Thorin
LOTR Purist to the end
- Joined
- Aug 20, 2001
- Messages
- 1,428
joxy and PRH are more nit-picky then even me!
To me, I don't really care about whether it was night or day at Lorien. I also don't care when Gandalf spoke the black tongue at the CoE. The fact that he did and Elrond spoke accordingly like the book, lifted PJ's version of the CoE up drastically in my opinion. Boromir's extended speech also made my day. I still didn't like the dwarf axing the ring or the squabble or the rushed way the fellowship gets slapped together, but the extra scenes were straight from Tolkien.
Now that I think about it, Sam's comment about wanting a knife was a out of character and wasn't esteeming in the eyes of the viewer for Sam. I wish that had not happened. But overall, the extra scenes at Lorien stomped all over the theatre cut.
Something else I didn't mention is the extra scenes in Rivendell that explain who Aragorn is and where he came from (i.e. now we know what Arwen meant when she asked "Do you remember the first time we met?" Now we know because Elrond mentioned about Gilraen bringing Aragorn to Elrond.
I just don't understand how anyone can say that the theatre version was better. The extended version saved the movie in my opinion and it is a shame that most of the movie going public will not have this version to explain and interpret the other two movies (i.e. how the heck are they going to explain the gifts and broaches in the next two scenes?) The EE made so much more sense to the original that flopped and rushed through scene after confusing and empty scene in terms of character development.
To me, I don't really care about whether it was night or day at Lorien. I also don't care when Gandalf spoke the black tongue at the CoE. The fact that he did and Elrond spoke accordingly like the book, lifted PJ's version of the CoE up drastically in my opinion. Boromir's extended speech also made my day. I still didn't like the dwarf axing the ring or the squabble or the rushed way the fellowship gets slapped together, but the extra scenes were straight from Tolkien.
Now that I think about it, Sam's comment about wanting a knife was a out of character and wasn't esteeming in the eyes of the viewer for Sam. I wish that had not happened. But overall, the extra scenes at Lorien stomped all over the theatre cut.
Something else I didn't mention is the extra scenes in Rivendell that explain who Aragorn is and where he came from (i.e. now we know what Arwen meant when she asked "Do you remember the first time we met?" Now we know because Elrond mentioned about Gilraen bringing Aragorn to Elrond.
I just don't understand how anyone can say that the theatre version was better. The extended version saved the movie in my opinion and it is a shame that most of the movie going public will not have this version to explain and interpret the other two movies (i.e. how the heck are they going to explain the gifts and broaches in the next two scenes?) The EE made so much more sense to the original that flopped and rushed through scene after confusing and empty scene in terms of character development.


