• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Peter Jackson is NOT a disgrace

Originally posted by simbelmyne

It's just that PJ is SUCH a disgrace (well, sort of), it's hard not to talk about it!

Man people, lighten up. Seriously, I admitt PJ screwed alot of stuff up. Like I said, just because something is a little different from what you want doesn't make it horrible and a discrase. I seems like all you people do in you spare time is to easily hate PJ and what job he done, find something better to do.

Hey, here's a thought, why don't you look at what PJ and crew have done for once! Jeez...
 
It doesn't work like that in a film (or anything else for that matter). At the end of the viewing, there isn't a balance sheet wherein one totes up the number of things liked vs. the number of things disliked and the judgment is made depending upon which gets the higher number. Also, many of the things that were wonderful (like the "visuals") are of lesser importance than a correct handling of the plot and characters. In many instances, Jackson's films follow Frodo's prescription of the servants of the Dark Lord: they look fair and feel foul.
 
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
Frodo's prescription of the servants of the Dark Lord: they look fair and feel foul.
Isn't that Aragorn's assessment of himself at Bree, inverted? Or are the PJ-isms getting on top of me and making me forget "reality"?
 
Originally posted by Éomond
....why don't you look at what PJ and crew have done for once....
We DO look, all the time, and we see that, for $300million, he hasn't done all that GOOD a job!
I'd want better value than that for my $3meg....
 
Originally posted by joxy
Isn't that Aragorn's assessment of himself at Bree, inverted? Or are the PJ-isms getting on top of me and making me forget "reality"?
Frodo tells the disbelieving hobbits that if Aragorn were really a servant of the Enemy, he would "look fair but feel foul". Aragorn then gives a wry smile and notes that Frodo must mean that he "looks foul but feels fair". Both characters use the phrase, but certainly I think that it is a very apt comment upon these films (Frodo's, that is!).
 
Let me some it up for all of you peoples out there.

You LIKE Jackson for bringing the books alive in a movie format that is well recieved to the NORMAL VIEWING PUBLIC as well as MOST FANS. You implore him to make more lotr movies (Hobbit) and although may not love what he has changed, you still RESPECT him for it.

You HATE Jackson for horribly corrupting the books in a few small instances and will never forigive him for butchering the books. You dont understand the movie world because you actually think a direct translation from book to movie is possible. You would cringe at the thought of Gimli's beard being 2 and a quarter feet instead of the tolkien specified 2 and 3 eights feet.


Now which one are you?? Either one or two, no inbetweens.
 
Hmm. Just a comment on the movie-side of things. These are some of the most successful movies of all times. I am not just talking about box-office, I'm talking about every single level that a movie can succeed on. Yes, they have broken many box-office records, and they are hugely succesful with the 'general audience'. The neat thing is that they are also hugely popular with the critics; that is to say, those professionals who have made it their point in life to judge films based on technical merit, etc. In fact (dare I say it?), the movies are pleasing the critics on a level which even the books never did.
Some technical awards that Two Towers was nominated for: Art direction, film editing, sound, sound editing, visual effects. Granted, how 'good' any of these aspects are in a film is subjective. However, (IIRC) these categories require nominations from within the field. In other words, it was experts in the fields of editing etc. that said that TT was worthy of Oscar nods, not studio execs or some such. I encourage all of you to state your opinions on what you liked/disliked about these films, but please keep in mind that when you are criticizing the films as films you are decidedly in the minority, furthermore you are disagreeing with professionals who by their career choice are considered experts in this particular field. Again, I think everybody has the right to voice their opinion. However, we should keep in perspective that when we say things such as 'these movies seem slapped together', we might be speaking from the tail end of the distribution.

If anybody would like me to post statistics, etc showing who thinks what about a given movie, I would be glad to.
 
If you think that Jackson's trashing just about every major character in the book involves a "few small instances" of deviation from the book, then perhaps you should re-read the book with an especial point of noting Tolkien's characters - that is, their characters and not just their physical actions. I think that you will find the word "butchered" would be more than apt, thank you.

However, this does not mean that anyone "hates" Mr. Jackson. Those of us who feel this way certainly dislike greatly what he has done with Professor Tolkien's characters, but this doesn't translate into any particular feeling one way or the other about the man himself. I merely wish that he had decided - given his personal view of life - to film some other story.
 

In your world view it seems impossible for me to exist. But, since I actually do exist, maybe the world view is somewhat wrong?
I don't go around hating people for doing something that didn't involve any physical or mental damage to other people. Nor do I like someone who really annoyed me with unnecessary changes to a wonderfull story which I have enjoyed reading many times and still do.

I like movies, especially good ones. I can really enjoy special effects and CG activity. Yet, if the story's messy, it hurts the movie too much for anything to make it up with. And in the case of TTT, that's what happens. Which makes it even worse, is the fact that I'm a big fan of a very similar, but much better story.
 

that was seriously uncalled for
 
The interesting thing I find is that many of those of us who do not care for Jackson's "reinvention" of LOTR are able to divorce the films from the book and enjoy the films for their own sake. (I am having an increasingly difficult time doing even that but others are certainly able to do so.) On the other hand, those who just LOVE these films seem to find some sort of personal animus for those who feel otherwise. For some reason, they take our criticism (however warranted) and parlay that into some sort of hatred for Peter Jackson - or even for themselves as film lovers! This is nonsense! I don't know of any film critic who demands that film lovers stop loving the films! On the other hand, I have seen film lovers who take it as a personal affront when someone criticizes the films, however just that criticism may be.

Like the films, hate the films or somewhere in between. It is up to the individual as to how he or she views it and that individual has every right to hold whatever opinion he or she holds. That being said, however, if a valid criticism has been made, it cannot be rendered null and void simply because someone "feels" otherwise. Jackson changed the characters, in some instances completely. If one wishes to accept those changes and has no problems with them, all well and good. But those of us who neither like these changes nor wish to "accept" them are also free to hold our opinion of Jackson's actions. It's as simple as that.
 
Originally posted by Evanescence
You dont understand the movie world because you actually think a direct translation from book to movie is possible.
For the greater part of FOTR, and for the beginning of TTT, it is obvious that PJ himself DOES
"think" a direct translation of the books IS possible - because that is what he gives us.
Does HE, therefore, "not understand the movie world"?
It is only when he departs from the direct translation, which he has shown he is perfectly capable
of rendering, for no obvious reason, and presumably to satisfy some strange whims of his own,
and quite needlessly, that we begin to state our dislike for the diversions.
No-one "hates" someone for not doing a particularly good job, but it is perfectly reasonable to dislike part of the product.
 
I don't begin to understand what that first sentence means; perhaps you'll explain it.
What I do know is that about a third of the way in to TTT, it DOES begin to look "slapped together" and that look gets steadily worse right through to the end. Many others here have seen that and reported it.
We have also commented many times that the views of professional critics and those who make awards are THEIR views alone. They are not and don't claim to be a "majority" or to represent a "majority" opinion. Frankly, they don't interest me one little bit, and they certainly don't influence my opinions of the films.
If they can't see the obvious flaws in TTT, including, and perhaps especially, the technical ones, then any respect I might have had for their professionalism drops to zero.
 
'Tail end of the distribution' is a statistical term, meaning 'both in the minority' and 'far from the center/mean/average'. Emm. I'm betting that's what needed clearing up, if not then ask again (and more specifically please).
I don't expect critical or even majority opinions to affect your own personal opinion of the movie (i.e. they SHOULDN'T, IMO). However, you are putting the film makers in a bit of a bind when you say 'The movie shouldn't be made to please the critics or the majority of movie-goers. It should be made to please me.' One might say that the movies could feasibly do both, but it's hard to argue that the movies are going to please everyone (at least not all the time).
 
I don't think that the films critics are saying that. However, what they are saying is that the adulation which seems to be poured out upon Jackson's efforts is not universal nor does it reflect the opinions of all serious students of Tolkien's work. Most of us "purists" who hoped that LOTR was at last coming to the screen have been disappointed not by all the attendant finery of these films, but by their basic content of character and plot. Mr. Jackson and his screenwriters had a treasure at their fingertips but they chose the dross over the gold and no matter how they "dress it up", that fact remains. Some people believe that this choice was dictated by commercial considerations, but from what I have read of Mr. Jackson's own "vision" of the story, I would opine that his choices had more to do with his own darker view of life than any concern with the box office.
 
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
I don't think that the films critics are saying that.
This was just my take on Joxy:
Originally posted by Joxy
If they (edit: the 'professional' critics) can't see the obvious flaws in TTT, including, and perhaps especially, the technical ones, then any respect I might have had for their professionalism drops to zero.
What this says to me is that Joxy considers there to be obvious flaws in the editing of the 2/3 of the movie ('What I do know is that about a third of the way in to TTT, it DOES begin to look "slapped together" and that look gets steadily worse right through to the end.'). Once you acknowledge that the professionals (those that nominated TTT for an academy award in editing) and the general public (those that have heaped money on this movie and who have consistently ranked it as peer to the Godfather series, Citizen Kane, etc) disagree with you, it seems that you are asking for a film that specifically appeals to you. Joxy can please clarify if he disagrees with my characterization. This is independent of how well the movie follows the book. Most of my posting has been re. simbelmyne's critical assessment of the technical merits of the film, which (again I ask for correction if I'm wrong) were not in regards to how well script followed book: Simbelmyne does indeed seem to be disappointed by the attendant finery of TTT, specifically those occuring after Gandalf heads out the door. H/She graciously states this to be their opinion, and I have simply pointed out that this perfectly valid opinion is at odds with both the critics and the general public. In other words, a TTT could have been made that was more pleasing to Simbelmyne on technical merits (even if Frodo jumped off a cliff and Gollum took the Ring to Mordor), but that the majority of critics and the general audience thought that it was fine in these technical aspects as it was. This does not even say that the critics & general audience wouldn't prefer Simbelmyne's preferred version. I'm simply trying to make a statement of fact to provide context to "TTT, slapped together or otherwise". How PJ's interpretations/additions effect the movie is (I believe) a subject for a different discussion.
 
Yes that was what needed clearing up - it's a long time since my maths course with stats in it,
and we were a bit more formal in the use of the terminology then!
WHEN I say?? That's never!
What I DID say was that I'm not much interested in what critics say, and I'll add now what I've said many times before - that no-one can know what pleases the majority -as a statistician you ought to know that!
 
I'm not sufficiently educated in the art or craft of cinematography to know whether it is the editing that results in the flaws. As one who has seen the films many times - and much enjoyed them, in part - all I can say is that I am not alone in seeing many occasions, particularly in those 2/3 of TTT, when blunders jump out of the screen at me, and at many others who have reported the fact here.
As I've said, I'm not much interested in agreeing or disagreeing with professional critics and awarders, but I insist there is no way of knowing what the "general public" thinks. They do indeed flock to the films, but that doesn't mean for a moment that they don't see the same blunders
that I and many others have seen. In this respect what I am asking for is not a film that "specifically appeals to me", but one that justifies the $300million spent on it by being of uniformly high quality, as film. I don't know enough films to make comparisons; I judge TTT on its own merits, and I consider those not enough to warrant high praise from me or from anyone.
I agree, this is independent of the quality of adaptation.
 
That last bit is true- short of asking everyone in the general public and always getting an honest answer (i.e. never), you will not be 100% sure in your statistics. However, with representative sampling and decent inference you can get a good general idea about these things. In the case of presidential elections etc, where the difference in Yea vs. Nea is typically approximately equal to you margin of error, it is difficult to generalize. However, in the case of TTT approval, the number of general audience members saying 'I liked' vs. 'I didn't like' has (IMO) left little room for doubt- the margin is wide and the number of responses is gigantic. That is not to say that certain subsets of the population (i.e. TTF folks, members of the Tolkien family) have a low opinion of the film. But in general, in every poll/rankings/box office statistic I have seen, TT has been overwhelmingly approved.


ps. I'm actually a scientician
 
Well I am glad i got your attention with my HIGHLY simplified (and largely wrong) sum up of the world. I just wanted to make a point that almost everyone has characteristics from both view points, which is totally fine (like me for instance). I wrote those overexaggerations to poitn out the faults in which a person says the movie was SLAPPED TOGETHER. Does anyone really think that? I do not disagree with mosts posts, (poorly written story, plot development, character changes) but I agree also.
I see the books and the movies as two totally different things, not two different genres, but two different "personalities." One must adapt a story for it to work in a movie, and movie to story. Adapt and only go so far, and I think that is where everyone is disagreeing. Was the adaption to much? (or to little?) Should there have been an adaption?
Basically, the movie is amazing in many ways, and disappotinted in many ways also. the viewer of the movie has to understand that his/her expectations WILL get in the way of what the perfect movie will be, so be OPENED MINDED to changes, except them for what they are (bad or good) and try to relish other parts of the book. Dont just focus on the negative.

So.... I love in The Two Towers Arwen and her love for Aragorn. I believe it heightens the audiences emotions and the underlying feelings we will have if something happens to them. I also like Golum. (who doesn't?)
I dislike Faramir, but can understand why Jackson put that in there.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…