• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

My God, It Was Horrible (Part III)

simbelmyne said:
The inconsistencies in PJ's characters OR Tolkien's characters?
That reference was to supposed inconsistencies in the way that Tolkien's characters are affected by the One Ring. It completely misses the point that T makes it clear that the Ring affects different people in different ways, according to the nature of the people and of their intentions towards it, and on other factors such as the length of time the Ring is in a person's custody.
I've seen one other Tolkien "inconsistency" offered here, about a sword that is present in the main book, but not in an appendix. I'm not sure if it's correct, but if it is then I compare it to PJ's barrels that are present in one shot, but not in the next!
 
simbelmyne said:
I've read this thread a few pages back...I'm not sure exactly what is being discussed. FH, what are you saying here? The inconsistancies in PJ's characters OR Tolkien's characters? What does it matter if the inconsistancies in PJ's characters are centered on what hapens to them when they encounter the ring? The point is the behavior of the characters is wildly inconsistant, both with how they act in other parts of the movies and with the book characters. Please provide an example for clarification ;)

I am making the point that PJ's are more consistant than JRR's and the NPW's should give PJ the same leeway as they do JRR. For some reason they keep hounding on the fact that the characters are different than JRR's and that makes them (PJ's) inconsistant compared to JRR's. I do not think it is fair to discuss the books inconsistancies in depth because this is the movie review thread.

As long as we can discuss the movie characters (supposed) inconsistancies in the context of the movie, we can move foward. If we are going to continue to harp on the fact they are different from the book the thread will go nowhere because everyone knows they are (and were always going to be) different.

The problem the book has it that it has no source material other than what JRR wrote and since he has passed on we have no way to confirm those issues that are not specifically written about. This is why the npw's cannot agree on many areas. They imagine details that are not written about and THINK that their reactions are exactly the ones JRR wanted them to have.

PJ has the luxury of having the source material and anything that was missed by JRR, that wouldn't work on film, PJ has the obligation to fabricate and still stay as close to the source material and still make it work on film. There is very little ambiguity in the films and a lot of times we can refer back to tolkiens writings to justify those that are not totally clear. Now I am not referring to the cameos etc but other characters consistancy.
 
Foe-Hammer said:
....fact that the characters are different than JRR's and that makes them (PJ's) inconsistant compared to JRR's. I do not think it is fair to discuss the books inconsistancies in depth.
There are only two sets of inconsistencies: those within the films and those within the books. The differences between the books and the films are not a matter of consistency.
You raised the subject of the set of inconsistencies within the books; I say those are minimal or non-existent, and I and others have asked for examples if you continue to refer to them. They are irrelevant in any case to the inconsistencies of the films, so, for this different reason, I would prefer, as you do, not to discuss them here - it's up to you whether or not you continue to refer to them.
 
while we're on the subject. . .

joxy said:
You raised the subject of the set of inconsistencies within the books; I say those are minimal or non-existent, and I and others have asked for examples if you continue to refer to them. They are irrelevant in any case to the inconsistencies of the films, so, for this different reason, I would prefer, as you do, not to discuss them here - it's up to you whether or not you continue to refer to them.

And if you should choose to continue harping on this matter of inconsistencies, Foe-Hammer ol' foe, you might also consider working on spelling them correctly; it may help to enhance your "credibilty". Give JRR a last name('s initial), while you're at it! :D
 
Aldanil said:
And if you should choose to continue harping on this matter of inconsistencies, Foe-Hammer ol' foe, you might also consider working on spelling them correctly; it may help to enhance your "credibilty". Give JRR a last name('s initial), while you're at it! :D

Spellin, far as relatin to topic discussion, is a pretty weak response, specially when we's all knows whats wuz meant. I have always found that argument the last desperate attempt to have ones say when everything else they have said has been rendered moot.

But you go ahead and continue to harp on spellin'. maybe that will help with your credibility, but I doubt it. :D
 
joxy said:
There are only two sets of inconsistencies: those within the films and those within the books. The differences between the books and the films are not a matter of consistency.

Whew! That is a good place to start.

joxy said:
You raised the subject of the set of inconsistencies within the books; I say those are minimal or non-existent, and I and others have asked for examples if you continue to refer to them.

This is not the place to discuss them in depth.

joxy said:
They are irrelevant in any case to the inconsistencies of the films, so, for this different reason, I would prefer, as you do, not to discuss them here - it's up to you whether or not you continue to refer to them.

Like I already stated, my references to the book inconsistancies centered mostly towards people whose argument were comparing the book against the movie. Since you have agreed not to do that we should be able to move forward.

Ultimately, the book will have to be refered to when your percieved inconsistancies in the movie characters are really a result of PJ attempting to stay closer to the book. I have already stated this and I am weary of repeating it. So, if you cannot understand the concept, please say so and I'll move on with those that can.

If you would like to give specific instances in the movie where the characters were inconsistant for no reason, then by all means go for it.
 
Foe-Hammer said:
If you would like to give specific instances in the movie where the characters were inconsistant for no reason, then by all means go for it.

Hey, do I really get to go for it? :p Allrighty, here's a start...

1. Theoden - these are so obvious that I'm reluctant to go into detail (once again). He's strong and brave in one scene, then weak and scared in the next...and not because of things happening in the plot. Just senselessly random...."Who am I?" indeed!

2. Aragorn - He pleads his troth to Liv (gross) in FOTR, but changes his mind in TTT flashback...why would he go to sleep in Rivendell sworn faithful (for many many years) and wake up the next morning rejecting her when he's FINALLY made the decision take control (as shown by then bossing Theoden around) and she's told him she'd rather die than live without him? and then he changes his mind again in the infamous fake death sequence for no apparant reason...

3. Gandalf - the strongest, wisest character in FOTR, teaching Frodo, etc. about showing your enemies pity and not dealing out death and judgment. Yet in ROTK he beats up Denethor and then PUSHES him onto the funeral pyre. And Gandalf, book or movie, does not need to ask Aragorn how Frodo and Sam are or need to have it explained WHY marching to the Black Gates is a good diversion tactic. Ridiculous!!

4. Frodo - yes, there is some tension between F and S concerning Gollum, that builds as the movies progress. To go from Frodo getting mad at Sam for picking on Gollum to Frodo believing and trusting Gollum and calling Sam a liar over food is completely inconsistant with what was established for all three characters in FOTR. Ring or no ring, Frodo knows Gollum is a liar, theif and murderer. The steadfast Sam has sacrificed his life to follow his master, and gives Frodo most of the food for the entire journey...too big of a leap for logic.
 
Foe-Hammer said:
....the book will have to be referred to when your perceived inconsistencies in the movie characters are really a result of PJ attempting to stay closer to the book. I have already stated this and I am weary of repeating it. So, if you cannot understand the concept, please say so and I'll move on with those that can.

All errors in spelling and grammer are entirely by design in order to enrage those who have nothing left to add to the discussion and therefore seek superiority through personal attacks.
Actually I don't recall that many - any, in fact, at the moment - times when you claimed that film inconsistencies were due to PJ trying to be closer to the book. It's something I've considered, certainly, and that I DO indeed understand - thank you! - but it's
a relatively new concept here.
So, example number one: :confused:

I have restrained myself from direct references to anyone's spelling aberrations, but if I HAD made comments on them then those comments would NOT have been "personal attacks", they would have been gentle hints to the people who organise these forums, that a built-in spell-checker would make reading some postings a more enjoyable experience than it currently is. :cool:
 
simbelmyne said:
Hey, do I really get to go for it? :p Allrighty, here's a start...

1. Theoden - these are so obvious that I'm reluctant to go into detail (once again). He's strong and brave in one scene, then weak and scared in the next...and not because of things happening in the plot. Just senselessly random...."Who am I?" indeed!

well, atleast he knows Eowyns face :D

2. Aragorn - He pleads his troth to Liv (gross) in FOTR, but changes his mind in TTT flashback...why would he go to sleep in Rivendell sworn faithful (for many many years) and wake up the next morning rejecting her when he's FINALLY made the decision take control (as shown by then bossing Theoden around) and she's told him she'd rather die than live without him? and then he changes his mind again in the infamous fake death sequence for no apparant reason...

This works fine, Aragorn wants what is best for Arwen, even if this means to send her across the sea. But then on the other hand he wished to be with her until the end of his days. He can't decide which is the right thing.

3. Gandalf - the strongest, wisest character in FOTR, teaching Frodo, etc. about showing your enemies pity and not dealing out death and judgment. Yet in ROTK he beats up Denethor and then PUSHES him onto the funeral pyre. And Gandalf, book or movie, does not need to ask Aragorn how Frodo and Sam are or need to have it explained WHY marching to the Black Gates is a good diversion tactic. Ridiculous!!

well, he didn't exactly have a choice or time to make another decision regarding denethor, he was doomed anyway.
And I never saw Gandalf asking Aragorn to explain anything to him, he only questioned the rationality of charging the black gate head on.
 
simbelmyne said:
Hey, do I really get to go for it? :p Allrighty, here's a start...

1. Theoden - these are so obvious that I'm reluctant to go into detail (once again). He's strong and brave in one scene, then weak and scared in the next...and not because of things happening in the plot. Just senselessly random...."Who am I?" indeed!

The scenes with Theoden didn't stand out for me that way but I will view it again and get back to that one.

simbelmyne said:
4. Frodo - yes, there is some tension between F and S concerning Gollum, that builds as the movies progress. To go from Frodo getting mad at Sam for picking on Gollum to Frodo believing and trusting Gollum and calling Sam a liar over food is completely inconsistant with what was established for all three characters in FOTR. Ring or no ring, Frodo knows Gollum is a liar, theif and murderer. The steadfast Sam has sacrificed his life to follow his master, and gives Frodo most of the food for the entire journey...too big of a leap for logic.

The issue wasn't the food. The issue was the fact that Sam asked for the ring. Boromir wanted the ring. aragorn was tempted. gandalf was tempted by the ring. galadrial was tempted also. bilbo was still struggling with it. Faramir desired it. frodo sent sam away to protect sam, not to honor gollums words. It is entirely plausible and realistic for someone who has been so burdened by the stress of the ring, the journey, lack of food and rest, and the fact that he needs gollum to get into mordor, to act the way he did. This is entirely consistant within the movie and each character who owns the ring has lapses in judgement.
 
Foe-Hammer said:
Spellin, far as relatin to topic discussion, is a pretty weak response, specially when we's all knows whats wuz meant. I have always found that argument the last desperate attempt to have ones say when everything else they have said has been rendered moot. But you go ahead and continue to harp on spellin'.

I'm not sure that a single brief mention really qualifies as "harping on" there, Foe-Hammer; I certainly wouldn't claim (nor ever have) that correct spelling is in itself any great evidence, one way or another, for the merit of an argument. I'm an English teacher by trade, so slovenly persistent inattention to detail sticks in my professional craw just a bit; it's a minor point. Your proudly deliberate and mature refusal to get the little things right, on the other hand, in an over-strained effort to provoke those whose opinions you sneer at, seems to be only too indicative of your general respect for simple accuracy and what passes for "logic" in these assertions you offer. Given your apparent disdain for ad hominem insults, you surely dispense them without much restraint.

For the well-intentioned and judicious joxy: I think the Forum's built-in filters have quite enough to do, preventing us from invoking Melville, etc., to burden them with the further responsibility of keeping our orthography inside the lines. After all, if every misspelled word got caught and cut out by them censors, some folks' posts would be even more full of holes than they already are!
 
Aldanil said:
I'm not sure that a single brief mention really qualifies as "harping on" there, Foe-Hammer; I certainly wouldn't claim (nor ever have) that correct spelling is in itself any great evidence, one way or another, for the merit of an argument. I'm an English teacher by trade, so slovenly persistent inattention to detail sticks in my professional craw just a bit; it's a minor point. Your proudly deliberate and mature refusal to get the little things right, on the other hand, in an over-strained effort to provoke those whose opinions you sneer at, seems to be only too indicative of your general respect for simple accuracy and what passes for "logic" in these assertions you offer. Given your apparent disdain for ad hominem insults, you surely dispense them without much restraint.

Most people that "get it" just 'gnore the okkasional spellin' misteak so as to focuss on the topik at hand. You can attempt to justify your nit picking but in the end that is all it really is. Since you seem bent on it, please start a new thread to complain about spelling and I is sure you will have the entire membership join you and these threads will just die off.
 
I said earlier no more than that improved spelling would make some postings more enjoyable to read.
As others have chosen to continue discussing the subject I have to add a further objection to inaccurate spelling.
It reminds me of those little points in the film, where the dialogue suddenly falls out of step, with such expressions as "let us hunt some orc" and "is this it?". To me those do two things: first, they hurl themselves at me and put me off for a moment from enjoying the film; and, second, they suggest to me that such carelessness may well be a reflection of a more general carelessness by the perpetrator. The same applies to spelling mistakes here: they are unimportant in themselves, but are, first, an irritating distraction, and second, an indicator of deeper carelessness that can only affect the level at which to take the entire posting seriously.
I think teachers will appreciate that there are more reasons for correcting spelling mistakes than the immediate and obvious one.
 
The same applies to spelling mistakes here: they are unimportant in themselves, but are, first, an irritating distraction, and second, an indicator of deeper carelessness that can only affect the level at which to take the entire posting seriously.

I completely disagree with this. Of course, this has nothing to do with being a TERRIBLE speller myself :p. I was going to say atrocious just now instead of terrible, but you see I have no idea if I spelled it correctly. Am I supposed to scurry off to the dictonary or whiz over to "dictonary.com" every time I post here? I thought this was supposed to be fun...I have to worry about my spelling with almost everything else I write. I have many skills (as we all do in DIFFERENT areas), but spelling ain't one of them. I bow down to spellcheck. It has nothing to with being careless.

Foe-Hammer said:
The issue wasn't the food. The issue was the fact that Sam asked for the ring... It is entirely plausible and realistic for someone who has been so burdened by the stress of the ring, the journey, lack of food and rest, and the fact that he needs gollum to get into mordor, to act the way he did.
What I'm referring to happens BEFORE S ever asks for the ring. PJ makes lembas an issue by devoting so much of the scene to it (sprinkling of crumbs, brushing of crumbs, etc.) with Frodo saying, "He's right. He doesn't eat it". He is choosing Gollum's word over Sam's about something that he should be able to figure out on a pretty basic level. After all, he keeps walking towards Mordor to destroy the ring, he hasn't lost his basic sense of right and wrong. THEN Sam asks for the ring, which is suppossed to be the "last straw". Better that PJ had left out the lembas all together.
 
simbelmyne said:
I completely disagree with this. Of course, this has nothing to do with being a TERRIBLE speller myself :p. I was going to say atrocious just now instead of terrible, but you see I have no idea if I spelled it correctly. Am I supposed to scurry off to the dictonary or whiz over to "dictonary.com" every time I post here? I thought this was supposed to be fun...I have to worry about my spelling with almost everything else I write. I have many skills (as we all do in DIFFERENT areas), but spelling ain't one of them. I bow down to spellcheck. It has nothing to with being careless.

I find the mentioning of someones bad spelling the last ditch attempt of the desperate to "get back" for their lack of debating skills.

simbelmyne said:
What I'm referring to happens BEFORE S ever asks for the ring. PJ makes lembas an issue by devoting so much of the scene to it (sprinkling of crumbs, brushing of crumbs, etc.) with Frodo saying, "He's right. He doesn't eat it". He is choosing Gollum's word over Sam's about something that he should be able to figure out on a pretty basic level. After all, he keeps walking towards Mordor to destroy the ring, he hasn't lost his basic sense of right and wrong. THEN Sam asks for the ring, which is suppossed to be the "last straw". Better that PJ had left out the lembas all together.

Again, this to me is an obvious effect of the ring. F & S are not hearing each other. Sam says gollum took it. Frodo says gollum doesn't eat it. And he isn't taking gollums words over sams, he is addresing sams continual harassment of gollum. Something frodo has been against through the entire movie. Then, sam asks for the ring. That is the straw that breaks the camels back. Frodo orders sam to go home. He still needs gollum and he surely does not need sam if sam is starting to be tempted by the ring.
 
Please remember the rule about no personal attacks on TTF. Thanks. :rolleyes:
 
simbelmyne said:
I have many skills (as we all do in DIFFERENT areas), but spelling ain't one of them.
I have to say that I have NEVER seen a spelling mistake in one of YOUR postings. :cool:
Of course, I was generalising, but I think it's safe to say that SOME people do betray their carelessness of thought by their carelessness in spelling. I named no names when I offered the theory; I name none now.
 
joxy said:
I have to say that I have NEVER seen a spelling mistake in one of YOUR postings. :cool:
Of course, I was generalising, but I think it's safe to say that SOME people do betray their carelessness of thought by their carelessness in spelling. I named no names when I offered the theory; I name none now.
Ah! Well! Spelling! When I was young, my mother used to say that I was more "creative" with my spelling than accurate! That is why I try so hard to be accurate. I am especially careful because many so-called spelling errors are really "typos" which occur when one is hurried (and there is no "spell-check" on site, alas!).

Nonetheless, since the time I once sent a very important legal document in an envelope addressed to Pi$$burgh, Pennslyvania, I have tried never to comment upon another's spelling mistakes given my own weaknesses! :p :eek: :rolleyes:
 
joxy said:
Of course, I was generalising, but I think it's safe to say that SOME people do betray their carelessness of thought by their carelessness in spelling. I named no names when I offered the theory; I name none now.

That is an interesting theory. How do you arrive at the conclusion that correct spelling is required before clear thinking can be achieved?
 
Foe-Hammer said:
That is an interesting theory. How do you arrive at the conclusion that correct spelling is required before clear thinking can be achieved?
The theory was that SOME people spell carelessly because they think carelessly.
As I have not set out on a road that might lead to a conclusion that correct spelling is REQUIRED before clear thinking can be achieved, I cannot specify a route to such a destination.
 

Today's events

Back
Top