• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Peter Jackson is NOT a disgrace

Originally posted by simbelmyne

As to PJ's Aragorn *sigh*, I think his moment of challenge with the ring is suppossed to be when Frodo offers it to him. There is the faint sound of A's name being called, and he looks confused and like he's about to cry (of course that how he normally looks, so not really a big moment)...Then, after he sends Frodo on his way, he gives the hundreds of orcs facing him a big smile. He has conquered his desire and is now ready to face death!!! maybe not. [/B]
I don't know. Perhaps it is his "moment of decision", but if it is, Jackson certainly doesn't make very much of it given the buildup we've had about the character's concern for his "weak blood". Furthermore, Jackson never built up the suspense with Aragorn at all during the trek from Rivendell to Parth Galen. He did give us moments of angst on Boromir's part, but even Galadriel takes Aragorn out of the mix when she declares that only one member of the Company is in danger of falling to the lure of the Ring. Once she has done that, what possible fear did Frodo have of Aragorn?
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top