• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

My God, It Was Horrible (Part III)

simbelmyne said:
Not sure why PJ added the scene of showing the hobbits to "the white wizard" to discover if they are orcs and THEN includes this same debate at the entmoot....

This is another case where to understand why PJ did some thing you must "forget" your knowledge of the book and look at it as a movie audience member who has never read the books. An audience member does not know at that point in the movie that Gandalf has returned as Gandalf the White. As far as they are concerned Gandalf is dead. Even if they have heard rumors or suspect that Gandalf might be back they do not know he is know the "White Wizard". The audience member still does not know for sure what to make of Treebeard. Yes, he has rescued Merry and Pippin from an orc so he is probably a "good guy", but now he is taking them to see the "White Wizard" and the only White Wizard that audience member knows of is Saruman.

As for including the question of whether Merry and Pippin are orcs in the Entmoot, Foe-hammer has addressed that already: it is from the book and it is to show how slow and deliberate the ents are. The fact that Treebeard already knows Merry and Pippin are not orcs is irrelevant. The assembled ents (the Entmoot) has to make that decision for themselves and we can assume that Treebeard conveys his knowledge to them. It still takes a longtime for them to decide to agree on this point.
 
joxy said:
It's the same old story: the meaning of words, but this time the Atlantic isn't to blame.
Christological has a specific definition in theology: "the study of the person, nature, and role, of Christ".
Mrs M wasn't referring to that study.
My comment was about a "religious" matter, something quite distinct from that, and something of a "first" for me.

The meaning of Christological is irrelevant. You stated (in post #619 on this thread):
joxy said:
"Christological" has to join the list of those postings I have sadly missed, and which I can't expect anyone to point out to me, as such things are too much to ask around here.
clearly claiming that you had not seen Mrs. M's use of the word. (Notice I have given you precise directions to your quote as well as including it.) Aragil pointed out your activity on a number of threads where Mrs. M had used the word including the close proximity of your posts to us in some cases (immediately following in one case as I pointed out). I would not go as far as Foe-hammer and accuse you of lying, but IMHO a reasonable person could wonder about what appears to be a highly selective memory on your part.

The other day I spent a few hours reading through most of the "PJ is a disgrace" thread that was started after the release of TTT. I found that you were fairly active on it. The very title of the thread is an example of the PJ bashing that you claim does not happen on this forum. I also noticed that in the thread you regularly denied the bashing (as you still do) and just as regularly demanded specific citations saying you had not seen them (as you still do). Once again, IMHO, one can only wonder about the apparently selective nature of your memory and/or reading of threads. IMHO one can also only wonder whether your memory and requests for specifc citations is not just a debating ploy.
 
Greenwood said:
The meaning of Christological is irrelevant....clearly claiming that you had not seen Mrs. M's use of the word.
"PJ is a disgrace"....The very title of the thread is an example of the PJ bashing that you claim does not happen on this forum. I also noticed that in the thread you regularly denied the bashing (as you still do) and just as regularly demanded specific citations saying you had not seen them (as you still do).
The "search" mechanism here brings up precisely six uses of the word "Christological" this year. Three are in threads that I have not used. I did not reply to, or comment on, any of the other three. I've said, quite recently, that I do NOT read every post,
and I see no reason to suggest that I DID read any of these three. If I did, then I'd forgotten the use of the word - I am blessed with a memory that doesn't retain every word it sees - which is actually quite the normal type of memory. That confirms my claim not to have seen the word being used - unless you can give further chapter and verse.....
That thread title is as much a disgrace as the title of this one - we all know that. They're meant to be amusing, and I'm sure Mr Jackson has a thick enough skin, and a sufficiently distorted sense of humour, to be able to appreciate the fact, and not to accuse their perpetrators of "bashing" him with them.
Yes, I'm still waiting for citations for "bashing" done in postings. I could have missed them - like P Jackson, I AM only human.
 
Last edited:
Gandalf The Grey said:
Who was which White Wizard when?
Well, what words would we write which wouldbe worthy?
Your alliteration is matched only by your erudition. Remember the roxy moxy contest? :D
I've always found the "Treebeard throws P&M at feet of glowing ghost" scene, and the start of the entmoot, wildly confusing, and would really like to know what people think is supposed to be happening. So, Treebeard knew Gandalf had taken over from Saruman as The WW, and knew just where he would be at that particular moment?
My assessment of the quality of thinking of PJ's ent collective is close to that of simbelmyne, whom I thank for the response.
 
joxy said:
Well, what words would we write which wouldbe worthy?
Your alliteration is matched only by your erudition. Remember the roxy moxy contest? :D

Thank you. Yet not too erudite, I hope! Here is what I chose for my saying back when we denizens of TTF were allowed a comment next to our names under the subject heading of "Deep Thoughts:" ..... "Deep thoughts are always welcome. That said, may wisdom not cancel out merriment!" :)
 
Greenwood said:
This is another case where to understand why PJ did some thing you must "forget" your knowledge of the book and look at it as a movie audience member who has never read the books.

What about an audience member who's paying strict attention to dialogue? :p Just a joke, yet I'm not referring to the books at all, but to the earlier scene joxy has dubbed "the glowing ghost". Yes, the audience first wonders who is this wizard Treeeard is consulting about whether Merry and Pippin are orcs, but we all quickly learn it was Gandalf. (the mechanics of THAT meeting mystify me also...) SO why does Treebeard then have to have a lengthy discussion with Quickbeam, etc. to establish what he went to some trouble to find out from Gandalf? The book audience has a better idea why, knowing its part of LOTS of things discussed at the moot. I've talked to some non-book readers who were completely confused.
 
joxy said:
The "search" mechanism here brings up precisely six uses of the word "Christological" this year. Three are in threads that I have not used. I did not reply to, or comment on, any of the other three. I've said, quite recently, that I do NOT read every post,
and I see no reason to suggest that I DID read any of these three. If I did, then I'd forgotten the use of the word - I am blessed with a memory that doesn't retain every word it sees - which is actually quite the normal type of memory. That confirms my claim not to have seen the word being used - unless you can give further chapter and verse.....

It is not really very hard to "give further chapter and verse" on your apparently selective memory. In what I believe was the first exchange of posts between the two of us on the "Purity and the Critics" thread you did one of your usual protests that you had never seen any of the type of behavior (PJ bashing) under discussion. I cited (among other things) posts from the "My God It Was Horrible (III)" thread. Your reply was:
joxy said:
I haven't seen, and can't find that MGIWH thread, but I agree it was not up to our standard!

(emphasis added)
Now that was in post 33 of the "Purity and the Critics" thread and you made it on 9 Jan 2004. Yet when one reads through the "My God It Was Horrible (III)" thread one finds that posts 45 and 46 on that thread were both made by you on 1 Jan 2004. Of course, it is impossible for anyone else to know what you do and do not remember, but if your memory is really as faulty as it seems and also given your oft stated willingness to accept other people's comments about films you haven't seen, I would suggest you refrain from your constant demands that people cite individual acts of PJ bashing and other rudeness they have seen on the forum. You should just accept their reports as you accept reports on the films that you haven't seen. Otherwise, it seems reasonable to me to just view your constant denials of having seen things and demands for specific citations as just a debating ploy and time waster.
 
simbelmyne said:
SO why does Treebeard then have to have a lengthy discussion with Quickbeam, etc. to establish what he went to some trouble to find out from Gandalf?

Treebeard does not have to establish for himself that the hobbits are not orcs. As you say, he already knows this. But the other ents do not. We can assume that Treebeard tells the Entmoot any information he has gained from Gandalf. The episode is merely to show how slow the ents are to decide things and comes pretty directly from the book.
 
Greenwood said:
The episode is merely to show how slow the ents are to decide things.
But that had already been done, ad nauseam, in the "good morning" thing.
Everything that happens in Fangorn is confusing; maybe it's something in the water causing it.......

Greenwood said:
....further chapter and verse.... etc....
Well, I may be forgetful, but you're pretty good at diverting from the subject, and at misunderstanding what other people say.
You quote at length from my posting about "Christological", than say nothing about that, but return to "bashing" instead.

Regarding the quotation you gave in January from MGIWH, my note, that "I couldn't find that thread", obviously didn't mean the WHOLE thread - no-one could miss that! I meant I couldn't find the posting you quoted from the thread, which, again as we all know, contains a very large number of them. It would have been better if I'd said that I couldn't find "that specific posting in that thread" rather than just "that thread", but my meaning was obvious in the context. It's some time ago, but I vaguely remember that the index was not working properly at the time, so I simply could NOT find the original posting just then.

I still don't see why it's so difficult for someone to give a specific reference, as you've just done to my postings, and indeed, as you did for the MGIWH reference, for these allegations of "bashing", which I gather you regard as quite serious. Maybe it's simply a matter once again of the meaning of words; I must say I find the word "bashing" so vague and generalised that it says more about the person who uses it than it defines about the person who is being accused of it.

You actually, and generously, gave a second quotation, as an example of "bashing", at the time you gave me MGIWH one:
<from a thread discussing Jackson perhaps filming The Hobbit:
Quote: And your momma PJ! I swear, if you touch the hobbit I will cut you 'another'.>
As I said at the time, I haven't the slightest idea what that means, and you didn't respond to my request for a translation.
If you can translate it now, I may well agree again, as I did about the MGIWH example, with your verdict of "bashing", against it.
 
Last edited:
joxy said:
I think that says it all.

And that says it all about your bias. I have spoken to non-book readers who had no problem and weren't confused at all. Given the sheer numbers of people who saw these films you can probably find people who thought just about everything about anything in the films. On the book forums I have also seen readers who evidenced a rather surprising lack of understanding about key points in the book. I know of peolpe who thought that the hobbit farmer in FOTR (Farmer Maggott) was the same as the hobbit farmer in ROTK (Rosie Cotton's dad). I do not take that as evidence of a failure on Tolkien's part.
 
Greenwood said:
And that says it all about your bias.
Which says it all about your sense of humour!
Has the hilarity generated by broken carrots and dwarf-tossing really so dulled your soh that you can't recognise any humour
that's even slightly above that level? Do I have to add a smiley face each time I say something mildly humorous? :confused:

Simbelmyne's experience was no less, and no more, significant than any of the claims that are regularly made about the opinion of "most people" - something which no-one can, and no-one ever will, know. It was interesting though! :cool:

Just a personal note: I showed the opening of TTT at the weekend to someone who knew nothing about it; he was as impressed as I always am, until Sam's box was opened - "roast chicken?! what's that nonsense all about?". He didn't want to see any more.
 
aragil said:
Wow. The charge of the Rohirrim was probably the most stirring moment I've seen in a film, ever. It actually follows the books.

Just perusing this thread, and I have to comment on this. The charge of the Rohirrim does not follow the books. If it had followed the books, the Rohirrim would have charged without any warning to the forces of Mordor. As it happens in the movie, the Rohirrim marshal their forces in full sight of the the Orc armies sitting in front of the city--giving Theoden the opportunity to make a Braveheart speech of encouragement (this time usurping the later lines of Eomer after the "death" of Eowyn--if I remember right). If it had followed the books, the attention of the armies of Mordor would have been turned to the assault upon the Gate and the confrontation between the Witch-King and Gandalf. As it is, the charge of the Rohirrim in the movie resembles the book only in the most superficial manner possible.
 
aragil said:
rs69191 (at least) seems to think that the books have been diminished by the movies. He (I assume) recently said that switching the character's dialog or the context of dialog was a disservice to the original, which I assume means that the original is somewhat diminished. How this occurs, I have no idea- indeed I agree with you that the idea is absurd! However, Rowan's point stands that some purists have said this (if I bothered to dig, I know I could find more).

Wow, I didn't even know that I was involved in this thread! It makes me feel warm and fuzzy.

Anyway, please don't put words in my mouth (so to speak). The book is not diminished by these cinematic farces. In fact, now when I read the book, I appreciate even more the sublety and beauty which Jackson et al. couldn't get very close to. However, the persistent niggling changes to dialogue mock the book, and that indeed does the book a disservice.
 
Mrs. Maggott said:
If Tolkien was so impossible and/or difficult to make into a film or films, why chose his book? Why not just go straight to King Kong and leave it at that?

The answer is simple: he couldn't find anyone to bankroll King Kong. The rug was pulled from under him while King Kong was in preproduction. But now, with the success of the "trilogy", he had no difficulty getting a deal for Kong. LotR was a stepping stone for him.
 
rs691919 said:
Just perusing this thread, and I have to comment on this. The charge of the Rohirrim does not follow the books. If it had followed the books, the Rohirrim would have charged without any warning to the forces of Mordor. As it happens in the movie, the Rohirrim marshal their forces in full sight of the the Orc armies sitting in front of the city--giving Theoden the opportunity to make a Braveheart speech of encouragement (this time usurping the later lines of Eomer after the "death" of Eowyn--if I remember right). If it had followed the books, the attention of the armies of Mordor would have been turned to the assault upon the Gate and the confrontation between the Witch-King and Gandalf. As it is, the charge of the Rohirrim in the movie resembles the book only in the most superficial manner possible.
You'll want to re-read the book here, I think. Theoden's "braveheart" speech is almost directly from the book:
Book:
Arise, arise, Riders of Théoden!
Fell deeds awake: fire and slaughter!
spear shall be shaken, shield be splintered,
a sword-day, a red day, ere the sun rises!
Ride now, ride now! Ride to Gondor!
...
Movie:
Arise! Arise, Riders of Théoden!
Spears shall be shaken! Shields shall be splintered!
A sword day! A red day! Ere the sun rises!
Ride now! Ride now! Ride! Ride for ruin, and the world's ending! Death!
I suppose I could point you to where I have described in great detail how the movie action is similar to book, but I'd guess that with your attitude towards the movie it wouldn't be worth the effort.
 
aragil said:
You'll want to re-read the book here, I think. Theoden's "braveheart" speech is almost directly from the book: I suppose I could point you to where I have described in great detail how the movie action is similar to book, but I'd guess that with your attitude towards the movie it wouldn't be worth the effort.

From the movie: said:
Ride now! Ride now! Ride! Ride for ruin, and the world's ending! Death!


That is a direct lift from Eomer's exhortation to his Riders after the apparent death of Eowyn.

I have indeed just looked at your description of how the movie action is similar to the book. I agree that it is similar--in the sense that in both movie and book, the Rohirrim do marshal their forces and do charge at the Orcs.

Similarity ends there. In the movie, the Rohirrim marshal their forces in direct sight of the Orcs. The Orcs have time to reorder their own lines, with pig-head Orc even readying his archers (or something to that effect). The two lines stare at each other menacingly, and then the Rohirrim charge. Meanwhile, other Orcs are still pouring into the first level, Gandalf has to run off and save Faramir, and then have a nice little chat with Pippin about death (you and I have discussed that little gem previously).

The effect of these alterations is to weaken one of the most crucial points in the narrative: the forces of the West at the absolute nadir of their fortunes and the sudden braying of the Horns of Hope echoing in Mindolluin's sides. For the assault on the Gate is carried on despite the charge of the Rohirrim, and the Orcs reach the second level while the Rohirrim are still on the field of battle. Thus their charge (in the movie) is diminished: it does not sweep the armies of Mordor from that Gate through which no enemy had yet entered. It does not save the city from an invasion that had not occured in its entire history.
 
rs691919 said:
The answer is simple: he couldn't find anyone to bankroll King Kong. The rug was pulled from under him while King Kong was in preproduction. But now, with the success of the "trilogy", he had no difficulty getting a deal for Kong. LotR was a stepping stone for him.
Ah, a $300,000,000 gamble by New Line that if it had failed probably would have meant the end of the studio and certainly the end of Jackson's career. I can certainly see how Jackson and New Line considered LOTR a "stepping stone" to King Kong.

rs691919 said:
That is a direct lift from Eomer's exhortation to his Riders after the apparent death of Eowyn.
To quote from another thread: "So what?" The last few words of Theoden's exhortation were spoken by Eomer in the book. The rest of it was, as Aragil said, "almost directly from the book".

rs691919 said:
I have indeed just looked at your description of how the movie action is similar to the book. I agree that it is similar--in the sense that in both movie and book, the Rohirrim do marshal their forces and do charge at the Orcs.


Similarity ends there.
Yes, and then the movie has all that made up stuff about Haradrim on mumakils and Theoden being crushed by his horse when the Witch-King arrives to turn the tide of battle against Rohan, and a silly confrontation between Eowyn and the Witch-King in which she kills the Witch-king, and Aragorn arrives with a fleet full of ghosts to save the day, etc. But wait, it seems to me I read all that somewhere about forty years ago. Jackson must have copied it from somewhere. I will have to go to my library and see if I can find where.


rs691919 said:
Thus their charge (in the movie) is diminished: it does not sweep the armies of Mordor from that Gate through which no enemy had yet entered. It does not save the city from an invasion that had not occured in its entire history.
I can certainly see how breaking up the assault on a city whose defenses have already been breached and entered would be considered less of an accomplishment than breaking up the assault on a city that has not yet been entered. :rolleyes: It may diminish Minas Tirith, but it does not diminish Rohan's charge.
 
Greenwood said:
Ah, a $300,000,000 gamble by New Line that if it had failed probably would have meant the end of the studio and certainly the end of Jackson's career. I can certainly see how Jackson and New Line considered LOTR a "stepping stone" to King Kong.

I'm not sure that my post had anything to do with New Line. New Line wasn't the studio that bailed on King Kong in the first place. Whether New Line considered LotR to be a stepping stone to Kong, I have no idea (nor do I care). Jackson himself has said on many occasions that Kong is his first love; and he said as recently as last month on the Charlie Rose show that LotR has opened up new avenues for him that were previously not available (heavy paraphrasing). So more power to him that he gets to film his first love.


Greenwood said:
thread: "So what?" The last few words of Theoden's exhortation were spoken by Eomer in the book. The rest of it was, as Aragil said, "almost directly from the book".

So what? My point was that the end of Theoden's "speech", he speaks Eomer's lines. And consider those lines and the context in which they are spoken in the movie. "Ride to ruin and the world's ending...death, death, death." Theoden isn't riding to death at that point in the story. He is riding to break the siege--the staves that he speaks in the book are more words of hope than of the madness and despair which are reflected in Eomer's exhortation.

Greenwood said:
Yes, and then the movie has all that made up stuff about Haradrim on mumakils and Theoden being crushed by his horse when the Witch-King arrives to turn the tide of battle against Rohan, and a silly confrontation between Eowyn and the Witch-King in which she kills the Witch-king, and Aragorn arrives with a fleet full of ghosts to save the day, etc. But wait, it seems to me I read all that somewhere about forty years ago. Jackson must have copied it from somewhere. I will have to go to my library and see if I can find where.

No, the movie did not make up the Haradrim on their Mumakil, did not make up Eowyn's confrontations with the Witch-king; it did however, make up Aragorn's arrival with a fleet full of ghosts.


Greenwood said:
I can certainly see how breaking up the assault on a city whose defenses have already been breached and entered would be considered less of an accomplishment than breaking up the assault on a city that has not yet been entered. :rolleyes: It may diminish Minas Tirith, but it does not diminish Rohan's charge.

But in the movie, the attack of the Rohirrim doesn't break up the assault, which is my point. The attack of the Rohirrim doesn't accomplish much at all, for the Orcs still pour in the through the Gate up even to the second level. It takes the arrival of Aragorn and the ghosts to drive the Orcs from the City itself. The charge of the Rohirrim fails to do just this, while in the book, the charge diverts the attention of the Witch-King so that he vanishes from the Gate and sends the armies of Mordor into (momentary) confusion, giving the men of the City time to regroup and send out their own companies out onto the field.
 

Today's events

Back
Top