• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

My God, It Was Horrible (Part III)

Aragil,

Thank you.

I noticed that in one instance joxy had a post immediately following one of Mrs. M's "Christological" posts.
 
joxy said:
I normally make a point of not discussing religion at all - it's an English thing, we don't discuss religion or politics in polite company! - and I don't recall being persuaded to do so by anything from Mrs M, or from anyone else, until yesterday!

Allow me to refresh your memory ... * good-natured bow *

On page three of a thread called Purist or not

I addressed simbelmyne from a Catholic perspective ... and joxy, to whom I did not address myself, chose to respond.

My Quote to simbelmyne, which joxy chose to re-quote in his post to me:
Originally posted by GandalftheGray
The Catholic World Report showed its disappointment with "The Two Towers"
....simbelmyne, I echo your sentiments....

joxy's response to me:

Interesting, we seem to have even more in common than has so far been apparent.

Curiouser and curiouser! :)
 
Greenwood said:
I noticed that in one instance joxy had a post immediately following one of Mrs. M's "Christological" posts.
It's the same old story: the meaning of words, but this time the Atlantic isn't to blame.
Christological has a specific definition in theology: "the study of the person, nature, and role, of Christ".
Mrs M wasn't referring to that study.
My comment was about a "religious" matter, something quite distinct from that, and something of a "first" for me.
I do try to avoid discussing religion here. I am only human - who does that remind me of? - so I may fail occasionally - mea culpa.


Gandalf The Grey said:
....joxy, to whom I did not address myself, chose to respond....
Curiouser and curiouser! :)

That was months ago, and was a very brief passing reference to religion; I don't get your point in quoting it - explain, please?
Thanks though, as it happened, very oddly, to be a duplicated posting, so you gave me the opportunity to find that out, and delete one of them!
Do you object to people, other than the one you address, responding? If so, why? If not, why mention it?

Aragil: Thanks for the information. I still don't see why people can't quote "chapter and verse" themselves when they make references; they must know which specific postings they are referring to when they make their own postings. I try to make my postings relevant to the "QUOTE" that I start them with - again, I may fail occasionally - my fault.
 
Last edited:
joxy said:
That was months ago, and was a very brief passing reference to religion; I don't get your point in quoting it - explain, please?
Thanks though, as it happened, very oddly, to be a duplicated posting, so you gave me the opportunity to find that out, and delete one of them!
Do you object to people, other than the one you address, responding? If so, why? If not, why mention it?

No, of course I do not object to people, other than the one I address, responding to my posts. Being that this is a public forum, it's only to be expected that anything I post is fair game for anyone wishing to reply. Beyond that, joxy, please be assured that you are welcome to reply as you like to my posts. * bows *

As for my lack of explanation, there is no ill will behind it. Though my color is grey and the matter I mention not nearly so weighty as that of a palantír, yet the following quote I believe remains validly illustrative.

'Well, if Gandalf has changed at all, then he's closer than ever that's all,' Pippin argued. 'That -- glass ball, now. He seemed mighty pleased with it. He knows or guesses something about it. But does he tell us what? No, not a word. Yet I picked it up, and I saved it from rolling into a pool. Here, I'll take that, my lad -- that's all. I wonder what it is? --- The Palantír, Lord of the Rings, J.R.R. Tolkien

Then again, one might say that we are communicating via palantír.
 
joxy said:
As I said, I don't read everything on the forums; if I miss something and then ask a question to which the answer is in the something I missed then it would only be courteous to supply the appropriate reference.

Joxy,

Here is a link to your profile.

http://thetolkien.forum/member.php?userid=3087

On the average of 4.5 posts per day within a year and a half, I wonder just what the heck you could possible be missing? My search of all your posts gave just 500 results of the 2,552 you have written. Do you know when the oldest post of the 500 was? 1/05/2004. 1/05/2004. That is 500 posts in 2 months and most of them are in the "new Line Cinema" thread. You claim you are missing what is abundantly clear to most everyone else, but you respond to a lot of posts. I know you must be responding to something you've read but your claim makes me think that you only read posts directed to you, but we know thats not true because you constantly respond to what is said to others. My conclusion is that you are in denial or you are just plain lying.

This is just another example of your statements just not washing with the evidence.
 
Foe-Hammer said:
I wonder just what the heck you could possible be missing?
You claim you are missing what is abundantly clear to most everyone else, but you respond to a lot of posts.
you constantly respond to what is said to others.
My conclusion is that you are in denial or you are just plain lying.
I could be missing all the threads that I don't even look at, and there a lot of those; I could be missing posts that are ten times the average length of mine because I haven't time to read them; I could be missing posts from people who I know from experience to use rhetoric and hyberole instead of reasoned discussion and which I therefore pass over; I could be forgetting things rather than missing them - I don't register everything I glance at.
Those are points that I COULD miss. Here are two that I DID miss, and to which, on my request, I was courteously directed:
a posting made last year, that I'd forgotten; a phrase that had been attached to a poster's name but subsequently removed.

How do you know what is abundantly clear to most everyone else?

I respond to any posts that I'm interested in. This is an open forum, not a set of cosy tables for two.

Regarding the number of posts I make: that might seem high, though I haven't the interest to check the numbers by anyone else; but check the volume: mine are mostly short and concise - compare the total length of some others! :)

I don't know what you mean by "in denial". Please withdraw the reference to lying.
 
Gandalf The Grey said:
Then again, one might say that we are communicating via palantír.
Well, it's always good to see someone taking the opportunity to quote from the books, even if the relevance is obscure!
And great grey wizard, and with total irrelevance, do you think PJ's Treebeard knew who The White Wizard was?
 
joxy said:
I could be missing all the threads that I don't even look at, and there a lot of those; I could be missing posts that are ten times the average length of mine because I haven't time to read them; I could be missing posts from people who I know from experience to use rhetoric and hyberole instead of reasoned discussion and which I therefore pass over; I could be forgetting things rather than missing them - I don't register everything I glance at.
Those are points that I COULD miss.

You are missing them. And each one of those are totally in your control. So, fix your problem or suffer the continued questioning of your erroneous claims.

joxy said:
How do you know what is abundantly clear to most everyone else?

Read, joxy, read and you'll see the posts I am referring to. I fail to see how you don't see them since you continue to respond to them even though they were not directed to you.

joxy said:
I respond to any posts that I'm interested in. This is an open forum, not a set of cosy tables for two.

And I will continue to point out how off base you are every time you do.

joxy said:
I don't know what you mean by "in denial". Please withdraw the reference to lying.

Sorry, I retract niether because those are the only logical choices I see left to explain your continued refusal to see the examples that you say do not exist.
 
Foe-Hammer said:
And I will continue to point out how off base you are every time you do.
I retract niether because those are the only logical choices I see left to explain your continued refusal to see the examples that you say do not exist.
I don't know what "off base" means, but let's be clear: are you saying the forum IS meant to be set of cosy tables for two, each isolated from all the other diners, who may not join the conversation? If you are saying that then I think you're wrong; if you're not saying that, then what ARE you saying about a third person commenting on postings from one or two others?
You're too keen on telling people what they say: I do NOT say they don't exist. I may say I haven't seen them - a perfectly reasonable thing to say.
 
joxy said:
I don't know what "off base" means, but let's be clear: are you saying the forum IS meant to be set of cosy tables for two, each isolated from all the other diners, who may not join the conversation? If you are saying that then I think you're wrong; if you're not saying that, then what ARE you saying about a third person commenting on postings from one or two others?

I will continue to question you when you presume to devine what other people mean.

joxy said:
You're too keen on telling people what they say: I do NOT say they don't exist. I may say I haven't seen them - a perfectly reasonable thing to say.

Then I say go back and re-read or stop wasting everyones time with your silly complaints.
 
Foe-Hammer said:
....your silly complaints.
This whole thing that you've got is just that: silly.
This is supposed to be an area for reasonable discussions, not for trying to start childish squabbles - anyway, you've won this squabble - I've blocked your postings.
Will someone else tell me what "off base" means? :rolleyes:
 
joxy said:
This whole thing that you've got is just that: silly.
This is supposed to be an area for reasonable discussions, not for trying to start childish squabbles - anyway, you've won this squabble - I've blocked your postings.
Will someone else tell me what "off base" means? :rolleyes:

off base...wrong or mistaken
 
it's a bit discourageing for a newcomer to try and read this thread. i started backwards, sort of, and i gave up.... (hard to keep up with skirmishes amongst established members :))

not that i really had a lot to add, but i thought beorn's post was great, the first one of the thread that is, and i wanted to tell him/her so...

now i'm gonna tiptoe out of here and resume the exploration of the forum.... :eek:
 
duilwen said:
it's a bit discouraging
now i'm gonna tiptoe out of here
Bienvenu, and come back soon - most people here are really very nice, and they'd like to hear your opinions on everything.
 
duilwen said:
it's a bit discourageing for a newcomer to try and read this thread. i started backwards, sort of, and i gave up.... (hard to keep up with skirmishes amongst established members :))

not that i really had a lot to add, but i thought beorn's post was great, the first one of the thread that is, and i wanted to tell him/her so...

now i'm gonna tiptoe out of here and resume the exploration of the forum.... :eek:

Oh don't leave! The beauty of newbies is they always have something new and interesting to add because they are not entrenched in the three years of debate many of us have been. You don't have to follow this discussion or get into the name calling etc. You can respond to any and all posts in this thread.

Really, we all would welcome a change of pace, so please, post your thoughts.
 
joxy said:
And great grey wizard, and with total irrelevance, do you think PJ's Treebeard knew who The White Wizard was?

Well, as joxy responded to G the Grey's post to me, I'd like to take this opportunity to respond to a question asked of him... :p I didn't realize that was a question. Is there any reason Treebeard wouldn't have known who the white wizard was?

If you are referring to that nonsense about the Ents at the moot deciding M and P are not orcs, all I can say is poor judgement on PJ's part to make this question a focus at the moot (only thing mentioned besides deciding not to help ME), when Treebeard had already spoke to Gandalf about it. However. it was discussed at the moot in the book...despite Treebeard himself already being sure they weren't orcs, so, if PJ had made the ents more thoughtful and intelligent otherwise, I would have been fine with the change. The way things stand, the "orc debate" makes them look even more ignorent and clueless then they already do.

Of course, you may be referring to something else entirely :p
 
Last edited:
I like your answer, simbelmyne. :)

Now I'll answer, in a more alliterative, perhaps less serious, vein:

Who was which White Wizard when? :p

* puffs at his Old Toby and grins good-naturedly, while encircling smoke rises up in the shape of question marks *
 
simbelmyne said:
all I can say is poor judgement on PJ's part to make it seem like that was all that was discussed at the moot.

It seemed to me that the major point of discussion was their decision to not get involved. The bit about whether they were orcs or not was the setup for the extreme length of time it takes the ents to say anything. Both from the book and I thought worked very well on film. (especially since that part of the book was frustratingly boring)
 
Foe-Hammer said:
It seemed to me that the major point of discussion was their decision to not get involved.

...since that part of the book was frustratingly boring

Yes, you're right - I miswrote (and re-edited my post).

What's this? You forgot to write IMO after that last statement. :p I love the ents. Personally my eyes glaze over when Aragorn goes to look for that dumb white tree on the mountain...

Gandalf the Grey, you crack me up. ;) I would also like to know the answer to that question. And then ask "Why?" Not sure why PJ added the scene of showing the hobbits to "the white wizard" to discover if they are orcs and THEN includes this same debate at the entmoot....
 
What's this about your eyes glazing over when Aragorn goes looking for ... * AHEM! * ... "that dumb white tree on the mountain," simbelmyne?

The day on which Aragorn finds the sapling happens to be my birthday, no less! So I might even consider it my own personal Party Tree. :)

And as for your answer to my question, simbelmyne, apparently the question as I asked it was intended to lead to a point quite different than the question as you answered it? Congratulations ... you're turning the tables and leaving me befuddled. :D * bows a gracious defeat *
 

Today's events

Back
Top