• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

My God, It Was Horrible (Part III)


I referred specifically to technical reasons for "the complete change in the appearance of Bree" and "the emphasis on the humorous sides of ....Gimli, to the exclusion of all other aspects of their characters". We have indeed exchanged ideas on these topics, but I now reject "out of hand" the claim that I rejected your ideas on them "out of hand". Those ideas did not cover this specific point of the technical reasons, the explanations which I, as an uneducated layman, am not fitted to understand. I would be interested to hear about those - as I said before, let me at least try to understand them, when I know what they are -, as well as to have references to your postings on those "several other matters".
As you've lost interest in our exchanges, maybe some other person with a knowledge of the fine art, or craft, of cinematography will offer technical explanations for the two changes above, and for the other two I raised: "giving dialogue from one book character to a different film one" and "sometimes leaving Tolkien's words intact and at other times changing them to or replacing them with words in a modern anachronistic idiom?". What cinematographic requirements are there, that forced those changes?

You know nothing about my "skills" - and I know nothing about yours.

And it obviously didn't work, for others, because they didn't like it.
And again, and much more reasonably, the whole of the films worked PARTLY for some people because they liked them PARTLY. That's a more reasonable attitude because it rejects the notion that the films were either close to wholly perfect, or close to wholly bad.

I have never attacked the calibre of anyone, or any other aspect or part of anyone, in my whole life.
 
Last edited:
jallan said:
And an argument that the majority of people who like the film like the film demonstrates nothing.

Again, I stopped reading here, because you have completely missed the point.

Movies are made to make money. They make money by being popular. They are popular because they appeal to a broad portion of the population. The more popular the movie the better it is.

For you to arrogantly insist that YOUR personal changes would make the movie a better one for the majority of the population, when your tastes are in the minority, makes no sense and is the only basis I need to dismiss your assertions out of hand.

Of course, you next claim will be that the majority is somehow flawed and that explains why you and those of your opinion (who are more "enlightened") are qualified to criticize the art of film making. (another fallacious claim since you know nothing about it...and worse yet, refuse to be educated)
 
Thorin said:
Not great screenwriting abilities IMO.
While I agree with those who find the adaptation, characterisation, and other aspects of the films, less than satisfactory, I have to say that, because I have a special interest in languages and particularly in Tolkien's use of languages, the aspect which I find much the least satisfactory is the dialogue.
Like Thorin I have heard on the DVDs the writers' comments, that quite openly contradict their claims to respect their source material, and their true feelings are made quite obvious by the sound of their product.
 

Two points....I have explained the reasons why bree was changed...."Technically", to me, means within the limits of technology and in that sense bree could have been shot many different ways. It was shot the way it was because it was more realistic to the story.

2nd.....if you have ever made the comment that this film was popular because society likes gratuitous sex and violence or the like, then you have insulted every person that sees nothing wrong with this movie. But because you love responding to posts that were never directed to you, I can't say if you have ever said that. You are possible just responding, AGAIN, to something that was said to someone else.

When you do that, I assume that you accept it as a discription that aplies to you also. If that is the case, who am I to argue?
 
I have a solution for you npw's that think your changes to these movies would make them better for the majority of the population. Enter this contest and if you can make it as a finalist, I'll admit I was wrong.

http://filmtv.tisch.nyu.edu/object/CocaCola.html

If you cannot do that, then you must admit that you know nothing of filmmaking and defer to the professionals.

(Pardon me whilst I chuckle to myself at the possibilty of that happening...HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!)
 
Joxy,

"Of course you will then attack the caliber of person who liked it. (again, with no hard provable data to back it up)"

If you never did that, I apologize. Please realize that if you are going to continue to speak for others, you will occasionally get lumped in with them.
 
Foe-Hammer said:
If you never did that, I apologize. Please realize that if you are going to continue to speak for others, you will occasionally get lumped in with them.
Thanks, and it's OK; "we" all make mistakes.
I gather I made a mistake of omission: I've forgotten - what was it I said I would check the DVD for?
And to clarify this "we" business as some say here in the UK, I don't try to "clarify" what Mrs M means; I simply say what I think she means, just as you say what you think she means. It is then up to Mrs M, if she so wishes - as I usually add -to add her own clarification.

My questions, about the changes to Bree, M&P, Gimli, and the dialogue, arose because you said, correctly, that I "do not have the technical knowledge", and, incorrectly, that I do not have "the desire to be educated about said knowledge", in order to "give your argument some credibility." I assumed from that, that you do have such knowledge and education, and I therefore invited you to offer some insight, some education, into the technical reasons for the changes.
 

I looked and I do not see where I used the word "Technical". If you could please state the post number I'll go back and check the context that I meant it in.

As I have said, the reasons why bree were shot very dark were to increase the tension in the scene. Strider NEEDS to feel like a threat and so does bree (especially the inn). There is not enough time to shoot bree the way jrr wrote it. It's mostly about time and perception. The part of the brain that is active during reading involves different areas and usage than when you watch a movie. Use your own experiences to teach yourself this fact. How much of your active imagination do you use during a movie? How much while reading a book? It is a very simple concept that anyone can understand that reads and watches movies IF they take the time to pay attention to the details of their imaginitive processes. Words represent ideas that our brain has to convert. Groups of words make more complex ideas. That is why jrr needed two pages to discribe a scene or a character. A movie can use 10 seconds of film to present the same visuale concept that it takes words to do in 5 pages.

I suggest that you take a class, because if you can't figure it out by now, then perhapes my methods are inadequate for you. Although I do understand the way it works, I am not a professional teacher.
 
Mrs M, I can say that I totally agree with what you just said. It is perhaps sad that the new morality of the majority is less constrained and I blame that on the 60's and 70's. But without the upheaval of those years, many, many improvements that came from it would not have happened either. <quote Foe Hammer>

Thank you, F.H. for your kind words. They are deeply appreciated. Yes, it is sad that our culture has become "coarsened" - and that is a good word for what has happened to us for although many good things have come about since the 1950s, we have also lost many of the things that put the "civil" in "civilization". I do believe that Mr. Jackson might have been willing to put more effort into the quieter aspects of the story had we not been a culture of people with a two minute attention span!

As for the "popularity" of the films with the public: I think we are talking about apples and oranges here. The critical and public popularity of the films has to do with their excellence as films (albeit with their weaknesses as well) and nothing whatever to do with how good - or bad - they are as adaptations of the book. About the only thing that is influenced by the latter is how well (or badly) fans of the book respond to the films. Ergo, those who have never read the book or only read it once long ago like my son-in-law and my husband are unaffected by any comparison of the films to the book while those who read it often and love it may be very much affected (myself, for instance). On the other hand, as we know from this forum, there are "book lovers" who have simply decided to "forget" the book and enjoy the films for their own sake.

But whatever the case, the overall popularity - critical or otherwise - cannot influence how a "book lover" views these films. It is a "non-issue" for us because our response to the film is entirely personal. As I have said before, it is a matter of taste and subjective opinion - and, yes, F. H., that means my opinion as well!
 
#425, not directly about the film industry, but in an analogy with space travel, and to Jallan, not to me, though it was equally relevant to me. I used the word "I" when I quoted from it in my last posting, so my apologies for that mistake - I DID say we all make mistakes.
And now we need to know the technical, or whatever, reason why the scene needed to have its tension increased! Strider always DID feel like a threat at their first meeting with him, in CONTRAST to the welcoming atmosphere of the Inn. Why do Bree and the Inn NEED to be additional threats? I think the contrasting sequence of the "escape" to Bree, followed by the relatively normal village and the friendly bright inn, and then Aragorn's apparently looming presence, sets up a very adequate tension. How does shooting TIME come into the way Bree LOOKS?
 

Whew! Thats a relief. I thought I might have been sleep posting. LOL.


The scene established the tension as a setup for strider to feel threatening. One of the subconsious things our eyes and mind pickup. Had there not been a buildup, all we get is strider sitting in the corner smoking a pipe. It works better than him saying a lot of stuff to make the hobbits suspecious like he did in the book. Shooting bree two different ways takes the same amout of time and then we have to add scenes and dialogue to make him a threat. This was an effective time efficient way to establish that AND people expect to find unsavory characters in a dark inn on a rainy night.

joxy said:
Strider always DID feel like a threat at their first meeting with him, in CONTRAST to the welcoming atmosphere of the Inn.

In the book or the film?
 

If I felt as you I might have those exact sentiments. But I do not. I have the hope that the people who liked this film are decent people with family's and jobs and a firm belief in being good. I do not think that these movies generate any negative feelings that a person would act out in society.

People have died over shows like springer and that is why I feel they are an unfair comparison.

The worse thing I see as a result of these movies are an increase of tripping by those who don't know how to walk while wearing their Gandalf robes.
 
Temporary derailment

OK, this part about my 'assumptions' is rather insulting. I did not 'assume' anything. I went back to the DVD where this was discussed, and listened to it. Not only that, I mentioned where such knowledge could be found (on the TT EE, part three of the appendices, 'books to film' section), so that any who doubted my honesty could go see for themselves. Apparently this was not specific enough, so here goes another effort:
The idea was pitched to New Line in spring 1998, and the project was announced in August of that year. Principal photography began in October 1999 and continued through December 2000. Unless all these people were lying, then the decision to cut Arwen from Helm's Deep occcurred sometime between October 1999 and December 2000- in the second half of this shoot according to Liv. This is Looooong before the FotR release date of Dec. 2001. So either everyone on the film is lying, or else the decision was made without basing it on audience reaction to the Fords scene in FotR.
 
with a fond nod to yon Parrot

Foe-Hammer said:
I suggest that you take a class, because if you can't figure it out by now, then perhapes my methods are inadequate for you. Although I do understand the way it works, I am not a professional teacher.

If I may borrow the phrase from my other old friend from Montana,

You're kidding, right?

You aren't? Seriously?


Actually, as jallan has recently and quite eloquently demonstrated (although, thus far, without apparent effect) it's your reasoning that's inadequate, not your pedagogical method, and there's really no "perhapes" about it.
 
Last edited:

Why don't you explain to the class why your version of the book would be better than PJ's version?

I'll answer it for you. Because you don't have a clue. All you have is rhetoric while I have a blockbuster movie with millions of satisfied viewers and awards out the ying-yang.
 
a distinction without a difference AND an ancient wrath reawakened


Having just chided Foe-Hammer for his recurring illogic, it perhaps ill-becomes me to assail My Main Man from Montana with a quibble better suited to a Nit-Picking Attorney. Nevertheless, as I suggested to Parrot in a somewhat similar case a few pages back, I believe that the evidence you offer, aragil, in fact helps to buttress the point you oppose. Your timeline effectively establishes when the alteration in Arwen's character, and the concomitant "cut" not to bring her blade to Helm's Deep, was decided on; the commentary from the EE (which I also own, but haven't yet been able to "find time" to watch) that you cite to support said timeline, however, seems to strongly suggest that one of the principal reasons, attested to by BO, Liv, and PJ, for said alteration and "cut" was the virulence of "fan reaction" on the Internet. It was indeed, as you say, not the movie-audience's unhappiness in theaters ('cause by then it was much too late, alas!) with her Q-tip sword-point and the reimagined Flight to the Ford which prompted the mid-course correction and Revision of Evenstar, but I do think that the (quite properly) fan-fearing principle of "um ... there were a lot of objections" clearly had "a lot" to do with it.




I know the following extended outburst is, strictly speaking, out of place on this thread for Part III, but My God! It Was Horrible! I got up from my iMac for a minute, feeling more than a little conflicted about having just heaped yet another few polysyllabic teaspoons of scorn on a fellow Forumite whose arrogant sneering is what really annoys me, turned on the TV in the den, and found LOTR:FOTR playing on Encore. Frodo's life-saving mithril had just been uncovered, and so I watched for a little, as the Fellowship flees from the Chamber of Mazarbul. Some very striking visual effects, undoubtedly, but man! What an overwrought mess! Orc-insects everywhere, popping suddenly up out of cracks in the floor and swarming down pillars from the cathedral-high ceiling like so many nests full of locusts and spiders, surrounding the outnumbered Company five thousand to nine; things sure look bad for our heroes! But what's this? A red-orange glow in the distance? Whatever it is spooks the goblin-cicadas to silence, and they conveniently scatter and vanish. The bright golden-red light at the far other end of the enormous long chamber grows stronger, and taller. "A Balrog, a demon of the ancient world!" says the wizard. "RUN!"

Tell me, are we excited yet? Is the scene sufficiently thrilling? Apparently not, because now it's time for The Terrifying Stairway of Khazad-dum! After all, if we don't have our fear and suspense at this point torqued waaay up extra here for us, how can we possibly appreciate the most devastating shock in the story? Not to mention being cheated out of One Hi-Larious Line!

The Dog's Breakfast in Moria, although I didn't use that title, was the subject of my first long screed on this Forum, a discontentedly detailed diatribe which has subsequently been disappeared from the Archives, deleted along with quite a few other of my earliest posts. (As Yossarian says, "Where are the Snowdens of yesteryear?") I really don't have the heart, or the hours (this being a school-night) to lay out my horror again, but I did notice this time, along with all the rest of the sheer physical implausibility, utterly unnecessary emotional excess, and wretchedly tone-deaf joking which so irked me on three earlier viewings, that the very first flight of broken steps, over whose abrupt and vertiginous brink Boromir drops his torch into the abyss, would have led directly (had it not been already destroyed) to that same landing below which the Fellowship then hurries down to by a switch-back and indirect route.

Don't bother wasting your brain to consider the consistent dynamics of masonry-columns, or the absence of hand-rails, or the sudden profusion of bottomless chasms, or even the hopelessly book-prompted question of why the master-stonecarvers of Durin's Folk, who hewed the splendors of the Dwarrowdelf from the living rock of the Misty Mountains, would have built such ridiculously flimsy stairways out of brickwork; put all that aside for the moment. These are abstract and thoughtful notions. As the expert Foe-Hammer has so persuasively explained, your mind doesn't work the same way when your eyes are engaged by a movie, and the fast-paced nature of film doesn't allow for much thinking. Just pause the DVD for a minute, and take a look at where those first broken stairs would be going. That minor detail says it all, in a nutshell, about overkill for cheap thrills' sake.


(And what would you know, Iaradanduin, about saying anything "in a nutshell"?)
 
Sorry Aldanil. Your post to Parrot was several pages deep by the time I came around, and I had only planned to make my two previous comments about scriptwriting credits and the 'lie' between Sam and Faramir. However, before I was overwhelmed, I had meant to point something out about your argument (about Parrot's argument about Mrs. Maggott's argument): the only reason we know about Trotter and Bingo is because of the immense popularity of the books. The only reason we know about Arwen at Helm's Deep is the immense popularity of the films. Both are viewed under the microscope, so we are 'allowed' to see the thought process behind the creation of both, and thusly know the errors that came about before the 'true' path was discovered. Personally I wish I didn't know that Strider was originally a Hobbit, as I find that it distracts somewhat from me as I re-read the books. And I most certainly wish I didn't know about the filming of Arwen at Helm's Deep, because it (much like my reading of Strider) opens my eyes to an apparent dichotomy which I wouldn't even notice if I knew less. That changes are going to occur during the creation of such an epic tale, in cinema or book form, is inevitible. For me it doesn't matter whether these come about as a result of fan feedback (certainly JRRT took CS Lewis's and CT's suggestions to heart when writing the story) or from simple brainstorming among the creative elements (PJ/FW/PB in the movie, JRRT by his lonesome for the book).

ps. 'taint easy to transcribe speech to paper, at least not for me, and especially not when the dialog is as rambling as it was in those interviews. Nevertheless, I was quite pleased with "... and, um ... there were a lot of objections to that thought." That was one where I think I was able to convey the sentiment with the correct punctuation, and it still makes me laugh to see the temerity and eventual understated honesty in that statement.
 

ROFLMAO! After reading that, I have to ask....are you trying to be an effective communicator or are you just engaging in an exercise of self-puffery? What a silly, rambling, exercise in pretentiousness that post appeared to be motivated by!

Just so the forum gets what you were trying to say, I'll try to parse it into what it appears that you are saying.

First, you know your next complaint is in the wrong thread, but you are going to go off on it anyway. Foe-hammer has got you so aanoyed that you went off on him and now you're aren't sure it was the right thing to do. Although the scene in the FoTR at the stairs in moria was quite striking, you were bothered by a few things.


A: The orcs act like insects
B: The Orcs acted like locust
C: The orcs acted like spiders
D: The Orcs acted like cicadas

It seems you are bothered by the orcs scattering because of the Balrog.

You think the stairway and the dwarf tossing line is needless hype.

Next paragraph....you had an old post that you can't find now that detailed your disgust at the sight of stairs without handrails, brickwork over chasms, and perfect columns holding up the roof. You know that those are not consistant with jrr's dwarves and that PJ added they with no real thought for anything except cheap thrills.

I think that about puts it "in a nutshell".

My response?

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!

First, I would like a forum admin to move your post to the thread it really belongs in.

Insects is general term that describes the orcs behavior very well. (I would have used "ants" because that simple term discribes the orc behavior much more accurately.) But locusts fly around and eat everything in sight. I saw none of that. Spiders spin webs and wait for their prey to get stuck in them. I saw none of that until the RoTK. Shelob is the spider and you are obviously confused with that scene. Cicadas fly around and make noise. Yes the orcs made noise, but again, I saw no flying orcs.

The Balrog scattering the orcs. Jrr himself used a lot of convienent behavior by his bad guys to further the plot. Are you bothered by his use of those also? The most glaring one is invisible bad guys who wear clothing so everyone can see them. The invisible is much more scary than the visible. (see a movie called the invisible man or even hollowman..that is only meant to illustrate the fear shown by those who cannot see what is after them and how effective it is) If Nazgul were real and their first order of business was to get the ring, they would cast off their garb and throttle poor frodo and take the ring. How utterly convienent that they never did that.

Your wandering complaints about the stairs is next to impossible understand.You admit the the first set of stairs were originally broken. That is why the hewn stones were used. So what?
Ya know you act like the dwarves had x-ray vision and could see where all the chasms and fissures in the rock were and would build around them. Tain't so. As they burrowed, they built what the needed and if something broke, they rebuilt it using hewn stone. If you pay attaention you can see where the living rock stops and the hewn stone work begins. And they didn't get to decide which direction the viens of oar traveled. They had to mine it where it was and build around it.

Handrails....This is so obvious I almost laugh myself to incontenence. Have you ever seen a mountain goat walk the side of a cliff? Now, why wouldn't dwarves, who rarely go above ground, who are raised from infancy underground, need to spend the time building handrails? For orcs? Or the occasional human or hobbit? HAHAHAHAHAHA! Spare us all this silliness!

Speaking of orcs, they live underground too and would certainly been able to scale sheer walls like ants since they are in fact corrupted elves and elves were pretty fleet of foot too.
 
Hey Al, Nice to hear from you.

Great post, with many valid points, but none of them really related to my simple point; anyone who has ever engaged in any creative medium has had first impulses that later turned out to be wrong and ended up in the scrap-heap. Criticizing PJ for doing the same is a pretty hollow indictment of his ability as a film maker.
 
aragil said:
....or else the decision was made without basing it on audience reaction to the Fords scene in FotR.
I've seen, somewhere, Liv herself saying that she was surprised and upset by the adverse reaction to her first appearance in FOTR and to a lesser extent to the whole Flight to the Ford scene. I'm sorry I can't give the reference to it, as you so helpfully do to your quotation.
My point is that, if she knew of the adverse reaction to the HD idea, she should have been able to anticipate the similar reaction to FttF. Further, and more important, the writers should ALL have made the same anticipation: "If HD isn't going to work, surely FttF won't either".
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…