Mrs. Maggott
Home is where the cat is
- Joined
- Oct 2, 2002
- Messages
- 3,463
Personally I wish I didn't know that Strider was originally a Hobbit, as I find that it distracts somewhat from me as I re-read the books. <quote Aragil>
Actually, I wouldn't let it bother you. Tolkien originally wanted some sort of "wild hobbit", that is, one who had lived much as did Strider and who meets and assists the four hobbits once they get to Bree. However, it just didn't "work". I suppose he just couldn't reconcile his own description (and mental image) of hobbits with "Trotter" and so he had to "think again". This time, he decided upon a man who would help the four - and the matter went on from there. But "Strider" was never "Trotter" and vice versa.
Frankly, I think Tolkien was quite right to believe that even the "wildest" hobbit would not have been much of a help in the flight to Rivendell and his choice of a "mysterious stranger" was a much better plot ploy. After all, the hobbits would have been inclined to trust another hobbit - however wild - and the few moments we have in the story in which Frodo has to make up his mind whether or not to trust Strider adds to the suspense.
Actually, I wouldn't let it bother you. Tolkien originally wanted some sort of "wild hobbit", that is, one who had lived much as did Strider and who meets and assists the four hobbits once they get to Bree. However, it just didn't "work". I suppose he just couldn't reconcile his own description (and mental image) of hobbits with "Trotter" and so he had to "think again". This time, he decided upon a man who would help the four - and the matter went on from there. But "Strider" was never "Trotter" and vice versa.
Frankly, I think Tolkien was quite right to believe that even the "wildest" hobbit would not have been much of a help in the flight to Rivendell and his choice of a "mysterious stranger" was a much better plot ploy. After all, the hobbits would have been inclined to trust another hobbit - however wild - and the few moments we have in the story in which Frodo has to make up his mind whether or not to trust Strider adds to the suspense.
