• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Peter Jackson is NOT a disgrace

Originally posted by Evanescence
I wrote those overexaggerations to poitn out the faults in which a person says the movie was SLAPPED TOGETHER. .

i don't think it was neccesarily a "slapped together" movie cause PJ himself clearly knew where he was going with it, it was just a poor movie
 
No matter if it is a book or a movie, for me characters are always the most important thing. In making a movie about a book the most important thing for me is capturing the characters, to me it is more important then the plot or visuals. Characters are what make the story for me. The LotR films failed horribly at capturing the characters, no matter how good the visuals are I can not enjoy the films because of the character changes, TTT was the worst. Gimli, Theoden, and Faramir are my top three favorite characters in the trilogy and all three of the characters were destroyed in the film. For me the character changes shows disrespect to the author and the source material, and shows disrespect to the fans who love these characters.

I keep hearing people say that stuff has to be changed for the films, that it is impossible to film the whole book, and I agree with that. I understand while Bombadil was cut, the Barrowdowns, Crickhollow, all these cuts make sense. But there are to many changes that don't make sense, why change the ending of the Second Age from 3441 to 3434? was it nessessary to the film that that had to be changed? I can not find out why. Why in the begining do they say that Sauron forged the One Ring and they show metal being poured into a cast? I knew the difference between casting and forging in the 3rd grade. How could anybody who knows anything about LotR not notice that Fangorn is not north-east of the Anduin? These may be small points to some people but to me it is a big deal.
 
Originally posted by Melko Belcha
How could anybody who knows anything about LotR not notice that Fangorn is not north-east of the Anduin? These may be small points to some people but to me it is a big deal.

:confused:

The latest movie involving the story by J.R.R. Tolkien I've watched concerned a Fangorn situated west of the river Anduin, close to Isengard. I'm not going to comment on the technicalities involving ring-production, but when were the exact dates of the ending of the Second Age mentioned? Or were you being sarcastic?
 
Originally posted by aragil
....in the case of TTT approval, the number of general audience members saying 'I liked' vs. 'I didn't like' has (IMO) left little room for doubt- the margin is wide and the number of responses is gigantic.
....in every poll/rankings/box office statistic I have seen, TT has been overwhelmingly approved.
ps. I'm actually a scientician
Again, as any statistician knows, it depends on the question!
If asked for a straight yes or no to "did you like?", even I would find it quite difficult not to answer
"I liked"! There is enough good, even in TTT, for me to admit that I like parts of PJ's product.
The fact that more people express approval than the opposite does not mean that none of them saw the flaws and blunders!
Who are these "general audience members" who have actually been asked the question, in such gigantic numbers?
Rankings and box-office statistics say nothing to me, but again, where are all these "poll statistics", which give the overwhelming results?
Scientician? I guessed that it could only be a US term, and deliberately chose Merriam-Webster in which to look it up - but it's not there!
 
Originally posted by Melko Belcha
Why in the begining do they say that Sauron forged the One Ring and they show metal being poured into a cast?
For the same reason that a cave is full of barrels one minute, and they've vanished the next - incompetence!
 
Originally posted by DGoeij
:confused:

The latest movie involving the story by J.R.R. Tolkien I've watched concerned a Fangorn situated west of the river Anduin, close to Isengard. I'm not going to comment on the technicalities involving ring-production, but when were the exact dates of the ending of the Second Age mentioned? Or were you being sarcastic?

The line about Fangorn being north-east is when Aragorn, Legolas, and Gimli are chasing the Uruk-hai and Legolas says their traveling north-east to Fangorn or Isengard, can't remeber the excact quote.

The date for the ending of the Second Age is in Fellowship when Gandalf goes to Minas Tirith and reads about the description of the Ring that was written by Isildur, again I can not remember the quote but Gandalf says something like, "3434 the end of the Second Age". While in the book SA 3434 is the Battle of Dagorlad and the begining of the Siege of Barad-dur, the Second Age ends in 3441 with the defeat of Sauron and Isildur taking the One Ring.
 
I won't find fault with the cast/forged matter simply because most of the audience (myself included) were uninformed, disinterested and otherwise unconcerned with the difference between the two in the scene in which the matter appeared.

However, the here-and-then-gone barrels are in fact a matter of shooting scenes sometimes months apart in order to make some small change that has occurred to Mr. Jackson. In the same way, frequently riders in the same scene appear on two different horses (sometimes two actually different colored mounts!) within what is apparently a lapse of moments between the first and second shots. This again results when a scene is reshot months later - and the first horse has been sold! - and so the rider appears on a totally different mount! Indeed, actors have mentioned that lines which were learned the previous evening for a scene to be shot the following day had been complete changed by the time the scene was ready to be shot! This indicates to me that Mr. Jackson frequently (especially in the second film) was "making it up as he went along", something that became every frequently apparent as TTT progressed. Frankly, by the time the Director was halfway through TTT, he certainly should have known what he was doing. His constant reshooting and messing about did not help the continuity of the second film!
 
Like I said some people will not care about small details like the forging and casting, but i do not see how they could have people there forging swords for the films but not get it right in the prolouge. Casting is pouring molten metal into a mold, Forging is heating the metal and hammering it into shape. They are two completely different processes.
 
Or another description of "Forge" that may have some meaning here. ;)

forge v
To Make an imitation or copy of (a thing) in order to pass it off fraudulently as real
 
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
....frequently riders in the same scene appear on two different horses....
Different people notice different blunders: one man's metallurgy is another woman's zoology; chronology compares with geography!
If each person notices different blunders, and misses others, how many must there be throughout the entire product, and how did a budget of $300million allow them to reach the finished product?!
 
Originally posted by joxy
Different people notice different blunders: one man's metallurgy is another woman's zoology; chronology compares with geography!
If each person notices different blunders, and misses others, how many must there be throughout the entire product, and how did a budget of $300million allow them to reach the finished product?!
As I noted, I think Jackson simply couldn't make up his mind. He was like a kid in a candy store. Also, I believe that he began to find that the story was far more complex than it first appears - as anyone who has read the book many times can tell you! What Tolkien did in three decades, Jackson tried to do in two years; that is, make it all fit together. TTT is a great example of what happens when you think you "know better". I am not surprised that ROTK is going to have such huge battle scenes! I belive that Jackson uses them to "cover up" all of his loose ends and plot nonsense.
 
They are called blunders people, they happen in any film, and with a project the size of the lotr, THE BIGGEST FILM PROJECT IN HISTORY, undertaken by ONE DIRECTOR, is completely amazing. Back to the comment about capturing the characters, I think that Jackson did a wonderful job in capturing the characters in a MOVIE SENSE. He might have done them differently, but I still believe that he brought life to all the characters (although they might not be the "same" character from the book, ie Faramir, they still had essence on the screen.) And can we please get over 3 flipping years?????????? WHO CARES. IT DOES NOT RUIN THE MOVIE. NOR DOES THE CASTING AND THE MELTING AND THE FORGING.
 
Originally posted by Melko Belcha
Like I said some people will not care about small details like the forging and casting, but i do not see how they could have people there forging swords for the films but not get it right in the prolouge. Casting is pouring molten metal into a mold, Forging is heating the metal and hammering it into shape. They are two completely different processes.
Perhaps (in an obviously doomed endeavor) the filmakers were trying to placate the purists by using an oft-repeated error of the good professors:
from LotR, book II, chapter 2
For in that time he was not yet evil to behold, and they received his aid and grew mighty in craft, whereas he learned all their secrets, and betrayed them, and forged secretly in the Mountain of Fire the One Ring to be their master.

from LotR, book VI, chapter 1
His thought turned to the Ring, but there was no comfort there, only dread and danger. No sooner had he come in sight of Mount Doom, burning far away, than he was aware of a change in his burden. As it drew near the great furnaces where, in the deeps of time, it had been shaped and forged, the Ring’s power grew, and it became more fell, untameable save by some mighty will.

from LotR, Appendix A, III Durin's Folk
Of this Ring something may be said here. It was believed by the Dwarves of Durin's Folk to be the first of the Seven that was forged; and they say that it was given to the King of Khazad-dûm, Durin III, by the Elven-smiths themselves and not by Sauron, though doubtless his evil power was on it, since he had aided in the forging of all the Seven

from The Silmarillion, Akkalabeth
And Sauron hated the Númenóreans, because of the deeds of their fathers and their ancient alliance with the Elves and allegiance to the Valar; nor did he forget the aid that Tar-Minastir had rendered to Gil-galad of old, in that time when the One Ring was forged and there was war between Sauron and the Elves in Eriador.

from The Silmarillion, Of the Rings of Power and the Third Age
Now the Elves made many rings; but secretly Sauron made One Ring to rule all the others, and their power was bound up with it, to be subject wholly to it and to last only so long as it too should last. And much of the strength and will of Sauron passed into that One Ring; for the power of the Elven-rings was very great, and that which should govern them must be a thing of surpassing potency; and Sauron forged it in the Mountain of Fire in the Land of Shadow.
...
Therefore the Three remained unsullied, for they were forged by Celebrimbor alone, and the hand of Sauron had never touched them; yet they also were subject to the One.
...
The Ruling Ring passed out of the knowledge even of the Wise in that age; yet it was not unmade. For Isildur would not surrender it to Elrond and Círdan who stood by. They counselled him to cast it into the fire of Orodruin nigh at hand, in which it had been forged, so that it should perish, and the power of Sauron be for ever diminished, and he should remain only as a shadow of malice in the wilderness

from The Silmarillion, Index of Names
Orodruin: 'Mountain of Blazing Fire' in Mordor, in which Sauron forged the Ruling Ring; called also Amon Amarth 'Mount Doom'. 357, 363-6
I suppose one could argue that when the Professor said 'forged', he meant 'forged'. But then it becomes difficult to imagine how one could obtain a description such as Gandalf's:
` "The Nine, the Seven, and the Three," he said, "had each their proper gem. Not so the One. It was round and unadorned, as it were one of the lesser rings; but its maker set marks upon it that the skilled, maybe, could still see and read."
Moral of the story: "Meddle not with making purists happy, for they are detail-oriented, and swift to irritation"
 
Originally posted by joxy
Again, as any statistician knows, it depends on the question!
If asked for a straight yes or no to "did you like?", even I would find it quite difficult not to answer
"I liked"! There is enough good, even in TTT, for me to admit that I like parts of PJ's product.
The fact that more people express approval than the opposite does not mean that none of them saw the flaws and blunders!
Who are these "general audience members" who have actually been asked the question, in such gigantic numbers?
Rankings and box-office statistics say nothing to me, but again, where are all these "poll statistics", which give the overwhelming results?
A good question. The two that I am most familiar with are:
1) IMDB- the Internet Movie Database
http://www.imdb.com/top_250_films
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0120737/
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0167261/
Note that FotR and TT are ranked #6 and #8, bracketing that 'slapped together' Citizen Kane. Also note the average rating (out of ten) and the enormous numbers of votes for each film- over 103,000 for FotR, and over 55,000 for TT. In this scientician's mind 103,000 people is plenty large of a sample size to get a feel for what the 'average' person feels about the movies, and ranking on a 0-10 scale avoids the problems associated with 'yes or no' questioning.
2) Rotten Tomatoes:
http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/TheLordoftheRingsTheFellowshipoftheRing-1108476/
http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/TheLordoftheRingsTheTwoTowers-1118285/reviews.php
http://www.rottentomatoes.com/top/bestofrt_year.php
http://www.rottentomatoes.com/top/rt_awards.php
Rotten Tomatoes is useful as a measure quite independent of IMDB. First off, while IMDB voting is open to any who register (i.e. showing the opinion of the 'average' viewer), Rotten Tomatoes is for critics only. While Joxy in particular might not have respect for the critics' opinions, it is worth noting that RT takes into account 200/181 critics' votes for TTT and FotR, respectively, so it still canvasses a relatively large portion of the 'critic population'. Another nice thing on RT is two 'flavors' of ranking- one is an average score out of ten (just like IMDB- http://www.rottentomatoes.com/pages/faq#avgrating), the other is on the 'tomatometer' or 'tomatometre' scale (http://www.rottentomatoes.com/pages/faq#tomatometer), which shows what percentage of critics recommend the film. On the tomatometer scale, FotR received 94% rating, while TT received a 98%. This would be an answer to Joxy's 'yes or no' question- more critics actually recommend the Two Towers than RotK, it is #87 on the all-time 'freshness' list, and it is THE HIGHEST rated non-animated film with over 100 reviews. Not too shabby. In contrast, FotR (which most TTFers seem to regard as a superior film) gets only a 94% rating (less critics would recommend it). However, in average rating FotR beats TT by a margin of 9.0 to 8.7 (out of a perfect 10). The 'cream of the crop' (most popular tv/newspaper critics) becomes even more divergent. FotR rises to 97% fresh rating, while receiving an average score of 9.6 out of 10. TT gets a perfect 100% freshness rating, but falls to an 8.3 average score. And of course, if anybody is interested in awards, FotR and TT were both Rotten Tomatos 'Best Film' of their respective years.


And of course, if anyone out there is mindful of the almighty dollar, there's always Box Office Mojo:
http://www.boxofficemojo.com/alltime/domestic.htm
http://www.boxofficemojo.com/alltime/world/
http://www.boxofficemojo.com/alltime/adjusted/
FotR and TT rank (respectively): 12th and 7th in all time US gross, 7th and 4th in all time world gross, and 68th and 54th in all time US domestic dollars, adjusted for inflation (the last statistic is a little misleading, as films with multiple releases have all adjustments made according to the year of their first release).

So there you have it Joxy. I hope 103,000+ is overwhelming enough. And again, I don't expect these statistics to influence anybody's opinion on the movies (they SHOULDN'T!). However, when people start asking 'how could Mr. Jackson make such an inferior product with so much money and such a brilliant set of books for a basis?', I might respond with 'A lot of people/critics/pocketbooks thought the movies were pretty good, in fact some of the best films ever made.'
 
Originally posted by joxy
Scientician? I guessed that it could only be a US term, and deliberately chose Merriam-Webster in which to look it up - but it's not there!
Ah, another lesson in American pop culture, this time courtesy of the Simpsons:
Jimmy: Uhh, Mr. McClure? I have a crazy friend who says its wrong
to eat meat. Is he crazy?
Troy: Nooo, just ignorant. You see your crazy friend never heard
of "The Food Chain". [Flash to a picture of "Food Chain",
with all animals and arrows pointing to a silhouette of a
human.] Just ask this scientician.
Scientician: [Looking up from a microscope.] Uhhh...
Troy: He'll tell you that, in nature, one creature invariably
eats another creature to survive.
[Images of various wild carnivores attacking and eating
others appear.]
Don't kid yourself Jimmy. If a cow ever got the chance,
he'd eat you and everyone you care about! [Image of a cow
quietly chewing cud.]
A fun poke at the fact that propaganda often tries to influence the ignorant through the manipulative use of us scienticians, independent of whether or not the science actually agrees with the propoganda.
 
Originally posted by joxy
Different people notice different blunders: one man's metallurgy is another woman's zoology; chronology compares with geography!
If each person notices different blunders, and misses others, how many must there be throughout the entire product, and how did a budget of $300million allow them to reach the finished product?!

Look at www.moviemistakes.com ,at the link 'top films' (top, as in the number of noticed mistakes) FOTR and TTT are among the top ten. And this site exclusively lists movie mistakes, in other words, no mistakes concerning the difference between the movie and the true story are taken into consideration. Not that you can't enjoy a movie with a lot of obvious and less obvious mistakes of course.

And Melko Belcha, I do not remember those words by Legolas myself either, but I know for certain that Gandalf said 3434. Pretty sloppy indeed.
 
Originally posted by Evanescence
T Back to the comment about capturing the characters, I think that Jackson did a wonderful job in capturing the characters in a MOVIE SENSE. He might have done them differently, but I still believe that he brought life to all the characters (although they might not be the "same" character from the book, ie Faramir, they still had essence on the screen.) And can we please get over 3 flipping years?????????? WHO CARES.
It does not ruin the movies for you. Films are very subjective things. Many which receive critical acclaim do not appeal to me and others that have been "panned" I find that I enjoy. Furthermore, when a film is made about a story that I know and love, to find the characters pale imitations or even diametric to what they are in the story has a tendency to make the film less than a favorite of mine. How about a "gay" Sam Spade (The Maltese Falcon) or a cowardly Captain Blood (from the film of the same name) or a 300 pound Peter Pan? I don't know about you, but whatever "essence" such characters would have in the film would not overcome or make up for the director changing the character so completely from the original.
 
Originally posted by aragil
....us scienticians....
That certainly answers my question as to where all the statistics appeared, and yes, 100,000 is quite a large sample, even of the many millions who have seen the films. Those statistics with rankings 1-10 sound the most interesting and I'll check them all out.
So the word "scientician" comes from this TV cartoon? It must make a strong impression on its viewers, though the editors of Merriam-Webster have apparently not caught up with them yet!
 
Originally posted by DGoeij
'top films' (top, as in the number of noticed mistakes) FOTR and TTT are among the top ten.
Remember FOTR and TTT are also high on the list of the most expensive films - surely some of the millions could have been spared for the equivalent of a book's sub-editor. I don't expect an expensively produced book to be full of typographical mistakes. Why are so many people perfectly happy with the film equivalent of a badly checked book?
 
Originally posted by joxy
Remember FOTR and TTT are also high on the list of the most expensive films - surely some of the millions could have been spared for the equivalent of a book's sub-editor. I don't expect an expensively produced book to be full of typographical mistakes. Why are so many people perfectly happy with the film equivalent of a badly checked book?

Well, my guess is that the amount of mistakes to be found in a movie, is equivilant to the square of the size of a movie project, in terms of finance, people involved, stunt doubles, size doubles etc. etc.:rolleyes:

Somehow people seemed to have loved 'Titanic' by James Cameron as well. And as a personal side note to the statistics mentioned. Me and my younger brother really enjoyed 'Beverly Hills Cop III' when we saw it in the cinema. That one came out in 1994. I'm 23 years old, my brother is 3 years younger.

I find continuity errors like smudges being there and being gone in an instant (unless really obvious) less troublesome than Legolas looking over his right shoulder at the pursuing Uruk-hai when travelling south across the Anduin. Or obvious mistakes that are actually written down, like the 3434 in the Second Age and the North-east debacle as mentioned by Melko Belcha.
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top