• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

My God, It Was Horrible (Part III)

Mrs. Maggott said:
...although not necessarily those who like the films but dislike Jackson's adaptation of the tale

I consider myself in this category, although I don't dislike the adaptation outright; I just think it's flawed in places.

Hence, many of the things which Mr. Jackson and his writers might/would see as inexplicable and/or nonsensical, make their own sense when viewed within the context of the myth itself. Therefore, when Jackson sees fit to "change things" to create "realism" within Tolkien's fantasy world, all he manages to do is make nonsense of the meaning of the myth - albeit, it may make sense to those for whom the myth is non-existent or unimportant.

I'm interested in your idea that Jackson wanted to make Tolkien's story more "realistic." Could you give some examples of the changes he made to accomplish that? The only one I can think of at the moment is Faramir's behavior toward the ring.

For Jackson to have presented LOTR on film he would have had to be as true as possible to the characters of the story for it is through them and their interaction that the tale is told, not through the plot line or the outward, superficial appearance of their world. Unfortunately (at least for those for whom it was important), he chose to do otherwise.

Yes, the characters are important! But why do you think they're of the greatest importance? I think this might be a matter of opinion from reader to reader. Since the story sprang up out of Tolkien's invented languages, for example, one could make a good argument that language is the most important. Jackson would have failed if we looked at it solely in that respect, I admit, because the movie's dialogue and variations of speech between characters is nowhere near as nuanced as Tolkien's.
 
Mrs. Maggott said:
If Sauron had been able to "think in a morally good way", he wouldn 't be evil!

Well, he no longer would have been totally evil, but still fairly evil nonetheless, and probably a much more effective evil guy. :)
 
Mrs. Maggot said:
For Jackson to have presented LOTR on film he would have had to be as true as possible to the characters of the story for it is through them and their interaction that the tale is told, not through the plot line or the outward, superficial appearance of their world.

So if Jackson had completely changed the plot, or moved the story to modern times and had the Ring be some WMD, but all the characters were the same, that would have been OK with you? :rolleyes:
 
Sôval Phârë said:
I consider myself in this category, although I don't dislike the adaptation outright; I just think it's flawed in places.

I found it more than merely "flawed in places". (see below).

Sôval Phârë said:
I'm interested in your idea that Jackson wanted to make Tolkien's story more "realistic." Could you give some examples of the changes he made to accomplish that? The only one I can think of at the moment is Faramir's behavior toward the ring.

Faramir is only one character the magnitude of whose change from the book makes him "stand out". However, Aragorn is equally changed. He rejects his heritage, is extremely fearful of his "weak blood" and appears to seek to escape from Arwen rather than embrace her love. He tells Galadriel that he wants her to go into the West (as opposed to the diametric interplay of characters in the book). And there are so many other character changes: Elrond is cynical and nasty. Treebeard doesn't know what's going on. Merry and Pippin (though they do get better as time goes on) are nothing more than madcap sneakthieves, hardly the tried and true comrades determined to accompany Frodo into danger and exile. Frodo is unacceptably weak and not a little stupid ("Go home, Sam!" Really!). And there are others whose changed characters have been frankly talked to death.

The point is this: a moral message is transmitted in large part not through plot ploys such as the Ring, but by the interaction among and between the characters as well as the "character" of the characters themselves. Make fundamental changes in the characters and you have fundamentally changed their interplay as well as the meaning of the tale even if you have every possible plot ploy remain the same. It may appear as if Jackson has given us the same story but he hasn't and this isn't only my opinion. A great many other people (and not just on this forum but also persons of considerable scholarly background in Tolkien have made the same assessment of the films).

Sôval Phârë said:
Yes, the characters are important! But why do you think they're of the greatest importance? I think this might be a matter of opinion from reader to reader. Since the story sprang up out of Tolkien's invented languages, for example, one could make a good argument that language is the most important. Jackson would have failed if we looked at it solely in that respect, I admit, because the movie's dialogue and variations of speech between characters is nowhere near as nuanced as Tolkien's.

Tolkien himself declared that he didn't much care what changes a film maker made to his plot, but he considered his characters sacrosanct because it is through them that he is conveying his message and meaning. True, different readers may discern different things, but I don't know of any reader who will translate a strong man into weakness or an evil one into good. On the other hand, something put on the screen takes away the individual's ability to interpret. You pretty much get what you get and I for one (and others both on and off this forum) didn't like what we got in many instances. Not every character was changed for the worst, but far too many of the really important ones were.

Can people (even purists) still like Jackson's characters? Certainly! They are quite modern and understandable for that reason. However, when we see the story developed through them, it is Jackson's message, not Tolkien's that is conveyed.
 
Greenwood said:
So if Jackson had completely changed the plot, or moved the story to modern times and had the Ring be some WMD, but all the characters were the same, that would have been OK with you? :rolleyes:
Actually, it would have been more acceptable if the thrust of the author's message was conveyed therein. It is possible to convey a message in a different setting as the modern presentations of many of Shakespeare's plays have proven. The message remains the same even though the setting is entirely alien to the original.

You have chosen to embrace the appearance, the form, over the meaning or the substance of what is being told - and that' s fine if you are satisfied with it. For me, I find horses and castles and c.g. monsters do not in and of themselves tell the story. They are its setting, not its heart and soul.
 
Mrs. Maggott said:
If Faramir had died as did Boromir at Parth Galen, assuming all other things were the same, Frodo would have had no fear of Boromir had he met him in Ithilien since Faramir had never been a threat to him.

there is certainly nothing to suggest that the hobbits would have been in any danger from their captor. Boromir fell, but he was a good and noble man until the strain of the conflict of interest which assailed him together with the blandishments of the Ring overcame him.

Of course there are a lot of "what-ifs" here, but I don't think Faramir would have died at Parth Galen at all. Boromir left the group in search of Frodo - so he was alone when he ran to the assistance of M&P...Faramir would have fought with the others. What I always wonder is, would Frodo have left the way he did without the actions of Boromir? Hmmm...

Yes, Boromir was a good man, but a willfull man ready to follow his father's orders. Frodo and Sam would have been sent to MT without Boromir batting an eye - he probably wouldn't even have waited for explananations. (more like our buddy movie Faramir)...
 
Sôval Phârë said:
Gollum obviously does an evil thing when he bites off Frodo's finger at Mount Doom to get the ring... and as a result, the world (and Frodo) is saved!

Is Gollum capable of making a moral decision about the ring? Not to mention the pity that SO many characters show towards Gollum (I love how he's always described as a possible large squirrel or a log, etc. and always slips behind a tree trunk) is what saves Frodo. Denethor knows right from wrong, does the wrong thing and (possibly) saves ME...
 
Actually, Frodo wandered away from the camp in order to work up the courage to go alone to Mordor. He didn't want to have anyone go with him. He knew that Boromir and Aragorn wanted to go to Gondor and he certainly didn't want to bring any of his hobbit comrades with him. Only Gimli and Legolas remained of the Fellowship and he believed that they would either seek their own lands or remain with the Fellowship after his departure. Boromir's attack merely hardened the resolve he was already building up to go alone.

However, if Frodo was still missing from the group after some time, then certainly Aragorn would have gone looking for him, perhaps leaving the other hobbits in Faramir's care. It is possible that the same thing might have taken place. Of course, the blame for the attack on the obviously unprepared Fellowship is Aragorn's. He trusted that there were no orcs on that side of the river although Legolas had warned that he was uneasy. Aragorn's permitting Frodo to wander away alone was not wise and to my mind puts to a final rest any claims that Tolkien's character was some sort of "perfect" superhero.
 
Mrs. Maggott said:
However, Aragorn is equally changed. He rejects his heritage, is extremely fearful of his "weak blood" and appears to seek to escape from Arwen rather than embrace her love. He tells Galadriel that he wants her to go into the West (as opposed to the diametric interplay of characters in the book). And there are so many other character changes: Elrond is cynical and nasty. Treebeard doesn't know what's going on. Merry and Pippin (though they do get better as time goes on) are nothing more than madcap sneakthieves, hardly the tried and true comrades determined to accompany Frodo into danger and exile. Frodo is unacceptably weak and not a little stupid ("Go home, Sam!" Really!). And there are others whose changed characters have been frankly talked to death.

I agree with you that these are some big departures from the text, many of which are unnecessary, but I still don't see how they support your interesting assertion that Jackson was going for "realism."

Getting a bit off the topic... I don't really mind movie Aragorn's ambivalence about Arwen. He knows that if she stays with him she will die, and no one would wish that fate on someone he loves, especially not on someone who was meant to live forever. If movie Aragorn "spurns" Arwen's love, it's because he doesn't want her to suffer. I know that's hardly Tolkien's vision, but I fail to see what makes it so offensive.

The point is this: a moral message is transmitted in large part not through plot ploys such as the Ring, but by the interaction among and between the characters as well as the "character" of the characters themselves. Make fundamental changes in the characters and you have fundamentally changed their interplay as well as the meaning of the tale even if you have every possible plot ploy remain the same. It may appear as if Jackson has given us the same story but he hasn't and this isn't only my opinion. A great many other people (and not just on this forum but also persons of considerable scholarly background in Tolkien have made the same assessment of the films).

I see your point, and it's a good one, but I'll have to do some more thinking about this before I can contribute any more to the subject.
 
Mrs. Maggott said:
You have chosen to embrace the appearance, the form, over the meaning or the substance of what is being told - and that' s fine if you are satisfied with it. For me, I find horses and castles and c.g. monsters do not in and of themselves tell the story. They are its setting, not its heart and soul.

And I find your sanctimonious moralizing far more offensive than anything Jackson did to LOTR. I would almost rather read the absurd contentions of the people who say that Frodo and Sam were gay lovers and that LOTR was some sort of playing out of repressed homosexual urges on Tolkien's part. IMHO Peter Jackson had a far truer understanding of Tolkien and LOTR than either they, or you, possess.
 
Last edited:
Thorin said:
:D I was wondering when we'd see another infamous MGIWH post from you. Your's and my "A Purist Review" series are things this forum can look foward to, hey (heh heh).

I don't get it...what did TTT do to Faramir?


2) Denethor the piggish crazy guy and all scenes with him in it (it was even worse then what TTT did to Faramir)
 
Greenwood said:
And I find your sanctimonious moralizing far more offensive than anything Jackson did to LOTR. I would almost rather read the absurd contentions of the people who say that Frodo and Sam were gay lovers and that LOTR was some sort of playing out of repressed homosexual urges on Tolkien's part. IMHO Peter Jackson had a far truer understanding of Tolkien and LOTR than either they, or you, possess.

You asked a question: would I be satisfied if the characters remained the same but the settings were changed. I answered it thoughtfully and politely. You do not address that response to your own question but, instead call me names and then praise Mr. Jackson as if doing so made some sort of point (it doesn't). Unfortunately, this seems to be a fairly standard mode of behavior among some people when they don't have a credible response to a valid point which has been made. Sad that. But it certainly does shorten the debate! :rolleyes:
 
Sôval Phârë said:
I agree with you that these are some big departures from the text, many of which are unnecessary, but I still don't see how they support your interesting assertion that Jackson was going for "realism."
Many people (including various writers on the film) were heard to state that they changed Aragorn (and some other characters) because they were too "mythical" and heroic. I merely assumed that Jackson's characters changes were a desire to instill "realism" and "modernism" rather than "heroism" into the character. Certainly Aragorn as presented in the films is a recognizeably modern character. He is conflicted in his love life, unsure about his future, unhappy about his past and definitely filled with self-doubt concerning just about everything. More modern you can't be, already! :p
 
Mrs. Maggott said:
You asked a question: would I be satisfied if the characters remained the same but the settings were changed. I answered it thoughtfully and politely. You do not address that response to your own question but, instead call me names and then praise Mr. Jackson as if doing so made some sort of point (it doesn't). Unfortunately, this seems to be a fairly standard mode of behavior among some people when they don't have a credible response to a valid point which has been made. Sad that. But it certainly does shorten the debate! :rolleyes:

Someone needs to explain to MM that she comes off as sanctimonious quite often. I do not know if it is intentional or if that is the kind of person she is. I make no judgements on her character, but never the less, she does do a lot.
 
Mrs. Maggott said:
You asked a question: would I be satisfied if the characters remained the same but the settings were changed. I answered it thoughtfully and politely. You do not address that response to your own question but, instead call me names and then praise Mr. Jackson as if doing so made some sort of point (it doesn't). Unfortunately, this seems to be a fairly standard mode of behavior among some people when they don't have a credible response to a valid point which has been made. Sad that. But it certainly does shorten the debate! :rolleyes:

OK, I will directly address that part of your response. I find your continual statements that seem to indicate you are nearly the only one who truly understands Tolkien's LOTR annoying and offensive; as offensive as jallan's statements that people who enjoyed the films are mindlessly viewing them. In the last several months of reading your posts I have seen you state that your priest, your family members, your friends and just about everyone who has seen and enjoyed these films does not see or understand the "true" moral message of LOTR and how Jackson has twisted this message; "diametric" being your favorite word. I find your posts and attitude sanctimonious: only the pious Mrs. Maggot truly understands that the heathen filmmakers have corrupted the supremely moral LOTR. It is as silly and offensive as Thorin thundering blasphemy about Arwen.

Talk about shortening debate! Only the moral and pious Mrs. Maggot truly understands Tolkien, LOTR and what the terrible filmmakers have done to it! The rest of us heathen are either too stupid or blind or immoral to see or understand it.

That you derive some spiritual comfort from LOTR is fine. I am happy for you. All great literature can be read at many levels and LOTR is certainly great literature. That Tolkien was a deeply religious man and that his own feelings are reflected in a book he spent years working on is no surprise (the reverse would be amazing!) and I would never argue otherwise. But Tolkien did not write LOTR as a religious text and said so many times. You are merely using Tolkien's work for your own personal beliefs and ends, something you are constantly accusing Jackson of doing.
 
You know, for people who ostensibly enjoyed these films, I am astounded at the hostility that seems to accompany their defense. Are they worth that much angst?

I am not going to bother defending myself against contentions that have been made regarding these films and their fidelity to Tolkien's message by persons with a great deal more experience and knowledge of the subject than I possess. Whether you know it or not, my points have been made by far more people than myself and others on this forum, many of whom have credentials which even the most sincere FAD would have to acknowledge - providing, of course, that he or she were being honest. So your point that I am speaking for myself alone is frankly, erroneous.

Nor do I doubt that those who love the films have gained some message from them, albeit it is not Tolkien's original message. Indeed, even many FADs admit that this is Jackson's version of the story, not Tolkien's.

However, let me say this about your original question: it was the most perceptive and fundamental question that has yet to be asked on these threads by anyone - and that is why I answered it. Is it better for the person adapting the story to choose character over setting or vice versa? Would Tolkien's message have survived a complete resetting as long as the film retained its fidelity to the characters, or is the setting the means by which the message is conveyed? I considered this a deep and very insightful question. I hoped you might appreciate that I gave a lot of thought to its answer owing to the respect I felt for the person who asked it. I guess I was wrong.
 
Mrs. Maggott said:
However, let me say this about your original question: it was the most perceptive and fundamental question that has yet to be asked on these threads by anyone - and that is why I answered it. Is it better for the person adapting the story to choose character over setting or vice versa? Would Tolkien's message have survived a complete resetting as long as the film retained its fidelity to the characters, or is the setting the means by which the message is conveyed? I considered this a deep and very insightful question. I hoped you might appreciate that I gave a lot of thought to its answer owing to the respect I felt for the person who asked it. I guess I was wrong.

And if your answer had restricted itself to my original question I would not have responded as I did and perhaps a useful dialogue could be started. You will notice I did not criticize the first part of your response:
Mrs. Maggott said:
Actually, it would have been more acceptable if the thrust of the author's message was conveyed therein. It is possible to convey a message in a different setting as the modern presentations of many of Shakespeare's plays have proven. The message remains the same even though the setting is entirely alien to the original.
I am well aware of (and have enjoyed) updates of Shakespeare (including The Tempest being done as The Forbidden Planet). However, when those productions are done the criticism is usually directed at whether or not the retelling/updating worked in its new form. The adapter/director/producer are generally not subjected to the kind of personal villification Jackson has been subjected to. And people who enjoyed those update/adaptations have not been subjected to the kind of attacks that people who have enjoyed these films have been subjected to.

But as usual, you did not end your response with a simple answer to my question. You had to go on with the second and closing part of your response:
Mrs. Maggott said:
You have chosen to embrace the appearance, the form, over the meaning or the substance of what is being told - and that' s fine if you are satisfied with it. For me, I find horses and castles and c.g. monsters do not in and of themselves tell the story. They are its setting, not its heart and soul.
Thereby implying that my enjoyment of the film is somehow more shallow, less thinking and comprehending than your implied deeper, more profound understanding of the meaning of Tolkien. That is the attitude I find sanctimonious and condescending and that is what I responded to. That is the attitude that prevents a true discussion of the movies. And BTW, I do not think that you are the only one who exhibits that attitude. Neither do I think that all purists or others who disliked the films exhibit it.
 
Last edited:
Greenwood said:
....the kind of personal villification Jackson has been subjected to.
....the kind of attacks that people who have enjoyed these films have been subjected to.
Thereby implying that my enjoyment of the film is somehow more shallow, less thinking and comprehending than your implied deeper, more profound understanding of the meaning of Tolkien. That is the attitude I find sanctimonious and condescending.
Jackson has NOT been "subjected" to any personal, or any other kind of, "vilification". The suggestion is absurd.
People who have enjoyed the films, who include ME among their honourable ranks, have NOT been "subjected" to any "attacks". The suggestion is absurd.
Can't you see the difference between "criticism", in the strict sense of the word, and "vilification" and "attacks"??
And this is where you go wrong again: in your "implying". You should be more careful what you "imply" from what you read. Mrs M writes in very clear and precise language, saying exactly what she means, and no more, and leaves no room for implications. I see NONE of the implications you take from those comments. There's nothing sanctimonious about Mrs M, or condescending; she is amazingly patient in the face of some extraordinarily unpleasant and totally unjustifiable comments made against her.
I could say the same for myself!
 
joxy said:
Jackson has NOT been "subjected" to any personal, or any other kind of, "vilification". The suggestion is absurd.

joxy,

As I said, stop wasting my time. Aragil has given you examples before as have I, but since you seem to have trouble remembering things here again are some simple ones: From the first page of MY God It Was Horrible:
Beorn said:
MAY YOU BE CAST INTO THE CRACKS OF DOOM, YOU OBSINATE FOOL, PETER JACKASS. MAY YOU SUFFER ENDLESSLY, BEING TORTURED UNTIL YOU ARE NEXT TO DEATH. MAY YOU FEEL THE PAIN THAT WE HAVE FELT, HAVING OUR FAVORITE BOOK OF ALL TIME DESTROYED, MADE INTO A BASTARDIZATION OF THE GREATEST WORKS WRITTEN THIS CENTURY. MAY YOU BE TORTURED BY DEATH THREATS, NAME CALLING, AND FEAR OF BEING ATTACKED UNTIL YOU FIND A WAY TO REPAY YOUR DEBT TO TOLKIEN, HIS FAMILY, AND US, HIS LOYAL FANS. FOREVER CURSE YOU TO THE TORTURES OF BEING THE DESTROYER, THE RAPER OF TOLKIEN'S WORKS.

AND, A QUOTE FROM THE MOVIE, WHICH WAS ONE OF THE FEW THINGS YOU DID RIGHT...

Quote:
Many that live deserve death. And some that die deserve life. Can you give it to them? Then do not be too eager to deal out death in judgement.

YOU CAN BET YOUR FAT A$$ THAT I WOULD BE SWIFT TO MAKE THIS JUDGEMENT. I WOULD NOT HAVE YOU PUT TO DEATH, BUT I WOULD HAVE YOU STRIPPED OF ALL DIGNITY, ASSUMING YOU HAVE THE SLIGHTEST TRACE OF IT, I WOULD BE SURE THAT YOU NEVER AGAIN ARE ALLOWED TO WORK WITH ANY SHRED OF THE LORD OF THE RINGS, BY J. R. R. TOLKIEN

You might also try looking at the first page of this thread. Others can be found. I am just tired of wasting my precious time posting the examples over and over and then having you claim they don't exist.

A person being accused of being mindless for their enjoyment of the films is an attack, whether you will recognize it as such or not.

I agree Mrs. M's writing is quite clear, as is her condescension.

I repeat, stop wasting my time.
 

Today's events

Back
Top