Gandalf White said:And the fact that they are very good films...
I don't like it either, but I'm on the record as being out of my right mind already, so whatever.Anyone in their right minds to start a hoo-haa about something like that quote is out of their right minds.
Foe-Hammer said:Because the movie is such a record breaking success, we must admit that pj and company did a mighty fine job in adapting this to the screen. No one, with any real credibilty, can claim that any script or scene change would have made this movie a bigger success. [emphasis mine]
his utter absence from the theatrical release of ROTK (unlike Sean Bean, Christopher Lee doesn't even appear in the credits)
"No one tosses a Dwarf!",
But mostly Orlando Bloom's complexion...and maybe Elijah Wood's freakishly huge eyes
Rhiannon said:....
Hah!
The Bashki film was not closer to the book, and was a failure due to the fact that it was absolutely absurd in every way, shape, and form. The Rankin & Bass film, while reasonably close to the book, was a failure due to the fact that it only covered the third book and was a small scale production. And anyway, I like it, for nostolgic reasons. When I was six I thought it was great.
Rhiannon said:....The New Line films are without a doubt more successful, but this has nothing to do with the changes made in the story and everything to do with the budget, the marketing, the hype, and Orlando Bloom's complexion.
Aldanil said:Gotta tell ya there, Glamdring ol' pal, I really do think those looong rusty years of hanging neglected, on the wall of that filthy rank lair in the Trollshaws, waiting to be claimed by the passing Mithrandir, have finally begun to undermine your reason:
A couple of old jokes come to mind at this point. One of them, using table manners for its premise, mimics my shock at your genuinely mind-boggling comment, but in an implicitly self-deprecating way, so as not to give offense: "The other day in a restaurant I saw a man eating peas off a knife; I was so appalled I almost dropped my entire handful of mashed potatoes!" Another, the second word of which I won't even attempt to put (unaltered) past the Forum's omnipotent built-in censors, and which very likely will cause less vulgar tongues to tut-tut disapprovingly, is a simple slogan: "Eat Shi[f]t! 20 Billion Flies Can't Be Wrong!"
But seriously, folks. . .
Whatever I and other relentlessly negative nit-picking weenies like Thorin & Company (without whose timely help, remember, you'd still be hanging neglected, etc.) may think about his "credibilty" as a screenwriter, no less esteemed a person than PJ himself apparently disagrees with you. As late as last October, according to a special behind-the-scenes documentary on the Discovery Channel, Jackson was shooting take after take after take of new dialogue between Aragorn and Gandalf at Edoras. Rather feeble and sappy new dialogue at that, to my mind: "What does your heart tell you?" The wizard only smiles slowly in simpering answer. (Doting devotees of the original narrative may well ask themselves what Gandalf and Aragorn are even doing, at this point in the story of The Return of the King, communing in Theoden's hall in the first place; never mind about that.) As late as last November, by all reports, Saruman had a brief but important part to play in the film-trilogy's final episode; not surprising, given that he was the major villain in its first two installments, certainly the one who received the most screen-time. Whether his utter absence from the theatrical release of ROTK (unlike Sean Bean, Christopher Lee doesn't even appear in the credits) is in any measurable way responsible for the undeniably enormous commercial success of the movie is surely an unanswerable question. Whether the absence from the screenplay of such feckless lines as "No one tosses a Dwarf!", "Just don't tell the Elf!", etc., would have increased or diminished the films' popularity is probably another moot point. (I employ the phrase with some hesitation, considering the altogether wretched hash that was made of the Entmoot; never mind about that.) No dispute; many, many people laughed out loud at these moments of "comic relief" (the quotation marks are used here to express sarcastic displeasure, rather than delineate a literary/technical term), at least at each of the showings that I attended, but I could only grimace and mutter unhappily, and I have every confidence that our dear John Ronald would have recoiled in horror, if not screamed, to hear them. Perhaps you will choose to interject here, Foe-Hammer, that such a mirthful reaction from the vast movie-going public (see joke #2 above) is further proof of PJ's improving on Tolkien; speaking just for myself, I remain unconvinced.
Speaking more broadly, I'd argue that the very existence of, to say nothing of the brisk sales-figures for, the EE DVDs of these films demonstrates that Jackson and very many others do indeed think "script and scene changes" can improve them, at least by way of additional material. You have only to read with cursory attention the postings of numerous folk here in the movie section of our beloved Forum to recognize how many have been reconciled to PJ's adaptation by all of the extras the EEs provide. I can only wish fondly that my DVD player had the capacity to cut scenes out, so's I could delete such dreck as Frodo having to three-peat his offer and shout down the Council of Elrond, or Aragorn coming back from the dead, or deep left field, or wherever he goes when he goes over that cliff.
Finally, Foe-Hammer, if by such "success" you mean even more millions of tickets sold or even more money in the bank-accounts of New Line Cinema, it's pointless to quibble with Big Box-Office Boffo. If, on the other hand, that phrase is understood to mean not only an enormous world-wide audience of very satisfied fans but also an example of the film-maker's art fully worthy of that master-work of literature whose depth of imagination and richness of detail are ultimately and indisputably the primary reason for the movie's "success", then I (for one) think that PJ could indeed have done better. It's a very high standard I'm invoking, I know, but a part of my heart has dwelt in Middle-earth since I was fourteen (just nine decades ago!), and no one likes to see his first true love ill-used. Hearing the horn of Boromir echo in the valley of Rivendell, instead of watching Lurtz rise out of Isengard-slime; seeing Legolas the bright-eyed Elf shoot a Nazgul out of the night sky with the bow of Galadriel, instead of Pippin the well-renowned mountaineer clamber straight up a cliff to sneak-light the beacon of Gondor; having the Heir of Isildur secure in his lineage, instead of an Aragorn who distrusts his own blood and bids Undomiel embark for the West without him; could substituting any of these original elements from Tolkien's story for the second-rate inventions of Jackson's screenplay possibly have failed to improve it?
It's a rhetorical question, at least by intention, but those who are not already persuaded aren't likely to be so by this long-winded diatribe (as I've said elsewhere before, at the thread-start of another lengthy screed about "Grinding Prime Rib into Hamburger Meat"); still, there's fun to be had in voluminous venting. Lest anyone take joke #2 above too much to heart, let me hasten to include myself among the buzzing bluebottles: I've seen these three movies twice each in theaters, own both of the EE DVDs currently available, and no doubt next autumn will acquire the third (though I haven't yet been able to bring myself - or "find the free time", as we schoolteachers say - to actually sit down and watch The Two Towers). Watching Peter Jackson's latest interview with Charlie Rose on PBS may have me grumbling, "Didja hear that? I knew it!", but I've got it on tape. After all, if I didn't enjoy the Kiwi Kaiser's Telep Esgal Ungwe in some considerable measure, how could I take such obvious pleasure in slashing with Sting at his silver-screen spider-web? (I was thinking of using that famous sword which once belonged to the King of Gondolin for my gleeful blade-labor, but I've been lately informed that somebody else has it. . .) With what other motive? Just to hear myself type?
Now if we've got that straight, as someone tone-deaf once put it, LET'S HUNT SOME ORC!
Foe-Hammer said:Ahhhhh....What an assinine statement that is!( Just more veiled insults of those who liked the movie.) So, your contention is that the only reason these movies are a success is that we have been fooled by marketing and hype, New Line threw a ton of money at it and everyone had a crush on OB? Rhiannon, the little credibilty you did have is now completely gone. Please remove yourself from further discussion because are just un-teachable.
IE, people who like these movies are either ignorant of jrrs work or they are from the video game crowd. I am niether, yet thoroughly enjoyed all three movies.
Eriol said:(yes, one -- don't count the 20 billion people who have watched the movie with you, as they haven't posted here). So we can laugh at you with impunity Welcome.
Eriol said:Do you prefer open insults?
Not that I would mind either style, but if you're so sensitive as to consider yourself insulted by the remark about Orlando Bloom and budget (both so obvious as to be undeniable), then you should pick your own insults more carefully.
Eriol said:Foe-Hammer, my friend, look at what you said here:
"IE, people who like these movies are either ignorant of jrrs work or they are from the video game crowd. I am niether, yet thoroughly enjoyed all three movies."
Eriol said:Show us a contradiction in a character.
Well, the Bashki drew Peter Jackson, so what does that tell us? Bashki failed because he made a freakishly awful film, and this purist, at least, hates and despises it a good deal more than Peter Jackson's films--though it is good for a laugh. If you're claiming the Bashki film was closer to the book, in the 1/2 of the book it covered, you might want to turn away while I laugh in your face. I just got up and haven't brushed my teeth yet.The R&B film failed before it had a chance to film the rest of the movie, that is why it was not finished. The Bashki film was closer to book than what we have in the PJ version, yet it failed. That is the point....this story.....as written is so great that it should be able to stand on it's own, without changes (or very few changes), but the closer to the book, the worse it did. Niether drew many people to jrr's original work.
Geez, people, there you go again. I was being humorous. You are being insulting. And you misspelled 'assinine'. You obviously have not been reading everything I have said, and are merely latching on to a flippant remark I threw out for no reason other than that I found it amusing as an excuse to insult my intelligence. Am I being clear enough about the fact that I am insulted? I don't want to be too subtle. I know how you hate anything veiled.Ahhhhh....What an assinine statement that is!( Just more veiled insults of those who liked the movie.) So, your contention is that the only reason these movies are a success is that we have been fooled by marketing and hype, New Line threw a ton of money at it and everyone had a crush on OB? Rhiannon, the little credibilty you did have is now completely gone. Please remove yourself from further discussion because are just un-teachable.
And again with the hypocritical statements. Pretty soon I'm going to be talking like my mother and bring up kitchen utensils of a particular color. Where's the support for your claim? We haven't seen a reasonably well done film that was close to the book. We have two poorly done animated films, neither complete, one of them scary in its bad-ness, and a big-budget film packed with freakishly expensive special effects. Give us a big budget film that follows the book, see if it flops, and then you can talk.You have no data whatsoever that supports your claim that ANY changes that make the movie closer to the book would have made the movie a bigger success. The opposite is true. Movies that were closer to the book have done worse.
Foe-Hammer said:B: When I do point them out, the NPW's start telling me what (in their imagination and not what was actually written)......they have their own version of jrrs work themselves.
Foe-Hammer said:This is not the book review thread.
Rhiannon said:Well, the Bashki drew Peter Jackson, so what does that tell us? Bashki failed because he made a freakishly awful film, and this purist, at least, hates and despises it a good deal more than Peter Jackson's films--though it is good for a laugh. If you're claiming the Bashki film was closer to the book, in the 1/2 of the book it covered, you might want to turn away while I laugh in your face. I just got up and haven't brushed my teeth yet.
Geez, people, there you go again. I was being humorous. You are being insulting. And you misspelled 'assinine'. You obviously have not been reading everything I have said, and are merely latching on to a flippant remark I threw out for no reason other than that I found it amusing as an excuse to insult my intelligence. Am I being clear enough about the fact that I am insulted? I don't want to be too subtle. I know how you hate anything veiled.
And again with the hypocritical statements. Pretty soon I'm going to be talking like my mother and bring up kitchen utensils of a particular color. Where's the support for your claim? We haven't seen a reasonably well done film that was close to the book. We have two poorly done animated films, neither complete, one of them scary in its bad-ness, and a big-budget film packed with freakishly expensive special effects. Give us a big budget film that follows the book, see if it flops, and then you can talk.
Eriol said:Ah, but your comment was about the BOOK, not the movie. "JRRT's characters are constantly exhibiting contradictory behaviors", or something like that.
I myself like the movie a lot (though I prefer FoTR). But I take issue with your comment about the book. And you claim to be knowledgeable about the book. If you were a mindless Orlando Bloom fan I'd shrug you off. But you (by your own admission) are not. So you should be able to come up with one (just one) example instead of evading the question for a series of posts.
Or perhaps retract your statement about the constant contradictions in the BOOK. If you won't do either, you'll lose the last supporter of your credibility in this thread.
Fechin, as I hope this post made clear, I have no beef with the movie. Do you agree with Foe-Hammer that Tolkien's characters are worse and more contradictory than PJ's? Then I have a beef with you, and I'd like examples from you too.
Simple as that.
Eriol said:Fechin, as I hope this post made clear, I have no beef with the movie. Do you agree with Foe-Hammer that Tolkien's characters are worse and more contradictory than PJ's? Then I have a beef with you, and I'd like examples from you too. Simple as that.
Fechin said:I may not have the same opinion as Foe Hammer but I do know you should......
Fechin said:I do agree with Foe Hammer that it is not a book review thread mainly because its not that is another part of the forum.
Gandalf White said:But FH needs to use some examples from the book to back up his argument. If he refuses to do so, he should never have started on that line of reasoning.
I have not tracks to cover. I said, very clearly, several times, that I enjoyed the films. To a point. They had good qualities. Lots of people are perfectly justified in liking Peter Jackson's films. But I think I am justified in saying that a large part of their success is due to the fact that there was a lot of marketing and hype and scary Orlando Bloom addictions; we have perhaps not been fooled, but we have been influenced. And not to say that there's anything wrong with marketing, even if I am sick to death of seeing Orlando Bloom's face pasted everywhere. You're the one harping on a flippant remark made in all good humor; perhaps you should tend to your own joints instead of mine.Foe-Hammer said:Why don't you quit trying to cover your tracks and admit that this is what you truely believe:
"So, your contention is that the only reason these movies are a success is that we have been fooled by marketing and hype, New Line threw a ton of money at it and everyone had a crush on OB?"
I think you should stop and think before you answer that because up to this point you have been in "knee-jerk reaction" mode.
It's not a matter of "admitting" that he did, if not necessarily a "mighty fine", but certainly a pretty good, job in the adaptation;Foe-Hammer said:Because the movie is such a record breaking success, we must admit that pj and company did a mighty fine job in adapting this to the screen.
No one, with any real credibilty, can claim that any script or scene change would have made this movie a bigger success.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?