• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Peter Jackson is NOT a disgrace

Sadly, my friend, if you have indeed "waited for years" for LOTR to be made into film, you still must wait for that to happen for whatever else Peter Jackson created, it certainly wasn't LOTR! Oh, it had the names and the places and the general plot outline, but the meaning of the story, the "vision" of its author and the real point of the whole thing got lost under the mass of Mr. Jackson's rather large ego which determined that he - and not J. R. R. Tolkien - really knew how to tell the story!

I am happy that you are able to enjoy what Mr. Jackson has created, but whether you like it or not or whether you agree or not, what you are seeing is LOTR in name only. If that satisfies you, fine and dandy. But it doesn't satisfy me and I suspect that such is the case for the rest of us "purists".
 
Originally posted by hairyhobbit
PJ is no disgrace!

Purists, why do you seriously bother even viewing any of PJ's movies. Really, why???
You already know like everybody that Tolkien's work can tear shreads of PJ's adaption before even walking into a cinema. Unless posting endless passages of negative comments about PJ's work gives you some sense of happiness or fulfillment. Again, why bother?? Or better still, tell all posters what you have achieved in the world of cinema. What is your contribution to the world of cinema or what have you done to expand the publics appreciation of J.R.R Tolkien???? How about bugger all!!!
Oh my...This sounds like Foe-Hammer reincarnated!:D
Originally posted by hairyhobbit I have found that for all the extra "fluff" PJ incorporated into the cinema release, or information either cut out or character changes that occurred, the EE helps to smoothes things out (FOTR),please note not fix it, but rather settle, and I'm hopeing that TTT EE will be the same.
Amazingly enough, even with the Arwen fiasco (which came awful close to spoiling the whole movie), sputtering Gandalf, idiot Pippin and wimpy Aragorn along with some cheesy dialogue, the FoTR EE did impress me. Had they shown the EE in the theatres (after getting over the initial shock of the above mentioned PJ-isms), I would have been alot softer in my criticism of FoTR. The EE improved the theatre dreck version 10 fold. The difference between FoTR and TTT is that their wasn't much deviation from the book in FoTR, and TTT goes off on horrible tangents the majority of the time that only take away from Tolkien's LoTr, not add to it (warg riders, Aragorn's cliff 'death' and horse kissing scenes, Arwen and Elrond arguing ad nauseum, side trips to Osgiliath etc). Overall, FoTR was a much better movie than TTT from a cinematic perspective (and not because TTT is a middle piece of a three part story).

Even though TTT EE can only improve and flesh out the awful theatre version, no amount of adding or 'fluffing' can change the horrible damage done to the characters and meaning of the story. It can only help the editing and scene transition. Then you add in all the other fabricated PJ-isms that will only take away from the story, rather than add to it, and you don't have much stock left in being impressed with TTT EE. I am going to buy it and hope that some of the damage PJ did in the theatre cut can at least be minimalized.
 
Originally posted by Thorin
Oh my...This sounds like Foe-Hammer reincarnated!:DAmazingly enough, even with the Arwen fiasco (which came awful close to spoiling the whole movie), sputtering Gandalf, idiot Pippin and wimpy Aragorn along with some cheesy dialogue, the FoTR EE did impress me. Had they shown the EE in the theatres (after getting over the initial shock of the above mentioned PJ-isms), I would have been alot softer in my criticism of FoTR. The EE improved the theatre dreck version 10 fold. The difference between FoTR and TTT is that their wasn't much deviation from the book in FoTR, and TTT goes off on horrible tangents the majority of the time that only take away from Tolkien's LoTr, not add to it (warg riders, Aragorn's cliff 'death' and horse kissing scenes, Arwen and Elrond arguing ad nauseum, side trips to Osgiliath etc). Overall, FoTR was a much better movie than TTT from a cinematic perspective (and not because TTT is a middle piece of a three part story).

Even though TTT EE can only improve and flesh out the awful theatre version, no amount of adding or 'fluffing' can change the horrible damage done to the characters and meaning of the story. It can only help the editing and scene transition. Then you add in all the other fabricated PJ-isms that will only take away from the story, rather than add to it, and you don't have much stock left in being impressed with TTT EE. I am going to buy it and hope that some of the damage PJ did in the theatre cut can at least be minimalized.
Ah, yes, my beloved Dwarf, but the point still must be hammered home that the only thing that the EE can do is make Jackson's story "better". It cannot make Jackson's story into Tolkien's story. Thus if you big problem is that the films left the book a long time ago - I would say almost from the outset or at least from the beginning of the "diminution" of M&P followed by the "u-r-i-n-e-ization" of Bree, the "wimpization" of Aragorn and the "masculinization" of Arwen - then all the "EEs" in the world won't help the problem! Yes, they may make the Jackson version of LOTR (and how I hate to even have to say that!) better, but that is all that they can do. However, in the end they cannot make a silk purse out of a sow's ear which is what they would have to be able to do to win my vote!
 
My grandfather used to say" You can't make a turd shine." I am comfortable using that analogy of the second movie.
 
Originally posted by hairyhobbit
You already know like everybody that Tolkien's work can tear shreads of PJ's adaption before even walking into a cinema.
Yet, overall I'm happy.

You DON'T know PJ's agenda in this movie, nor financial responsibilites, and comprimises that have been made to get the book into a movie.
You're very easy to make happy, then!

We DO know what PJ said his agenda was - to present the works of Tolkien on the screen;
we DO know he had $300million to play with - and we see how he wasted so much of it;
we DO know AND accept compromises - only PJ doesn't compromise - he destroys!
 
I don't HATE Peter Jackson, I just think that he gets a little CARRIED away with his deviations.....THATS ALL and yes it does make me mad at times......;)
 
Originally posted by hairyhobbit
Unless posting endless passages of negative comments about PJ's work gives you some sense of happiness or fulfillment.

Well, HH, you make a fair point. Why bother to rail against PJ at all? Don't think I'm a purist, but here are my reasons...

I had no expectations about FOTR for exactly your reasons (although I had hope based on PJ's incredible "Heavenly Creatures"). It was a hollywood movie, could never equal the book, etc...I was glued to my seat during the opening of FOTR, popcorn frozen in midair. Because it was GOOD. Really good. I had forgotten it was possible to combine the traditional elements of a "good" movie (sound script, characterization, talented acting) with things that are now valued in movies...incredible special effects and precision editing. Not to mention it's one of the most well-paced movies ever made. I went back to the theater the next day. *gets on soapbox* More than that, FOTR was inspiring. There were real values talked about onscreen, themes to identify with... You can't change all the bad things in the world, but you can do what you can in the time you're given. If you're confused about what direction to take, follow your senses. How special friendships are, how easy it is to fool yourself... Many of the themes at the "heart" of LOTR, which is one of the most popular books in the world for a good reason. The book is very humble, and the movie seemed that way too...delivering great visuals while valuing nature, love and honesty. There were changes, most I was OK with, some I weren't. The mistakes and the bad choices were dwarfed :D by the overall phenomenal product. The bar had been raised for what an action movie could be. The EE just got better.

OK...I think it's great that people love watching TTT. I am the proud owner of "Never Been Kissed" on DVD for god's sake. Different people value different things in movies. So go for it! That said...

I expected TTT to be about as good as FOTR. But for PJ to make a B grade Hollywood flick?!? The facts are that the classic elements of a "good" movie were missing. Regardless of where it came from, the story was mostly mediocre and sometimes stupid. It's one thing to make an action movie, it's another to promise the audience more. PJ did (and delivered in FOTR).

I felt I had been let down by a friend. Not beause I was, or because I have nothing better to do, but because IT DOES MATTER.

WHY? Becaue a movie is a work of art being made NOW. It affects people and comments on society. A movie can shape the way people think. More and more, its about treating people like they can't think for themselves - "don't confuse them with a subtle plot, let's spoon feed them the story!" We deserve more!

PJ recognised that in FOTR. That's my problem. He let his ego get in the way and let the important stuff slide in TTT. He KNOWINGLY took the safe and easy way out when the added pressure was on. PJ's contribution to the world is movies, most people contribute in other ways. When the test came to"show his quality", he didn't.

Thank god J.K. Rowling is helping to shape/change minds. PJ should read up on her continuing theme "doing what's right is often a lot harder than doing what's easy". Sorry for being long-winded.
 
Originally posted by simbelmyne
I was glued to my seat during the opening of FOTR....Because it was GOOD.
I expected TTT to be about as good as FOTR. But for PJ to make a B grade Hollywood flick?!?
You're talking about the film that starts, after the prologue, with Frodo jumping out on top of Gandalf as if he is a long-lost cuddly uncle, the cart appoaching Bag End from two different directions, Bilbo dashing around and worrying about sponge cake, Gandalf bumbling around and bumping his head, and goes on to see M&P carrying out an idiotic potentially lethal act.
Yet I agree with you: FOTR, especially as the EE, is good enough, in general, and TTT is bad enough, to make TTT look as B-grade as they come.
 
Hey Joxy, in a couple of weeks, the EE will be released. I would appreciate your opinion of the EE. Also, I ask, that you view this as the main FEATURE movie by PJ (not cinema release), basically completly disregard the cinema version!! Reply if you are interested, within this post, this is open to all. I acknowledge your thumbs up for the EE of FOTR, lets see what the next EE is like.

I, Joxy am in fact difficult to please!! I have read and re-read Tolkien's work over the last 15 years, still keep coming back to it.I guess that in relation to PJ's work, I am more REALISTIC. Nothing can compare to Tolkien's work, which has immense depth,vision,language,culture and grandeur. NO big Hollywoodesque style adaption, could ever come close. Pj's is good on the whole (some changes deplorable), not brilliant!! Still love to have all three EE's in the DVD cabinet..... Wouldn't you??

See ya HH
 
Originally posted by hairyhobbit
Hey Joxy, in a couple of weeks, the EE will be released. I would appreciate your opinion....
Nothing can compare to Tolkien's work....PJ's is good on the whole....
Hi HH! HH just happen to be my real initials!
The release date here is 18 November, and if my suppliers are as efficient as they were with the initial DVD, I shall be watching TTT EE even before then! Thank you; watch this space!
I can't give "on the whole", but actually I think - and I've often said - that SOME parts of the films CAN compare to the original. The tragedy is that PJ can't, or won't allow himself to, maintain that high standard. Just imagine a film that was as good throughout as the FOTR EE "Concerning Hobbits", and one as good throughout as the start of TTT - they would be very close to Tolkien. What a tragedy that they have to stay in the imagination!
 
Sean Bean as Boromir's Acting

Boromir was not more noble than Faramir Mrs Maggott in either book or film. He is more consumed by the ring and shows greater weakness of character than Faramir. I think you confuse the qualities of the actor rather then the character:)
 
Re: Sean Bean as Boromir's Acting

Originally posted by Minas
Boromir was not more noble than Faramir Mrs Maggott in either book or film. He is more consumed by the ring and shows greater weakness of character than Faramir. I think you confuse the qualities of the actor rather then the character:)
Certainly Boromir was more noble in the film (the opposite of the book). Yes, he was consumed by the Ring in the end, but unlike the book Boromir, Jackson had his character explain to Aragorn that he wanted to please his father and "make things right if I could". In the book, Boromir made no such comments. Furthermore, in the film, Boromir had the decency to show some guilt under Galadriel's scrutiny while in the book, Boromir calls the Lady's motives into question.

However, if the difference in nobility between Boromir in the book and the film was slight and subtle, in the case of Faramir it was diametric. The film's Faramir is an entirely different character altogether. I cannot even think of one in the book who might serve as an example! Jackson's Faramir was a bully. His treatment of the hobbits was boorish and that cannot simply be explained by the necessity of leaving swiftly a place from which an attack had been launched against Sauron's allies (as was the case in the book). Signal among the examples of the film's Faramir's actions is his use of his dagger to pull the Ring from under Frodo's clothing. He then turns his head and leers at both Ring and Bearer in the same way some yahoo might leer at a well endowed woman's breasts. This is nobility? Then he is so soft in the head that a mere comment by Sam is able to turn him from his stated purpose to bring the most powerful and important talisman in Middle-earth to his father in Minas Tirith - and let the hobbits go! So Jackson portrays the character as both boorish and none too bright. I fail to see how you can adjuge that the film's Faramir was "more noble" than the film's Boromir since in my mind he showed precious little nobility at all - and you cannot blame the actor for that failure. The blame goes strictly to the Director and his writers.
 
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
....Jackson portrays the character as both boorish and none too bright.
I agree, and yet he shows even here that all too familiar characteristic of inconsistency.
Surely his Faramir should have despatched the messenger immediately to kill Gollum at the Forbidden Pool, rather than - with a touch of nobility? - hand over to Frodo the responsibility of saving him.
 
Unfortunately for the character, PJ failled to understand that a nobler man than Boromir doesn't equal a Faramir, even if he has the right hair colour, which the movie character does not! And his twisted idea of a noble man is of he who is able to reject the Ring and lives to tell it: thus Boromir died and Faramir survived.

At least that's what we get not only from the movie but also from PJ's arguments that Faramir was still there, only he decided to make things a bit harder to, in the end he thought, still present Denethor's son as he trully is..., hence, PJ's idiotic "genius" concluded, Faramir is better than Boromir. Again, unfortunately for the character, not only did PJ failled to grasp the dept of Faramir's nobility, he also failled to produce one who was nobler than his brother.

Why did noble Faramir refused the Ring? If the director had given enough attention to his own work instead of focusing on his hiper-productive ego he would have found several clues in the first movie. There are three characters that reject the Ring, another contradiction to PJ's bogus argument on his changes to Boromir's brother: Galadriel, Gandalf and Aragorn. All of them are lore-wise, at least enough to know what the Ring is, what it does, how it works and why it had to be destroyed: Gandalf shows that when he tells Frodo why he cannot take it, while Aragorn also knows what he's saying at the Council of Elrond when Boromir suggests they use it against Sauron; and Galadriel, well, goes without saying, I guess.

The similarities between Isildur's heir and Faramir should also be noted: both living memories of Númenor, both men of Numenorean blood. In the book, Sam tells his captor he sees a look of wizard in him, to which Faramir answers that the hobbit's probably discerning "from far away the air of Númenor". And like any good man of old, Faramir was naturally deep-minded, not to mention his physical traits that sometimes do seem to have a bit of elvish (1). Also common to both men is the fact that at one point in their lives Gandalf played some sort of role in their education, hence Faramir's close relationship with Mithandir and Denethor accusation to his son that he's a "wizard's pupil" in Book V, chapter IV.

So why was Faramir the kind of man that would reject the Ring right on the spot without a second thought? Because he had the necessary basis to do so: knowledge, wisdom, strengh of will and character, the very things that PJ's Faramir lacks. Like Aragorn he was of Numenorean blood, like Aragorn he knwen the lore and was deep-minded, like Aragorn he had been learned something from Gandalf: if PJ was anything close to coherent, he would have given Faramir that same capacity to resist the Ring he gave to Aragorn at Amon Hen.

So no, to in the end reject it or regardless of any intention to give the Ring to his father and not to keep it to himself - one of the most riculous arguments I have ever heard - is not enough! Faramir is not in the movie, even if there is a guy with a different hair colour but with the same name, who also claims to be the brother of Boromir and the son of Denethor and in the end refuses to take the Ring, wondering around in the movie. Once more, the resemblances with Tolkien's story is simply superficial, even if some do prefer to pretend that that's not the case: how people can get so desperate over the production of a movie and are willing to have any over none - even if the any stinks - is something I find hard to understand. Does their enjoyment and love for Tolkien's work (or its quality) depends on it being made into a movie or not?




(1) - From what I've read some time ago on the internet, it appears that Faramir does have some elvish blood in him, something related to the geneolagy of the princes of Dol Amroth. Any ideas?
 
Last edited:
Also, it is all important to note that in the book, Faramir noting Frodo's hesitancy as they speak of "heirlooms" takes an oath that he would not take "the thing" even if he saw it lying by the side of the road (that is, it belonged to no one and so he could not be considered as having "stolen" it from its owner/bearer). Therefore, when he learns what the "heirloom" is, he has already sworn not to "touch" it and hence, he is bound by something stronger than mere desire.

The difference between Jackson's and Tolkien's Aragorn is subtly made at the Council of Elrond in FOTR. In the book, when Frodo learns that it was Islidur who took the Ring from Sauron, he turns to Aragorn and says, "It belongs to you, then!" or words to that effect. At that, Aragorn responds in such a way as to [1] deny ownership of the Ring and [2] indicate that the Ring's fate was in the Council's hands, not his.

In the film, that interchange never happens because Jackson is busy building up the "frightened of my blood" business with Aragorn who obviously does not trust that he is strong enough to resist the Ring. Of course, he then goes on to do so quite stolidly throughout the first film with never a sign of weakness (go figure!) and it comes as no surprise when he is able to send Frodo on his way at Parth Galen. What does come as a surprise is why Frodo - having been in Aragorn's power twice now (between Bree and Rivendell and between the fall of Gandalf and Parth Galen) - is still concerned that the man might attack him to gain the Ring! Either Mr. Jackson's Frodo is too stupid to live or he has failed to maintain the business about Aragorn's possible fixation with the Ring. Either way, the plot suffers from the Director's reinvention of the plot line.
 
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
Also, it is all important to note that in the book, Faramir noting Frodo's hesitancy as they speak of "heirlooms" takes an oath that he would not take "the thing" even if he saw it lying by the side of the road (that is, it belonged to no one and so he could not be considered as having "stolen" it from its owner/bearer). Therefore, when he learns what the "heirloom" is, he has already sworn not to "touch" it and hence, he is bound by something stronger than mere desire.

Thank you! I had forgotten all about that detail. Indeed another example of Faramir's noble personality: an oath is an oath, a man's word cannot be broken. There's something like that in one of the lays in the Icelandic Poetic Edda, but I can't remember exactly where, only that it's in one of the heroic poems.
 
In ancient societies, the worst thing one could be was an oath breaker (treason was considered "oath breaking" because one betrayed those with whom one had a covenantal relationship). A murderer was more accepted than an oath breaker since if one could not be trusted to keep one's oath, what trust could there possibly be anywhere? Hence, Faramir tells Frodo that his people seldom take an oath (because of the serious nature of that action) but once an oath is given, they will die in the keeping of it rather than break it.

Interestingly enough, Tolkien is able to prevent Boromir from going to his death as an oath breaker because Elrond demands no oath of the Fellowship upon its departure from Rivendell save only Frodo who is bound by his oath not to give the Ring to any servant of the Enemy or throw it away or let anyone handle it save members of the Fellowship and only then at great need. The others realize that the are in the Fellowship to help the Bearer to fulfill his quest, but an oath is demanded from none of them. And so, when Boromir attempts to take the Ring from Frodo, he has no oath binding him against that act. I think this was deliberate on Tolkien's part and a very nice way of handling the matter since had Boromir broken his sworn oath, what redemption could he claim? Even his sacrifical death would not have been enough in the culture Tolkien presents to us. However, as it was, Boromir was not even supposed to go with the Bearer to the Fire, but he and Aragorn were bound for Minas Tirith to defend that City. Of course, the death of Gandalf change Aragorn's plans, but Boromir was still considered as going "home" when the Fellowship came to Parth Galen.
 
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
In ancient societies, the worst thing one could be was an oath breaker (treason was considered "oath breaking" because one betrayed those with whom one had a covenantal relationship). A murderer was more accepted than an oath breaker since if one could not be trusted to keep one's oath, what trust could there possibly be anywhere? Hence, Faramir tells Frodo that his people seldom take an oath (because of the serious nature of that action) but once an oath is given, they will die in the keeping of it rather than break it.

:) If I was already feeling happy by becoming a member of a Tolkien forum where I found people with great critical sense and deep knowledge of the book, who aren't bound to be stunned by the fireworks of PJ's movies and actually disliked them, I'm even more happy now as I finally found a Tolkien forum where there are also people with a minimal and consistent knowledge of old societies. Thank you and thank Gods! I was beginning to think that a good conversation on Tolkien's work and pre-Christian Europe was something I could only find in highly academic circles, as the best so far had been basic and small chats with a considerable amount of uncritical source reliance and absence of a good reading.
 
Just thought I'd pop in

If you two keep it up the mods will have to move this thread to the book section. ;)

None of your arguments are changing my mind about the movies, but I am seriously enjoying the character analysis that is going on here. If possible, it has even deepened my appreciation of the books, and I simply can't wait to 'meet' Faramir once again after all these insightful posts on his character.

My sincere thanks. :)
 
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
And so, when Boromir attempts to take the Ring from Frodo, he has no oath binding him against that act...Even his sacrifical death would not have been enough in the culture Tolkien presents to us.

I also am loving this discussion! :) Although I've read the book about 10 times I always thought that Boromir HAD broken his word in some way by manhandling Frodo, and that the breaking of his oath was the "reason" for his death....once again others (Mrs. M's insight :)) have pointed out what I have missed...B only says "so be it" when the fate of the ring is decided. I'll have to remember that the next time I want to get out of something!!

As to PJ's Aragorn *sigh*, I think his moment of challenge with the ring is suppossed to be when Frodo offers it to him. There is the faint sound of A's name being called, and he looks confused and like he's about to cry (of course that how he normally looks, so not really a big moment)...Then, after he sends Frodo on his way, he gives the hundreds of orcs facing him a big smile. He has conquered his desire and is now ready to face death!!! maybe not.
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top