WizardMagus
New Member
- Joined
- Nov 21, 2003
- Messages
- 12
If I recall correctly, in one of the books, it said that prior to Aragorn and Arwen, only two other Human-Elf couples existed. Then again, it clearly stated that Prince Imrahil, of Dol Amroth, had a fair bit of Elven blood in him. While it is possible that he could just be a descendant of Elros, it seemed to me that Tolkien implied he was more Elven than the other Numenoreans. He made a bigger deal of it than with, say, Faramir. He also talked about some Elves who had passed that way (wasn't one of them called Amroth?), implying that they mated with humans there, leading to Imrahil.
So, that means one of a few things:
A) Prince Imrahil is no more Elven than any of the other Numenoreans, but showed more qualities of it than they did.
B) Tolkien came up with Imrahil's character after the statement of there only being three Human-Elf couples.
C) Tolkien forgot about Imrahil, when making that statement.
I don't have a copy of the book with me, or else I would just reread that section again in hopes it would answer it. Does anyone know whether Imrahil really has more recent Elven blood than Elros?
So, that means one of a few things:
A) Prince Imrahil is no more Elven than any of the other Numenoreans, but showed more qualities of it than they did.
B) Tolkien came up with Imrahil's character after the statement of there only being three Human-Elf couples.
C) Tolkien forgot about Imrahil, when making that statement.
I don't have a copy of the book with me, or else I would just reread that section again in hopes it would answer it. Does anyone know whether Imrahil really has more recent Elven blood than Elros?
