• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

New scenes -- new stuff to complain about!

I definitely preferred the theatrical edition. Although the extra bits were nice to see as a tolkien addict, they actually worsen the film as something to watch overall. Frankly, its just too long.
 
Originally posted by Talimon
[from PRH]"My point was that the scene was originally set up to fool the audience into expecting a Nazgul waiting for Frodo in Bag End."
It still fulfills that end.
WAS it deliberately set up for that purpose? The thought didn't even cross my mind that it was a wraith. Of course a reader knows it wasn't, but I don't see any strong reason why a non-reader should think otherwise, and I certainly don't undertstand why PJ should want them to- very childish if he did. Inserting the new scene does make it even less likely.
 
Last edited:
Originally posted by PRH

and this?:
16) Yes another weird edit: The Fellowship is aprehended just as they enter Lothlorien. It is probably late in the day but it was still decidedly before dusk. Then we cut to the tree tops and it is clearly nighttime. THEN introductions and greetings are made! Why the huge time lapse here?

Is it just always dark in the tree tops, or is the movie actually trying to imply that the Fellowship spent the night in the tree tops before heading to Caras Galadhron (as in the book)(and if yes, why would they wait so long to make introductions?)? [/B]

This was one of the (few) things that irked me about the SEE version, or are we calling it EE... :confused: Anyway, it is following the book: When the fellowship arrive in Lorien late in the day and they spend a night in the treetops. In the book, only Legolas and Aragorn can see the Lorien elves clearly. Remember the bit before Gollum tries to climb up the tree and Frodo is watching how still the elves are and how much they blend into the trees? I would have loved to see that in the film!

In FOTR:SEE the scenes follow the order of the book but don't make sense, at least as far as continuity. I loved seeing more of Lorien and FINALLY the golden wood actually looked golden! woo! Also loved the (too short imo) scene with them looking at the mallorn trees of Caras Galadhon from the hill.This gave you more perspective when they entered the 'heart of elfdom in middle earth'. That was worth it!
 
Originally posted by Talimon
Why do you assume it's nighttime? I looked over it again, and you can clearly see behind Elrond that it's day. It's just in a grove and shaded, but you can see it's daytime.
It's absolutely nighttime at the grave site! Compare the lighting to that of the Aragorn/Arwen bridge kissing scene. The bridge scene is clearly at night and they have the same sort of lighting. If that's not enough - listen to the crickets chirping away (compared to birds in the Legolas/staircase shot)!
 
Crickets? Call me deaf, but I don't hear any. Maybe some running water, and some birds way off. And that scenes lighting is very different from the Arwen/Aragorn scene. Look at the light reflecting off of the grave, at the light behind Elrond.
 
Originally posted by PRH
2) Frodo the interrupter: What a jerk! Why would Frodo butt in while Aragorn is singing nicely to himself demanding to immedietly know who he's singing about? That would've played a lot better if Aragorn had ceased singing and Frodo had paused and asked his question more calmly. It was a very nice little scene until Frodo crapped on it.
Am I the only one who thought Aragorn's singing was, well, crap? It sounded much more like "mumble, mumble, mumble" than singing the Lay Of Luthien. And this was supposed to be one of the main additions to the EE as well.
 
Originally posted by Talimon
Crickets? Call me deaf, but I don't hear any. Maybe some running water, and some birds way off. And that scenes lighting is very different from the Arwen/Aragorn scene. Look at the light reflecting off of the grave, at the light behind Elrond.
There are crickets and it is the same lighting scheme as at the bridge.
 
Re: Re: New scenes -- new stuff to complain about!

Originally posted by CraigSmith
....Aragorn's singing....sounded much more like "mumble....
The vocal line on EE often seems to get buried, and if Frodo heard Aragorn the way we do there's no way he could have made out what he was singing about- even if he HAD known the language. Nice idea, poor execution.
And WHY did Aragorn have to try to stop Sam singing? He wasn't even there!
 
To clear that up, joxy posted in another thread about the singing. Saves you doing it, joxy :)
Hey, I missed G's snores: I thought at first A had taken a swipe at SAM, then guessed he had just punched a cushion or something! Sam's song is great though; Astin really deserved to have the extra minutes he gets in EE.
 
Would you all kindly remember that everything you are saying is truly only your opinion. Some of you are having fun blasting the new discs and seem to take great delight in complaining while it just so happens that there are some of us who enjoyed the newly added stuff.

Here is my take on the scenes.

1) The redone scene 'Concerning Hobbits' was in my opinion skillfully done and brought out a great deal about hobbits that was missing from the book. I greatly enjoyed Bilbo talking about the lives of the hobbits about how they work the land, love beer, food, and pipeweed but how especially they love a quiet and simple life. This showed a little bit more why Bilbo and Frodo were considered 'cracked'. I also loved how they put in the Sackville Baggins with Bilbo running and hiding from them.

2) The scene at the Green Dragon in was lovely and even though it did somewhat inturrupt the suspence of the film for those who might be watching it for the first time, those of us who had seen the theatrical edition didn't really find that scene very suspensful any more any way. It added a lot more lightheartedness to the hobbit's lives by showing the viewers the hobbits singing and spending time together. It also added to the story of Sam's feelings for Rosie.

3) I loved the added scene with the wood elves going to the Grey Havens. The singing was exquisite and sent a chill down my spine. It was a very etherial moment. The next scene with Sam and Frodo finding discomfort with the ground which made up their bed was a good way of introducing the real suffering that the hobbits will have to go through not only from the enemy but from being seperated from the common comforts that they had been always used to.

4) After the hobbits go of with Aragorn there are various new shots and dialogue that just add to the story in general. The new scene with Aragorn singing about Luthien is lovely and it is interesting how Frodo surprises Aragorn by showing his slight knowledge of the Elvish language and how Aragorn seems to really be relating to the song as he thinks of his romance with Arwen.

5)They added in little shots here and there from this point on that again just add to the story. The extended dialogue with Aragorn and Boromir in Rivendell is good as well.

6) I thoroughly enjoyed the redone Council of Elrond scene with Boromir right from the beginning showing his desire to use the ring and Gandalf revealing how evil it truly is.

7) The scene with Aragorn at his mother's grave is beautiful if not slightly out of context with Aragorn's character from the book. Although it is interesting to see Elrond showing a more fatherly side towards Aragorn.

8) The fellowship's departure is beautiful and Elrond's speech is straight out of the book. Seeing Arwen's grief over her love's departure is another nicely added element. I also truly enjoyed watching Frodo bravely departing Rivendell and then quietly asking Gandalf to lead his steps in the right direction.

9) Even though some consider the scene with the restling hobbits and Aragorn to be slapstick, I thought it was fun.

10) The new dialogue outside of Moria between Gandalf and Frodo is a nice addition and I love seeing Gimli tapping on the walls trying to find the doors and then Gandalf's comment about even their own masters forgetting the secrets. "Why doesn't that surprise me?" says Legolas. A real funny moment.

11) I loved all the new stuff in Moria and won't get into detail because a lot of it was just extending fighting with a new addition of Aragorn saving Boromir's life.

12) LOTH LORIEN really made my day. Everything new in it was wonderful. The scene on the flets was interesting with Haldir speaking with Legolas and Aragorn. Gimil cursing at Haldir in Dwarfish because he was annoyed that the elf was speaking Elvish was hysterical. It was interesting to see Aragorn repremanding him. And for those of you who said how the heck could Aragorn understand him? Where in the book does it say that Aragorn hadn't had any knowledge of the Dwarf language. He might have. Then again he might not have. Who knows? It really isn't a big deal.

The scene with them travelling to the heart of Loth Lorien and then seeing the White City of Trees was delightful. Gave more golden light and feeling to the whole place.

I loved the newly done scene with Celeborn and Galadriel greeting the company. It was almost like in the books and it gave more character to Celeborn. Also it was wonderful to see Galadrial speaking so kindly to Gimli. Did you see the way he looked at her?

12) The part with the lament for Gandalf was neat. It was sweet of how Sam was miffed that the elves were not singing about Gandalf's fireworks so he just stood up and tried to do them justice. Aragorn slapping Gimli to get him to quit snoring was funny too. I didn't see it at all as ill humored on Aragorn's part.

13) The entire gift giving scene and the departure from Loth Lorien was beautiful. Celborn counciling Aragorn was good. I loved Galadriel even more as she gave the gifts to the company. It was interesting how she gave daggers to Merry and Pippin and how she saw the fear in Pippin's face so she encouraged him. It was cute how Sam also showed his fear of what was coming by asking for a dagger. The scene between Gimili and Galadriel was definately my favorite. He was so taken by her. I also enjoyed the dialogue between Galadriel and Aragorn. Oh, and that line where she says she will not see Aragorn again, that was in the book so it was not a fault of PJ's. Galadriel told Aragorn that she would not see him again but she did as she came to Aragorn and Arwen's wedding. Possibly Tolkien intended to show his readers that not even Galadriel could see the future as clearly as it would occur. The addition of Legolas and the Lembas was hysterical. They got that elf to smile alot more and then when Pippin says that he ate four of the pieces of Lembas, we were all laughing hysterically.

14) From then on there is more fighting added into the story and new scene on the river bank about Gollum and Aragorn's mistrust of Gondor. If I were to say that I disliked any of the new scenes it would have to be that one because Aragorn could have delt with the situation a little less harshly.
 
Last edited:
Re: Re: New scenes -- new stuff to complain about!

Originally posted by CraigSmith
Am I the only one who thought Aragorn's singing was, well, crap?
I like Nóm's points about why Aragorn's singing sounded like crap. Here's a little extra bit from the book further excuse Viggo's apparent lack of talent:
The Lord of the Rings, A Knife in the Dark
'I will tell you the tale of Tinúviel,' .... He was silent for some time, and then he began not to speak but to chant softly:
So not only do we have the move reasons that Aragorn was singing to himself and trying not to wake the Hobbits, but even in the book the lay was not sung but chanted, and not chanted loudly but softly.

Ariana- My opinion: I liked those scenes too.
 
Originally posted by Ariana Undomiel
there are some of us who enjoyed the newly added stuff.
I don't think there are many who do NOT like MOST of the newly added "stuff"!
You pick out some of the very best yourself: the new beginning is a vast improvement, Moria is better, Lorien is truly magnificent, the river scene even better than it was.
Where I clash with you is in your use of three words: fun, cute, and hysterical. PJ's idea of "fun" is very different and inferior to T's idea of "humour". Cuteness doesn't come into T at all. Hysterical laughter is completely out of place in the entire book and film, and if PJ really wanted to provoke that then his famous "vision" takes a severe denting.
 
Originally posted by CraigSmith
To clear that up, joxy posted in another thread about the singing. Saves you doing it, joxy :)
But I'll still take up a posting to say thanks! We Brits should stick together!:)
 
Just watched the EE on our new 65" Mitsubishi. Well, it was an eye-opener.

I still disagree with Jackson's "take" on many things - Aragorn especially, and other things as well. But still and all, it seems to me that most of what Jackson saw fit to cut OUT was what made the film make sense. It explained MANY things and often these expositions came so quickly (and succintly) that they only took a matter of seconds so there was no question that they were so long that they had to be omitted. Frequently, it was no more than a passing few words or a single scene. Of course, there were things that, though wonderful to see, could have been omitted without otherwise affecting the STORY line (like the inn scene in Hobbiton).

However, I noted many things that were KEPT in the original film that could have been abbreviated - the "wizard swinging" and one less than the five trees that were uprooted - to name must two. Also, the scene where they were being chased by orcs after the battle at Balin's tomb was alright, but being surrounded by orcs and standing there until the orcs fled at the coming of the Balrog was unnecessary since the Balrog was KNOWN to the orcs and allied with them. They would hardly have fled at his coming although doubtless they would have given him a wide berth.

Some film scenes could have been eliminated entirely - the "staircase chase sequence" in Moria added to the "action" but not the plot line. There was already quite enough action between the Chamber battle and the flight to - and fight on - the bridge. The time that staircase scene took would have been better used to include much of the dialogue and small scenes that defined the whole film. Even my husband - who is not knowledgeable in these things - said the film made INFINITELY more sense with the added scenes.

Those who said we would learn much from the EE were, in fact, correct. We learned that the Director cared more about making an action adventure than telling a great story. :rolleyes:
 
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
We learned that the Director cared more about making an action adventure than telling a great story. :rolleyes:
Is this the royal We MM? I'd just like to point out that this We learned quite the opposite: that PJ et al really appreciated the books, and were regretful of every omission. However, the theatrical release still got the story right (In the Royal We's opinion), did so in 3 hours, and was wildly succesful with both fans of the books and Tolkien virgins. Not bad for a proported horror-movie hack with nothing on his mind but action and gore.

ps- I want a Mitsubishi 65" tv. Do you even need to bother going to the theater any more?
 
Of course Jackson could have done some ridiculous things; in fact he DID some ridiculous things in my opinion. But inclusions of scenes such as the staircase scene - which was long - required him to cut other things that would have made SENSE out of the plot. For instance, he cuts out the part where Isildur puts on the Ring in hopes of escaping the orcs and it slips from his finger, betraying him to his death. My husband cried out, "So THAT'S what happened!" (That's called exposition and is NECESSARY if you are going to have a story!)

And there were countless other "small" bits - sometimes no more than a few words of dialogue, other times a short scene or an addition to a scene in the film. We could have done without the stolen fireworks scene if something had to go. Why did the Director care more about showing Merry and Pippin as silly practical jokers than as caring friends of Frodo and Sam? And the list goes on.

As for "we", I meant those of us who watched the EE - and that included my daughter, a hard-line Jackson supporter. She kept saying, "WHY DIDN'T HE PUT THAT IN? IT WAS NECESSARY!! However, somehow I suspect that the three of us (my son-in-law was happy with the action scenes and since he had never read the book, didn't care HOW the plot developed!) will not be the only ones to reach the same conclusion. But I will let them speak for themselves, if they wish.

As for the TV: my husband at 65 after almost five years of unemployment with all our expenses from medical and other problems (my son is in a wheelchair and lives at home because he CANNOT live elsewhere) has been forced to take a job in Connecticut where he lives four days a week. He bought the TV so that he could stay home and watch his films and his football games and listen to the sound on his hi-fi equipment. It was little enough to provide for his limited amount of pleasure and I don't begrudge it although I am not a great TV person and could have lived very well without it. I only mentioned the TV because it meant that I had a GOOD LOOK at the EE and was not squinting at it through a 19" set in over in the corner where I COULD have missed important things. (And, yes, for the person who asked the question in this or another thread - Gandalf's eyes appear to be two different colors in the scene with Frodo in bed in Rivendell. It's a response to the lighting: his right eye is in shadow and appears dark, the light is coming from the back left and shines THROUGH his left eye which makes it appear much lighter.)

As for going to the movies, I DON'T - except for films like LOTR and the Harry Potter films and a few others which I enjoy. Most - not all - of what passes for "entertainment" today I wouldn't pay to see. Remember, when you get to be my age, you will have PAID your dues. One still has the right - for now at least - to decide where one's hard earned money goes until such time as the government sees fit to take ALL of it and "redistribute the wealth" which in our case is very little, I assure you or my husband would be comfortably retired at his age!

Finally, such considerations as to how or where I watch the film has no bearing WHATSOEVER in the validity of my comments. It's a free country (for now) and I am as entitled to my viewpoint and to its expression as anyone else.
 
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
Finally, such considerations as to how or where I watch the film has no bearing WHATSOEVER in the validity of my comments.
If you hadn't mentioned it in the first place, Aragil wouldn't have had the opportunity to make his very brief remark, which I am sure was free of the implications you assign to it.
However, you've put many of my thoughts on EE into fluent words, so thank you for that!
 
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
Some film scenes could have been eliminated entirely - the "staircase chase sequence" in Moria added to the "action" but not the plot line. There was already quite enough action between the Chamber battle and the flight to - and fight on - the bridge. The time that staircase scene took would have been better used to include much of the dialogue and small scenes that defined the whole film.
Yes, EE confirms what we have been saying all along: that leaving out irrelevant scenes, such as the staircase, wizard-swinging, tree-uprooting, and orc-birthing, would have left enough time to include all the excellent new material, the full scenes and the very significant brief additions alike, and still left the whole film very close to Newline's desired 3 hours.
The staircase scene is impressive, exciting, and well done, except for the dwarf-tossing line, but as well as being superfluous it is also misleading, as Gandalf has just said THE bridge is close ahead, but now they have to cross the collapsing stairs which look like a bridge, and then reach the actual one.
 
Mrs. Maggot -

I agree with joxy -- aragil was just voicing a little playfully innocent jealousy.

As for this staircase scene - this is not wholecloth invention. After Mazarbul they do run down a staircase, and before Mazarbul they do need to occasionally jump over sections of the path which are missing. Combine the two and throw a few orcs in the mix shooting arrows and you have this scene -- which I loved --- probably more so than the 'big action setpiece' in Mazarbul. Not a waste of time, especially for the thrilling shot when they finally all cross the gap and start running down the stairs (with the upper section now falling into the depths), probably one of the very best shots in the entire movie.
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top