Hmm. Just a comment on the movie-side of things. These are some of the most successful movies of all times. I am not just talking about box-office, I'm talking about every single level that a movie can succeed on. Yes, they have broken many box-office records, and they are hugely succesful with the 'general audience'. The neat thing is that they are also hugely popular with the critics; that is to say, those professionals who have made it their point in life to judge films based on technical merit, etc. In fact (dare I say it?), the movies are pleasing the critics on a level which even the
books never did.
Some technical awards that Two
Towers was nominated for: Art direction, film editing, sound, sound editing, visual effects. Granted, how 'good' any of these aspects are in a film is subjective. However, (IIRC) these categories require nominations from within the field. In other words, it was experts in the
fields of editing etc. that said that TT was worthy of Oscar nods, not studio execs or some such. I encourage all of you to state your opinions on what you liked/disliked about these films, but please keep in mind that when you are criticizing the films
as films you are decidedly in the minority, furthermore you are disagreeing with professionals who by their career choice are considered experts in this particular field. Again, I think everybody has the right to voice their opinion. However, we should keep in perspective that when we say things such as 'these movies seem slapped together', we might be speaking from the tail end of the distribution.
If anybody would like me to post statistics, etc showing who thinks what about a given movie, I would be glad to.