simbelmyne said:
joxy said:It's the same old story: the meaning of words, but this time the Atlantic isn't to blame.
Christological has a specific definition in theology: "the study of the person, nature, and role, of Christ".
Mrs M wasn't referring to that study.
My comment was about a "religious" matter, something quite distinct from that, and something of a "first" for me.
clearly claiming that you had not seen Mrs. M's use of the word. (Notice I have given you precise directions to your quote as well as including it.) Aragil pointed out your activity on a number of threads where Mrs. M had used the word including the close proximity of your posts to us in some cases (immediately following in one case as I pointed out). I would not go as far as Foe-hammer and accuse you of lying, but IMHO a reasonable person could wonder about what appears to be a highly selective memory on your part.joxy said:"Christological" has to join the list of those postings I have sadly missed, and which I can't expect anyone to point out to me, as such things are too much to ask around here.
The "search" mechanism here brings up precisely six uses of the word "Christological" this year. Three are in threads that I have not used. I did not reply to, or comment on, any of the other three. I've said, quite recently, that I do NOT read every post,Greenwood said:The meaning of Christological is irrelevant....clearly claiming that you had not seen Mrs. M's use of the word.
"PJ is a disgrace"....The very title of the thread is an example of the PJ bashing that you claim does not happen on this forum. I also noticed that in the thread you regularly denied the bashing (as you still do) and just as regularly demanded specific citations saying you had not seen them (as you still do).
Well, what words would we write which wouldbe worthy?Gandalf The Grey said:Who was which White Wizard when?
joxy said:Well, what words would we write which wouldbe worthy?
Your alliteration is matched only by your erudition. Remember the roxy moxy contest?
Greenwood said:This is another case where to understand why PJ did some thing you must "forget" your knowledge of the book and look at it as a movie audience member who has never read the books.
joxy said:The "search" mechanism here brings up precisely six uses of the word "Christological" this year. Three are in threads that I have not used. I did not reply to, or comment on, any of the other three. I've said, quite recently, that I do NOT read every post,
and I see no reason to suggest that I DID read any of these three. If I did, then I'd forgotten the use of the word - I am blessed with a memory that doesn't retain every word it sees - which is actually quite the normal type of memory. That confirms my claim not to have seen the word being used - unless you can give further chapter and verse.....
Now that was in post 33 of the "Purity and the Critics" thread and you made it on 9 Jan 2004. Yet when one reads through the "My God It Was Horrible (III)" thread one finds that posts 45 and 46 on that thread were both made by you on 1 Jan 2004. Of course, it is impossible for anyone else to know what you do and do not remember, but if your memory is really as faulty as it seems and also given your oft stated willingness to accept other people's comments about films you haven't seen, I would suggest you refrain from your constant demands that people cite individual acts of PJ bashing and other rudeness they have seen on the forum. You should just accept their reports as you accept reports on the films that you haven't seen. Otherwise, it seems reasonable to me to just view your constant denials of having seen things and demands for specific citations as just a debating ploy and time waster.joxy said:I haven't seen, and can't find that MGIWH thread, but I agree it was not up to our standard!
(emphasis added)
simbelmyne said:
But that had already been done, ad nauseam, in the "good morning" thing.Greenwood said:The episode is merely to show how slow the ents are to decide things.
Well, I may be forgetful, but you're pretty good at diverting from the subject, and at misunderstanding what other people say.Greenwood said:....further chapter and verse.... etc....
I think that says it all.simbelmyne said:I've talked to some non-book readers who were completely confused.
joxy said:I think that says it all.
Which says it all about your sense of humour!Greenwood said:And that says it all about your bias.
joxy said:obviously didn't mean the WHOLE thread -
aragil said:
aragil said:rs69191 (at least) seems to think that the books have been diminished by the movies. He (I assume) recently said that switching the character's dialog or the context of dialog was a disservice to the original, which I assume means that the original is somewhat diminished. How this occurs, I have no idea- indeed I agree with you that the idea is absurd! However, Rowan's point stands that some purists have said this (if I bothered to dig, I know I could find more).
Mrs. Maggott said:If Tolkien was so impossible and/or difficult to make into a film or films, why chose his book? Why not just go straight to King Kong and leave it at that?
You'll want to re-read the book here, I think. Theoden's "braveheart" speech is almost directly from the book:rs691919 said:Just perusing this thread, and I have to comment on this. The charge of the Rohirrim does not follow the books. If it had followed the books, the Rohirrim would have charged without any warning to the forces of Mordor. As it happens in the movie, the Rohirrim marshal their forces in full sight of the the Orc armies sitting in front of the city--giving Theoden the opportunity to make a Braveheart speech of encouragement (this time usurping the later lines of Eomer after the "death" of Eowyn--if I remember right). If it had followed the books, the attention of the armies of Mordor would have been turned to the assault upon the Gate and the confrontation between the Witch-King and Gandalf. As it is, the charge of the Rohirrim in the movie resembles the book only in the most superficial manner possible.
I suppose I could point you to where I have described in great detail how the movie action is similar to book, but I'd guess that with your attitude towards the movie it wouldn't be worth the effort.Book:
Arise, arise, Riders of Théoden!
Fell deeds awake: fire and slaughter!
spear shall be shaken, shield be splintered,
a sword-day, a red day, ere the sun rises!
Ride now, ride now! Ride to Gondor!
...
Movie:
Arise! Arise, Riders of Théoden!
Spears shall be shaken! Shields shall be splintered!
A sword day! A red day! Ere the sun rises!
Ride now! Ride now! Ride! Ride for ruin, and the world's ending! Death!
aragil said:You'll want to re-read the book here, I think. Theoden's "braveheart" speech is almost directly from the book: I suppose I could point you to where I have described in great detail how the movie action is similar to book, but I'd guess that with your attitude towards the movie it wouldn't be worth the effort.
From the movie: said:Ride now! Ride now! Ride! Ride for ruin, and the world's ending! Death!
Ah, a $300,000,000 gamble by New Line that if it had failed probably would have meant the end of the studio and certainly the end of Jackson's career. I can certainly see how Jackson and New Line considered LOTR a "stepping stone" to King Kong.rs691919 said:The answer is simple: he couldn't find anyone to bankroll King Kong. The rug was pulled from under him while King Kong was in preproduction. But now, with the success of the "trilogy", he had no difficulty getting a deal for Kong. LotR was a stepping stone for him.
To quote from another thread: "So what?" The last few words of Theoden's exhortation were spoken by Eomer in the book. The rest of it was, as Aragil said, "almost directly from the book".rs691919 said:
Yes, and then the movie has all that made up stuff about Haradrim on mumakils and Theoden being crushed by his horse when the Witch-King arrives to turn the tide of battle against Rohan, and a silly confrontation between Eowyn and the Witch-King in which she kills the Witch-king, and Aragorn arrives with a fleet full of ghosts to save the day, etc. But wait, it seems to me I read all that somewhere about forty years ago. Jackson must have copied it from somewhere. I will have to go to my library and see if I can find where.rs691919 said:
I can certainly see how breaking up the assault on a city whose defenses have already been breached and entered would be considered less of an accomplishment than breaking up the assault on a city that has not yet been entered.rs691919 said:
Greenwood said:Ah, a $300,000,000 gamble by New Line that if it had failed probably would have meant the end of the studio and certainly the end of Jackson's career. I can certainly see how Jackson and New Line considered LOTR a "stepping stone" to King Kong.
Greenwood said:
Greenwood said:Yes, and then the movie has all that made up stuff about Haradrim on mumakils and Theoden being crushed by his horse when the Witch-King arrives to turn the tide of battle against Rohan, and a silly confrontation between Eowyn and the Witch-King in which she kills the Witch-king, and Aragorn arrives with a fleet full of ghosts to save the day, etc. But wait, it seems to me I read all that somewhere about forty years ago. Jackson must have copied it from somewhere. I will have to go to my library and see if I can find where.
Greenwood said:I can certainly see how breaking up the assault on a city whose defenses have already been breached and entered would be considered less of an accomplishment than breaking up the assault on a city that has not yet been entered.It may diminish Minas Tirith, but it does not diminish Rohan's charge.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?