Hey there, Parrot! "I hear you, man!" It never has ceased to amaze me (on those random occasions it crosses my mind) that the original name of
Bilbo's nephew the Ringbearer, retained for a considerable stretch of time in the early manuscript-history of
The Lord of the Rings, was actually
Bingo Baggins!! What can ol' tone-deaf John Ronald have been possibly thinking? Or hearing, anyway; I thought he was supposed to have some rare sort of gift for inventing strange names and imagining
languages!
Upon further examination, however, I'd opine that the point which you offer (and I largely agree with) in fact serves to buttress the case you oppose. It's not, after all, for their "first inclinations" at flight that Orville and Wilbur are deservedly famous; they labored for years to make real their idea, and only when they finally got it Wright (for an impressive twelve seconds, not too far south of my house) did the world see fit to acclaim them. And it's not just pioneering aeronauts, either, as you take pains to observe: poets and painters and composers and cooks each follow their unfolding way through the thickets of artistic creation, trying something out, seeing if it holds together, deciding it doesn't, coming at it from another direction, perhaps chucking it in and starting over from scratch. The critical difference is that your famous painter (at least while he's alive) doesn't have his first pencil-sketches on display in a gallery; your better-known poets don't read their rough and unpolished drafts to attentive large audiences.
Tolkien did
not publish the first third of his story and only afterwards recognize that "Trotter" and "Bingo" just really weren't working, sounded quite stupid in fact, and then go back to revise them. He labored alone for an obsessive twelve years, and only when he finally had written it right (to his own satisfaction) did he send it to Allen & Unwin. The wide world's resounding acclaim, and the existence of our own beloved Forum, and the tremendous anticipation before the New Line release,
and the enormous commercial success of these movies;
all these are owed to that long, lonely effort.
Writing a book is, of course (calm down,
Foe-Hammer) a
very different kind of creative process from making a movie, even one far less complex and logistically demanding than The Amazing PJ's all-three-at-once epic. Hundreds of people contribute in dozens of ways to an extremely cost-intensive and schedule-conscious collaborative process; nineteen different kinds of details need to be kept straight simultaneously; there's simply no time in a mega-budget production to take more than a decade for someone to get it "just right". Nevertheless (to cut to the chase, as we say in the film biz) there aren't too many movies better than the scripts that they're shot from. Screenwriting is
always the most important element; the number of great movies that are badly written can be counted completely on the toes of a salmon.
If aragil's right (and isn't he near about always?) concerning just who did just what, I should probably have been heaping my hot coals of opprobrium on the heads of Philippa and feckless Fran all along, and given poor over-worked Peter a break. Whoever may be most responsible for the screenplay, however, the amply documented fact remains that the process of writing and rewriting and re-rewriting these movies was in a state of permanent flux throughout the fifteen months of the main production schedule, and even, apparently, for a year or two afterward. New lines of dialogue were being created, and others deleted, on a continual basis; new conceptions of characters came into being, and others discarded; scenes were altered substantially, often from one day to the next; new scenes were being added as late as last autumn. The master-script for this massive project was put together piecemeal and in most disjointed fashion.
Shooting a movie out of narrative sequence is extremely common; trying to
write one all out of its natural order, cobbling it together more or less on the fly, seems to nit-picking me like just asking for trouble.
Especially if the source-material being adapted is itself complex and tightly interwoven, although Jackson made clear in a recent PBS interview with Charlie Rose that the screenwriters really
"weren't interested in being faithful to the detail" of the original. "We, we made up a lot of scenes. If, if something wasn't in the book that we needed, that we felt we needed - like there's a key sequence in
The Return of the King where, um, where we wanted to just have a real moment of conflict between
Frodo and
Sam, that
Gollum creates, and so there's a moment that, that Frodo tells Sam to go home. He's, he's, Sam has been helping Frodo all of this way, and Frodo says, 'I don't need you anymore, Sam. I don't want you. Just go!' And, and that's not in the book, that scene. We, we felt we wanted to have that moment in the story, so we, y'know, if it wasn't there, we created it. We, we also, we also felt that we were making the films for people that read the
books ten years ago, not ten weeks ago."
So I suppose that
other scene on the Stairs of
Cirith Ungol, in which Gollum finds Frodo and Sam nestled together in sleep, and for a brief heart-breaking moment seems "an old weary
hobbit, shrunken by the years that had carried him far beyond his time, beyond friends and kin, and the
fields and streams of youth, an old starved pitiable thing" was simply beyond the cinematic powers of PJ. (Too much for him, or not enough?) Boffo blockbuster movies just
can't show such subtle emotion! Understatement obviously "does not work" on film! Sure, his dear uncle Bilbo can be suddenly transformed before the Ringbearer's eyes into a slavering wretch with pointed teeth, but render poor Gollum sympathetic without schizophrenia? Don't think so! Better he should be just a worm-squeezing creep from the start. Sure, Tolkien himself thought this "fleeting moment" the saddest in the entire story, but what does
he know about "being true to the spirit of Tolkien"?
Anyone who believes that the stupendous box-office success of these movies is primarily due to the genius of Jackson and the unimprovable professionalism of his film-making craftsmanship, rather than to the inherent and ultimately indestructible merits of his source-material, needs only to take a good look at
The Frighteners.