enough with the quietness of the house, he realized the idea might become tempting to him.

Still, he had all his books up here, and no brothers or parents to bother him! He could finally make some serious progress on the speech he had started to write for the city council!

For some hours, he kept himself thoroughly amused. Only his parchment, legal books, and several cups of tea served as his company. When was the last time he had uninterrupted time to focus on his studies like this? Had he ever had such time in his life?

There were a few times when he grew tired and sore, and he lay on his bed and allowed himself to rest a while. How good it felt to be able to fully stretch his legs again… he decided he would ask the healers if he could stay up here from now on. He didn’t need so much from them now, after all. All he needed was for them to give him medicine and change his bandages a few times a day. This was a world of difference from three or four days prior.

After some hours, the silence was making him restless, and his eyes wandered to something he had not touched in years: his lyre, sitting in a corner and collecting dust. When was the last time he had played that? Probably not since his voice changed and he lost all confidence in his singing abilities.

Fëanáro and Nerdanel had taught all their sons in music, though none of them had taken to it the way Makalaurë had. Most of the brothers weren’t patient enough to learn how to play chords, read music, or sing scales. Maitimo had the patience, but as his voice had begun to change and crack constantly, he had become too mortified to dare singing again. Now, he was far too busy for such endeavors, and he could never hope to keep up in singing along with Laurë’s impossibly high range anyway.

Figuring nobody was around to judge him, he spent some time cleaning and tuning his lyre, and then he carefully plucked out what he could remember of a song of Valinorë his parents had taught him long ago. And, though his heart pounded for some reason, he tentatively began to softly sing the words, an octave lower than the way he had sung it as an Elfling.

Maitimo had no idea if he sounded good or not, but the notes vibrated pleasantly in his chest. If he didn’t strain after any high notes, the song felt comfortable, at least.

The hours drew on, and eventually, Maitimo lost focus on his activities, and his mind wandered to thoughts of his brothers. The lights of the Trees would be mingling soon, and there was no sign of any of them.

Well, I did tell them to be back by the mingling of the lights, not before, he told himself. They will probably want to search till the last possible second. They still have time.

Regardless, though, the brothers had clearly been searching all day, and no one had found Tyelko. That was a sickening thought indeed; it meant the situation was every bit as serious as Maitimo suspected.

Desperate for some company, he went downstairs and returned to the healing halls. Sívenettë and Tyalindë told him not to worry, but they had no substance behind their words. They couldn’t give him a good reason not to worry other than it was bad for his health.

The silver and gold lights mingled. Still no brothers.

Maitimo’s slight worry grew to a distinctive sick feeling in his stomach. They’re bad at keeping track of time, he tried to reassure himself. Still, how hard was it to pay attention to the broad beams of light illuminating the entire land? Moryo was especially conscientious regarding time; he’d have followed Maitimo’s command to the letter, and made sure the others did too. Kano, though he easily got lost in his own daydream world, was highly sensitive to Maitimo’s feelings, so he would have understood the importance of returning at least close to the agreed time. Curvo would have likely seen the logic of the agreement too. So the only ones who might have believably dishonored the agreement were the twins, and Moryo was supposed to be with them. No, there had to be some reason why all five of the brothers were still gone.

The healers eventually went to bed and told Maitimo to do the same. He tried, but his heart and his mind raced.

What are the chances that none of them would be back by now? Something bad must have happened…

Maitimo tossed and turned for what must have been a few hours. Not even the strong nighttime medicine the healers gave him helped him fall asleep.

Finally, he sat up and sighed. This was ridiculous. He was the older brother of these young Eldar, and in his parents’ absence, he was the head of the house. And as the day had demonstrated, he was no longer bedridden. And he wasn’t doing himself any favors by tossing and turning all night.

He didn’t bother to ask the healers because he knew they would have said no. He went to the armory and put a mithril mail shirt on over his clothing, and took a hunting spear, just in case he encountered any wolves.

His side hurt a little when he mounted a horse, and his head throbbed, but he was too anxious to care. Maitimo took off and rode into the night.

* * *​

That day, Tyelko rode Huan to the eastern beaches of Valinorë. It wasn’t far from Tirion, and he did nothing for a while except sit in the sand and stew miserably in his thoughts.

Huan wasn’t talking to him. Though, in all fairness, Tyelko wasn’t talking to Huan either. But still, Huan would turn his big dark eyes away whenever Tyelko glanced in his direction. This stung Tyelko’s heart, though it would have stung his pride even more to try to talk about what had happened, let alone apologize.

What was beyond those tranquil blue seas, anyway? Fëanáro and Finwë and the history books all spoke of the Elves who first awoke in Cuiviénen, which was across the sea. Tyelko was also quite familiar with the wars Melkor and the Valar had fought with each other, wild and bitter wars which destroyed entire continents.

Maybe I’d fit in there, Tyelko thought. Wildness and destruction… that certainly sounded more like Tyelko than all these perfect, wise, crafty Noldor he lived with. And the Vanyar and Teleri were utterly perfect too, running around looking pretty or writing poems or building ships. Again, nothing like Tyelko. And not to mention the Maiar and Valar who lived all over Valinorë. Even Oromë, who loved wandering and hunting, was apparently too perfect for Tyelko.

Whereas across the sea, there lived the strange Elves who did not come to Valinorë. Whoever they were, they didn’t know Tyelko. They didn’t know how he had first failed his brother and then harmed one of the very beasts he claimed to love. Over there, he could become a new person. He could hunt to his heart’s content and indulge in every wildness he craved. Do everything Maitimo and the adults constantly told him not to do.

But the problem was, how? He had no boat. If Curvo were here, he probably could have figured out how to craft something functional enough to do the job. Maybe not as beautiful as the swan boats of Alqualondë, but Tyelko didn’t care about that. With a sigh, he grabbed the largest boulder he could lift and hurled it into the water. It plopped into the sea with a dull kaplunk.

Alqualondë. That was it! Tyelko internally kicked himself for not having thought of it. Maybe someone there would be willing to give him a boat. He wasn’t about to ask for a swan boat, but rather something small and simple. Now, he didn’t have any money on his person. It was never needed when hunting in the forest, and Maitimo and Moryo usually kept track of everyone’s spending money when they went shopping in the city. And Tyelko couldn’t go home to get some money, obviously.

A sick feeling settled in his stomach as he realized he did have something very valuable: Huan.

The great hound stared pathetically at him, as though he knew Tyelko’s thoughts. At first, Tyelko dismissed the idea. Huan is my best friend! How dare I ever give him up?

But perhaps… perhaps it was better this way. Tyelko didn’t feel he was worthy of Huan anymore. And maybe the lands beyond the sea were too dangerous. Perhaps it would be cruel to force Huan to come along on this perilous journey, especially after Tyelko had scared him the way he did. Huan had once been Oromë’s, so maybe now it was time for him to find someone new, someone better than Tyelko.

“I’m sorry, Huan,” he whispered, squeezing his eyes shut, and some tears leaked out. “I have to do this. I don’t deserve you anymore.”

Huan made no response.

Tyelko got up and didn’t even bother to brush the sand out of his clothes. He decided he did not deserve to use Huan as his mount, so he trudged north towards Alqualondë on foot.

Huan followed him, loyally as ever.

* * *​

Maitimo rode in a careful perimeter around the House of Fëanáro, knowing his brothers would certainly not be so close by, but wanting to be certain of which areas he had covered and which he hadn’t. And he slowly expanded the perimeter over time.

At first, his spirits were high. He rode carefully at an easy canter, knowing too much jerky movement might rip out his stitches. But with plenty of medicine still in his body, he wasn’t in much pain, and his mind was alert. He felt so much better riding out here, doing something useful, than he would have lying in bed and worrying.

Every little noise startled him, though. Every time a raccoon scuttled through the bushes or his horse snapped a stick, he raised his spear and glanced around for wolves.

A few times over the next few hours, he paused to rest his horse. But he was starting to find he needed the rest too, perhaps even more so than the horse. As the medicine started to wear off, his wounds throbbed more and more noticeably.

During one such instance where his horse grazed and he leaned against a tree, struggling to catch his breath, an eerie noise made him jump: the howling of wolves.

His horse jerked its head up and its ears flicked towards the sound, its eyes wide. Maitimo knew that look: the horse was getting ready to bolt.

He scrambled over, thrust his arm out and grabbed the reins. Then he yelped as a sharp, ripping sensation of pain shot through his side.

No time to think about that now. He jumped up on the horse, and they took off at a gallop away from the howling noise.

They galloped for some minutes, with Maitimo paying no mind to their direction other than getting away. Eventually, the howls faded to silence, and Maitimo allowed his panting horse to slow to a walk.

He glanced around at their surroundings. Where exactly were they, anyway? All the woods looked the same, so Maitimo had been solely relying on his mental sense of direction, which was now disoriented.

For some reason, he was finding it difficult to think. His heart still pounded, and he felt a little lightheaded. The forest seemed to blur as he tried to study it.

Well… last he remembered, he wasn’t far from the Nolofinwians. Maybe he’d find some sort of landmark eventually.

* * *​

The morning light of Laurelin hadn’t quite appeared yet, but Findekáno and Írissë were already out on their morning hunt. No matter how much they tried, they could never get Turukáno to participate, since he was a boring brother and preferred to study in the morning instead.

“Bet you can’t catch me!” Finno sang as his horse raced past Íri’s. He wasn’t far from coming of age, so his skills in hunting and riding were well advanced. Still, his small height and innocent personality had not seemed to catch up with his numerical age yet.

“Hey, no fair, you didn’t tell me we were racing!” Íri hollered, scowling and kicking her horse until it galloped. Being a young adolescent now, she had accumulated plenty of hunting and riding skills in her own right. “Besides, you’re gonna scare all the prey away!”

“You’re sounding like Tyelko. You’ve been hanging out with him too much lately!”

“And I’m going to be a more competent hunter than you because of it.”

“You’re also going to lose all your sense of fun!” Finno glanced behind at Íri and grinned, but her eyes widened.

“Finno, watch out!”

Finno glanced ahead, cried out in surprise, and yanked his horse to a halt just in time to avoid colliding with another rider on another horse: none other than Maitimo!

At first, Finno and Íri could only stare at him, jaw dropped. A few days ago, their father had received a rather ominous and vague note from Uncle Fëanáro saying Maitimo had been seriously hurt in an accident. No one had heard anything from any of the Fëanorians since then.

So what in all Arda was said cousin doing here, in the wee hours of the morning?

“Maitimo?” Finno blurted. “What are you doing here?”

“I… I don’t know.” Maitimo’s voice sounded weak and dazed. He didn’t look so good either, with his face ashen and clammy, and his hands shaking. He was wearing armor and wielding a spear for some reason. Leaves and twigs were tangled up in his messy curls. His gaze looked blank and disoriented.

“What’s wrong?” Íri asked, riding up next to him and carefully taking the spear out of his hand.

“Everything’s wrong… my brothers… they’re missing…”

“But what about you? Are you hurt?” Finno asked, his brow creasing in concern.

Maitimo shrugged and said nothing. But his eyes started to roll back, and Finno and Íri both reached out and managed to grab him before he could fall. They slowly lowered him until he was leaning against his horse’s neck.

Being this close to him, Íri, being on Maitimo’s right side, noticed a few droplets of blood collecting on the rings of his mail shirt. Her own face paled and she glanced wide-eyed at her brother. “Finno… he needs help.”

“I can see that,” Finno said, trying to keep his voice calm in the midst of his rising nerves. “Come on, let’s take him inside to the healers. I’ll lead his horse and you keep him steady.”

Íri nodded and sheathed the spear at her back, alongside her many other hunting weapons, and put a steadying hand on Maitimo’s shoulder. Finno took the reins of Maitimo’s horse, and together they all rode back towards the house.

Luckily for Íri and Finno, Maitimo stirred awake before they reached the house, though he gagged at the sensation of horse hair in his face. He tried to right himself, but a firm hand accompanied by a familiar voice stopped him.

“Good morning!” Finno exclaimed, his voice sounding bubbly and energetic as always. “I’m glad to see you’re awake!”

“Well… I’m not,” Maitimo grumbled, not questioning for a moment why his face was in a horse’s mane and Finno was cheerfully bidding him good morning.

“It is a bad morning,” Íri solemnly agreed.

“Someone gets it,” Maitimo said.

Finno frowned at them and hummed in disapproval. “I am not going to tolerate that sort of negativity from you two. We get to see the healers, and they’re going to get Maitimo all fixed up, and it’s all going to be okay!”

His voice sounded far too enthusiastic for such an early hour, but he had always been like this.

“Why do I need to be fixed up?” Maitimo mumbled.

“You tell us,” Íri retorted. “You’re the one who stumbled half-conscious into our lands!”

“I did? I’m sorry…”

“No need to apologize, cousin. I’m always happy to see you, even if it’s half-conscious on a horse in the wee hours of the morning.” Finno grinned and lightly patted Maitimo on the back, which forced him to crack a smile. “And we’ll get to see Aranya, which is always a fun time too—"

Aranya?” Maitimo’s eyes shot wide open and he once again tried to right himself on the horse, but Finno and Íri once again held him firmly to his position. “I can’t see Aranya! I must look like a wreck! Again!”

“Trust me, she won’t care,” Íri muttered under her breath, smirking to herself.

“You don’t deny that I look like a wreck,” Maitimo said miserably, cognizant enough to hear Íri’s words, yet not enough to pick up on their implication.

* * *​

Aranya hated getting up early, but she hated being pestered by Tecno even more. Waking up well before the mingling of the lights was her only way to escape him, and get a few hours in which she could read or do some embroidery in peace. It also helped to have a valid excuse to go to bed early, so Tecno had no time to bother her after supper.

On this early morning, she sat by a windowsill in the healing halls. The fading silver light of Telperion and flickering golden candlelight danced over the silver threads of her half-finished embroidered kitten. She planned to affix this to the front of her healing robes along with her other embroidered patches of bunnies, squirrels and flowers.

The sound of hurried footsteps, sounding like a thunderbolt in its disruption of her serene silence, caused her to drop her embroidery hoop and mutter a curse. Was Tecno here already? Had he figured out her new early schedule?

But rather than Tecno, she spotted the last three people she ever expected to see in the entrance to the healing halls: Findekáno, Írissë, and Maitimo. The three of them were hurrying yet hobbling along, with Íri and Finno struggling to support Maitimo, who constantly shifted from one side to another due to the great difference in height between him and his cousins. He was wearing a mail shirt, which was absolutely befuddling to her.

Though Aranya’s mind burned with a thousand questions, she tried to remain calm as she directed Finno and Íri to help Maitimo sit down on the closest bed. One of the first rules she had learned as a healer was to withhold any questions about how the incident had happened at first, no matter how great her curiosity was. Solving the immediate problem was the first priority.

“What’s wrong?” she asked Maitimo, forcing her voice to remain calm and even, and then wincing at how deadpan it sounded coming out of her mouth. “How do you feel?”

“Embarrassed,” he blurted out, avoiding her gaze. His breaths were short, choppy and panicked. “I know I look a wreck, and I just saw you three days ago—no, four— or was it five?"

Despite the urgency of the situation, Aranya fought the urge to smile. “No, Maitimo, I mean, what do you feel physically? Are you in pain? Is it hard to breathe? Are you dizzy?”

His frantic breathing slowed for a moment as he seemed to pause and think about it. “I guess… I’m dizzy.”

Aranya nodded and looked for any blood on him, which she didn’t notice at first until she saw the scarce droplets pooled up on his mail… which likely meant there must have been much more underneath it.

“Let me help you get the mail off,” she said, though her heart pounded a little. “And I’ll need to look directly at the wound itself, too.”

Maitimo nodded in understanding. But despite the paleness of his complexion, his cheeks flushed pink, and he glanced awkwardly at Finno and Íri, who were standing nearby and watching.

“You two, go send for Arcamë and tell her what’s going on,” Aranya told them. It felt strange to command her prince and princess, but the healing halls were her domain of authority. “Tell her we likely need to redo his stitches.”

Whether or not Arcamë wanted to bring Tecno, that was her business. Aranya was not about to specifically ask for his help, even if he was a perfectly competent healer.

“I think only one of us would need to go,” Finno piped up, his expression blank and innocent.

Íri seemed to better understand Aranya’s polite implication, and she took Finno’s arm. “No, Finno, she needs both of us out of the way at the moment. Come on, let’s go find Arcamë.”

Finno looked no less confused than before, but he shrugged and went along with Íri as she guided him out of the room. Meanwhile, Íri glanced back at Aranya with a smirk, and she mouthed the words, “I’ll stall.”

Aranya fought back another smile and nodded gratefully. Regardless of the certain feelings between her and Maitimo, she couldn’t imagine he would particularly like his younger cousins standing around and watching him undergo the private work of a healer.

Glancing back at Maitimo, Aranya found him fiddling with the snap closure at the back of the neck of his mail, but his hands were too shaky to make any progress.

Aranya firmly shook her head. “Let me do it.”

He sighed with resignation, but made no further argument as she carefully unhooked the snap. She held his hair out of the way while carefully helping take the mail off.

Aranya had never held mithril mail before. It almost felt more like liquid than metal, sparkling under the silver treelight and draping over her hand like flowing silk.

She set the mail aside and then, before Maitimo could object or she could allow her panic to stop her, she unlaced his tunic. Her heart pounded so hard she was certain he could hear it.

Don’t think about it. Don’t think about it, she urged herself repeatedly. This needs to happen. I need access to the wound—

Interestingly, she had never felt so panicked when working closely like this with other male patients. She had helped Arcamë work on wounded hunters and soldiers many times, and yet she never felt the slightest bit of flustered nerves. For some reason, only Maitimo made her feel this way.

Maitimo kept quiet and still as Aranya worked, though when she glanced up at his face, his cheeks were flushed distinctively red, a stark contrast from his earlier pallor.

“Lie down,” Aranya told him, her voice coming out blunter than she intended, in her effort to disguise her racing nerves.

He did as she asked, and she tried not to let her eyes linger on the muscles of his figure as she peeled off the mangled, bloodied bandages around his waist.

“Are you angry with me?” he asked quietly. “I ruined the stitches you did. And I got you expelled from the House of Finwë. I’m sorry I wound up back here to bother you.”

“Oh, Maitimo, no, of course not!” Aranya winced at herself for making him think she was upset with him, and she offered him a strained smile. “I’m concentrating on my work here, that’s all. What happened at the House of Finwë was my fault, not yours. And don’t worry about the stitches. It’s no trouble for us to redo them. Besides… I’m not glad this happened to you, but I am glad I got to see you again.”

She pulled away the last of the bandages and glanced towards his face again to see his expression relax slightly.

“This is going to hurt,” she warned him before taking a clean cloth and pressing it firmly against the wound. He yelped, and she felt all his muscles tense up.

“Way to change the subject,” he huffed.

“I have my ways of making people shut up.” Aranya grinned at him, and the pained look on his face softened a little.

They both fell silent as Aranya held the cloth steady, trying to slow the bloodflow as they waited for Arcamë. Thankfully, it wasn’t anywhere near as much blood as it had been when the accident first happened. If everything had been going well over the past few days—until Maitimo stumbled out of the Nolofinwians’ woods, anyway—the wound had been healing for all that time, so the cut would be much shallower. Still, even shallow cuts could be messy.

Aranya noticed something else. Even after a few minutes passed, Maitimo’s breathing remained choppy and ragged, and his body felt much too warm to the touch. Burning heat indicated a fëa overburdened with passion, and the panicked breathing was likely a symptom too. He must have been incredibly stressed about something, then. And Aranya got the feeling it wasn’t related to his injury or the awkward tension between them.

She resolved she would get to work identifying the problem. But based on the hurried footsteps sounding from beyond the doorway, Aranya realized she had no time to address it. No, whatever was going on, Maitimo would likely only open up about it if she got some extended time alone with him. He almost certainly wouldn’t talk to the other healers, and possibly not in depth to his cousins either. And Arcamë would probably agree with Aranya’s assessment.

Aranya tried not to smile. Extended alone time with Maitimo was apparently what he most needed for his healing. Such a shame!
 
Return to top

Chapter 12: Searching, Stargazing, and Healing

Fëanáro and Nerdanel rode north at a leisurely pace, for once in their lives. To both of these high-achieving creators, it felt strange and empty to have no pressing matter to attend to. No place to be in a timely manner. There was only the gentle creaking of wood as ancient trees swayed slightly in the breeze, and the melodious calls of songbirds, and the smell of recent rain upon the rich soil and fresh grass.

It felt like the olden days. The days before they were married, when they wandered far and wide across Valinórë. And yet, something was missing; so much had changed since those merry and innocent times.

They were silent for a while. Uncomfortable, almost. When was the last time they had shared such a peaceful solitude, with no children or servants running around?

Fëanáro casually pointed out some caves which he had once explored and mined for gems or metal. Nerdanel listened and nodded, but she didn’t have much to say in response. She hadn’t been around for most of these expeditions he described.

He paused and frowned after one such instance, noticing her quietness. “Are you still angry with me, love?”

“No,” she told him, and unlike many recent times, she spoke truthfully. “I am simply at a loss for words. I was not with you when you explored these places, and my knowledge of mining for gems is but scarce. You know the only place I frequent is my quarry… Maitimo often used to go with me to help me haul the stone, in the days when he and I were both less busy.”

A bittersweet smile crossed her features. Part of her wished she had asked Fëanáro to wait, so she could stay with Maitimo a little longer. How was he faring now? She wasn’t sure she had much rational reason to worry, since he was recovering well and the healers were watching over him. But why was there still a knot in her stomach when she thought of him?

Fëanáro gazed at her intently. With his gaze came a strong thought, so clear that Nerdanel could sense it in her own heart. He knew how she still worried for her eldest son.

Tears came to Nerdanel’s eyes. She couldn’t remember the last time they had exchanged a thought through ósanwë. Yet even after all these years of distance and strife, her husband still knew her better than anyone.

“Forgive me, love, if I am a little distracted,” she told him. “My mother’s heart cannot be fully at ease until he is well.”

Fëanáro nodded in understanding, his bright blue gaze calm and thoughtful. “See, for me, I believe my job is done, and I have solved the problem. But perhaps for you, your job is not done. My role was to provide the resources he needed to recover, and I did that, and I am satisfied. But I suppose your role is to nurture him until he is fully healed, and that is not complete…” His voice trailed off, and his gaze dropped to the ground, and he frowned slightly. “Would you rather return home? Perhaps I called you away too early.”

“No. No,” Nerdanel reassured him, despite this accurate naming of her feelings and intuitions. She could read hurt in his words, and too many times since they became parents, she had neglected him in favor of the children. “I know it is not rational for me to worry too much, since he is faring so much better, and the healers are caring for him diligently. I only ask for a little patience if my mind wanders elsewhere.” Putting a hand on his muscular arm, she added, “You deserve my time and my love every bit as much as Maitimo does.”

From there, their conversation flowed more freely as they spoke of the antics of their children, and their crafts, and the memories they shared in these woods to the north of Tirion. Though Nerdanel realized it might have been helpful to address some of the recent wounds they had dealt each other, it didn’t seem as important now as just… having fun again. Pretending they were unwed lovers planning a future again.

But before they had ridden very far north, they were startled by some familiar voices. The loud, brash voice of Carnistir. The high, light voices of the Ambarussar.

Fëanáro and Nerdanel shared a puzzled glance. What were their children doing here? Had they been following them?

They rode towards the source of the noise and discovered the three of them on horseback, arguing with each other about something relating to Tyelko. They were so engrossed in their argument that they didn’t notice the appearance of their parents.

“Boys! What are you doing here?” Fëanáro’s deep, resonant voice made all three of them jump, and their faces go white.

“Um, no reason, Atar,” Telvo said, his face flushing, and he squirmed in his saddle and fidgeted with his reins. “We were just—having fun—”

“Knock it off. You’re a horrible liar,” Moryo scolded him, scowling. “I guess I might as well say it. Tyelko went missing, and none of us know where he is. We’re looking for him.”

Fëanáro and Nerdanel exchanged a horrified glance.

“I don’t understand,” Nerdanel said. “I spoke with Tyelko just last night. He agreed to watch the two of you.” She nodded in the twins’ direction.

“Well, we don’t understand either. He’s just gone,” Pityo said with a shrug. “Nelyo asked us about him at breakfast this morning, and no one knew where he was. Nelyo got really worried, and Kano said we should all go out searching. He and Curvo are around searching somewhere, too. Nelyo stayed home, of course.”

Nerdanel could feel the blood draining from her face. Oh, how Maitimo would worry, especially being stuck home alone! And what of Tyelko? What if he had gone on a late-night hunt and gotten attacked by wolves?

“Where are Kanafinwë and Curufinwë now?” Fëanáro demanded.

“We don’t know. Like I said, they’re probably somewhere around here. We only just started searching.”

“Have you agreed upon certain areas to search, and when to regroup?”

Carnistir replied, “Nelyo asked us to be home by the mingling. We agreed that the Ambarussar and I would search north, and Kano would go west, and Curvo would go south. There isn’t much ground to cover east, so we figured we should save that for later.”

“If Pityo and I had been allowed to go by ourselves, we could have gone east,” Telvo grumbled.

Fëanáro sighed loudly. “That is the opposite of what you should have done. You should have gone east first precisely because there is less ground to cover. You could have eliminated the possibility quickly. Come, let’s find Kanafinwë and Curufinwë, and I will design a more efficient method of search.”

The three brothers wouldn’t have admitted it, but they were relieved to have their father take over the strategy of the search, and they gratefully followed as he led them swiftly in a perimeter around Tirion. It wasn’t long before they found Curvo first and then Kano, since they were searching their respective areas thoroughly, and hadn’t gone very far in either direction. They also checked the beaches east of Tirion, since it was an easy possibility to eliminate, as Fëanáro suggested. And surely enough, Tyelko wasn’t there.

With the entire party assembled, they took a moment to gather around on the beach and discuss their next strategy. Curvo looked sheepish when Fëanáro once again explained to everyone why they should have gone east first, and how they should have planned in more detail which areas to search. “I should have thought of that,” he grumbled.

“Now, before we search anywhere in any particular kind of detail, we should think logically about where Turcafinwë might have gone,” Fëanáro told everyone. “Does anyone have any ideas?”

“The Woods of Oromë!” Pityo piped up.

Fëanáro nodded in agreement. “This could indeed be a possibility, though why would he go there without telling anyone, especially when he agreed upon some responsibility at home?”

“I wouldn’t be surprised if he just forgot about it,” Kano muttered.

“There are unanswered questions, but it is a worthy place to search,” Nerdanel said.

Fëanáro nodded in agreement. “Any other ideas? What say you, Curufinwë? You seem to be his closest confidant.”

Curvo bristled at the question. Why did everyone, even his Atar, have to keep asking him that? Still, Atar might be more likely to understand than Nelyo or anyone else, so he did his best to explain. “Tyelkormo has barely breathed a word to me recently. I don’t understand what’s going on in his mind. I have no more useful information than anyone else, and thus, cannot make an informed guess.”

Sure enough, Fëanáro’s expression changed from a look of hardened focus to a gentler, more sympathetic gaze. “You are in the dark as much as we are, then. However, you still have your ability to reason logically, so if you come up with any ideas based on your limited information, please tell me.”

Curvo nodded, feeling as though some sort of uncomfortably tight screw in his body had been loosened, and his muscles relaxed. Finally, he was released of this expectation to read Tyelko’s mind. Nelyo seemed able to read everyone’s mind, and was probably frustrated with Curvo for lacking the ability. However, Fëanáro was more like Curvo, preferring observable facts over attempting to read the complex and often self-contradictory feelings and moods of others.

“Does anyone have any better guesses than the Woods of Oromë?” Fëanáro asked. The brothers all shook their heads, and Fëanáro seemed to think for a moment before saying, “This is the plan, then. We will split up so we cover more ground, but as a unit, we will move south. We will regroup at the mingling as Nelyafinwë suggested, but since we are moving south, we will make camp and continue searching until we reach Oromë.”

Both Nerdanel and Laurë balked at the idea for Maitimo’s sake, and Laurë was the first to speak up. “But Atar, we promised Maitimo—”

“He will be fine,” Fëanáro retorted, his eyes narrowing and his voice growing suddenly icy. “Nelyafinwë has an intelligent brain in his head, and he will not be stupid enough to leave home while he is still wounded. He may worry, but it is more important that we not waste time in our search.”

Curvo, Moryo and the twins all nodded, agreeing with this logic. Only Makalaurë and Nerdanel shared an uneasy glance, both knowing Maitimo well enough to disagree with Fëanáro’s assessment. While Laurë resented Fëanáro essentially calling Maitimo stupid, he also knew full well that Maitimo’s intelligence was mostly in the areas of academics and diplomacy, and not in, well, common sense. Laurë couldn’t fault him there, since he was inclined the same way. Honestly, so was pretty much everyone in this family. Besides, he wasn’t sure Maitimo would be able to endure the stress of waiting home alone for all his missing brothers, even if he knew it would be stupid to go out searching for them. If his past patterns of behavior were any indicator, Maitimo would always put his brothers’ needs first, and his own needs last.

Nerdanel had similar thoughts, knowing how she would feel if she were stuck home alone and her entire family were missing, and she had no way of contacting any of them. A sick feeling settled in her stomach as she considered the mental agony this would put Maitimo through. Yet both she and Makalaurë could tell Fëanáro was in one of his moods, and he was firmly set in his plan, and he wouldn’t listen to either of them.

Nerdanel silently sent a prayer to Eru Ilúvatar and the Valar, asking them to give Maitimo some peace in his heart, and to prevent him from doing anything foolish.

* * *​

Tyelko and Huan reached Alqualondë later in the evening, just as the silver light of Telperion began to mingle with the gold of Laurelin. He had not spoken to Huan this entire time, nor Huan to him. The silence weighed heavier and heavier on Tyelko’s heart, especially as he realized these were among his last moments of spending time with his beloved hound. Yet he couldn’t bring himself to say anything. He would have to apologize first, and his pride couldn’t bear that.

To Tyelko’s great surprise, he felt… a sort of calm being here. Being on the other side of the eastern mountains of Valinórë, the Trees did not shine as brightly here. The silver-gold light of the Trees was a dim glow, just enough to light the streets. This allowed Tyelko to see the black, velvety sky above, twinkling with silver stars.

Where Tirion would have been settling down for the night, Alqualondë seemed to be just waking up. The Teleri Elves of this city gathered around on the shore to watch the waves shimmering under the starlight.

And Tyelko blended in here. In Tirion, his head of silver hair stuck out almost as badly as those of his redheaded mother and brothers. But here in Alqualondë, many of the Teleri had silver hair, so no one glanced at him as he entered the city.

You could stay here. A thought strangely appeared in his mind. It was not something Tyelko would have thought on his own. You are not known here. You don’t have to go across the sea.

Tyelko firmly shook the thought aside. His uncle Arafinwë lived here, so he would be found out eventually.

He was never great at negotiating for things, unlike Nelyo, so he had no idea how to start. Normally, his winning strategy was to ask for something and throw a fit if he didn’t get his way. So, he decided to just walk up to the nearest mariner, who was tending the sails of one of the mighty swan-boats.

At first, Tyelko entirely forgot his words, so enraptured was he with the glistening white vessel. It was carved in detail with feather shapes all over its body, the lines of them looking exactly like those of a real bird. The neck of the swan arched gracefully, and its eyes glittered with pearlescent gems.

Tyelko suppressed a grin. Real swans weren’t nearly that nice. Most of them were brats. But as soon as he realized his thoughts were taking him in a happy direction, he shoved them away. He didn’t deserve to enjoy himself here. He was doing something wrong, as a punishment to himself for the other wrongs he had done.

“Excuse me,” he blurted out to the startled Teler. “I was wondering, where can I get a boat with which to sail across the sea?”

The mariner, a silver-haired nér much like himself, stared incredulously at Tyelko and burst out laughing. “No one has crossed the seas since our ancestors arrived centuries ago, my boy. And these swan-boats are the treasure of our people. They are not for sale.”

“I didn’t mean the swan boats,” Tyelko shot back, his face reddening. “Real swans aren’t like that, anyway. They’re obnoxious and they bite people. They’re not as nice as you make them out to be.”

The Teler looked peeved, with his silver brows creasing and a faint scowl crossing his lips. He shook his head in disapproval. “You need some time under the stars.”

“Excuse me?”

“Time under the stars. Exactly what it sounds like.”

“I don’t understand.”

“Are you not from around here?” the Teler said incredulously.

Tyelko was silent, trying to figure out whether or not he should reveal himself. If he admitted he wasn’t from around here, he ruined any chance of passing as a Teler. But then again, he might have ruined it already.

Timo would be able to fix this if he were here.

Apparently Tyelko’s silence drew on long enough that he gave himself away. The Teler’s annoyed and confused gaze softened, and he climbed down from the boat and joined Tyelko on the dock. “Are you lost, boy?”

“No. I know I’m in Alqualondë. The overly nice swan boats kind of give it away. And by the way, I came here on purpose.”

“Ah… That’s not what I mean. You seem lost in your fëa to me. And you need time under the stars.”

Tyelko scowled deeply in an effort to suppress the tears welling up in his throat. He wouldn’t allow some random Telerin sailor to get to his feelings! He wouldn’t!

“I still don’t know what time under the stars means,” he huffed.

“Well, come here and I’ll show you.” The Teler put a gentle hand on Tyelko’s back and guided him onto the ship. They sat on a bench, intricately carved with designs of seashells and pearls. Huan followed them, his tail thumping slightly for the first time during this whole trip. Tyelko didn’t know why he was following this nér, but perhaps it simply sounded better than continuing to fight everyone.

“The Trees aren’t the only source of light, you know,” the Teler said, gazing upwards and smiling slightly. Though his face looked as youthful as all the immortal Eldar, his eyes looked ancient, brimming with thousands of years of memories. “The stars are perhaps even more hallowed, being created by Varda herself. If you gaze at them long enough, there will be no room for evil in your heart.”

“That’s ridiculous,” Tyelko retorted. “First of all, how can some starlight get rid of evil? Second of all, I’m not evil.”

He stopped himself. Hadn’t he been calling himself evil this whole time?

“I’m not saying you are, young one. But whenever one of us is angry or hurt or in despair, it is often because we have not spent enough time with the stars. Gazing at them in silence. Contemplating how they, though beautiful and splendid in their own right, point to the greater beauty and splendor of those who created them. Varda, and ultimately Eru Ilúvatar.”

“Oh, so now you’re making this all about the Valar!” Tyelko’s face flushed and he stood up, preparing to leave, but the Teler put a gentle hand on his arm.

“If you wish to leave, so be it. But might I ask you to test my word first? I will speak no more, and I will leave you alone if you wish. But I invite you to sit and watch them for a while. Watch them twinkle. Look for pictures in them. And if it doesn’t help you, well then, you’ve proven me wrong.”

Sitting and meditating was not something Tyelko found fun, but proving this old Teler wrong sounded like a good challenge to him.

“How long do I have to sit here?” he asked.

“As long as it takes for something to change in your heart.”

“Any sort of change at all? Even if I become angrier or sadder?”

The Teler seemed puzzled, but he nodded and shrugged. “I don’t believe the stars will do that to you. But test me and see what you think.”

Tyelko gave a satisfied smirk as the Teler got up and left to work on the ropes and sails of the ship. He sat and looked at the stars for a long while, but nothing changed. He just got bored and started thinking of other things.

Things he didn’t want to think about. Like his family, and how they might have all been searching for him. How Timo was probably still suffering and in pain because of him. Well, they would all be better off without him. They’d grieve at first, but they’d quickly grow accustomed to the absence of Tyelkormo and his hot temper.

He thought of Morirámo and quickly shoved the thought aside. And of Oromë. And Huan, sitting beside him and contentedly wagging his tail.

“I guess you like the stars better than I do, huh?” Tyelko huffed.

Huan looked up at Tyelko and uttered a happy bark.

Tyelko’s face paled and his heart crashed into the pit of his stomach.

He heard only a hollow bark, and understood no words.
 
Last edited:
Back to top

Chapter 13: Things Mended

Several pairs of footsteps grew louder and louder as they approached the healing halls. Both Maitimo and Aranya glanced uneasily in their direction, and Aranya groaned audibly. Finno, Íri and Arcamë had returned with a fourth companion: Tecno.

Maitimo, seeing this, raised his eyebrows slightly. “Is that the fellow?” he whispered.

“That’s the fellow.”

Tecno spotted Aranya, and he grinned and waved at her. Aranya ducked her head, pretending not to see, and focused instead on the bloodied cloth she was holding against Maitimo’s side.

“Hello, dear,” Arcamë said with a warm, calm smile as she approached Maitimo. “I heard we have a bit of trouble?”

“Yes. My brothers are all missing,” Maitimo blurted.

“His stitches got ripped open,” Aranya said, her voice flat and deadpan.

“Ah… well, I can’t do much to help you with the first problem, but I can with the second,” Arcamë said. Maitimo smiled sheepishly. If he were feeling like his normal self, he probably would have laughed.

Arcamë walked around to stand next to Aranya and asked her to lift the cloth off so she could see the wound. Aranya obeyed, and Arcamë gave a hum of approval. “Nicely done in slowing the bloodflow, Aranya. This should be quick to stitch up.”

“Fascinating!” Maitimo caught a distinctive whiff of garlic and onions as Tecno crowded up and shoved himself between Arcamë and Aranya. “Yes, Aranya did a most excellent job, as always! There is none so skilled of hand as she! Now, I believe we should apply a numbing salve—”

“I know how to numb and stitch a wound,” Aranya shot back, scowling as she edged away from Tecno.

Maitimo had never pitied Aranya more than he did in that moment, especially since he now felt like his own personal space was being violated too. Was this what she had to put up with every day?

Arcamë, mercifully, was quick to notice this tension. “Tecno, dear, why don’t you go fetch us the numbing salve?”

Tecno’s face fell, but he nodded, quietly turned, and left. Aranya wasn’t sure how she would cope in the world without Arcamë. She was one of those rare people to whom Tecno actually listened, and she frequently commanded him to give Aranya some space.

Maitimo let out an unconscious sigh of relief as Tecno disappeared. But then he glanced in the other direction and saw Finno and Íri there, both staring at him with wide, fascinated eyes.

Suddenly self-conscious, Maitimo crossed his arms over his bare chest. “Quit gawking at me, you two!”

Aranya tried to suppress an outburst of laughter, but it still partially came out as a snort. Arcamë’s lips twitched, but she otherwise kept a calm, serious demeanor as she said, “Your Highnesses, we have to stitch your cousin’s wound, and this is private work. It would be best if you leave him alone for a little while, and we will let you know when he’s ready to see you. Perhaps in the meantime, you should inform your father of what has happened.”

“But—Maitimo—” Finno stammered. “I just thought he’d want some company…”

“No one wants company while they’re being stitched up,” Íri said with a smirk. “Arcamë is right. Let’s go get Atar, and come back when the healers get us.”

With that, they departed the healing halls, and Maitimo was finally left alone with Aranya and Arcamë.

“May I see your hands?” Arcamë asked Aranya.

Maitimo blinked in confusion at this, but Aranya nodded and held out her hands. Arcamë examined them closely and nodded in approval. “Good. They are steady.”

Unfortunately, Tecno was quick to return with the numbing salve. His lips were pursed in a smug smile as he handed the mixing cup to Arcamë. “My lady Arcamë, I was wondering, as I am always seeking opportunities to refine my stitching skills, if I might have the honor of doing these stitches?”

Aranya’s face flushed and her dark eyes glinted with fury. Maitimo was almost worried for Tecno—though now he could see the overbearing young nér must have deserved whatever Aranya had coming for him—but thankfully, Arcamë spoke up before any heated words could be exchanged. “Thank you for offering. However, I’d like to give this task to Aranya.”

Aranya showed no mercy in shooting Tecno a smug grin of her own.

“But—but—why?” Tecno demanded, in a voice which could only be described as whiny.

“My reasons are my reasons. Now, Tecno Lóremo, let us not argue in the face of a patient who needs our help. Please, go prepare a draught for pain.”

Tecno scowled deeply, whipped around, and stomped off, repeatedly heaving great sighs.

“I’m sorry about him, Your Highness. He is not normally so moody,” Arcamë whispered, watching his tantrum in disapproval.

But Aranya shook her head slightly and mouthed the words, “Yes, he is.”

Despite all his worry and discomfort, Maitimo couldn’t suppress a small burst of laughter.

“Aranya has stitched wounds before,” Arcamë explained to Maitimo. “Don’t have any doubts in her ability. I wouldn’t ask her to do this if she were not capable. But I want to make sure you’re comfortable with this, Your Highness. Would you prefer me to do it instead?”

“No,” Maitimo said with a firm shake of his head. The motion made the room seem to tilt and spin all the faster, but he didn’t care. “I know Aranya, and I trust her.”

Aranya’s eyes lit up and she smiled widely, but she couldn’t express the extent of her delight. Instead, she was forced to remain serene as Arcamë handed her the cup of numbing poultice and took a few steps back.

“Don’t look at the wound or what my hands are doing,” Aranya told Maitimo, hoping her voice was remaining steady, not so much from fear this time, but from excitement. “Focus instead on the bunnies and kittens I’ve embroidered onto my robes.”

Maitimo nodded and smiled faintly as he focused his gaze on the intricately embroidered woodland critters adorning the collar of her robes. He remembered when she had embroidered most of these, as she often brought her embroidery hoop to their picnics. Just one little bird or squirrel often took weeks to embroider. They each had a blend of different colored threads, depicting the fur of the animals with uncanny realism. Aranya was almost always embroidering. She told Maitimo her hands were always restless, even when she was trying to relax or talk to someone.

And yet, as much as Maitimo loved the artistic work of her hands, he found his eyes drawn upward to her face. To her intently focused eyes framed in dark lashes, and her soft lips and rosy cheeks.

Aranya’s work was quick and skillful. Maitimo didn’t feel a thing, and she was finished stitching within a few minutes.

“There. Much easier than embroidering a bird,” she told him with a smile.

Arcamë, who had been watching from a distance, came over to inspect Aranya’s work, and she nodded with approval. Then they worked together to bandage the wound, and, to Maitimo’s great relief, they found a loose tunic with a wrap closure for him to wear.

It didn’t bother him whenever Sívenettë, Tyalindë, or the healers of Finwë had worked on him. So then why did it send his heart racing when Aranya was the one to touch him?

Tecno waited a short distance away with the draught he had made. “Can I give it to him yet?” he asked with a whiny air of impatience.

Yet? Maitimo wondered. Then he realized, perhaps Tecno had been consistently offering the draught as Aranya worked, and Arcamë had kept them shielded from his pestering.

“Give it to me,” Arcamë told him. “You are dismissed, Tecno. There is little more to do here other than keep watch.”

“But I can keep watch! Have I not kept watch over a great many patients?”

“Do not argue with me.” Even the levelheaded Arcamë’s voice now took on a testy edge. “Not every healer is suited to every patient, regardless of competence. I will send for you if you are needed.”

Tecno’s round eyes somehow seemed to widen even further, and his thin lips pinched into an even thinner line. Without another word, he bowed and stomped out of the healing halls.

Aranya and Arcamë rolled their eyes at each other. Then Arcamë approached Maitimo with the draught, but Aranya put a hand on her arm. “Wait. May I see that?”

Arcamë blinked at her, seemingly puzzled. “Why? It’s just an ordinary draught to ease pain and promote sleep.”

“About that—” Maitimo spoke up, but neither of them seemed to hear him.

“I just want to verify it was made correctly,” Aranya said.

“Aranya, dear, why in all Arda wouldn’t it be? You know Tecno is incredibly precise when it comes to mixing medicines, and he has never made something incorrectly before.”

“Just… I don’t know, can I check it anyway?”

Maitimo was confused by this conversation, but he mustered enough strength to speak up a little louder. “I can’t go to sleep anyway. I need to get back to looking for my brothers.”

Both the healers were stunned to silence, and they stared at him with wide, incredulous eyes.

“Your Highness, with all due respect, I’m not sure you are thinking clearly,” Arcamë said, uncharacteristically seeming to stammer over her words. “You lost a fair amount of blood. Prince Findekáno and Princess Írissë told me you fainted when they found you, and you will surely faint again if you go back out there.”

“But my brothers could very well be in danger, from wolves or who knows what else, and my parents don’t know they’re missing, and I might be the only one who can help them—”

His breath was once again reduced to choppy gasps, and his eyes reddened with tears. Aranya and Arcamë exchanged a meaningful glance and began to whisper to each other.

“He really needs that draught, then,” Arcamë whispered. “It smells perfectly fine to me, Aranya. I don’t think there is any reason to believe Tecno made a mistake.”

Aranya shook her head. “No, Maitimo won’t take it willingly, and I don’t want to force him. Have you noticed his burning fëa, Arcamë? I think if you give me some time alone with him, he may talk to me, and I might be able to soothe him.”

Arcamë was silent for a moment before giving a hesitant nod. “If anyone can get through to him, you are indeed the most likely one of us. I will keep the halls empty, then. But don’t hesitate to get me if you need any help or are uncertain of anything, understand?”

Aranya nodded, and Arcamë turned to leave, and then both the healers gasped. Maitimo had gotten out of bed and was trying to stand up fully. His stance was incredibly shaky.

Thankfully, they ran to him and grabbed his arms before he could fully collapse, and they helped him lie back down. Aranya could feel his racing heartbeat.

“I’m sorry,” he mumbled. “That was stupid…”

“If you’re going to wait for me to deny that, we’re going to be here a while,” Aranya said bluntly.

She also realized nobody had taken the time to take the twigs out of his hair, so she pulled them out as carefully as she could.

Maitimo smiled sheepishly, and Arcamë added, “We can’t, and wouldn’t, keep you here against your will, Your Highness. But I hope you can see you can’t go anywhere on your own.”

“I think I figured that out,” Maitimo said dully.

“Aranya has agreed to stay here with you a while. We won’t put you to sleep if you don’t wish it. And perhaps if you try to relax, and tell her in as much detail as you can what has happened with your brothers, we can see what we can do to help in that area.”

Maitimo nodded, but he guiltily avoided both the healers’ gazes. Arcamë’s annoyed gaze softened, and she gently patted Maitimo’s hand. “Don’t be ashamed; this isn’t your fault. When the brain is deprived of blood, it can be hard to think straight. Just trust us, and try to get some rest. We’re only trying to help you.”

“Thank you,” Maitimo said with a strained smile. Arcamë nodded, curtsied, and quietly left the hall.

Aranya pulled up a chair next to Maitimo’s bed and pulled out her embroidery hoop. This design featured a mother duck followed by her seven ducklings, of which only two and a half were complete. “I suppose you won’t be able to sleep or anything while this problem with your brothers is yet unresolved.”

He nodded. “I knew it might be dangerous to go out and search for them. And I tried to sleep at home, truly, but I tossed and turned for hours. I couldn’t stop worrying about them, and I still can’t.”

“So what happened, exactly? Start from the beginning. Why did your brothers leave?”

So Maitimo told her about the family breakfast that morning—or, the previous morning, he realized—and how everyone realized Tyelko was missing following his strange moods. He then went on to explain the explicit agreement for them all to be home by the mingling, and how not a single brother honored the agreement, not even Kano or Curvo or Moryo.

Aranya’s dark brows furrowed as she listened to the tale. “And what of your parents? Why were they not around to know about this? Or were they around, but busy and distracted, and you just didn’t tell them?”

Maitimo explained his conversation with Nerdanel the day prior, and how she and Fëanáro had decided to go on a little trip of their own. “I felt a little uneasy about Ammë leaving, and so did she. But I haven’t seen my parents act like they love each other in such a long time, and my heart yearns for peace in the household, so I told her I was fine with her decision. And I would have been, if not for this problem with Tyelko.”

Aranya nodded and sighed as she considered all this. Though she couldn’t relate to the way Maitimo carried the burdens of his brothers, since she had no siblings, she knew how she felt on the rare occasion when her parents fought. To hear them raising their voices at each other from behind closed doors, or to see one of them cast a nasty glare at the other, it put a sick feeling in her stomach. Normally, her solution was to get out of the house and run in the forest or tend the garden. And now, since she boarded at the House of Nolofinwë, she was rarely home, so she rarely experienced that problem anymore. She couldn’t imagine living in a situation like Maitimo’s, where the conflict between his parents was near constant, and he couldn’t leave because his brothers depended on him. Especially since he absorbed the feelings of others like a sponge, this seemed to her like a poison constantly dripping into him. It was small wonder, she realized, that he was so anxious and exhausted all the time.

He would never consider such a possibility because he loved his family too much, but Aranya wanted him out of there. She wanted to see him become a powerful lord of Tirion in his own right and establish a House of his own. He was more than capable of such a thing, and already headed down that path thanks to his achievements in the city council. And he had accomplished so much despite being barely one hundred! His family, she thought, was a shackle on his brilliant mind. She could only imagine what he would have been capable of if he weren’t forced to babysit and endure family conflicts and sacrifice sleep all the time. The House of Nelyafinwë… it had a nice ring to it.

Comparing that mental image to the current circumstances nearly brought tears to Aranya’s eyes. She firmly shook her head and returned her focus to the present moment.

She had a thought, but kept it to herself because it would have grieved Maitimo too much. He should have sent guards out to search rather than going himself. It really was as simple as that. She would let him figure it out on his own later. Right now, she couldn’t bear to heap any more guilt on him than what he already carried.

“Let’s consider what might have kept your brothers away, causing all five of them to dishonor the agreement they made, despite this being out of character for three of them, at least,” she said, trying to keep her voice level. “What’s the worst case scenario in your mind? What are you afraid happened?”

“That they got attacked by wolves and wounded or even killed.”

“All five? In the middle of the day? When they all went separate ways?”

Maitimo fell silent, and his gaze sheepishly dropped.

“If one or two of them went missing, that would be a far likelier possibility,” Aranya said gently. “Wolves are only really a danger to lone riders at night. Like you.”

“But what if only one got attacked and went missing?” Maitimo blurted. “And the others realized it perhaps as they regrouped, and they all resumed their search again?”

Aranya nodded slowly. “Perhaps that could be a possibility. But don’t you think one of them, such as Kano, would have sent you word?”

“Not if Kano was the one attacked. Besides, even if not, they might not have wanted to worry me with the knowledge that another brother went missing.”

“If any of them were thinking straight, they ought to have known either option would worry you. Hearing bad news, or hearing nothing at all. At least telling you of the news would have removed the fear of the unknown, and let you know that a plan was in place, and reminded you to stay put. But, I suppose, they’re probably all anxious too, so none of them might have been thinking straight.”

“Knowing them, probably not,” Maitimo agreed.

“Alright, so we’ve got one decently plausible explanation. One brother got attacked or otherwise went missing, and the others all went off looking for him without telling you. Can we agree that this is the worst case scenario, and it’s not as bad as all five of them getting killed?”

Maitimo nodded slowly. “Yes… I suppose so.”

“So what about other possibilities? Are there other explanations, ones that do not have a disastrous outcome?”

“I… I don’t know.” Maitimo sighed heavily and blinked slowly, his face showing weariness rather than panic. “It’s getting too hard to think about it. And if you’ve taught me anything, it’s that I’m not really capable of thinking about things correctly right now.”

Aranya winced. “Well, that’s not how I would have phrased it. But you do need rest, both for your body and mind. Will you let me make you a draught, just one to take the edge off your pain?”

Maitimo’s discomfort must have been growing, because he nodded wordlessly. Aranya stood and walked to the herb cabinets, and along the way, she took Tecno’s draught and dumped it in a waste bucket. She had no conscious reason to distrust what he made, but she preferred the certainty of making her own, especially since the kind Tecno made would have had a heavy sleeping aid. Maitimo looked exhausted enough that Aranya didn’t think it was necessary, and natural sleep was healthier anyway.

It only took her a few minutes to mix the herbs and liquids and bring the mixture back to Maitimo. “I promise it won’t knock you out for hours,” she told him as he sipped it, “because I think you look ready to sleep naturally, given that you were up all night. But if you feel you need a little help sleeping, let me know.”

“I don’t think I will,” Maitimo said, his blinking growing slower and slower.

But rather than just leaving him alone, Aranya sat by him again and hummed a soft melody, a healing lullaby her mother had taught her. And though her heart pounded a little, she reached for his curls and stroked them gently. It didn’t take him long to fall asleep.

Once his breathing had fallen into a steady rhythm, Aranya laid a hand on his forehead. Still hot, but not nearly as much as before. Aranya suspected his fëa wouldn’t settle down completely until he knew for certain what had happened to his brothers. But he had at least settled down and realized there was nothing more he could do, and Aranya was thankful for that. She whispered a prayer of thanks to Estë for guiding her through this.
 
Back to top

Chapter 14: The Redemption of Tyelkormo

Upon realizing he couldn’t understand Huan, Tyelko took a few staggering steps back and then sank to his knees. The ship and the stars spun dizzyingly around him, and if he weren’t so shocked, he might have wept.

He had just lost the one thing that no one else in his family had. The thing that made him special. The thing that made him Turcafinwë Tyelkormo.

If he couldn’t talk with the animals now, then who was he? No one, most likely.

Oromë, why?” he cried out in a loud voice. “How could you do this to me? Haven’t I been through enough?”

There was no response. Typical of the Valar, to show up to rebuke him but not to help him.

Something warm and wet brushed up against his face—Huan’s tongue. Tyelko glanced up miserably into the face of his hound, with big brown eyes staring at him so warmly and sweetly as always.

“Is this a trick?” Tyelko said bitterly. “Say something, Huan. Say something!”

Huan only uttered some soft whimpering noises. Again, Tyelko could not understand.

Tyelko’s shock finally gave way to tears, and his body trembled as he wept.

He heard footsteps on the wooden planks of the ship, sounding as though they came from the Teler. “Go away!” Tyelko snapped. “The stars didn’t help me! You were wrong!”

“Was he, though?” The deep, resonant voice from behind didn’t sound like the Teler, and instead it was familiar. Tyelko didn’t even have to look up to recognize his master.

“So you’ve come here to gloat at me and rebuke me again? I think I get the picture, Oromë. I’m nothing but a worthless failure! I guess I don’t deserve the gift of animal speech anymore, nor do I deserve Huan. All I ask is that you stop humiliating me further, because I’ve learned my lesson. Just leave me alone and let me go my own way, and I promise I won’t be a bother to you or anyone else till the end of time.”

“Ah, Tyelkormo… you’ve learned a lesson, but not the lesson I’d like to teach you.” The boards creaked as Oromë sat on the floor beside Tyelko, and his voice sounded calm, but Tyelko still didn’t dare look up at him. “What, exactly, do you feel you’ve learned?”

“That I’m a worthless failure.”

Tyelko could practically hear Oromë frown through his disapproving hum. “No, that is not true. No one is a failure or worthless so long as they are alive. And aside from the inherent value you carry simply for being one of the Firstborn of Ilúvatar, you also have many worthy achievements of your own. For example, if it weren’t for you and your quick action, your brother might very well have gone to the Halls of Mandos.”

Tyelko paused and lifted his head a little. Oromë rarely gave out compliments. Most of his hunting students were excited enough to simply get a silent nod of approval from him. But still, a compliment from Oromë, even if it was a rare occurrence, wasn’t a magical solution to his grief and anger.

“Well, I wouldn’t have had to drag his bloodied body up from the cliff if I had sensed what Morirámo was up to,” Tyelko said in a harsh and bitter voice. “Or, better yet, if you had shown up and stopped the whole thing from happening in the first place!”

“Let me ask you something,” said Oromë. “What ultimately happened to your brother Nelyafinwë?”

“He was taken to the house of my grandfather in time, before he could bleed out. And he started to heal, but then Atar decided Timo needed to be at home rather than at Haru’s house, and he made everything worse—”

“But ultimately, is he alive? Is he healing?”

Tyelko nodded slowly, suddenly confused as to where Oromë was going with this.

“Then that is a mercy from Eru. Nelyafinwë could have perished that day, but Eru Ilúvatar used you and your particular giftings to ensure he lived.”

Tyelko was silent for a long moment. Yes, that was true. Eru wasn’t obligated to keep all the Elves alive and safe. But then again, wouldn’t it have made Eru an evil and cruel force, like Melkor, if He did nothing to protect the very children He claimed to love?

But He didn’t do nothing. He put Tyelko there, and Curvo, who was also an essential part of Maitimo’s rescue thanks to his knowledge of how to tie secure knots.

As if he knew Tyelko’s thoughts, Oromë continued, “Do you, the Eldar, or even we, the Valar, have any right to define how much mercy Eru must show us?”

“No,” Tyelko conceded. “But frankly, that doesn’t make me like Eru, or you and the other Valar, any better. It just makes me understand you’re more powerful than me and I’m stuck with you.”

For the first time, Tyelko glanced over at Oromë’s face, somewhat nervous to see his reaction. He had never spoken so brazenly against his master before—except on the day when he struck Morirámo, that is—and now he had openly admitted his dislike for the Valar and even Eru.

Stupid, stupid choice of words, he scolded himself. They could strike you dead! It’s safer to pretend to like them and begrudgingly obey them!

But to his shock, the grim-faced Oromë was smiling.

“That isn’t untrue,” he said. “We are more powerful than you and you are stuck with us. Well then, it’s a good thing that we care for you, isn’t it?”

“I sure haven’t felt like you care for me!” Tyelko jumped to his feet, his face flushing with anger. “After what you let me go through these past few days! And especially taking away my animal speech…” His lip quivered, and he swallowed back tears.

“Do you want it back?”

The proud part of Tyelko’s heart wanted to declare he was perfectly fine without his gift. That he didn’t want anything to do with Oromë or the other Valar anymore. He didn’t want to have to submit to whatever game Oromë was playing with him to get the gift back.

But he found himself nodding. Perhaps, if nothing else, for Huan’s sake. Even if he couldn’t bring himself to join Oromë’s hunters anymore, and he had to give up Huan, he at least yearned to say goodbye to him properly.

“Then walk with me.” Oromë stood and headed towards the dock. “Learn from me, as you once did, and you will understand the animals again sooner than you know. Do you agree to this?”

Tyelko wasn’t sure he fully agreed in his heart yet, but he nodded anyway, and he and Huan followed Oromë.

But before they left the ship, Oromë raised his hand in farewell to the Teler sailor, who had climbed high up on the rigging to polish some of the higher beams of the sails. The Teler nodded deeply in return, and smiled at Tyelko, who ducked his head in shame.

“Perhaps after our journey, you will understand how it helped you after all to gaze upon the stars.” Oromë looked totally out of place in this ethereal, silvery city. The Teleri were all draped in sleek white and silver robes, with straight or wavy hair neatly arranged or tied back. And here was Oromë in his usual furs and leather, and his curly brown hair and beard, and his muscular arms clearly visible thanks to his sleeveless tunic. If Tyelko weren’t so upset, he would have laughed. Yet somehow, Oromë didn’t seem bothered by the curious stares he earned from the Teleri they passed.

“We can stay here tonight,” Oromë said. “Make camp just outside the city.”

Tyelko shook his head firmly. “I’m not tired,” he declared. This was true, but it also wasn’t. His muscles were a little sore from fatigue, but his mind was so restless that he knew he wouldn’t have been able to go to sleep.

Oromë gazed at him with an unreadable expression. “If you insist. We shall head south, then, to my woods.”

* * *​

Oromë and Tyelko rode south for a few hours, traveling at a swift pace. Tyelko didn’t feel at all worthy of riding Huan, and the idea of riding without being able to communicate with him made Tyelko anxious. But Oromë insisted, so Tyelko reluctantly obeyed.

The familiar feel of Huan’s coarse fur, and the view of his head bobbing back and forth as he ran, took Tyelko back to much fonder times. For a few minutes, it felt as though none of these things had happened. He and Huan were just out riding with Oromë again, chasing some stag or another.

And Oromë rode alongside them on a massive horse, whose shoulders would have been above Maitimo’s head. Even the mighty Vala of hunting with his height and muscular figure looked small against his giant steed.

Oromë repeatedly asked Tyelko if he needed to stop and rest. Each time, Tyelko insisted he was fine, though this answer became increasingly untrue as the night hours wore on.

Eventually, Oromë halted and declared he needed rest, even if Tyelko didn’t.

“You’re lying,” Tyelko huffed, his lip curling in a pout. “You’re just saying that to try to make me sleep. You’re a Vala! You can appear anywhere you want, like you did when I was yelling at you earlier!”

“I can indeed do that, young one, but I’m not lying. I have a physical fana, and it wearies after a long day of hunting and journeying. And so, too, does your hröa weary.”

He put a firm hand on Tyelko’s shoulder before arranging two bedrolls of fur on the ground, and climbing into one of them. “Now, you can stay awake and keep watch with my horse if you’d like. Or you can rest so you have strength for the tasks I give you tomorrow.”

“I’ll keep watch, thanks,” Tyelko retorted, folding his arms and leaning against a tree.

He stood there for some time, and it wasn’t long before Oromë’s breathing turned deep and rhythmic. Tyelko’s eyes burned as he fought to stay awake.

A soft nose bumped against his shoulder. He turned to see Huan, wagging his tail slightly. Then Huan curled up on the ground and stared up at Tyelko with his usual soft, sweet gaze.

Maybe it was because Tyelko’s eyes were tired and sore, but he found them welling up with tears. Though he couldn’t understand Huan’s speech anymore, he realized if he could, Huan was likely saying, Come cuddle with Huan, Tyelko.

“Leave it to you to think of cuddling at a time like this,” Tyelko muttered. The only other person he knew, besides himself and Huan, who loved cuddling that much, was Timo. And yet ironically, Timo didn’t appreciate Huan’s cuddling that much. Perhaps because it was typically accompanied by copious amounts of drool.

But then again… little brothers had been drooling all over Timo ever since Laurë was born, and that certainly didn’t diminish his enjoyment of their cuddling.

These thoughts made Tyelko’s tears flow all the more freely, but they also made the idea of sleep seem rather enticing. Eventually he could no longer resist the urge to snuggle against Huan’s furry hide, and he curled up against him and fell asleep.

* * *​

The savory smell of rabbit cooking over a fire stirred Tyelko awake. Beams of early mingling light shone in dappled patterns amongst the leaves of the trees. The light was mostly silver still, but fading, and dotted with glimmers of gold.

Despite only having slept a few short hours, and his eyes still feeling heavy and sore, Tyelko arose easily, since he normally went out hunting at this hour.

Huan lay perfectly still, clearly trying his best not to disturb Tyelko. But based on the way he sniffed the air, he seemingly struggled to remain still thanks to the tantalizing scent of the cooking meat.

To Tyelko’s great surprise, a hopeful thought came to his mind. I can still understand Huan a little.

Still, this wasn’t much comfort when the chattering of the birds sounded to him like meaningless noise, and not typical bird gossip about bugs they’d found or good places to nest.

“Come eat, my boy.” Oromë gestured for Tyelko to come join him as he rotated the rabbit meat on a spit. “You must be famished.”

If this were last night, Tyelko would have put up a fuss and refused to take any food from Oromë. But he couldn’t ignore the growling of his stomach, and so he sat by his master and gratefully accepted a cut of meat. Huan sprang up like a loosed arrow, and Oromë smiled as he tossed him a few pieces.

“We have only a few hours yet before we arrive in my woods,” Oromë explained. “We should arrive by mid-morning.”

“Really?” Tyelko frowned in concentration as he chewed on his meat. “But I thought your woods would have been at least a full day’s journey from Alqualondë, and we didn’t ride very long last night.”

“We have traveled swifter than you think.” Tyelko’s confusion only deepened, because he knew Huan could only run so fast, but Oromë promptly changed the subject. “Now, I cannot tell you what we will encounter upon our arrival, or what I will ask you to do. However, I ask for your obedience, which will not be for my benefit, but for yours. If I give you a command, do I have your word that you will obey?”

Tyelko didn’t like this: promising obedience when he didn’t know exactly what command he would have to obey. Still, it didn’t seem like he had much of a choice if he wanted his animal speech back. Besides, what was the worst he could encounter at the Woods of Oromë? Probably some of the other hunting students, who would surely laugh and scoff once they discovered Tyelko’s sorry new state. It would be humiliating, but it was a humiliation he deserved. The sooner he faced it, the sooner he could regain his gift.

“I’ll try,” was the most honest answer he could give to Oromë.

The Vala nodded in satisfaction, and not too long afterwards, they set out and rode swiftly southwards.

Tyelko had always gotten excited whenever he noticed the trees getting bigger and taller whenever he rode further south, and the animals appearing larger than usual. This was how he always knew he was nearing Oromë’s woods. But now, rather than his usual excitement, he only felt guilt and dread.

The trunks of these trees were so thick that Tyelko and Maitimo couldn’t have touched each other’s fingertips if they wrapped their arms around them. And they were so tall that Tyelko could only see the top if he lay on the ground. Their branches sprawled with a rich covering of dark green leaves, housing bird nests which were bigger than a washing bowl. These enormous nests were home to large birds like falcons and hawks. If one waited long enough, one might catch a glimpse of a stag running by, and these great stags were often larger than horses.

Tyelko remembered the first time Oromë had asked him to kill a stag. He had cried, because the creature was so noble and beautiful. But Oromë reminded him it was for the good of the rest of the forest, because if the deer grew too great in number, they would graze too much and drive out other animals like the birds and squirrels. Wolves were necessary for the health of the forest. As were hunters.

Normally the great trees and giant animals felt like wise guardians welcoming Tyelkormo home. Now, they felt stern and foreboding, looking down on him with disapproval.

Oromë took him through the camp, where deerskin tents and smoldering firepits were everywhere to be seen. The other hunters, all Eldar from all over Valinórë, and of varying ages and heights and hair colors, hauled in their morning kills and cleaned their weapons. Tyelko avoided all their gazes.

“Can we just get it over with already?” he mumbled to Oromë.

“I have not taken you to see the other hunters, my boy.”

Oromë led him through the camp and to its outskirts. Tyelko jumped as he recognized a tent: a huge rectangular tent, as big as a small house, with familiar red banners hanging from its walls.

“What’s my family doing here?” he asked, his voice tense. He unconsciously clenched his fists.

“Stay calm and trust me, Tyelkormo. I will guide you through this.”

Sure enough, Fëanáro, Nerdanel, and five brothers were gathered outside the tent, sitting in a circle and seeming to discuss something. The Ambarussar were the first to notice Tyelko and Oromë’s arrival. With a shout of joy, they jumped to their feet, rushed to Tyelko, and tackled him to the ground with a hug.

“Tyelko, Tyelko!” Pityo cried. “We were so worried! Where have you been?”

Despite Tyelko’s anger and suspicion towards his family, his eyes burned with tears, and he held the twins tightly to his chest.

But out of the corner of his eye, he spotted the people he really didn’t want to talk to: his parents, and Makalaurë. And upon noticing Curufinwë arriving with the group, Tyelko closed his eyes. He couldn’t bear to face his favorite brother after all this.

“Turcafinwë!” Fëanáro was the first to speak, and Tyelko was surprised to detect a certain amount of warmth and relief in his father’s voice. That didn’t last, though, as his tone grew suddenly angry. “We’ve been searching for you since yesterday morning—”

“Tyelkormo will explain everything if given a few moments of patience and understanding,” Oromë interrupted. His voice was perhaps the only one even deeper and more resonant than that of Fëanáro. “I ask you all to withhold your anger and listen quietly.”

Fëanáro’s eyes glinted like a diamond in the firelight, and he opened his mouth as though to speak, but Nerdanel placed a hand on his arm and quietly shook her head. This, to Tyelko’s great surprise, seemed to be enough to keep Fëanáro silent.

“Let us all sit by the fire and let Tyelkormo speak,” said Oromë.

Everyone agreed, and returned to their spots around the fire, but Tyelko lagged behind and trailed after Oromë. “Do I have to tell them everything?” he whispered. “About Morirámo, and my gift and all?”

“That grievance is between you and me, and I will not force you to explain it to them. But they deserve some understanding of your grief regarding Nelyafinwë, and the feelings which caused you to leave.”

Tyelko sighed deeply. Though he didn’t like it, he knew deep down Oromë was right. So, though he still couldn’t look his family members in the eye, he joined them and sat next to Oromë.

“I don’t even know where to begin,” he said.

“Chronological order would likely be easiest,” Moryo offered. “Start with the morning you left, perhaps. What were you doing?”

I was trying to hunt down Morirámo. “I was… hunting,” Tyelko said, and mentally kicked himself for how much it sounded like a lie. “I mean, I was trying to hunt something I shouldn’t have been. Something forbidden for hunters to harm. I had been spending a few days looking for this… this creature, and it was wrong of me. I thought it would make me feel better once I caught it. But, it didn’t.”

A memory flashed into Tyelko’s mind of Morirámo squealing, his ears pointed backwards, and the whites of his eyes showing. All signs of a terrified horse. All because of Tyelkormo and his hasty anger.

“Oromë came to rebuke me.” Tyelko forced his voice to remain even, and he kept his head bowed and his hair hanging in front of his face so hopefully no one would see his red eyes. “I didn’t want to hear it, even though I knew I was wrong. I didn’t think I could face anyone ever again, so I ran. I went first to Alqualondë, because I wanted to leave. Really leave.”

He didn’t have to look up to know everyone was staring at him. If all the Fëanorians were silent for once in their lives, they must have been shocked indeed.

“You mean… go across the sea?” Telvo cried. “But how would you have done it?”

“I couldn’t. That’s why I didn’t. Maybe if I had help, I could have, but I was alone… all alone except for… for Huan…”

He couldn’t resist his tears anymore, and Nerdanel quickly jumped up and threw her arms around him, holding his head close to her chest and stroking his hair. In that moment, Tyelko forgot why he should have been mad at his mother at all, and he held her tightly as he wept.

The twins also rushed over and joined in on the embrace. And there was one more redhead who would have done the same thing if he were here, and this made Tyelko cry all the harder.

“Where’s Timo?” he asked after a long moment, extracting himself from the hugs and wiping the tears away from his face.

“He’s at home,” Pityo said cheerfully. “Waiting for us.”

“Hopefully,” Laurë muttered dryly.

“Wait, what do you mean hopefully?” Tyelko cried, jumping to his feet.

“Well, because we were supposed to return to him by the mingling last night. He has no idea where we are right now, and I only hope he has not succumbed to his anxiety.” Laurë shot a nasty glare at Fëanáro, who glowered at him in return.

“Nelyafinwë has enough intelligence to not do anything stupid. You have no place to question my judgement!”

Tyelko groaned loudly, and his tears dried up as hot anger burned in his heart. “How could you all do this to him? He’s out looking for us right now, I know it! And maybe his wounds got reopened, and then some wolves smelled his blood—”

“How do you know that?” Curvo asked, his voice testy. This was the first time he had spoken since Tyelko’s arrival.

Tyelko looked long and hard at the varying looks of worry and confusion in all his family members’ eyes. “Because I’d do the same thing if I were him!”

His heart crashed into the pit of his stomach as a horrible realization came to him. Yes, his family could fairly be blamed, but ultimately, this was all Tyelko’s fault.

“If I hadn’t run away, none of you would be out here looking for me, and Timo wouldn’t have gone out either, and now he probably got hurt because of me again!”

He felt just about ready to bolt from the scene and look for Maitimo himself. This, unlike his hunt for Morirámo, would have been a worthy chase. He owed it to his brother whom he had now hurt twice. Assuming he wasn’t too late…

But just as his muscles tensed up, preparing for sudden movement, Oromë put a firm hand on his shoulder and shook his head.

“Fear not for Nelyafinwë. He is safe.” Oromë’s resonant voice cut through all the anxious murmuring amongst the family and silenced them. “However, Tyelkormo and Makalaurë are both correct in their judgment. Maitimo could not bear the worry of his entire family being missing, and he set out on his own search. I guided his horse to take him to a safe place. After all is resolved here, you must discover for yourselves where that safe place is.”

Now Fëanáro’s face drained white, and Makalaurë’s reddened with rage. Nerdanel closed her eyes, and tears trickled down her cheeks.

“I wish you all not to argue with each other and accuse each other of wrongdoing,” Oromë said. “Each of you thought you were doing what was best, and you must allow each other grace for your motives. Before anyone departs, I would like you all to admit your wrongs. And Nelyafinwë was not the only person wronged. Fëanáro, as the leader of your House, would you be the first to speak?”

“If this is true…” Fëanáro’s voice was uncharacteristically quiet, and he looked at Oromë with a pleading gaze, as though begging him for some reassurance, but Oromë was silent. “If this is true, then I have erred twice and harmed Nelyafinwë twice. First by removing him from my father’s House too soon, and then by leaving him alone to worry. I realize now I could have sent one of my sons back home yesterday to tell him the news.”

Oromë nodded in stern approval. “Very true. Is there anyone else here who deserves a word of repentance?”

Fëanáro turned and smiled sadly at Nerdanel. “My wise wife tried to dissuade me at the House of Finwë, and I did not listen to her. Perhaps this was why she did not speak up against me yesterday.”

“I did not wish you to feel I was opposing you.” Nerdanel reached out and took his hands. “I knew you were doing what you thought best for our family, though in my heart I disagreed. Still, for Maitimo’s sake, I wish I had followed my heart.”

Then she turned to Tyelko, left Fëanáro and embraced him. “And I wish I had known how your heart was hurting, love. I am sorry I did not seek you out, even though I knew this accident was particularly troubling to you. Will you forgive me?”

Tyelko couldn’t help but smile as she wiped the last few tears from his cheeks. “I forgive you, Ammë. And I’m sorry I was… such a brat.”

“You were acting out of love for your brother. I can hardly fault you for that. It brings such joy to my mother’s heart that my sons love each other so much.”

After Nerdanel pulled away from Tyelko, Oromë addressed the group once more. “Does anyone else have any words of repentance to share?”

Tyelko noticed Oromë looking long and hard at Makalaurë, but he remained moodily silent.

And there was someone else who remained in moody silence. Curvo.

Only then did Tyelko realize how nasty he had been to his favorite brother lately. In the days while Tyelko had been hunting, Curvo had been asking a bunch of questions, which had seemed nosy and irritating to Tyelko at the time, but now he realized Curvo must have been concerned for him and trying to help. And Tyelko had refused to let him.

If Tyelko knew Curvo, he needed a conversation in private, not with family members breathing down their necks.

“I want to talk to Curvo,” Tyelko whispered to Oromë. “Alone.”

Oromë nodded in agreement. “I would like someone skilled to sharpen a rather dull blade I have,” he said to the group. “Curufinwë, would you come with me and Tyelkormo?”

He nodded dully, still staring at the ground, and Tyelko’s heart twinged with guilt as Oromë led them to his armory. This place was a great stone hall, with walls and shelves stacked with spears and bows and arrows and daggers. Oromë handed a large hunting knife and a sharpening rock to Curvo, and then left the hall.

Curvo halfheartedly scraped at the blade, his movements lacking their normal concentration and efficiency.

“I’ve been a brat to you too,” Tyelko blurted.

“I’ve noticed,” Curvo said dryly.

“I was annoyed with all your questions, I have to admit.” Tyelko watched as Curvo scowled deeply, and a spark flew as he delivered a fierce stroke with the blade. “But I think I get it now. You were just wanting to help me, right?”

“Everyone expected me to have all the answers about you.” Curvo finally glanced up and regarded him with an icy stare, identical to Fëanáro’s. “As though I can read your mind, when… I can’t, Tyelko! I only know so much about you because you tell me everything. Or, you used to, anyway.”

Now it was Tyelko’s turn to drop his gaze to the floor. Curvo sighed, and his tone softened a little. “Why didn’t you tell me anything? You know I wouldn’t have judged you, right? I know how it is to be angry, even though I’m maybe not as impulsive in my anger as you are. But… I would have cared. And probably understood better than someone like Nelyo who’s perfectly nice all the time.”

“Are you calling me not nice? …Because, you’re not wrong.”

Curvo’s frown faded to a hint of a grin.

Tyelko paused for a moment as he thought about why he had refused to tell Curvo anything. “I don’t really know why I was so angry about your questioning. Don’t feel bad for not being able to read my mind, because I don’t understand what I’m thinking or feeling half the time either. Maybe I was just scared of being found out because I knew I was doing something wrong.”

He took a deep breath as he realized in that moment what he needed to do.

“In fact… Oromë said I didn’t need to tell anyone in my family about this. But I think you deserve to know.”

So he started explaining everything from the moment Maitimo fainted when getting out of the carriage, and how it made Tyelko thirst for revenge against Morirámo. He described the process of his hunt, and how he eventually found, and struck, Morirámo. He told Curvo how Oromë had confronted him, and how he had run away and then finally, lost his gift.

Tyelko thought surely he would have run out of tears by now, but apparently not. And even Curvo’s eyes were red and glassy by the time Tyelko finished.

“Well,” Curvo said, blinking rapidly and seemingly trying to hide his tears, “looks like we’ve got work to do. We need to work on getting your gift back.”

“That’s what I’m supposed to do with Oromë, but I don’t know how. He’ll tell me, I guess. But it’s not going to be easy, I’m sure.”

“If you need some extra help practicing—” Curvo regarded Tyelko with a stone-serious gaze— “I will do my very best to impersonate a bird.”

Tyelko burst out laughing so hard that he doubled over.

“You know, Curvo, I’d love to see your best attempt at that.”

They emerged from the armory, laughing heartily, and Curvo carrying the finely sharpened blade. And they discovered the rest of their family tacking up their horses, preparing to leave. Their tent was disassembled and its parts loaded up into several bags, which the horses bore on their backs. Oromë accepted his blade back from Curvo with a nod of thanks, and he sheathed it in its scabbard.

Tyelko turned to Oromë. “Can I go with them? I really want to see Timo.”

“Not yet, but you will get your chance sooner than you think. I have another task for you, should you accept it. It is something you must do alone.”

Tyelko nodded slowly and noticed Curvo’s smile fade. “I promise I’ll tell you all about it when I get home. And you’d better be working on your bird impression in the meantime.”

“Oh, I think I’ve already got some ideas.” Curvo let out an unearthly screech, which Tyelko had no idea was possible to come out of his little brother’s lungs. Rustling noises of flapping wings, and squawking sounds, came from the nearby trees as hundreds of birds took off and flew away in fear.

Tyelko and Curvo burst out laughing once more. “I think… I think I can translate that one,” Tyelko wheezed. “You just told them you are the most unhinged bird to ever exist.”

“Is that wrong, though?”

“Curufinwë!” Fëanáro’s voice roared out from where he sat on his horse. “Are you coming?”

Curvo sighed and nodded. But before he could leave, Tyelko threw his arms around him and squeezed him tightly, which he tolerated in silence.

“Goodbye to you too,” Curvo said flatly. “I’d like to be able to breathe now, Tyelko.”

“Picky, picky.” Tyelko released him, and he returned to the others.

As the family rode off into the forest, Tyelko felt like he had been carrying a heavy, half-rotten deer carcass for too long. And now, he had finally put it down.

“What’s next? Do I have to face the other hunters now?” he asked Oromë.

Oromë chuckled and shook his head. “That was never part of my plan. There is someone else I wish you to seek out.”

Tyelko kept trying to ask Oromë for more details as they rode north for some ways, but Oromë remained silent, so eventually Tyelko gave up. After a while, they came to a large clearing. A familiar black horse stood grazing in the distance. Upon seeing the newcomers arrive, the horse jerked his head up, and he galloped off and disappeared.

Tyelko’s face paled. “No, Lord Oromë, I’m not ready to face Morirámo yet. He clearly still hates me, and with good reason!”

“You may take as much time as you need. You must win back his trust on your own merits, and without any direct aid from me.”

“How am I supposed to do that if I can’t even talk to him?”

“How do those without animal speech manage to tame horses? Now go, track him, before he gets too far ahead!”

Tyelko sighed heavily and scratched Huan behind his ears, which was his favorite spot. “Well, if Master won’t help me with this one, will you help me, old buddy?”

Huan gave a happy bark in response, and bounded after the horse’s scent.

Despite all the stress of the last few days, and despite the loss of his gift, the rushing of the wind in his hair and the sound of Huan’s panting and bounding pawsteps made Tyelko feel like his old self again. He and Huan were on a hunt. And not a bad sort of hunt, but a good and worthy one.

He had no idea what he was doing, but then again, Turcafinwë Tyelkormo rarely knew what he was doing. With Huan’s help, he would find a way to make this right.



Notes:

Fana: the physical body of a Vala.

Hröa: the physical body of an Elf.
 
Last edited:
Back to top

Chapter 15: Observations and Interventions

“I don’t much like that Prince Nelyafinwë fellow.”

Aranya wanted to say, See how much water is in this bucket, Tecno? None, right? That’s how much I care about your opinion. But she actually said—through gritted teeth, while aggressively scrubbing a bloodstain out of her apron— “We are not supposed to dislike any of our patients, Tecno.”

“Or like them overly much,” Tecno said with his typical self-righteous nod.

Aranya rolled her eyes. She tried to scoot away from him as she rinsed her apron and wrung it out, twisting it with a fierce grip. But he had conveniently decided he also needed to wash his apron, at that exact same moment, and his wet hands brushed against hers as he dipped his apron into the rinsing basin.

She thought she was going to be sick.

She decided she didn’t care if she was tracking dripping wet fabric across the floor, so she took her apron, flung open the door of the laundry room, and hurried outside. Tecno ran after her like a pathetic wet dog.

The golden beams of Laurelin illuminated this field of tall grass and wildflowers. Delicate silks and fine linens hung from clothes wires, blowing gently in the breeze. Aranya hung her apron to dry alongside the other drying uniforms of healers and other servants, and Tecno hung his up right beside hers.

And unfortunately, he wasn’t done ranting about Maitimo. “From what I have observed of his overly muscular figure and incredibly stupid decision to ride in the woods alone at night while wounded, I have concluded that he spends far more time in athletic pursuits than in developing the mind.”

Aranya stopped abruptly, causing Tecno to collide with her, and she laughed loudly and harshly in his face. Even he winced at the volume of her voice.

“You have no idea what he does in his spare time, Tecno.”

“And you do?”

Aranya said nothing, and her lips were pursed in a smirk. Without answering the question, she turned and skipped away.

“I’ll be sure to tell Arcamë you were speaking ill over a patient!” she sang.

“Wait! Aranya, I was, ah, I was just joking—”

“The Healer’s Code doesn’t say speaking ill over a patient is acceptable if it’s a joke!”

She heard him mutter a curse, but it grew distant as he failed to keep up with her pace. And she didn’t slow down as she approached the gardens, and finally, the front gates. It was a roundabout way to reach the female servants’ quarters and Arcamë, but she didn’t mind taking it. Not when the day was so beautiful and there was an annoying nér to be avoided.

As she approached the gate, one of the guards of Nolofinwë, clad in blue velvet and mithril, rode out in haste. Aranya’s brows creased in confusion, and then she spotted Arcamë and Prince Nolofinwë conversing together near the front.

Trying to catch her breath and smooth her frizzy hair, Aranya tentatively approached them, curious about their conversation but unsure if she should insert herself into it. But Arcamë caught her eye, smiled, and motioned for her to come over. Nolofinwë smiled at her as well.

“Ah, young Aranya,” said Nolofinwë. “Arcamë tells me you did a fine job in caring for my nephew and settling him down enough for sleep.”

Aranya curtsied and felt some flush coming to her cheeks. “Thank you, Your Highness. I did my best.”

“She says this is not the first time you’ve been the only healer who could calm him.” Nolofinwë raised his eyebrows, and his smile turned into something of a smirk. Aranya’s blush deepened, and in that moment she wasn’t sure if she was grateful for Arcamë’s praise or mortified by it.

Thankfully, Nolofinwë changed the subject slightly. “My poor nephew. He’s always been so prone to anxiety, largely, I think, because of the many burdens and pressures placed on him. And I don’t fully understand what exactly he’s been through these past few days, but… in any case, it is a blessing to all of us to have someone as compassionate and skilled as you to help.”

“Thank you, Your Highness,” Aranya said again, at a loss for any other words. Normally, she found it easy enough to make conversation with Nolofinwë, as well as his wife and children. They were all an amiable bunch who seemed to have a genuine affection for their servants, and Nolofinwë often asked her about her higher aspirations as a healer. But was he sensing something going on between her and Maitimo? Would he be upset if he found out?

“I have just told him everything about our situation,” Arcamë said, breaking Aranya out of her thoughts. “He sent a guard just now to the House of Fëanáro to deliver a message that Prince Nelyafinwë is here. Whenever his family returns, they should receive it.”

“Good,” Aranya said. “I suppose our House is better at communicating than the House of Fëanáro.”

Nolofinwë’s normally stoic expression lit up with a wide smile. He laughed heartily and patted Aranya on the shoulder. “It is a low bar to reach, but we try. I have also sent some guards to search for my brother and his children.”

He excused himself from the healers and returned inside. And Aranya trailed after Arcamë as she headed back towards the healing halls. “Can I talk to you privately for a moment?”

“Of course, dear.”

“Tecno continues to refuse to respect my personal space. And what’s more, he was speaking ill over Maitimo.”

Arcamë stopped in her tracks and stared at Aranya with incredulous confusion. “Whatever would he have to say against the prince?”

“He’s too muscular, apparently.”

Arcamë seemed blank and frozen in shock for a second before she burst out in laughter, almost like how Aranya had laughed in Tecno’s face earlier. Aranya couldn’t help joining in, and it was a while before either of them could catch their breath.

“I shall have to tell Tecno that jealousy is not becoming in a healer,” Arcamë said, wiping a tear from her eye. “And remind him not to let bitterness set in his heart against a patient. But I am more concerned with his lack of consideration for your wishes. How many times have we told him he is not to touch you or come too close to you?”

“I’ve lost count,” Aranya said dully.

“It may be worth bringing up with Prince Nolofinwë at this point. He will understand, I think, and perhaps he can determine if a severe threat is all that is needed, or if we should dismiss him from our service. I will seek an audience with him as soon as I am able.”

Aranya nodded gratefully. Impulsively, she threw her arms around her mentor.

“Why, my dear,” Arcamë said with a note of amusement in her voice, gently rubbing Aranya’s back, “I’m only doing what any reasonable senior healer ought to. Frankly, I’m scolding myself for not having done it sooner.”

“Yes, I know, but… it’s not just that.” Aranya pulled away and sighed, unable to articulate her sentiments regarding the many years she spent learning under Arcamë.

* * *​

Nolofinwë visited the healing halls several times over the next few hours, anxiously checking to see if Maitimo was awake yet. Findekáno and Írissë accompanied him on one such visit, but after they raised their voices a little too loud when talking excitedly to Aranya, Nolofinwë led them out of the room and did not permit them to visit again until Maitimo was awake.

His heart was overwhelmed with confusion and sorrow as he gazed upon his nephew’s pale, clammy face. His mind ruminated over the scarce details he knew: Maitimo had been in a horse riding accident some days prior. Then Finno and Íri found him riding in their woods, wearing mithril mail, and looking disoriented. And according to the healers, he had been in nearly hysterical anxiety regarding his missing brothers. Only Aranya had managed to calm him.

None of it made sense to Nolofinwë. It didn’t seem at all like the Fëanáro he knew to keep his household in such a state of disarray. Nolofinwë had always looked up to his older brother, strong and loving and just, effortlessly earning the respect of all his children. Why, then, was his eldest wandering wounded in the woods, and his remaining children missing?

Nolofinwë’s only guess was that something terrible beyond belief must have happened. The more he thought about it, the more he worried. What if his brother and nephews were in danger? But what, in these blessed undying lands, could possibly pose a danger to someone so mighty and clever as Fëanáro?

Until they got some more information, all Nolofinwë could do was protect and guard Maitimo. His visits to the healing halls grew longer and longer as he grew increasingly worried and unwilling to leave Maitimo’s side. Nolofinwë couldn’t help but notice that Aranya behaved similarly. Even as Arcamë came and went from the healing halls, Aranya remained a short distance away, seeming to focus on her embroidery. But out of the corner of his eye, Nolofinwë spotted her casting brief glances at Maitimo.

Nolofinwë smiled slightly, but turned his head so she wouldn’t see. Normally Aranya hated to sit in one spot too long.

Thankfully, Nolofinwë’s patience paid off, because he was there when Maitimo awoke sometime in the mid-afternoon. Nolofinwë waited yet another few minutes as Maitimo blinked confusedly at nothing. Then, his glance landed not on Nolofinwë, but on Aranya.

“Maitimo,” she said, immediately noticing his gaze, “your uncle is here to see you.”

Maitimo finally turned his head towards Nolofinwë and smiled weakly. While he was distracted, Aranya quietly left for the kitchen.

“How are you feeling, Nelyo?” Nolofinwë asked.

“Mmm… tired, I think.” Maitimo blinked slowly, as though he could barely keep his eyes open, and Nolofinwë almost felt guilty, somehow, simply for talking to him.

“You can sleep more if you need it,” Nolofinwë told him. “Don’t feel obligated to keep me entertained. I am only here because I wanted to know how you’re doing. This is not a social visit.”

To Nolofinwë’s relief, Maitimo cracked a slight smile. “Good… I’m afraid I don’t make very interesting company right now.”

But his smile quickly faded, and his eyes widened ever so slightly. “Uncle… my brothers are missing.”

“So I’ve heard.” Nolofinwë gently patted Maitimo’s hand. “I’ve sent out my guards to look for them. You don’t need to worry about it.”

Maitimo nodded, seemingly relieved, but again, his relief didn’t last long. He closed his eyes and groaned.

Nolofinwë stood quickly, preparing to send for the healers, but Maitimo only said, “I could have sent my father’s guards! Why didn’t I think of that? I’m… I’m so stupid!

Nolofinwë winced and sat back down, mentally kicking himself. Clearly, he wasn’t as good as Aranya at keeping Maitimo calm. Where did she go and when would she be back?

“Anyone could have made such a mistake,” Nolofinwë said with a tense smile, hoping he was coming across as calm and reassuring, but unsure how successful he was. “No one holds you at fault. All we can do now is move forward, and for you that means resting and getting better.”

“And improving my decision-making capabilities,” Maitimo said bitterly.

Nolofinwë felt at a loss for words, but to his relief, Aranya returned, carrying a tray with a bowl of steaming soup. “Time to eat!” she said cheerfully.

Maitimo stared at her forlornly. “I’m not hungry.”

Aranya widened her eyes at him, looking as sad and pathetic as a kicked puppy, and even Nolofinwë felt an uncomfortable guilt when looking at her. “But I went all the way to the kitchen to get you this! It’s just a warm, mild, beef broth. Very comforting. I just wanted to share some of that comfort with you. Is my effort going to be wasted?”

“Well… no…” Maitimo sighed, winced, and avoided Aranya’s gaze. She and Nolofinwë carefully helped him sit up, and Aranya placed the tray on his lap. “I’m sorry. I don’t mean to scorn your kindness.”

“Don’t apologize. Just eat,” Aranya said bluntly.

And to Nolofinwë’s amazement, Maitimo obeyed her.

So, Nolofinwë had finally seen it with his own two eyes. Aranya, this healer who had practically grown up in his House, had a way with Maitimo which not even his own relatives had.

Nolofinwë had never been much of a romantic—he still marveled how he had managed to win Anairë’s heart with his awkward stammering—but even he could now understand the situation perfectly. He’d had his suspicions for many years, but now he saw it plainly as Aranya watched over Maitimo with tenderness and even coaxed him into laughter.

Did any of Maitimo’s brothers know about this? Did Fëanáro?

And as much as he loved and admired his brother, Nolofinwë’s heart sank a little as he pondered how Fëanáro and Nerdanel would surely react. Nerdanel was highly concerned with the opinion of the court and constantly spoke of finding a lady of “suitable birth” for Maitimo. Fëanáro didn’t care for such political niceties, but he’d find other ways to scrutinize any lady his son chose.

Nolofinwë only wished there were some way he could help his nephew bring this joy into his life. But based on his past experiences with Fëanáro, he knew any of his efforts to intervene would only make matters worse.
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top