Just think, he could have done a Bakshi, then think how much you'd all be complaining! Compared to that awful film, really it is, Jackson's would be considered brilliant, even to the critics here.Originally posted by Nóm
I mean PJ could have butchered the heck out of this story. Do people realize what he could have done?
Some of these insects are bigger than others, but:
Originally posted by Nóm
I am not using the criteria that PJ's movie could have been wrose to prove that it was good.
I was demonstrating a reason that in my opinion goes to show that Jackson was not making an action-adventure with little care to the story line.
If an action-adventure movie was his primary motive, and story-line were secondary or even 3rd,4th, or 5thary, then he could have crammed much more action in than he did, and hurt the story line so much that most of the defenders here would probably weep.
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
...he chose to leave out, edit and otherwise NOT HAVE IN THE FILM some EXTREMELY important scenes that would have [1] advanced the plot, [2] GREATLY improved character development and [3] made the film more closely akin to the original at least in SOME aspects.
We don't have to believe everything we're told, and I understand that there is nothing in his previous record to justify the claim.Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
As we are told that Mr. Jackson is such a wonderful Director, it must mean that the decision was not an error of judgment....Jackson "chose" to produce an action adventure film.
We can see already that PJ has created difficulties for himself by making changes in FOTR that will call for more changes in TTT, and then more in ROTK.Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
....there can be no doubt that FOTR will be the most FAITHFUL of the films to the original work simply because those changes already made must be continued in the subsequent films and the natural reactions to the changes in FOTR that will occur in TTT will themselves provoke further changes in ROTK....To paraphrase that old physics maxim: every action will produce an equal - and frequently opposite - reaction.
I'd meant to mention the idea of him doing walk-on parts as another hint of juvenilism. When Hitchcock came up with the ideaOriginally posted by Mrs. Maggott
I found this particularly true with his appearance as a very surly appearing character in Bree.
Voice-over to several scenes:Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
....the Director seems to put in something that gives you that "wink, wink, nudge, nudge" feeling; ....telling the audience to get in on the joke!
I don't either; I didn't know he did until someone here said so; and I agree that his choice of what to appear as was inappropriate.Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
I frankly didn't mind him appearing, but why like that?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?