Morgraphy posted:
Aragorn, a trained
Ranger and
Numenorean Royalty, with nine
Nazgul within earshot, in an age where
swords were a necessary and widespread tool of society. I am sure Aragorn would have reacted quite differently than "a friend."
Anyone who uses swords or
knives in any culture first learns to use them
carefully and not wave them about randomly and not to use them jokingly, e.g. don’t run with pointed scissors.
Also, the flat of a blade is not exceedingly sharp, and direct contact with a sharp blade will not lacerate the skin without considerable force.
Boromir is cut because he runs his finger along the blade.
Arwen has the
point of the blade against Aragorn’s throat, not the flat. Try it with the point of a
knife if you wish.
Knives are a necessary and widespread tool today. Movie-Arwen’s behavior whether with knife or
sword is indefensible in any period. It would be equally indefensible with a gun. “Oops! I tripped and it went off!”
Foe-hammer posted:
Your statement pre-supposes that YOU (and those like you) are they only ones capable of telling if a roof leaks. I'm here to tell you that most people can tell if a roof leaks, that would be a MAJORITY OF PEOPLE. A majority of people like the movies, as is, and do not view them as you do. Your opinion about this movie is OUTSIDE the majority. So, we are not talking about something as simple as a leak in a roof. Making a successful movie is not as easy as making a roof that doesn't leak.
Again, argumentum ad populum is a
fallacy Foehammer. Majority doen’t rule in taste, or in science, or in historical beliefs. Search out
argumentum ad populum on a web search engine. It can only makes sense as a subsidiary argument to indicate that a position supported by many cannot be disregarded entirely.
I provided several roof-leaks in the films. So have others. You could try to deny them by showing they are not roof-leaks. But insisting that only people who have studied architecture can recognize roof-leaks is silly. Even many of those who like the films may recognize some of the flaws.
When
Sam lies to about Boromir’s death and
Faramir doesn’t call him out on it something has slipped badly in the scripting. No matter how often you attempt your
argumentum ad populum the films themselves confute you on many issues.
The way I see your argument about changes that positively, 100%, for sure would have made it a better movie for everyone, is more along the lines of a compition to get to the moon. You figure all you have to do is take aim and fire and you'll hit it. The truth of it is the gravitational pull of the moon and earth along with a thousand other technical facts (that you are totally clueless of) makes your solution impossible. By the time you reached the original position, it's been long gone and now your momentum makes it impossible to get back. Meanwhile, your compititor is using all the technical knowledge and facts to plan his trip and his actually works because he hits the moon. But you sit there heading into deep space and complain that you didn't like the way he did it and if he had only done what you said it would have been better. He tries to point out why his plan worked, but you don't listen to that and continue to claim your plan was better, yet do not have the technical knowledge or the desire to be educated about said knowledge to give your argument some credibility.
You are raving. What does this moving target stand for in anything I’ve said?
You claimed Arwen’s joke with the sword is good film because it reveals character. What kind of character does it reveal? No answer of course, other than pointing at the moon!
I have asked you to educate by explaining why following the
books more faithfully would have necessarily have made Jackson’s films more like
Labyrinth. You seem unable to do so.
If you really feel that those changes would have made it a better movie for you and those like you, then say so, and stop claiming that everyone else (the majority) are somehow flawed because they liked this movie as it is.
More of the
argument ad populum fallacy: many others like something or believe something therefore everyone should like it or believe it.
And an argument that
the majority of people who like the film like the film demonstrates nothing.
Majority doesn’t much enter into convincing anyone on asethetics, other than to consider an argument or viewpoint.
It is very possible that the silent majority has been waiting for a feel good film that doesn't glorify behavior them deem immoral etc and are rewarding new line for giving them a good movie. I would suggest that people who like springer would NOT go see this movie because arwen breasts were not shown. I can see the segment of people that like survivor shows would not like this movie because the worst, sneakiest, low-life did not win in the end.
Now we see you arguing that you, yourself, are quite at liberty to dislike something many others like.
Of course I can take your argument to mean that there is a silent majority who likes Jackson’s films for moral reasons despite the flaws found. I don’t think you mean that. But silent majorities are rather imaginary things, arguments from silence.
For starters, Arragorns character is too fairytale-like for a realistic film.
Fairytale-like is what I said. Unrealistic. Not acting like a real king would.
Aragorn acts like no real king I am familiar with in either book or film
He is not a king for most of the story. So how can he act like one? But Aragorn in both film and book is as honest and self-sacrificing and conscientious and faithful a person as it is possible to be for a warrior-type (save that Jackson’s bad plotting makes movie-Aragorn advise
Théoden unwisely). That is certainly not like most historical
kings.
In the film Aragorn is more self-doubting. That doesn’t seem to me particularly more like a real king. Movie-Aragorn is also less ambitious. That doesn’t seem to me particularly more like a real king.
But what has any of this to do with realism? In fact there have been historical kings who doubted themselves and historical kings who were not ambitious.
A case can be made that movie-Aragorn is far more saintly than book-Aragorn. Movie-Aragon is unsure of his worth. Movie-Aragorn has no desire for power. Movie-Aragorn gives up Arwen for what he feels is her own good despite his deep love for her (shades of Rick and Ilsa in
Casablanca). Is that what you mean by good film? But in
Casablanca we saw the whole story. Showing the break-up in a flashback long after it happened and having it make no difference to the story isn’t especially good story invention.
So explain what you mean.
Jackson’s love story of Aragorn and Arwen is rather tacky on the whole.
(Aragorn is floating down the river. He washes up on a rocky shore. Scene fades to Arwen lying on a bed. Fades back to Aragorn on the shore. Arwen bends over his face and kisses him softly.)
Arwen: (voiceover) May the grace of the
Valar protect you.
(She fades away. Aragorn lies on the shore. Brego comes up and nuzzles him. He turns him onto his back.)
Honestly! Not great cinema. Or is this supposed to comedy? If so, it is not great comedy.
Foe-hammer posted:
I already explained
bree. And
Gimli. And several other points and you continue to reject them out of hand.
Not
out of hand if explanations were given.
I personally have no great problem with Bree. However I don’t see that it had to be changed. I don’t accept the idea that there is only one possible way to adapt
The Lord of the Rings and that Jackson’s way must be the best. Gimli sticks in my craw for example, just as Nigel Bruce’s Dr. Watson was annoying to many and possibly most Sherlock Holmes fans in the older films. Newer adaptations of the
tales show unequivocably that Watson didn’t have to be made into dumbed-down comic relief in films for the results to be popular.
Jackson created a schlock one-dimensional comic relief sidekick because that’s an easier and cheaper way to get laughs than to use comedy deriving from a fuller character. Yes Gimli is funny in that cheap sort of way. But the film is accordingly cheapened by it.
So, tell me, why should bother? You are not listening and you have no skills to justify not listening.
Then don’t bother. Continuous name-calling and insistance that majority rules (except in areas where
you don’t agree with popular taste) are not cogent arguments.
So, from now on when you ask a question like that my only answer to you will be....
"It obviously worked because people like it"
Then one can equally respond that something didn’t work because people don’t like it. That is a tautolgy in matters of aesthetics.
And counting heads to find out how many people liked or disliked something doesn’t work in aesthetics or science or history or in many other areas. It only shows current opinion which people may change when they examine more closely.
Britney Spear’s singing obviously works because people like it. It obviously dosn’t work because people don’t like it.
More honest is to say: “It works because I like it!” or “It works because I don’t like it!”
Of course you will then attack the caliber of person who liked it. (again, with no hard provable data to back it up)
You’ve been attacking the caliber of everyone who disagrees with you far more than you’ve been attacked personally.
You attacked the caliber of people who like reality television with no hard data to back you up. What’s the difference?