Would you all kindly remember that everything you are saying is truly only your opinion. Some of you are having fun blasting the new discs and seem to take great delight in complaining while it just so happens that there are some of us who enjoyed the newly added stuff.
Here is my take on the scenes.
1) The redone scene 'Concerning
Hobbits' was in my opinion skillfully done and brought out a great deal about hobbits that was missing from the book. I greatly enjoyed
Bilbo talking about the lives of the hobbits about how they work the land, love beer,
food, and pipeweed but how especially they love a quiet and simple life. This showed a little bit more why Bilbo and
Frodo were considered 'cracked'. I also loved how they put in the
Sackville Baggins with Bilbo running and hiding from them.
2) The scene at the Green
Dragon in was lovely and even though it did somewhat inturrupt the suspence of the film for those who might be watching it for the first time, those of us who had seen the theatrical edition didn't really find that scene very suspensful any more any way. It added a lot more lightheartedness to the
hobbit's lives by showing the viewers the hobbits singing and spending time together. It also added to the story of
Sam's feelings for Rosie.
3) I loved the added scene with the
wood elves going to
the Grey Havens. The singing was exquisite and sent a chill down my spine. It was a very etherial moment. The next scene with Sam and Frodo finding discomfort with the ground which made up their bed was a good way of introducing the real suffering that the hobbits will have to go through not only from the enemy but from being seperated from the common comforts that they had been always used to.
4) After the hobbits go of with
Aragorn there are various new shots and dialogue that just add to the story in general. The new scene with Aragorn singing about
Luthien is lovely and it is interesting how Frodo surprises Aragorn by showing his slight knowledge of the
Elvish language and how Aragorn seems to really be relating to the song as he thinks of his romance with
Arwen.
5)They added in little shots here and there from this point on that again just add to the story. The extended dialogue with Aragorn and
Boromir in
Rivendell is good as well.
6) I thoroughly enjoyed the redone
Council of Elrond scene with Boromir right from the beginning showing his desire to use
the ring and
Gandalf revealing how
evil it truly is.
7) The scene with Aragorn at his mother's grave is beautiful if not slightly out of context with Aragorn's character from the book. Although it is interesting to see
Elrond showing a more fatherly side towards Aragorn.
8) The fellowship's departure is beautiful and Elrond's speech is straight out of the book. Seeing Arwen's grief over her love's departure is another nicely added element. I also truly enjoyed watching Frodo bravely departing Rivendell and then quietly asking Gandalf to lead his steps in the right direction.
9) Even though some consider the scene with the restling hobbits and Aragorn to be slapstick, I thought it was fun.
10) The new dialogue outside of
Moria between Gandalf and Frodo is a nice addition and I love seeing
Gimli tapping on the
walls trying to find the doors and then Gandalf's comment about even their own masters forgetting the secrets. "Why doesn't that surprise me?" says
Legolas. A real funny moment.
11) I loved all the new stuff in Moria and won't get into detail because a lot of it was just extending fighting with a new addition of Aragorn saving Boromir's life.
12) LOTH
LORIEN really made my day. Everything new in it was wonderful. The scene on the flets was interesting with
Haldir speaking with Legolas and Aragorn. Gimil cursing at Haldir in Dwarfish because he was annoyed that the
elf was speaking Elvish was hysterical. It was interesting to see Aragorn repremanding him. And for those of you who said how the heck could Aragorn understand him? Where in the book does it say that Aragorn hadn't had any knowledge of the
Dwarf language. He might have. Then again he might not have. Who knows? It really isn't a big deal.
The scene with them travelling to the heart of Loth Lorien and then seeing
the White City of
Trees was delightful. Gave more golden light and feeling to the whole place.
I loved the newly done scene with
Celeborn and
Galadriel greeting the company. It was almost like in the books and it gave more character to Celeborn. Also it was wonderful to see Galadrial speaking so kindly to Gimli. Did you see the way he looked at her?
12) The part with the lament for Gandalf was neat. It was sweet of how Sam was miffed that the
elves were not singing about Gandalf's fireworks so he just stood up and tried to do them justice. Aragorn slapping Gimli to get him to quit snoring was funny too. I didn't see it at all as ill humored on Aragorn's part.
13) The entire gift giving scene and the departure from Loth Lorien was beautiful. Celborn counciling Aragorn was good. I loved Galadriel even more as she gave the gifts to the company. It was interesting how she gave
daggers to
Merry and
Pippin and how she saw the fear in Pippin's face so she encouraged him. It was cute how Sam also showed his fear of what was coming by asking for a dagger. The scene between Gimili and Galadriel was definately my favorite. He was so taken by her. I also enjoyed the dialogue between Galadriel and Aragorn. Oh, and that line where she says she will not see Aragorn again, that was in the book so it was not a fault of PJ's. Galadriel told Aragorn that she would not see him again but she did as she came to Aragorn and Arwen's wedding. Possibly
Tolkien intended to show his readers that not even Galadriel could see the future as clearly as it would occur. The addition of Legolas and the
Lembas was hysterical. They got that elf to smile alot more and then when Pippin says that he ate four of the pieces of Lembas, we were all laughing hysterically.
14) From then on there is more fighting added into the story and new scene on the river bank about
Gollum and Aragorn's mistrust of
Gondor. If I were to say that I disliked any of the new scenes it would have to be that one because Aragorn could have delt with the situation a little less harshly.