Gotta tell ya there,
Glamdring ol' pal, I really do think those looong rusty years of hanging neglected, on the wall of that filthy rank lair in the Trollshaws, waiting to be claimed by the passing
Mithrandir, have finally begun to undermine your reason:
A couple of old jokes come to mind at this point. One of them, using table manners for its premise, mimics my shock at your genuinely mind-boggling comment, but in an implicitly self-deprecating way, so as not to give offense: "The other day in a restaurant I saw a man eating peas off a
knife; I was so appalled I almost dropped my entire handful of mashed potatoes!" Another, the second word of which I won't even attempt to put (unaltered) past the Forum's omnipotent built-in censors, and which very likely
will cause less vulgar tongues to tut-tut disapprovingly, is a simple slogan: "Eat Shi[f]t! 20 Billion Flies Can't Be Wrong!"
But seriously, folks. . .
Whatever I and other relentlessly negative nit-picking weenies like
Thorin & Company (without whose timely help, remember, you'd still be hanging neglected, etc.) may think about his "credibilty" as a screenwriter, no less esteemed a person than PJ himself apparently disagrees with you. As late as last October, according to a special behind-the-scenes documentary on the Discovery Channel, Jackson was shooting take after take after take of new dialogue between
Aragorn and
Gandalf at Edoras. Rather feeble and sappy new dialogue at that, to my mind: "What does your heart tell you?" The wizard only smiles slowly in simpering answer. (Doting devotees of the original narrative may well ask themselves what Gandalf and Aragorn are even doing, at this point in the story of
The Return of the King, communing in
Theoden's hall in the first place; never mind about that.) As late as last November, by all reports,
Saruman had a brief but important part to play in the film-trilogy's final episode; not surprising, given that he was the major villain in its first two installments, certainly
the one who received the most screen-time. Whether his utter absence from the theatrical release of ROTK (unlike Sean Bean, Christopher Lee doesn't even appear in the credits) is in any measurable way responsible for the undeniably enormous commercial success of the movie is surely an unanswerable question. Whether the absence from the screenplay of such feckless lines as "No one tosses a
Dwarf!", "Just don't tell the
Elf!", etc., would have increased or diminished the films' popularity is probably another moot point. (I employ the phrase with some hesitation, considering the altogether wretched hash that was made of the Entmoot; never mind about that.) No dispute; many, many people laughed out loud at these moments of "comic relief" (the quotation marks are used here to express sarcastic displeasure, rather than delineate a literary/technical term), at least at each of the showings that I attended, but
I could only grimace and mutter unhappily, and I have every confidence that our dear John Ronald would have recoiled in horror, if not screamed, to hear them. Perhaps you will choose to interject here,
Foe-Hammer, that such a mirthful reaction from the vast movie-going public (see joke #2 above) is further proof of PJ's improving on
Tolkien; speaking just for myself, I remain unconvinced.
Speaking more broadly, I'd argue that the very existence of, to say nothing of the brisk sales-figures for, the EE DVDs of these films demonstrates that Jackson and very many others do indeed think "script and scene changes" can improve them, at least by way of additional material. You have only to read with cursory attention the postings of numerous folk here in the movie section of our beloved Forum to recognize how many have been reconciled to PJ's adaptation by all of the extras the EEs provide. I can only wish fondly that
my DVD player had the capacity to cut scenes
out, so's I could delete such dreck as
Frodo having to three-peat his offer and shout down the
Council of Elrond, or Aragorn coming back from the dead, or deep left field, or wherever he goes when he goes over that cliff.
Finally, Foe-Hammer, if by such "success" you mean even more millions of tickets sold or even more money in the bank-accounts of New Line Cinema, it's pointless to quibble with Big Box-Office Boffo. If, on the other hand, that phrase is understood to mean not only an enormous world-wide audience of very satisfied fans but also an example of the film-maker's art
fully worthy of that master-work of literature whose depth of imagination and richness of detail are ultimately and indisputably the primary reason for the movie's "success", then I (for one) think that PJ could indeed have done better. It's a very high standard I'm invoking, I know, but a part of my heart has dwelt in
Middle-earth since I was fourteen (just nine decades ago!), and no one likes to see his first true love ill-used. Hearing
the horn of Boromir echo in the valley of
Rivendell, instead of watching
Lurtz rise out of Isengard-slime; seeing
Legolas the bright-eyed Elf shoot a
Nazgul out of the night sky with the
bow of
Galadriel, instead of
Pippin the well-renowned mountaineer clamber straight up a cliff to sneak-light the beacon of
Gondor; having the Heir of
Isildur secure in his lineage, instead of an Aragorn who distrusts his own blood and bids
Undomiel embark for the West without him; could substituting
any of these original elements from Tolkien's story for the second-rate inventions of Jackson's screenplay possibly have failed to improve it?
It's a rhetorical question, at least by intention, but those who are not already persuaded aren't likely to be so by this long-winded diatribe (as I've said elsewhere before, at the thread-start of another lengthy screed about "Grinding Prime Rib into Hamburger Meat"); still, there's fun to be had in voluminous venting. Lest anyone take joke #2 above too much to heart, let me hasten to include myself among the buzzing bluebottles: I've seen these three movies twice each in theaters, own both of the EE DVDs currently available, and no doubt next autumn will acquire the third (though I haven't yet been able to bring myself - or "find the free time", as we schoolteachers say - to actually sit down and watch
The Two Towers). Watching Peter Jackson's latest interview with Charlie Rose on PBS may have me grumbling, "Didja hear that? I
knew it!", but I've got it on tape. After all, if I didn't enjoy the Kiwi Kaiser's Telep Esgal Ungwe in some considerable measure, how could I take such obvious pleasure in slashing with
Sting at his silver-screen spider-web? (I
was thinking of using that famous
sword which once belonged to the King of
Gondolin for my gleeful blade-labor, but I've been lately informed that somebody else has it. . .) With what other motive? Just to hear myself type?
Now if we've got that straight, as someone tone-deaf once put it, LET'S HUNT SOME
ORC!