• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

New scenes -- new stuff to complain about!

joxy and PRH are more nit-picky then even me!

To me, I don't really care about whether it was night or day at Lorien. I also don't care when Gandalf spoke the black tongue at the CoE. The fact that he did and Elrond spoke accordingly like the book, lifted PJ's version of the CoE up drastically in my opinion. Boromir's extended speech also made my day. I still didn't like the dwarf axing the ring or the squabble or the rushed way the fellowship gets slapped together, but the extra scenes were straight from Tolkien.

Now that I think about it, Sam's comment about wanting a knife was a out of character and wasn't esteeming in the eyes of the viewer for Sam. I wish that had not happened. But overall, the extra scenes at Lorien stomped all over the theatre cut.

Something else I didn't mention is the extra scenes in Rivendell that explain who Aragorn is and where he came from (i.e. now we know what Arwen meant when she asked "Do you remember the first time we met?" Now we know because Elrond mentioned about Gilraen bringing Aragorn to Elrond.

I just don't understand how anyone can say that the theatre version was better. The extended version saved the movie in my opinion and it is a shame that most of the movie going public will not have this version to explain and interpret the other two movies (i.e. how the heck are they going to explain the gifts and broaches in the next two scenes?) The EE made so much more sense to the original that flopped and rushed through scene after confusing and empty scene in terms of character development.
 
Interestingly enough, my husband - who is NOT a Tolkien enthusiast though he read the books in his youth - said that the EE was not "too long" and that he got so much from what was added, that he did not mind the additional 30 minutes viewing time.

He likewise concluded that some of what was left in could have been eliminated or edited to include the comments, dialogue, scenes and addition to scenes that made sense of much of what occurred. He also said that the original film SEEMED long to him because he was frequently confused as to why what was going on WAS going on - and the EE answered many of the questions that arose in his mind when he had watched the original in the theatre.

My son-in-law (who has never read the book) LIKED the "staircase" scene (so did I, as a matter of fact), and reached the same conclusion I did when I suggested removing it to make room for the other more important plot-defining moments. He said that the scene was kept because it was action packed and exiting and the film NEEDED that sort of scene otherwise all you had was people just "walking and talking"! But we had just experienced the Watcher in the Water and the battle at Balin's Tomb - neither of which could be categorized as mere "walking and talking" and yet, according to my son-in-law, this additional "action" scene was "necessary".

Therefore, if one is basing one's "enjoyment level" on the number of fast-paced, hack-and-slash action scenes (as did my son-in-law), I am sure that one would vote to keep the "staircase" scene in and forego all that other boring palaver. On the other hand, coonsider the book: how many "action" scenes were there in FOTR after the arrival at Rivendell - or even in the entire book for that matter? To edit out essential character and plot development in order to provide time for action scenes - however unnecessary - validates my comment that Jackson's LOTR was essentially an action adventure film rather than what it could (and SHOULD) have been.
 
About the "staircase scene" which I aknowledge I liked very much, but that I would have foregone in order to have other scenes that would have developed both characters and plot: even that would have been better done - and MUCH more suspenseful if Gandalf had closed the second door in the chamber (against the orcs) and they had fled UNPURSUED through the larger chamber (heading for the stairs) and in the background, one heard and saw the coming of the Balrog. You didn't need all those orcs (who would have shredded the company once they were surrounded and the whole thing with their withdrawal made NO sense whatsoever!). They could have done the staircase thing with the orcs shooting at a distance (as happened in the book) just as it happened and saved quite a little time in the scene before by removing the orcs. It would have made more sense, it would have been more dramatic and it would have prolonged the climax of the appearance of the Balrog. It was this "over-excess" of special effects which took away from the suspense of the scene: it was orcs, troll, more orcs and finally Balrog when it should have been orcs (NO troll), door closed, no orcs in the dark chamber and the coming of the Balrog as was done so excellently in the film.

Mr. Jackson has yet to learn what Mr. Hitchcock instinctively understood: sometimes LESS is MORE.
 
Originally posted by Nóm
I mean PJ could have butchered the heck out of this story. Do people realize what he could have done?
Just think, he could have done a Bakshi, then think how much you'd all be complaining! Compared to that awful film, really it is, Jackson's would be considered brilliant, even to the critics here.
 
Certainly, Jackson could have done far worse. But, I truly must ask, is THAT the criteria one wishes to use? Think of how much WORSE it could have been?? Talk about those who see the glass as being "half empty"! I would much rather think about how much BETTER it could have been - and then hope that we may all learn that it isn't enough to have all the technological bells and whistles if we use them without consideration of what we create through their use.

Tolkien HAND WROTE his books for the most part. He didn't have a typewriter or access to a typist (because of the cost) much less all the wonderful technological stuff available to us today such as word processors. Yet, he created masterpieces. Technology can HELP produce wonders, but it can't do it all by itself and, furthermore, it can become a HINDRANCE if one becomes so enamored of its use that it becomes the focus of attention rather than the story - or is used to "make up" for a poor plot.

All of these threads used to fulminate on the films are actually quite unnecessary except as a means of expressing one's opinion on the matter. The films are MADE. Nothing we say here can help or hinder the Director. If one does not wish to HEAR criticism - or praise for that matter - then one either should not subscribe to a thread or respond in one. If, on the other hand, one is interested in the viewpoints of others, then by all means, read and contribute. But criticism is NOT "blasphemy" (as some seem to think) since not even Jackson has pretended to perfection.
 
Some of these insects are bigger than others, but:
Right there on this one!
It demeans Sam and clashes with the tone of the scene.
PJ loves these clashes, on various scales:
the little remark from Frodo about Bilbo maybe talking through drink is another, on the smallest scale- it brings that emotional,
if puzzling, scene sharply down to earth.
 

I did not say that he had "little care" to the story line, but that in the end, he was LESS concerned with it than he should have been as is evidenced by what he chose to leave OUT (Bilbo's few seconds of panic when he can't find the Ring in Bag End, Isildur putting on the Ring to escape the orcs and it betraying him to his death, Gandalf's recitation of the Ring rhyme in the Black Language etc.) and what he chose to leave IN (the long wizard's duel, five tree uprootings, one more shot of the Urak hai in their "run" to Parth Galen etc.).

As for "cramming more action" in the film, I must disagree. There was no other place he could have put in "more action" without degrading the plot to the point of nonsense, especially to those unfamiliar with the books. He could have tried to put in the warg attack, but that was not something that could have simply been "stuck in" somewhere. It would have required a considerable amount of time to "set" the scene together with the scene itself - and that would have made it too long even for an action sequence, always assuming, of course, that he still wanted to keep it at 3 hours! I disagree that even Jackson could have added any more "action" to the film without SERIOUSLY degrading the plot!

However, there can be no doubt that FOTR will be the most FAITHFUL of the films to the original work simply because those changes already made must be continued in the subsequent films and the natural reactions to the changes in FOTR that will occur in TTT will themselves provoke further changes in ROTK, etc. etc. etc. To paraphrase that old physics maxim: every action will produce an equal - and frequently opposite - reaction. But only time will tell the extent of these "reactions" and the subsequent "reactions" that they then produce.

Aw, heck! It should be fun, no?
 
But if you have seen the EE, you must have noticed - as not only I did, but both my husband (who is NOT a Tolkien fanatic) and my daughter (a STAUNCH Jackson supporter AND Tolkien fanatic) that he chose to leave out, edit and otherwise NOT HAVE IN THE FILM some EXTREMELY important scenes that would have [1] advanced the plot, [2] GREATLY improved character development and [3] made the film more closely akin to the original at least in SOME aspects.

Instead, he chose to delete these in many cases very SHORT but ESSENTIAL bits that frequently were not more than a line or two of dialogue in an ALREADY EXISTING scene! On the other hand, he chose to keep in the film many "action sequences" which were [1] overlong (the wizard duel), [2] redundant (the tree uprooting) or [3] irritatingly unnecessary (the "millions" of orcs who quickly surround the Fellowship after the Chamber battle - and just as quickly - and inexplicably - disappear at the approach of the Balrog).

I, frankly, can see no reason WHY the Director chose as he did when he could have had an infinitely BETTER film with "very little loss" in any of the action sequences and the "total loss" of none (the orc sequence is part of the LONG action sequence commencing in Marzabul and ending at the bridge). As we are told that Mr. Jackson is such a wonderful Director, it must mean that the decision was not an error of judgment, but a considered determination to extend or enlarge various "action" scenes at the expense of plot and character exposition - and that is what I mean when I say that Jackson "chose" to produce an action adventure film.
 

And that is the key. Some will argue that some of those scenes cut would not have been good replacements for some of PJ's other fabricated and drawn out scenes.

I for one agree with you, MM. I think cutting out most of Lorien hurt the movie. There were many areas where PJ could have cut out some of his nonsense and kept the truer stuff he decided or had to cut. It would have made a much better movie.

I am ready to view it again, that is how much the EE improved the movie. Yes, Arwen still stinks; yes, Saruman is still a lousy crony; yes, Aragorn is a selfish wimp who doesn't want to own up to his heritage. All these are bothersome and not true to Tolkien....When one can get past these major changes (and not justify them by any means!), the EE has made a much truer rendition of Tolkien's LoTR in cinematic glory and excitement.

I don't feel that I would ever like the original. The EE made a big difference in my outlook on the movie, not just because it put in missing scenes, but because it explained, meshed and moved the story and characters much better.
 
The one ABSOLUTELY CRITICAL scene that is deleted early in the movie is the very small and subtle bit when Bilbo "loses" the Ring. His mounting panic and hysteria begin to introduce the audience to the effect that the Ring has even on someone as good natured and apparently as "benign" as Bilbo Baggins. This makes sense of the scene after the Party where Bilbo is severely tempted to KEEP the Ring and must be literally browbeaten into giving it up by Gandalf. It is an intellectual and emotional "tie in" to the effect that the Ring HAS on people.

Remember, this is a CRITICAL POINT IN THE STORY! The Ring CANNOT be claimed - never mind "used" - by ANYONE but it's maker. It is wholely evil and corrupts not only those who possess it but those who learn of it's existence and/or are physically CLOSE to it if they have a DESIRE for it. Frodo possesses but has not CLAIMED it - until the scene at Sammath Naur (in the book at least) - and so, like Bilbo who also "found" but did not "claim" or "take" the Ring from someone else, the evil is much slower acting but there, nonetheless.

But without that little scene of Bilbo's "desperation", one might be tempted to wonder what the "big deal" was in the post-party scene with Gandalf. It made infinitely more sense, however, when we are aware of just how much under the influence of the Ring Bilbo now is and how great was his effort of will to renounce it.
 
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
As we are told that Mr. Jackson is such a wonderful Director, it must mean that the decision was not an error of judgment....Jackson "chose" to produce an action adventure film.
We don't have to believe everything we're told, and I understand that there is nothing in his previous record to justify the claim.
The film, especially in the EE, goes along fine, and I begin to believe the claims, then something ludicrous happens, and the suspicion creeps into the mind that maybe Mr J has a juvenile streak that he just can't restrain, that he choses to indulge himself in at the direct expense of Newline, and then at the expense of the viewer- and of Mr T.
Those shorts might just be an indicator of the streak.....
 
In answer to the good Joxy: I am giving Mr. Jackson the benefit of the doubt although I do not for a moment discount the fact that he may have a rather adolescent steak which delights in poking fun at what might be considered cultural shibboleths. Certainly, he has an absolute mania with Pippin and Merry and their antics - even in fairly serious parts of the film - and manages to display a sense of the absurd even when it inhibits the mood that he himself appears to be attempting to create.

I found this particularly true with his appearance as a very surly appearing character in Bree. I would much more have expected the Director - who has already claimed to be mostly "hobbit" - to have appeared in the Shire rather than the muddy, miserable, dark streets of Bree with a scowl on his face. It was almost as if he WANTED to be the film's Bill Ferny, an absolute rotter if ever there was one.

But you are right. Just as all is going along swimmingly, the Director seems to put in something that gives you that "wink, wink, nudge, nudge" feeling; that he is telling the audience to get in on the joke! That might work in one of A. Schwartznegger's "over the top" spoofs on his own films, but it is badly out of place in a serious film even where some of the main characters have large and hairy feet!
 
We can see already that PJ has created difficulties for himself by making changes in FOTR that will call for more changes in TTT, and then more in ROTK.
Rather than the First Law of Motion, I've called the process a chain reaction, and there's also the expression from another discipline, the domino effect. One (bad) thing leads to another.
"Oh what a web they weave when first they practice to deceive...."
"If it ain't broke don't try to mend it...."
 
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
I found this particularly true with his appearance as a very surly appearing character in Bree.
I'd meant to mention the idea of him doing walk-on parts as another hint of juvenilism. When Hitchcock came up with the idea
xxxx years ago it was a witty amusing touch; now it's so cliched it has to be almost childish- I've mentioned that before and been shouted down for it! Of course, I do take your point about the kind of character he chose to walk on as.
BTW His performance of Bilbo in rehearsal in a DVD extra is actually quite good!
 
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
....the Director seems to put in something that gives you that "wink, wink, nudge, nudge" feeling; ....telling the audience to get in on the joke!
Voice-over to several scenes:
"You don't really like all this high-falutin' nonsense, do you?; come on let's have a bit of a laugh!"
 
I frankly didn't mind him appearing, but why like that? It's almost as if he were DENIGRATING the story. Surely, someone who LOVED it as he claims to, would have wished to appear in a more positive light - and he had plenty of chances to do so (the fellow sleeping with the pig wasn't bad!). As it was, compared to most of the Bree folk (who in the book were quite gentle and kindly - with a few exceptions, of course) "Strider" appeared to be positively "sweet".

Furthermore (to bring up another point in the film). The Bree folk were not fond of the Rangers as noted in the dialogue. In the book (oiy!) Strider follows Frodo back to his room after sitting and speaking with him normally in the common room. In the film, he picks the hobbit up roughly and carries him up the stairs, closing the door. Now, really, folks! Who in that room would have allowed THAT to happen? Never mind the hobbits that were with Frodo, the INNKEEPER would have rushed up the stairs with a good stout staff in his hands to give any such miserable vagabond "what for" if he had treated a paying customer so badly with heaven knows WHAT that he yet intended to do! But in the film, nobody seems to be concerned that a stranger has been dragged off to a locked room by a man that they all considered little better than an outlaw!

Bree is presented by the Director as a VERY unsafe place. Why on earth would Gandalf ever suggest that Frodo go there! The way things appeared, he could have had the Ring stolen by somebody who wouldn't have had the vaguest idea of what it was - except that it was gold!
 
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
I frankly didn't mind him appearing, but why like that?
I don't either; I didn't know he did until someone here said so; and I agree that his choice of what to appear as was inappropriate.
The idea of appearing, which he apparently does in all his films, occurred to me as maybe another symptom of the childish streak.
And of course I agree about A's snatching up of Frodo; that's a nonsense to the book, and wrong in the film for the reasons you give: the attitude in Bree to rangers, etc.
 
The way that Jackson had it set up - if Frodo were to put on the Ring, it called the Riders IMMEDIATELY - I can at least understand Strider grabbing him once he became visible and trying to get him out of harm's way as quickly as possible.

What I DIDN'T understand was why everybody else there (except Frodo's companions) had no problem with his actions! Let's face it, what would YOU think under the circumstances - given the fact that you believe Strider is a dangerous man, perhaps even a murdering outlaw? If you were Butterbur would you have simply said, "Ho, hum!" and let it go at that? Certainly not! And even if Butterbur had not seen what happened, somebody in the room would certainly have TOLD him about it!

It's one thing to be inconsistent with regards to the story, quite another to be inconsistent WITHIN the story you are telling or just plain inconsistent with regards to COMMON SENSE!
 
LOL!!! I knew someone would find a way to use the EE against PJ, by pointing out what he cut and what he didn't.

As for myself, all I can say is this: I'd feel much more cheated by the EE were it to include 30 minutes of action instead of charachter development. The fact that it includes the latter gives me a hint as to what was going on behind the scenes: New Line putting pressure on PJ to include certain scenes and cut others. I have a direct quote from PJ on how New Line pressured to cut the gift giving scene out. I'm sure we can fill in the gaps and assume many of the other scenes were a result of this as well. As long as an EE of each movie makes it out I'm happy. One thing I do hope though is this: With FotR having made back the money it took to make all 3 films, hopefully New Line will let PJ get away with more. One of the first things PJ says on the commentary track is how New Line was very loose throughout the whole production, and started cracking down around editing time (in this case regarding the prologue). It's hard to imagine what kind of pressures were put on him, but given the size and sheer scale I can use my imagination. I still stand by the fact that the TC is a very good movie, in my opinion easily the best of last year. Indeed, although it might not say much, it's the best fantasy movie ever made, bar none. Having said this, the EE makes it a much better movie, and I'm sure anyone who enjoyed the TC will give this a rent, if not a purchase. Trust word of mouth to result in folks seeing this edition. And there are very strong rumours around the campfire that this edition might make a theatrical stint sometime, perhaps hand in hand with TTT prior to RotK.
 
My Dear Talimon:

Did you seriously believe that we would have been HAPPY to find that the things cut from the film were better than much that was left in? (and by "we", I mean SOME of those of us whom you call "purists"!) Surely, you would see that knowing that the film could have been so much BETTER, would be bound to make us MORE and not LESS critical of the Director!

Was "New Line" responsible? I don't know, but surely since the film would not have had to "lose" important action scenes (or at least not ALL of the scenes as I have already pointed out) and would have kept necessary plot and character development, I can't imagine why the Company would have given Mr. Jackson all that much trouble in the matter!

I think it is time to face the fact that the Director HAD a "vision" for these films - and that in FOTR it was exactly what we saw in the finished product. Part of his "vision" - in my opinion the BETTER part - was sacrificed in order to give play to that part of his "vision" which he considered to be more important but which I (and some others on the forum) consider to be infinitely inferior. There is nothing wrong with this, but it's time to stop blaming time constraints, fiscal concerns and New Line Cinema for what Mr. Jackson has created. This is what he wanted and this is what he got! And, frankly, as the film grossed well - and the subsequent films will probably do as well or better, he has obviously "read" his audience correctly.

Now, of course, what that says for his audience - well, that is NOT the topic under discussion.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…