Sôval Phârë
Our Bog is Dood
- Joined
- Feb 2, 2004
- Messages
- 52
Mrs. Maggott said:...although not necessarily those who like the films but dislike Jackson's adaptation of the tale
Hence, many of the things which Mr. Jackson and his writers might/would see as inexplicable and/or nonsensical, make their own sense when viewed within the context of the myth itself. Therefore, when Jackson sees fit to "change things" to create "realism" within Tolkien's fantasy world, all he manages to do is make nonsense of the meaning of the myth - albeit, it may make sense to those for whom the myth is non-existent or unimportant.
For Jackson to have presented LOTR on film he would have had to be as true as possible to the characters of the story for it is through them and their interaction that the tale is told, not through the plot line or the outward, superficial appearance of their world. Unfortunately (at least for those for whom it was important), he chose to do otherwise.
Mrs. Maggott said:
Mrs. Maggot said:For Jackson to have presented LOTR on film he would have had to be as true as possible to the characters of the story for it is through them and their interaction that the tale is told, not through the plot line or the outward, superficial appearance of their world.
Sôval Phârë said:I consider myself in this category, although I don't dislike the adaptation outright; I just think it's flawed in places.
Sôval Phârë said:
Sôval Phârë said:Yes, the characters are important! But why do you think they're of the greatest importance? I think this might be a matter of opinion from reader to reader. Since the story sprang up out of Tolkien's invented languages, for example, one could make a good argument that language is the most important. Jackson would have failed if we looked at it solely in that respect, I admit, because the movie's dialogue and variations of speech between characters is nowhere near as nuanced as Tolkien's.
Actually, it would have been more acceptable if the thrust of the author's message was conveyed therein. It is possible to convey a message in a different setting as the modern presentations of many of Shakespeare's plays have proven. The message remains the same even though the setting is entirely alien to the original.Greenwood said:So if Jackson had completely changed the plot, or moved the story to modern times and had the Ring be some WMD, but all the characters were the same, that would have been OK with you?
Mrs. Maggott said:If Faramir had died as did Boromir at Parth Galen, assuming all other things were the same, Frodo would have had no fear of Boromir had he met him in Ithilien since Faramir had never been a threat to him.
there is certainly nothing to suggest that the hobbits would have been in any danger from their captor. Boromir fell, but he was a good and noble man until the strain of the conflict of interest which assailed him together with the blandishments of the Ring overcame him.
Sôval Phârë said:
Mrs. Maggott said:However, Aragorn is equally changed. He rejects his heritage, is extremely fearful of his "weak blood" and appears to seek to escape from Arwen rather than embrace her love. He tells Galadriel that he wants her to go into the West (as opposed to the diametric interplay of characters in the book). And there are so many other character changes: Elrond is cynical and nasty. Treebeard doesn't know what's going on. Merry and Pippin (though they do get better as time goes on) are nothing more than madcap sneakthieves, hardly the tried and true comrades determined to accompany Frodo into danger and exile. Frodo is unacceptably weak and not a little stupid ("Go home, Sam!" Really!). And there are others whose changed characters have been frankly talked to death.
The point is this: a moral message is transmitted in large part not through plot ploys such as the Ring, but by the interaction among and between the characters as well as the "character" of the characters themselves. Make fundamental changes in the characters and you have fundamentally changed their interplay as well as the meaning of the tale even if you have every possible plot ploy remain the same. It may appear as if Jackson has given us the same story but he hasn't and this isn't only my opinion. A great many other people (and not just on this forum but also persons of considerable scholarly background in Tolkien have made the same assessment of the films).
Mrs. Maggott said:
Thorin said:I was wondering when we'd see another infamous MGIWH post from you. Your's and my "A Purist Review" series are things this forum can look foward to, hey (heh heh).
I don't get it...what did TTT do to Faramir?
2) Denethor the piggish crazy guy and all scenes with him in it (it was even worse then what TTT did to Faramir)
Greenwood said:And I find your sanctimonious moralizing far more offensive than anything Jackson did to LOTR. I would almost rather read the absurd contentions of the people who say that Frodo and Sam were gay lovers and that LOTR was some sort of playing out of repressed homosexual urges on Tolkien's part. IMHO Peter Jackson had a far truer understanding of Tolkien and LOTR than either they, or you, possess.
Many people (including various writers on the film) were heard to state that they changed Aragorn (and some other characters) because they were too "mythical" and heroic. I merely assumed that Jackson's characters changes were a desire to instill "realism" and "modernism" rather than "heroism" into the character. Certainly Aragorn as presented in the films is a recognizeably modern character. He is conflicted in his love life, unsure about his future, unhappy about his past and definitely filled with self-doubt concerning just about everything. More modern you can't be, already!Sôval Phârë said:I agree with you that these are some big departures from the text, many of which are unnecessary, but I still don't see how they support your interesting assertion that Jackson was going for "realism."
Mrs. Maggott said:You asked a question: would I be satisfied if the characters remained the same but the settings were changed. I answered it thoughtfully and politely. You do not address that response to your own question but, instead call me names and then praise Mr. Jackson as if doing so made some sort of point (it doesn't). Unfortunately, this seems to be a fairly standard mode of behavior among some people when they don't have a credible response to a valid point which has been made. Sad that. But it certainly does shorten the debate!
Mrs. Maggott said:You asked a question: would I be satisfied if the characters remained the same but the settings were changed. I answered it thoughtfully and politely. You do not address that response to your own question but, instead call me names and then praise Mr. Jackson as if doing so made some sort of point (it doesn't). Unfortunately, this seems to be a fairly standard mode of behavior among some people when they don't have a credible response to a valid point which has been made. Sad that. But it certainly does shorten the debate!
Mrs. Maggott said:However, let me say this about your original question: it was the most perceptive and fundamental question that has yet to be asked on these threads by anyone - and that is why I answered it. Is it better for the person adapting the story to choose character over setting or vice versa? Would Tolkien's message have survived a complete resetting as long as the film retained its fidelity to the characters, or is the setting the means by which the message is conveyed? I considered this a deep and very insightful question. I hoped you might appreciate that I gave a lot of thought to its answer owing to the respect I felt for the person who asked it. I guess I was wrong.
I am well aware of (and have enjoyed) updates of Shakespeare (including The Tempest being done as The Forbidden Planet). However, when those productions are done the criticism is usually directed at whether or not the retelling/updating worked in its new form. The adapter/director/producer are generally not subjected to the kind of personal villification Jackson has been subjected to. And people who enjoyed those update/adaptations have not been subjected to the kind of attacks that people who have enjoyed these films have been subjected to.Mrs. Maggott said:Actually, it would have been more acceptable if the thrust of the author's message was conveyed therein. It is possible to convey a message in a different setting as the modern presentations of many of Shakespeare's plays have proven. The message remains the same even though the setting is entirely alien to the original.
Thereby implying that my enjoyment of the film is somehow more shallow, less thinking and comprehending than your implied deeper, more profound understanding of the meaning of Tolkien. That is the attitude I find sanctimonious and condescending and that is what I responded to. That is the attitude that prevents a true discussion of the movies. And BTW, I do not think that you are the only one who exhibits that attitude. Neither do I think that all purists or others who disliked the films exhibit it.Mrs. Maggott said:
Jackson has NOT been "subjected" to any personal, or any other kind of, "vilification". The suggestion is absurd.Greenwood said:....the kind of personal villification Jackson has been subjected to.
....the kind of attacks that people who have enjoyed these films have been subjected to.
Thereby implying that my enjoyment of the film is somehow more shallow, less thinking and comprehending than your implied deeper, more profound understanding of the meaning of Tolkien. That is the attitude I find sanctimonious and condescending.
joxy said:Jackson has NOT been "subjected" to any personal, or any other kind of, "vilification". The suggestion is absurd.
Beorn said:MAY YOU BE CAST INTO THE CRACKS OF DOOM, YOU OBSINATE FOOL, PETER JACKASS. MAY YOU SUFFER ENDLESSLY, BEING TORTURED UNTIL YOU ARE NEXT TO DEATH. MAY YOU FEEL THE PAIN THAT WE HAVE FELT, HAVING OUR FAVORITE BOOK OF ALL TIME DESTROYED, MADE INTO A BASTARDIZATION OF THE GREATEST WORKS WRITTEN THIS CENTURY. MAY YOU BE TORTURED BY DEATH THREATS, NAME CALLING, AND FEAR OF BEING ATTACKED UNTIL YOU FIND A WAY TO REPAY YOUR DEBT TO TOLKIEN, HIS FAMILY, AND US, HIS LOYAL FANS. FOREVER CURSE YOU TO THE TORTURES OF BEING THE DESTROYER, THE RAPER OF TOLKIEN'S WORKS.
AND, A QUOTE FROM THE MOVIE, WHICH WAS ONE OF THE FEW THINGS YOU DID RIGHT...
Quote:
Many that live deserve death. And some that die deserve life. Can you give it to them? Then do not be too eager to deal out death in judgement.
YOU CAN BET YOUR FAT A$$ THAT I WOULD BE SWIFT TO MAKE THIS JUDGEMENT. I WOULD NOT HAVE YOU PUT TO DEATH, BUT I WOULD HAVE YOU STRIPPED OF ALL DIGNITY, ASSUMING YOU HAVE THE SLIGHTEST TRACE OF IT, I WOULD BE SURE THAT YOU NEVER AGAIN ARE ALLOWED TO WORK WITH ANY SHRED OF THE LORD OF THE RINGS, BY J. R. R. TOLKIEN
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?