• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

My God, It Was Horrible (Part III)

Actually their aristic worth is probably quite a bit higher than the Hollywood norm. But remember Stugeon’s Law: ninety percent of everything is crap.

Today the average Hollywood picture goes to DVD immediately and most gradually drift into oblivion except for people interested in a particular actor or director or producer or camerman films in a particular era or tradition.

To say only that something is better than normal Hollywood output is damning with very faint praise, especially with films based on a story already so cinematic as was The Lord of the Rings.

I think the films will be reasonably lasting as spectacle pictures and because of of some very fine acting and some excellent pieces of cinematography and special effect and because much of the original tale does come through. I really don’t think anyone denies that these films are better than average Hollywood.

But if I can see a better visualization in my mind, why should I want to see them again? That I am more aware of their material makes them worse to me than they otherwise would be, just as if I read an historical novel covering an era I know well, I may find it worse because of errors than I would find for a far more inaccurate historical novel in a period I don’t know at all.

I’m not talking about Jackson’s changing things especially, rather that he loses the vision of the original and what he substitutes is mostly (but not always!) less. Yes, sometimes he is sooo good! But then come the Gimli jokes or a stupid oliphaunt Harryhausen tribute.

I really don’t care what film professionals in particular might have to say about such things. I’ve seen professional critics and commentators (on books and film) rave over things I don’t like and ignore much that I think excellent, not necessarily because they are bad commentators, but because they are appreciating or not appreciating particular works in a different way than I am. And the fault, as much as there is fault, may be mine.

And I’ve even seen commentators rave over things I like and know that they are talking nonsense, e.g. reading into Tolkien’s work meanings that just aren’t there.

That’s how it works.
rs691919 said:
I actually intended this question to be broader; that is, leave aside for a moment the discussion about the movies (and leave aside the question of being paid, which was poor wording on my part). Does my opinion on Tolkien therefore carry more weight than yours, because I have lectured on him off and on for the last four years?
Well Greenwood seems to stress elsewhere that he’s been a fan of Tolkien for over forty years as though that gives credibility to his statements. But Christopher Tolkien has almost everyone beat in terms of appreciation for his father’s writing and for Tolkien scholarship. Christopher Tolkien felt that the films should not have been made at all.

That’s the problem when one attempts to cite supposed experts as proof of one’s position. There are often other experts of opposite opinion. So one eventually has to start arguing the details of the work instead.

Greenwood seems now to insist that everyone has to be what he calls normal response. Eccch! That weak defense again. Normal people like it therefore it must be excellent from all viewpoints: the Britney Spears argument, the lowest common denominator argument.

In fact the films are in many ways superior to lowest common denominator material and also quite accessible. So it is not surprising they are a popular success. But their flaws remain along with their excellences and all the whining in the world about their popularity won’t make the flaws go away for those who see them and are bothered by them.

For example, the sword fighting remains fake Hollywood sword and shield sword fighting, probably good enough if you like that sort of thing, just as wire stunts in phony martial arts films are great fun if you like that kind of amusing schlock. But it remains amusing schlock.
 
jallan said:
Well Greenwood seems to stress elsewhere that he’s been a fan of Tolkien for over forty years as though that gives credibility to his statements.
I cite the number of years I have read Tolkien when someone says or implies that all true fans of Tolkien would dislike these films. I cite the number of years I have read Tolkien when someone says or implies that only someone who doesn't really know or is new to the books could like these films. Those seem perfectly valid rebuttals to me. It is possible I may have said that in forty years of reading the books I never thought of, or considered, a certain interpretation. That is a simple statement of fact.

jallan said:
Greenwood seems now to insist that everyone has to be what he calls normal response. Eccch! That weak defense again. Normal people like it therefore it must be excellent from all viewpoints: the Britney Spears argument, the lowest common denominator argument.
No, I have not said that at all. Read all the posts please. I have not said a thing about normal response or normal people. Prior to the last sentence I have not used the word normal even once on this thread. rs691919 is the one who invoked "Hollywood norm" as a standard of comparison. I stated these films do "transcend" (rs691919's word) the "Hollywood norm". A position you are evidently in agreement with since the first sentence of your post was:
jallan said:
Actually their aristic worth is probably quite a bit higher than the Hollywood norm.
You even said:
jallan said:
I really don’t think anyone denies that these films are better than average Hollywood.
On that last statement I would have to disagree with you because clearly rs691919 does deny that. (BTW, I am no fan of Britney Spears.)

jallan said:
But if I can see a better visualization in my mind, why should I want to see them again? That I am more aware of their material makes them worse to me than they otherwise would be, just as if I read an historical novel covering an era I know well, I may find it worse because of errors than I would find for a far more inaccurate historical novel in a period I don’t know at all.
That all seems quite reasonable to me.

jallan said:
I’ve seen professional critics and commentators (on books and film) rave over things I don’t like and ignore much that I think excellent, not necessarily because they are bad commentators, but because they are appreciating or not appreciating particular works in a different way than I am.
I have had the same experiences. I thought I had said something similar. Perhaps I didn't. If I did, I am sure I did not express it as well.

jallan said:
And I’ve even seen commentators rave over things I like and know that they are talking nonsense, e.g. reading into Tolkien’s work meanings that just aren’t there.
Once again we seem to have had similar experiences.

jallan said:
That’s the problem when one attempts to cite supposed experts as proof of one’s position. There are often other experts of opposite opinion.
Agreement again!

jallan said:
But their flaws remain along with their excellences and all the whining in the world about their popularity won’t make the flaws go away for those who see them and are bothered by them.
And again agreement! The only caveat I would make is that different people will see different things as flaws and one person's flaw may not be a flaw at all to someone else; also, people will vary in how much they are bothered by the perceived flaws.

Except for the cases I cite above where I believe you have mischaracterized my intent or misquoted me, we seem to largely be in agreement, at least on the subjects of your last post.
 
Last edited:
Greenwood said:
For a new work there is no such measure of endurance to fall back on. The closest we can come is the reaction of the professional critics and the general public.

The closest we can come is what our own opinions are, what our own hearts and minds tell us, rather than falling back on nebulous entities such as "the public" and "professional critics". I could understand and respect your opinion much more if there were not this pervasive reliance on critical and financial success to "prove" your point (not just in your post, but in several others). Understand: it matters not a whit to me what the critics or the public say when I view any art. All their ramblings, all that box office revenue serves only to dull the mind and keep it from truly examining and truly appreciating (or disliking) the work in question.

Greenwood said:
We can still disagree with that assessment and time may prove us right and the professionals and the public wrong. I wouldn't even begin to suggest odds either way. It is however extremely arrogant to take the attitude that you know what that judgement of history will be, especially when your opinion is currently the minority one.

A quote from a movie: "If you are a minority of one, the truth is the truth." Being in the minority has nothing to do with anything. It is not a question of odds; it is not a question of anything other than what do you truly think--when all the outside commentary has been stripped away--about the art in question.


Greenwood said:
All criticism is largely subjective.

Indeed. Which is why the praise (in and of itselfl) of the so-called professional critics cannot be used as evidence as to the artistic merit of any work.

Greenwood said:
Weight with who? You obviously place great weight on it. In any event, the question is irrelevant here because you have been setting yourself up here as a film critic, not a Tokien critic.

No, it actually carries no weight with me. The question, as I said, was meant to be broad. I specifically desired to leave aside the matter of film criticism and focus solely on my question. That is, does my having lectured on Tolkien make my opinion on Tolkien more valid than yours? And if the answer, as I suspect, is no, then why put so much weight on the "reaction of the professional critics".


Greenwood said:
You don't seem to [comprehend]..the commercial basis of Hollywood

Actually, I do comprehend it; it is, however, irrelevant to my point. I just don't care about the standard the industry holds itself to; I care only about the standard which I hold the industry to.

Greenwood said:
It is not pedantry to point out the misuse of the English language via the twisting of meanings of words.

I'm afraid the dictionary does not account for all uses of language. If you feel that "transcending the Hollywood norm" can only denote "making more money than the average Hollywood film and winning more awards", then you will certainly feel that my use of the phrase is a twisting of language. However, as I stated previously, I have never heard of "transcending" being used in conjuction with mere actuarial matters. Your utilization of dictionary entries in an attempt to narrow the definition of the phrase to suit your argument, then, connotes nothing but pedantry.


Greenwood said:
The norm you specified was the "Hollywood" norm. You have now shifted it to some vague "artisitc merit" norm which you further qualified as "enduring".

I did not, in fact, shift it; rather, since you have a rather narrow definition (see above), I attempted to clarify it with my follow up post:

rs691919 said:
But in terms of storytelling, which is (or should be) at the heart of any narrative art, there is a dreadful "sameness" that pervades these movies--the sensation that cinematic formula is more important than originality. Understand, I don't think that these movies are any worse than the other epic fare that we have been inundated with in the last several decades. They are really the same--Hollywood banalities inserted into a new setting. And what a setting it is!!! Middle-earth is the real hero of these movies. Strip away the majestic scenery, the intricate armor, the detailed costuming, and you basically have Braveheart, or Gladiator, or Star Wars or whatever you choose.


Greenwood said:
Finally, an explanation of "Hollywood norm".

Actually, as stated directly above, I had attempted to clarify my definition of "Hollywood norm", but you dismissed this as revision and stated that I had been proved wrong because of my backtracking.

Greenwood said:
I will now give my opinion that I think these films do transcend the "Hollywood norm" you just stated.

Good, now maybe we can have a discussion, because I'd like to attempt to understand why people feel these movies are any different (and here I mean different in the artistic sense, NOT in the sense that they made lots of money and were praised by professional critics) from Hollywood's usual output.

In post #670, I stated the following:

rs691919 said:
This is not historic storytelling. I watched the first half of Two Towers last night, and a particular scene sticks out in my mind. It is the scene where the Orc chases Merry and Pippin into Fangorn. The Hobbits climb up a tree, the music decrescendo's (is that a verb??), M&P give a sigh of relief, there is a slight pause, and then BANG! The Orc grabs Merry's leg as the music swirls up loudly around the viewer.

How many times have we seen scenes like this in movies? The pause for "dramatic" effect. How many times do we see it in these LotR movies? Again and again. The cave troll scene in Moria employs it; even the climax of the entire story utilizes it (the ultimate cliffhanger) with Frodo hanging on for dear life. And what's more, this director couldn't even be unoriginal with original material--he has to appropriate someone else's!

Would you care to comment on that?
 
Greenwood said:
On that last statement I would have to disagree with you because clearly rs691919 does deny that. (BTW, I am no fan of Britney Spears.)

I will have to amend one thing: for me the Hollywood "average" doesn't take into account things like Gigli or others of the irretrievable garbage that Hollywood often serves up. So, in that sense, I am judging RotK and the other movies against a higher standard, faint praise though it may be.
 
rs691919 said:
The closest we can come is what our own opinions are, what our own hearts and minds tell us, rather than falling back on nebulous entities such as "the public" and "professional critics". I could understand and respect your opinion much more if there were not this pervasive reliance on critical and financial success to "prove" your point (not just in your post, but in several others). Understand: it matters not a whit to me what the critics or the public say when I view any art. All their ramblings, all that box office revenue serves only to dull the mind and keep it from truly examining and truly appreciating (or disliking) the work in question.
I am not and have not used "the public" or the "professional critics" to prove or justify my opinion of the films. My opinion of the films is just that, my opinion, as your opinion is your opinion. You made an assertion (indirectly at first, but directly since) that these films did not "transcend" the "Hollywood norm". I merely pointed out that your statement could not be supported and you still have not supported it. You have revised it to "artisitc merit" which is a totally subjective thing. You tried to make "artisitic merit" an objective thing by referring to it as "enduring artisitic merit". I pointed out that once again your position can not be supported because we can not know what is going to prove to be "enduring". The best we can do is look at what the current view is and the only measures we have for that in the case of films are professional critic's reviews, awards, and public reaction gauged by box-office receipts. All of these go against your opinion of the films. Do they prove that your opinion is wrong? Of course not. It is your opinion and you are entitled to it. Do they prove that your opinion about how the future will view these films is wrong? Once again, of course not. Do they prove my opinion of the films is right? Again, of course not! You are the one who is trying to prove or validate your opinion by claiming the films have no "enduring artisitic merit". A claim that cannot be supported on its very face. I repeat your claim smacks of hubris.

rs691919 said:
A quote from a movie: "If you are a minority of one, the truth is the truth." Being in the minority has nothing to do with anything. It is not a question of odds; it is not a question of anything other than what do you truly think--when all the outside commentary has been stripped away--about the art in question.
Nice quote. What's it relevance? (Yes, that is a rhetorical question.) I have not denied you your opinion. I have repeatedly supported your right to an opinion. I deny you the right to claim your opinion is anything more than your opinion by your implication that you already know the verdict of history.

rs691919 said:
Which is why the praise (in and of itselfl) of the so-called professional critics cannot be used as evidence as to the artistic merit of any work.
And I have not used it for that purpose. I have used it for what it is, evidence of the views of professional critics. Surely you do not deny that the professional critics have overwhelmingly praised the film? I do not say that you have to change your opinion because of that. If you truly have the courage of your beliefs it should not matter what the critics say.

rs691919 said:
No, it actually carries no weight with me. The question, as I said, was meant to be broad. I specifically desired to leave aside the matter of film criticism and focus solely on my question. That is, does my having lectured on Tolkien make my opinion on Tolkien more valid than yours? And if the answer, as I suspect, is no, then why put so much weight on the "reaction of the professional critics".
Again, I do not let the professional critics determine my opinions of this or any other film. I make up my own mind. The way I use film reviews (of films I have not yet seen) is to get an idea of what the film may be about and whether it is then a subject I might be interested in. Through experience I have learned which critics have sensibilities similar (I say similar, not identical) and if I see such a critic praising a film I had not thought about seeing the review might cause be to consider seeing the film. It does not determine my own opinion of the film after I see it. I also base my judgement on whether to see a film on clips I see of it. Sometimes, no matter how much praise a film receives I will still decide not to see it. The reverse also happens. In the end the decision and the opinion after seeing the film is mine and mine alone.

rs691919 said:
I just don't care about the standard the industry holds itself to; I care only about the standard which I hold the industry to.
Good for you. I applaud your integrity. Just refrain from imlying that your standard is the same as the industry standard.

rs691919 said:
I'm afraid the dictionary does not account for all uses of language. If you feel that "transcending the Hollywood norm" can only denote "making more money than the average Hollywood film and winning more awards", then you will certainly feel that my use of the phrase is a twisting of language. However, as I stated previously, I have never heard of "transcending" being used in conjuction with mere actuarial matters. Your utilization of dictionary entries in an attempt to narrow the definition of the phrase to suit your argument, then, connotes nothing but pedantry.
If you are going to insist on using words to mean what you assign them to mean contrary to their accepted meanings as reflected in standard English dictionaries you should not attempt to hold discussions with others. BTW you are misusing the word actuarial, but I will refrain from giving the dictionary defintion. You could try looking it up yourself, though. :D

rs691919 said:
I will have to amend one thing: for me the Hollywood "average" doesn't take into account things like Gigli or others of the irretrievable garbage that Hollywood often serves up.
Then don't use words that don't fir your meaning, i.e. norm, if you don't really mean norm.

rs691919 said:
Good, now maybe we can have a discussion, because I'd like to attempt to understand why people feel these movies are any different (and here I mean different in the artistic sense, NOT in the sense that they made lots of money and were praised by professional critics) from Hollywood's usual output.
Fine, just refrain from any phrasing that implies you have a higher standard than people who enjoyed the films.

I will start out by quoting jallan above. I agree when he says these films contain: "some very fine acting and some excellent pieces of cinematography and special effect and because much of the original tale does come through." I find the films visually stunning. Having loved the books for years I am delighted to see much of them presented on screen. I enjoy hearing so much of the dialogue that I have previously only heard in my own head. I am amazed at the care that went into reproducing so many things that are described in the books, sometimes only sketchily. Given the complexity of the story I am surprised at how much of it made it onto the screen and that pleases me greatly. IMO, Hollywood is rarely as faithful to a book as these three films have been. Does all this mean that I think these movies are perfect? Not at all. There are decisions that Jackson made that I would not have made and that I do not like. There are others that he made that I would not have thought of but that I think worked quite well. Do I think there are no Hollywood cliches in the films. Not at all. You cite the orc grabbing Merry's leg. Yes, I saw it coming. Does it bother me to the point of ruining my enjoyment of the film? No. I thought an even worse cliche was Gandalf grabbing Frodo's shoulder out of the dark in the FOTR when he asks: "Is it safe?" I immediately thought of Laurence Olivier's Nazi dentist in The Marathon Man (I think that is the right title). These things just didn't spoil the whole movie for me. As I have said before, in each case when I first saw the movie I sat there cataloguing all the differences from the books to such an extent I felt I wasn't really watching the film. On second viewings I watched the movies and stopped thinking about the differences with the books and greatly enjoyed them. When I first saw TTT, my initial reaction was: "What the **** was that?!" On second viewing I felt it worked well as a movie and it carried the story along. Much of the story from the book was there, though there were major changes I disagreed with and things missing from the books I dearly would have loved to have seen. The difference between the many Tolkien fans like myself who love the books and who also enjoyed the films, IMO is that we separate the books from the films. The Tolkien fans who so dislike the films do not seem to make that separation. This is not meant in any way as a criticism of the "purists". I do not consider myself better than them, merely different. I understand the "purists" view since I share it to some extent, just not to the same extent.
 
Greenwood said:
The best we can do is look at what the current view is and the only measures we have for that in the case of films are professional critic's reviews, awards, and public reaction gauged by box-office receipts.

I don't understand why you repeat this statement when you subsequently say that their opinions neither support nor deny either of our opinions. If that is so, then it is not the "best we can do". The best we can do is examine the art itself, and not things external to the art. Of course, this is subjective, but that is the beauty of debate between two opposed subjective opinions: it allows us to understand more fully the opposing viewpoint and in fact strengthens our own (or maybe once in while changes our own!).


Greenwood said:
Nice quote. What's it relevance? (Yes, that is a rhetorical question.)

Rhetorical or not, the relevance lies in the following statement: "It is however extremely arrogant to take the attitude that you know what that judgement of history will be, especially when your opinion is currently the minority one".

Despite your protestations otherwise, you still seem to set much store in the fact that your opinion is backed up by the majority, and mine is not. If that is true, it is not arrogant (or hubris as you dramatically label it) but rather a sterile, impotent notion.

Greenwood said:
And I have not used it for that purpose. I have used it for what it is, evidence of the views of professional critics.

Sure doeesn't seem like that. Seems more like you use the similarity to the opinions of professional critics as evidence of the validity of your own.


Greenwood said:
Good for you. I applaud your integrity. Just refrain from imlying that your standard is the same as the industry standard.

I have never implied any such thing. You have inferred (incorrectly) that my standard (and here you read the noun while I was referring to the adjective) is the same as the industry's. In fact, this argument really stems from your dislike of opinions phrased in the declarative; thus you qualify your own opinions with filler like "in my honest opinion." Guess what? I already know it's your opinion. You don't need to inform me of that, and that qualifier is completely useless. So don't let a declarative statement gall you so much; argue against the statement itself, not the conviction of your opponent.

Greenwood said:
BTW you are misusing the word actuarial, but I will refrain from giving the dictionary defintion. You could try looking it up yourself, though.

Ah the pedantry knows no bounds. Take accounting if you like; or bean-counting if you prefer. Regardless, I think I'll have to start using the word transcend as you suggest--strictly by its dictionary definition. "The time in which I run a mile trancends yours." "The number of pens in my pocket trancends the number of pens in my wife's purse." "The Dallas Cowboys transcend the Philadelphia Eagles in football excellence."

You were right! I'm sure Winston Churchill would have thought you quite the language expert.

Greenwood said:
Then don't use words that don't fir your meaning, i.e. norm, if you don't really mean norm.

No, I must fully confess that the norm as I defined it did not take into account the lower echelon of film-like The Frighteners for instance. Still, the LotR movies are no better or worse than the norm as I see it.

Greenwood said:
Fine, just refrain from any phrasing that implies you have a higher standard than people who enjoyed the films.

Why are you so concerned about phrasing? If I truly believe that I have a higher standard than people who enjoyed the movies, is the way I phrase my opinions going to alter that belief in any manner? As it is, I don't believe I have a higher standard than all people who enjoyed the films, Foe-Hammer being a most notable exception.
 
Greenwood said:
I agree when he says these films contain: "some very fine acting and some excellent pieces of cinematography and special effect and because much of the original tale does come through."

I disagree about acting, which I find dreadfully stiff and unconvincing. Perhaps that is more a measure of the direction, but Elijah Wood has only two facial expressions in the three movies: dread and bewilderment.

The cinematography is at times moving, but trends towards the cliched for large stretches.

Special effects are excellent for the most part, but the special effects in The Phantom Menace were excellent too.

The original tale comes though primarily in the superficial sense, only occasionally does the heart of Tolkien's writing shine through.


Greenwood said:
I find the films visually stunning.

I do as well, for the most part. In the opening prologue, when Isildur cuts the Ring from Sauron's finger, and Sauron "explodes", the visual effect of row upon row of Man and Elf being flattened is stunning. The camera pan over the Argonath is stunning. The initial sight of Minas Tirith as Gandalf and Pippin ride toward it is almost stunning: all that's missing is the rising sun reflecting purple in Mindolluin's sides. The close-up of Gollum eating a worm at the beginning of RotK is not stunning. The confusion of the incessant battles--filmed all with hand-held cameras--is not stunning. I think it's interesting to note that the stunning sequences have much more to do with the scope of the story and the world; when Jackson gets up close to his characters, he loses originality except when he focuses on the grotesque (his obvious preference).

Greenwood said:
I enjoy hearing so much of the dialogue that I have previously only heard in my own head.

I really hate hearing the dialogue transfered from one character to another, or taken out of the original context (as it often is). It jars me out of the process of watching the movie, and usually is unneccessary to the translation from book to movie.



Greenwood said:
I am amazed at the care that went into reproducing so many things that are described in the books, sometimes only sketchily. Given the complexity of the story I am surprised at how much of it made it onto the screen and that pleases me greatly. IMO, Hollywood is rarely as faithful to a book as these three films have been.

I'm not really amazed or impressed. If the writers were more faithful to the book than is the norm in Hollywood (which I don't believe), then it is merely shades of mediocrity. Mediocrity, in the end, is mediocrity.

Greenwood said:
Do I think there are no Hollywood cliches in the films. Not at all. You cite the orc grabbing Merry's leg. Yes, I saw it coming. Does it bother me to the point of ruining my enjoyment of the film? No. I thought an even worse cliche was Gandalf grabbing Frodo's shoulder out of the dark in the FOTR when he asks: "Is it safe?" I immediately thought of Laurence Olivier's Nazi dentist in The Marathon Man (I think that is the right title). These things just didn't spoil the whole movie for me.

The problem is that these movies are full of such moments. Over and over and over again. Cliche after cliche. Unoriginal visual presentation of unoriginal material. When coupled with the plethora of alterations to the text--both large and small--the movies become banal from the standpoint of both cinema and adaptation.


Greenwood said:
The difference between the many Tolkien fans like myself who love the books and who also enjoyed the films, IMO is that we separate the books from the films. The Tolkien fans who so dislike the films do not seem to make that separation.

I could almost agree with you here, but for a couple of points. First, I have difficulty in separating the two, because I know the material so well. However, difficult or not, I have been able to detach myself from the books and view these strictly as movies. It is that detachment that leads me to say that the movies are wholly unoriginal in presentation. The themes and emotions are the same sentimentalities expressed in countless other films of the action/adventure/drama genre. Thus, I can conclude that the movies are no worse than a Braveheart or a Gladiator, but they are no better either. They don't even strike me as much better than The Phantom Menace: in fact the elements which make it a sounder movie are attributable to Tolkien and not Jackson et al.

Second, if your enjoyment of the movies stems from your ability to separate book from film, then why do you feel it necessary to justify the changes (even the smallest) which Jackson made to the text?
 
rs691919 said:
I don't understand why you repeat this statement when you subsequently say that their opinions neither support nor deny either of our opinions. If that is so, then it is not the "best we can do". The best we can do is examine the art itself, and not things external to the art.
I repeat it over and over since you seem unable to understand the point or in fact understand what you yourself have said. You chose to use the word "enduring" as a measure of the "artisitic merit" of the films. As I have pointed out over and over, none of us can know what the verdict of history will be; we cannot know if these films will "endure". You seem to think that you do know. But, I repeat the only objective evidence we have now on which to make a guess is the current assessment of these films. Yes, I like to point out that you are in the minority in your assessment, but that is because of your apparent arrogance in declaring you know what the judgement of history will be.

rs691919 said:
Despite your protestations otherwise, you still seem to set much store in the fact that your opinion is backed up by the majority, and mine is not.
See above.

rs691919 said:
Sure doeesn't seem like that. Seems more like you use the similarity to the opinions of professional critics as evidence of the validity of your own.
See above.

rs691919 said:
In fact, this argument really stems from your dislike of opinions phrased in the declarative; thus you qualify your own opinions with filler like "in my honest opinion." Guess what? I already know it's your opinion. You don't need to inform me of that, and that qualifier is completely useless.
I try to be careful to make it clear I am expressing my own opinions (I may not always succeed). Yes, I dislike opinions continually expressed in the declarative. They masquerade as facts rather than opinions. It strikes me as arrogant. (BTW, the acronym IMHO, I believe stands for "in my humble opinion", at least that is the way I have heard it translated. Perhaps you have heard different.)

rs691919 said:
Regardless, I think I'll have to start using the word transcend as you suggest--strictly by its dictionary definition. "The time in which I run a mile trancends yours." "The number of pens in my pocket trancends the number of pens in my wife's purse." "The Dallas Cowboys transcend the Philadelphia Eagles in football excellence."
I had no problem with your talking of "transcending the Hollywood norm". I assumed you meant surpassed/rose above/exceeded "the norm". I merely pointed out that by the standard measures used in Hollywood these films did transcend/surpass/rise above/exceed "the norm". The way you measure transcending/surpassing/rising above/exceeding "the norm" is irrelevant. Do go ahead and use transcend as you suggested above if you wish, but I am sure good old Winston would find your phrasings quite bizarre.

rs691919 said:
Why are you so concerned about phrasing? If I truly believe that I have a higher standard than people who enjoyed the movies, is the way I phrase my opinions going to alter that belief in any manner?
Why? Because that kind of phrasing is insulting and makes reasonable discourse impossible.

Moving on to your opinions of the films, I find them interesting though I disagree with most of them. I will correct one factual error in your comments. Gollum does not "eat a worm" in the opening sequence of ROTK. He eats a fish. He uses a worm to bait a fish hook (though the actual deed is done off camera). You seem to have confused the two together.

rs691919 said:
Second, if your enjoyment of the movies stems from your ability to separate book from film, then why do you feel it necessary to justify the changes (even the smallest) which Jackson made to the text?
It is not necessary for me to justify them. As a fan of the books with a considerable familiarity with them and as a fan of movies in general, I find it interesting to consider why Jackson made a specific change and in turn whether or not I think it worked. Obviously, a highly controversial change in the first movie was Arwen replacing Glorfindel at the Fords. I heard about it before I saw the film and assumed Jackson saw no reason for Glorfindel since he never appears again in any significant capacity in the story. I also assumed Jackson saw it as a way to increase Arwen's presence in the story so that movie audiences unfamiliar with the story would not say, "Who is this elf babe who appears just in time to marry the newly crowned King?" in the last film. I have not listened to Jackson's commentary on the DVD so I do not know if my guesses on his motives were correct. My question before seeing the film was would I think the change "worked" or not? In my view it worked fine. Quite obviously others disagree. Where I argue with people who did not like the change is when they declare that Tolkien would never have an elf maiden engage in anything so physically active. Or when they make the even more unsupportable statement that a Tolkien elf maiden would not use magic.
 
Last edited:
Greenwood said:
But, I repeat the only objective evidence we have now on which to make a guess is the current assessment of these films.

First it was objective. Then it was subjective. Now it's objective again. Well, which is it? Or is that too simple a question? First of all, go back and notice that the post in which I attempted to define "validity"--the meaning of which you did not understand--stated both "enduring strength" and "worth" as clarifiers. You have chosen to take the word "enduring" as the crux of my argument (something I have failed to comprehend till now--by my own fault), which it is not. You then posted the term "artistic merit", which I thought was a much better way of conveying the concept which I originally intended (thank you for that, by the way). So you can continue to wax lyrical about "enduring", but the concept is even broader. I call into question the validity, the worth, the artistic merit, the strength, the enduring strength of these movies, and your answer is: "The critics like it."

Now, like Titanic, I certainly do not think this movie will endure--in the sense that I think both the public and the critics will find a new flavor of the month sometime in the not-so distant future. But ultimately, I don't care if they "endure" or not. I don't care if the public still considers this one of the all-time great films ten years from now. Because, these movies will never demonstrate anything more than unoriginal, banal writing dressed up with grand special effects and majestic scenery. All that glitters is not gold.

Greenwood said:
Yes, I like to point out that you are in the minority in your assessment, but that is because of your apparent arrogance in declaring you know what the judgement of history will be.

If being in the minority has no bearing on the argument, then it has no bearing on the argument--no matter how arrogant I may be, no matter what hubris I may commit against the gods.

Greenwood said:
I try to be careful to make it clear I am expressing my own opinions (I may not always succeed). Yes, I dislike opinions continually expressed in the declarative. They masquerade as facts rather than opinions. It strikes me as arrogant.

If one has conviction in one's opinions, one shouldn't need to qualify them with "in my humble opinion." The masquerade occurs in the mind of a person unable to distinguish truly between fact and opinion. My intention is not to mask my opinion as fact, but to state my opinion with the conviction of Truth.

Greenwood said:
I had no problem with your talking of "transcending the Hollywood norm". I assumed you meant surpassed/rose above/exceeded "the norm". I merely pointed out that by the standard measures used in Hollywood these films did transcend/surpass/rise above/exceed "the norm".

Ah, but that is where you err. One does not use a word like "transcend" in the context of numerical measurement; thus your assumption that I would use "transcends the Hollywood norm" to imply that the movies do not meet the standard that Hollywood holds itself to is a complete misunderstanding of my statement (again, I have failed to note clearly where this misunderstanding occured--my apologies). "Transcends the Hollywood norm" implies artistically rising above that which is commonplace or average within Hollywood cinematic productions. It does not in any way, shape, or form, imply that the movies do not hold up to the standard by which Hollywood judges itself--namely financial success.


Greenwood said:
Gee, whatever happened to your protestations that you "never implied" your standard was the same as the industry's?

See above. The industry's standard, as defined by yourself, has more to do with gross revenue. My standard deals with artistic merit.


Greenwood said:
Why? Because that kind of phrasing is insulting and makes reasonable discourse impossible.

No, it doesn't. I'm sure that you think your opinion is right and mine is wrong, though you may not wish to admit it. That doesn't prevent me from engaging in disourse.


Greenwood said:
Moving on to your opinions of the films, I find them interesting though I disagree with most of them.

What do you disagree with? I would find that much more stimulating than esoteric (and ultimately idiotic) discussions about what the Hollywood norm constitutes.


Greenwood said:
I will correct one factual error in your comments. Gollum does not "eat a worm" in the opening sequence of ROTK. He eats a fish.

You are absolutely correct. My mistake.

Greenwood said:
It is not necessary for me to justify them. As a fan of the books with a considerable familiarity with them and as a fan of movies in general, I find it interesting to consider why Jackson made a specific change and in turn whether or not I think it worked.

Ok then, please describe some specific instances in which Jackson et al made a change and it did or did not work. I am interested in hearing your opinions on the good and the bad in Jackson's adaptation. So far, in my admittedly limited experience on this forum, I have yet to see you post a specific instance of the bad; when I stated that the charge of the Rohirrim does not actually follow the books, you felt the need to jump in and argue the opposite, despite the fact that the comment was directed at someone other than yourself. So, given that you obviously feel that the changes Jackson made at the Battle of the Pelennor fields work, give me some instances where the changes don't work.


Greenwood said:
Obviously, a highly controversial change in the first movie was Arwen replacing Glorfindel at the Fords.

It wasn't that controversial to me. I heard about it at the outset of the production, and indeed I included it in a lecture I twice gave in 1999 and 2000 regarding the difficulties in adapting Tolkien. Arwen doesn't bother me; it's the fact that Jackson (or Walsh and Boyens as the case may be) has Arwen carry Frodo over the Ford that is troublesome.
 
rs691919 said:
First it was objective. Then it was subjective. Now it's objective again. Well, which is it? Or is that too simple a question? First of all, go back and notice that the post in which I attempted to define "validity"--the meaning of which you did not understand--stated both "enduring strength" and "worth" as clarifiers. You have chosen to take the word "enduring" as the crux of my argument (something I have failed to comprehend till now--by my own fault), which it is not. You then posted the term "artistic merit", which I thought was a much better way of conveying the concept which I originally intended (thank you for that, by the way). So you can continue to wax lyrical about "enduring", but the concept is even broader. I call into question the validity, the worth, the artistic merit, the strength, the enduring strength of these movies, and your answer is: "The critics like it."
You claim I have mistakenly taken the word "enduring" to be the "crux" of your argument and you say it is not. Yet the last sentence in your paragraph is "I call into question the validity, the worth, the artistic merit, the strength, the enduring strength of these movies, ....." (emphasis added) You seem to be placing a considerable emphasis on "enduring" while claiming you are not. If you want to emphasize the word "worth" in your "validity" clarification I can point to box office again, but I don't think you want to go there. If you do not like my focusing on "enduring" stop making it such an important part of your argument. As for subjective vs. objective the questions of "worth" (in a non-monetary sense), "artisitc merit", and "strength" are all subjective. Once you throw in terms like "enduring" and "Hollywood norm" you have left the realm of subjectivity. To repeat, yet again, we can't know what is going to be "enduring". All we can look at is the current view and that can be "objectively" measured by looking at critical reception, including awards received. Once again for "Hollywood norm" we can get an objective evidence on the films from their professional and public reception.

rs691919 said:
If being in the minority has no bearing on the argument, then it has no bearing on the argument--no matter how arrogant I may be, no matter what hubris I may commit against the gods.
And it is because of your arrogance as demonstrated by your dressing up your opinions as facts by stating them in declaratives, that I so enjoy poking at it by pointing out your misuse of words like hubris (the gods punish you for it, you do not commit it against them).

rs691919 said:
If one has conviction in one's opinions, one shouldn't need to qualify them with "in my humble opinion." The masquerade occurs in the mind of a person unable to distinguish truly between fact and opinion. My intention is not to mask my opinion as fact, but to state my opinion with the conviction of Truth.
I try to clearly distinguish between my opinions and facts. If we are going to talk about confusion we might discuss the confusion caused by the supreme arrogance that leads a person to equate their opinions with Truth. (With a capital T even! Where is Zeus and his thunderbolts when he is really needed?)

rs691919 said:
"Transcends the Hollywood norm" implies artistically rising above that which is commonplace or average within Hollywood cinematic productions. It does not in any way, shape, or form, imply that the movies do not hold up to the standard by which Hollywood judges itself--namely financial success.
But Hollywood does not judge itself only by financial success. We have the annually presented awards from The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences, more popularly known as the Oscars. The Academy is composed of the professionals in the movie industry. The nominations are made by the practioners in each field, directors nominate directors, writers nominate writers, etc. and then all Academy members vote for the final awards. Who better to decide if a film "artistically rises above that which is commonplace or average within Hollywood cinematic productions"? With eleven Oscars the industry has clearly spoken quite loudly. Admittedly this is their judgement of the moment, but if you are going to fall back on what the future judgement will be you are back in your "enduring" bind.

rs691919 said:
The industry's standard, as defined by yourself, has more to do with gross revenue. My standard deals with artistic merit.
I have not limited it gross receipts; see above. If it is your standard than stop trying to imply it is anything more than your standard by carelessly throwing around terms like "Hollywood norm". You accuse me of pedantry, but it is not pedantry to ask that a person use the English language with at least a modicum of care and respect for the meaning of the words used.

rs691919 said:
No, it doesn't. I'm sure that you think your opinion is right and mine is wrong, though you may not wish to admit it. That doesn't prevent me from engaging in disourse.
Opinions are neither right nor wrong, that is why they are opinions. If they could be proven they would become facts. If you used the English language with more care and stopped arrogantly treating your opinions as Truth, it might be possible to actually discuss the films without these side discussions.

rs691919 said:
What do you disagree with?
It should be quite clear what I disagree with since I stated my views and you then gave a long list in contradiction.

rs691919 said:
So far, in my admittedly limited experience on this forum, I have yet to see you post a specific instance of the bad; when I stated that the charge of the Rohirrim does not actually follow the books, you felt the need to jump in and argue the opposite, despite the fact that the comment was directed at someone other than yourself.
"Yet to see a specific instance"? Did you not read my post in which I criticized the Gandalf "Is it safe?" line? It was only four posts back. Or do you insist I give at least one from each film? Fine. I didn't like the changes in Faramir's character in TTT (though I thought the EE redeemed him somewhat) and I didn't like the changes in Denethor's character in ROTK. I do not think he should have been portrayed as so crazed and I think there should have been more explanation of the reasons for his behavior (the palantir). As for my joining the discussion of the charge of the Rohirrim, we all join ongoing discussions. These are public forums and that is how they work. If you have objections to that you should not participate.
 
Greenwood said:
Then explain what "norm" you are talking about. So far the only thing I can see in your posts that might be considered a "norm" is a personal dislike of the films. You are entitled to that opinion (BTW have you seen ROTK yet? If not, you are not entitled to an opinion.) However, judging by objective criteria it does not seem to be the norm for the rest of the people seeing the film (both the professionals and the general public).
The fascinating duologue between my last posting and this one has left any answer from me redundant, but (!):
In this country at least, the idea of "the Hollywood norm" is almost a pejorative term; it refers to all the tired old details that rs describes, that are repeated over and over again, just with a few extra trimmings and the latest technical tricks to disguise them. If that "norm" is a straight line on a graph, then PJ's films can be represented by an awfully shaky line that sometimes reaches peaks way above the level, but for far too long waves gently along a few markers below it.
I do NOT have a "personal dislike" of the films; I've said that more times than I can remember, or count. I like some things about them, and dislike others; a perfectly reasonable attitude, and one which most people hold about most things.
Your comment about my "entitlement" to an opinion is patronising and offensive. Again I have said, many times, that if I make any comment on ROTK, which I rarely do, it is based on factual reports that others have given here, and which I see no reason whatever to disbelieve.
You may consider that you know the opinions of a majority of "professionals" - in which "professions" though? - but I have certainly seen some that have strong reservations. What you CANNOT know is the opinions of a majority of "the rest of the people", "the general public"; the fact that they have paid to see the films says precisely nothing about their opinions after they have seen them, nor is it relevant if they choose to see them several times.
 
joxy said:
Your comment about my "entitlement" to an opinion is patronising and offensive. Again I have said, many times, that if I make any comment on ROTK, which I rarely do, it is based on factual reports that others have given here, and which I see no reason whatever to disbelieve.
My apologies. You are of course entitled to your opinion and I regret making that comment. I hereby withdraw it. I suspect from the rest of your post you have not yet seen ROTK. Therefore, I would say that while you are entitled to an opinion about the movie, I consider that opinion to have no foundation other than bias and therefore valueless.

joxy said:
... nor is it relevant if they choose to see them several times
Do you mean that you have met lots of people who voluntarily and routinely pay money over and over again for something they dislike? The English must indeed be a strange people. :D
 
Last edited:
joxy said:
In this country at least, the idea of "the Hollywood norm" is almost a pejorative term ..
I assumed rs691919 meant "Hollywood norm" in a pejorative way. What have I said that could possibly give you the idea I thought rs691919 might mean it in anything but a pejorative way? The thing about norms is that by their very nature they can be transcended/exceeded/surpassed/risen above. No matter where you place the "Hollywood norm" this film has arguably transcended/exceeded/surpassed/risen above it.

[added in edit]The other day when talking about this discussion with my wife she reminded me of Garrison Keillor's line from his weekly radio program "Prairie Home Companion" broadcast on National Public Radio here in the States. His line is: "That's all the news from Lake Woebegone, where all the men are strong, all the women are beautiful, and all the children are above average." :D
 
Last edited:
Greenwood said:
You seem to be placing a considerable emphasis on "enduring" while claiming you are not.

In fact, I place no more emphasis on "enduring strength" than I do on validity, worth, artistic merit, or strength. It is yourself who is (incorrectly) choosing to emphasize that word above the others.

Greenwood said:
If you want to emphasize the word "worth" in your "validity" clarification I can point to box office again, but I don't think you want to go there.

Again, I don't wish to emphasize any of those words above the other. I am trying to convey a rather ethereal concept that perhaps the pedantic, concrete-thinking mind cannot grasp. In simplest terms, that concept is whether these movies are "good"--or rather, are they better than the Hollywood norm (which for me does exclude wholly worthless works such as The Frighteners)

However, if I did choose to emphasize "worth", then you could indeed point to the box office receipts, but it would be a largely irrelevant argument. The word "worth" does not connotate only a numerical value, and certainly my use of the word has nothing do with financial value.

Greenwood said:
As for subjective vs. objective the questions of "worth" (in a non-monetary sense), "artisitc merit", and "strength" are all subjective.

Indeed.

Greenwood said:
Once you throw in terms like "enduring" and "Hollywood norm" you have left the realm of subjectivity. To repeat, yet again, we can't know what is going to be "enduring". All we can look at is the current view and that can be "objectively" measured by looking at critical reception, including awards received. Once again for "Hollywood norm" we can get an objective evidence on the films from their professional and public reception.

Hardly. There is little objective about either "enduring" or "Hollywood norm" when applied to an art-form. Certainly, the Hollywood norm, when applied in a sense other than the pedestrian one in which you have tried to corner me into using, is subjective. Your norm is likely different from mine. But I'm sure that we could come up with several definitions as to what it means for a work of art to "endure"--subjectivity again.

The current view of the movies--as determined by "professional" and "public" reception--gives us no insight into the movies. It is an external irrelevancy which you have used repeatedly in fruitless attempt to assign objectivity to your view of the movies.


Greenwood said:
And it is because of your arrogance as demonstrated by your dressing up your opinions as facts by stating them in declaratives..

I do not dress up my opinions as facts; I merely express my opinions with the convinction that my beliefs are correct. One rarely sees qualifiers such as "In my opinion" in persuasive writing--still less such false pretenses of humility as "in my humble opinion".

If you misinterpret an opinion as fact, the responsibility for that error lies with yourself.

Greenwood said:
..that I so enjoy poking at it by pointing out your misuse of words like hubris (the gods punish you for it, you do not commit it against them).

I would welcome your educating me regarding the correct usage of the term hubris by citing a source a tad more authoritative on Greek civilization than dictionary.com. Start with the meaning of the Greek word hybris, and research it from there as it applied to Greek tragedy and Greek society.

Greenwood said:
But Hollywood does not judge itself only by financial success.

Earlier, you made it quite clear that Hollywood was primarily a commercial venture:

Greenwood said:
Whether you like it or not Hollywood is first and foremost a commercial venture. "Artisitic merit" comes second. By the "norms" of what Hollywood considers most important, what its very existence is based on, these films transcended the norms.

Artistic merit, in your view of Hollywood, is subordinate to financial success, and you have repeatedly stated that I do not comprehend that fact. I am therefore excluding the standard which you yourself claim as most important from my concept of the Hollywood norm. You have then inserted another standard, again one in which I have no interest and which is wholly irrelevant to my argument.

Greenwood said:
Who better to decide if a film "artistically rises above that which is commonplace or average within Hollywood cinematic productions"? With eleven Oscars the industry has clearly spoken quite loudly.

This is just another way of claiming the critical success of the movies as evidence that they are not merely average. It is, again, irrelevant.

Greenwood said:
I have not limited it gross receipts; see above.

But I thought Hollywood was primarily a commercial venture. Isn't that more important than artistic merit?


Greenwood said:
If it is your standard than stop trying to imply it is anything more than your standard by carelessly throwing around terms like "Hollywood norm". You accuse me of pedantry, but it is not pedantry to ask that a person use the English language with at least a modicum of care and respect for the meaning of the words used....If you used the English language with more care...

Before slinging such barbs, you might consider two things. First, usage of the English language is considerably more broad (and less concrete) than can be accounted for by dictionary.com.

Second, care and respect for grammatical precision and accuracy in writing is equally important:

Greenwood said:
I try to clearly distinguish between my opinions and facts....(With a capital T even! Where is Zeus and his thunderbolts when he is really needed?)
 
.

Put the book aside for a second and forget all the content errors. Just think as if there were no book for a moment. Once you see the EE DVDs you realize how great of movies they are. Even the EEs don't have everything in them, but they are alot better. I'm sure by the time ROTK comes out on EE DVD and you have a chance to watch all 3 in a row you'll really appreciate how much time they put into the movies. New Line cinema gave them $94M per book to make a movie with and they are lucky because the other company was only going to let them make it a 6 hour film. Imagine how bad that would have been. All in all this is the best motion picture trilogy ever made. We did get to see things that weren't described in the book if you think about it. Tolkien never describes anything about what the caverns of Isengard looked like, neither do you know exactly what happens at Orthanc when Gandalf goes there. Try not to be so negative, compare these movies to any other movie you've seen and the LOTR films are more than likely better.
 
rs691919 said:
In fact, I place no more emphasis on "enduring strength" than I do on validity, worth, artistic merit, or strength.
Perhaps you would care to enlighten us all as to your defintions of these words in regard to films instead of merely protesting you are misunderstood.

rs691919 said:
Again, I don't wish to emphasize any of those words above the other. I am trying to convey a rather ethereal concept that perhaps the pedantic, concrete-thinking mind cannot grasp. In simplest terms, that concept is whether these movies are "good"--or rather, are they better than the Hollywood norm.
I think we all know you don't think these movies are good.

rs691919 said:
The current view of the movies--as determined by "professional" and "public" reception--gives us no insight into the movies.
The professional reception of any movie gives insight into how "Hollywood" views the films and how "Hollywood" consider's they compare to the norm.

rs691919 said:
I do not dress up my opinions as facts; I merely express my opinions with the convinction that my beliefs are correct. One rarely sees qualifiers such as "In my opinion" in persuasive writing--still less such false pretenses of humility as "in my humble opinion".
We all believe our opinions are correct. Most of us do not consider our opinions equivalent to Truth. [following added in edit] We are all presenting our views of some films. Why is it so important to present those views as "persuasive writing" unless the aim is to prove one's personal view is correct and everyone else is wrong? Stating one's personal views with Olympian authority as if they are Truth actually diminshes the possibility those views will receive any serious consideration from others with different views. (IMHO ;) ) The views merely come off as arrogant and hinder any real discussion.

rs691919 said:
I would welcome your educating me regarding the correct usage of the term hubris by citing a source a tad more authoritative on Greek civilization than dictionary.com. Start with the meaning of the Greek word hybris, and research it from there as it applied to Greek tragedy and Greek society.
Actually it was the Random House Webster's and it did give hybris as the original spelling. Including that irrelevant fact would indeed have been pedantic as well as pompous. We can use the Encyclopedia Britannica if you would like: "in classical Greek ethical and religious thought, overweening presumption suggesting impious disregard of the limits governing human action in an orderly universe. It is the sin to which the great and gifted are most susceptible, and in Greek tragedy it is usually the hero's tragic flaw." Still no evidence for hubris to be against anyone.

rs691919 said:
But I thought Hollywood was primarily a commercial venture. Isn't that more important than artistic merit?
It is primarily a commercial venture. The word primarily is not equivalent to solely.
 
Last edited:
Just saw the following quote in Walter's signature here on the forum:

Whoever undertakes to set himself up as a judge of Truth and Knowledge is shipwrecked by the laughter of the gods. -- A. Einstein

Somehow, it seemed appropriate. ;)
 
Greenwood said:
I suspect from the rest of your post you have not yet seen ROTK. Therefore, I would say that while you are entitled to an opinion about the movie, I consider that opinion to have no foundation other than bias and therefore valueless.

Do you mean that you have met lots of people who voluntarily and routinely pay money over and over again for something they dislike?
You "suspect" that I haven't seen ROTK?
I said:
<....if I make any comment on ROTK, which I rarely do, it is based on factual reports that others have given here, and which I see no reason whatever to disbelieve.>
Isn't that near enough to saying flat out that I haven't seen ROTK, for anyone to get the implication without just "suspecting" it?!
Are you saying that the "factual reports that others have given here" are all biased, that I cannot rely on those others to have been truthful, and, therefore, that any opinions I reach on the basis of those reports are "valueless"?

Again, you force a suspicion that you didn't read what I wrote. I said:
<I do NOT have a "personal dislike" of the films; I've said that more times than I can remember, or count. I like some things about them, and dislike others; a perfectly reasonable attitude, and one which most people hold about most things.>
That's telling you that I do NOT dislike the films, and therefore your point about me, and anyone with similar opinions to mine, wasting their money, is irrelevant.

About this discussion of "norms": the level of rhetoric and lexicographical speculation has left me floundering, so I'm still not clear what's it's all about.
You say: "No matter where you place the "Hollywood norm" this film has arguably transcended/exceeded/surpassed/risen above it."
To which I can only add: which wouldn't be difficult, so what about it?
 
Last edited:
rs691919 said:
I would welcome your educating me regarding the correct usage of the term hubris by citing a source a tad more authoritative on Greek civilization than dictionary.com. Start with the meaning of the Greek word hybris, and research it from there as it applied to Greek tragedy and Greek society.

I apologize for this intrusion, but I've just got to say a word or two about "hubris."

What does Greek civilization have to do with this? How the ancient Greeks may have used "hubris" is completely irrelevant to its use in a modern conversation between English speakers, as it has developed a meaning of its own in English. And for that, dictionary.com should suffice. :)

I hardly think you would expect people today to conform to the original meaning of "weird," which was "fate."

The only language which does not change and evolve is a dead one.
 
joxy- I think Greenwood was assuming that the number of times someone watches a movie is proportional to how much they appreciate it. RotK has gotten more repeat views than most movies, so the assumption would be that it is more widely appreciated by the general audience than most movies. This is evidence which is suggestive of general trends, and it is evidence counter to your oft-repeated statement that we can never know what most people think of these movies.

rs- the conversation has of course moved way beyond the gates of Minas Tirith, but I suggest that you are quite incorrect with your interpretation of the events surrounding the charge of the Rohirrim. Ignoring (as you conveniently do) the necessity for showing the ordering of the Rohirrim after they blow their horns, there is still the fact that they arrive in the nick of time for those in the city, and they do manage to clear the gates of enemy forces, though they obviously do not clear out the enemies already within the city walls (what a trick that would be while on horseback). Immediately before the Mumakil charge the Rohirrim Eomer and Theoden alternatively say "Drive them to the river!" and "Make safe the city!"- we are also given a shot which shows that the forces of Mordor are withdrawing from the City (in the West) and being driven to the river (in the East). The charge of the Rohirrim frees the city from the immediate peril of the troops pouring into the city, and cuts off those enemies who are in the city from further reinforcements. True, it does not clear out the troops who are actually in the first level of the city, but the implication (based on Pippin and Gandalf emerging from the scrape at the second gate) is that the Gondorians are able to hold out in the second level until the battle out on the fields of the Pelannor is won.
 

Today's events

Back
Top