I'm with you in the discussion about their nature; but about their appearance I have to disagree: they're monsters in the sense of being large, otherwise, when seen individually or in small numbers, they're comical- well, they make me laugh! Except for the big one being dug out of mud, of course- he just makes me feel sick.
Originally posted by joxy
Except for the big one being dug out of mud, of course- he just makes me feel sick.
Of course, we get another result when Ugluk is in charge of things, but that's a topic for a different thread.Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
So even with a common desire, the orcs cannot overcome their conditioning EVEN for self-preservation.
Your evidence for this is what again? That we see faces of Orcs in the various split-seconds that Orcs are threatening the party? In the Fellowship of the Rings? In just what way does Saruman's speech fail to convey to you how the Orcs are dehumanized (in this case) Elves? Tolkiens own quote is that the Uruks/Uruk-hai/Orcs in general are good folk made bad. Again, this is exactly what Saruman's speech establishes- and that is what is scary about Orcs, not whether you see a few individual faces or not.Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
On the other hand, Jackson's orcs, although technologically impressive (except for the one who tippy-toes down the stairs in the Parth Galen scene), are not close enough to occasion in us the emotion that Tolkien WANTED us to feel - that is, a certain unease in the way that "absolute overlords" are able to dehumanize those over whom they have complete control.
I haven't seen many complaints about it; like most contributors I think it's made a big improvement to the film.Originally posted by Alcfalath
To everyone here....who have complained about the....<EE>
....Gollum, which shows how he caught up to the hobbits in TTT....
Gollum was Smeagol once, a creature unlike a hobbit.
....dont defile Tolkiens writings and his magnificent works by badmouthing the EE....
....if anyone has a problem....I apologise....
Oh for the love of....It's pretty obvious that you didn't even bother to read through this thread. You just went off the thread title and set to bashing us. Don't take the thread title at face value please...Originally posted by Alcfalath
To everyone here who is devoted to the writings of Tolkien, and who have complained about the Extended Version and the Extra scenes;
BE VERY ASHAMED WITH YOURSELVES, AND WAKE UP TO YOURSELVES .
If only tax was only on brass!Originally posted by PRH
I was just getting down to the brass tax
1]I suppose it was reasonable to introduce Gollum in FOTR, earlier than he should appear, and in that case you are right that his purpose had to be explained - and that should not have been omitted from the TC.1]Gollum....in EE, its explained that he was following the ring.
2]Smeagol....Tolkien wrote that he was MOST PROBABLY an ancestor of the shire hobbits, but was never proven....
3]....he ceased to be a hobbit, and became Gollum.
4]....many are just looking for a reason to hate Lord of the Rings because of the movie length
5]....who are we to judge what mistakes PJ made. ....
6]....seeing someone burn The Lord of the Rings Bound Hardback Book because they thought the movie was a waste of time...
So long for now
'What does this writing say?' asked Frodo, who was trying to decipher the inscription on the arch. 'I thought I knew the elf-letters, but I cannot read these.'
'The words are in the elven-tongue of the West of Middle-earth in the Elder Days,' answered Gandalf.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?