• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

The Hall of Essays

A Bonus... NOT TO BE JUDGED!

"In the pits of Sauron Beren and Felagund lay..."

- Aghhhhhhh!!!

These eyes. Hollow eyes. So cold and misty... seem like pale lights of fires gleaming among a mist that gathers at the foot of the hills at dusk... flooded by darkness deeper than that of the night's cloak. Like a nightmare. Yet, it is not a dream we are in. They are real, maybe even too real. Lethal... merciless... deadly-accurate... killing at will. Eyes. Mirrors of a tormented fëa - wild spirit ensnared inside a ruthless body of a wolf. Mad, furious, never at ease... the werewolf of Sauron. He threatened to slay us cruelly, unless one would betray the truth about our names and purposes... and he kept his word. Surely he is called Gorthaur the Cruel.

- No, please!! Noooo!! Aghhh!!

My people. Ten of them. The ten. The truest, most faithful, the only ones to stay loyal to his King. To me. My companions, my... friends. How will I ever repay you? You came along with me on this hopless road though I was abandoned by all. They broke their oaths of faith. You stayed until the bitter end, in this dungeon of misery and suffering. Put to a terrible test and still remained loyal; even now, when death, looking into your eyes, takes away these last breaths of your being and sends your spirits back to the Halls of Awaiting, far in the West.

- Edrahil...

- My Lor...<snap>

That was the last of them. The last of my companions. Farewell, my friends, farewell. Now it is only me. Left alone. With him. The child of Men. Men... I remember well my first encounter with them. In Ossiriand. They were so joyful and carefree. Seemed as the ones who had reached at last the land whithout fear. I remember all: my first teachings to them, long debates about their past, Bëor offering his service to the house of Finarfin. Bëor the Old. I will always remember him. And Barahir... how could I ever forget him? It was thanks to his mighty deed, brave and mad at the same time, that I can be here... yes, I'm here because of Barahir, because of him saving my life, but also because I swore an oath to him. The oath of abiding friendship and aid to him and all his kin. In every need. And the need finally came. In the person of him, Beren, son of Barahir, and his "quest"...
Sauron doesn't know who is the most important in this quest... doesn't realise. He probably thinks me to be the "one". I revealed my power before him in that contest of songs of power; I had no choice, but he occurred powerful. More powerful than me. Though he didn't find out my name, he must have already guessed my kinship... that I am one of the Noldor. That is why he will wish to "spare" me till the end. No. I cannot let that happen... I will not.


What was that? Ah, it is the sound of doom. It is approaching. I can hear its every footstep, heavy steps... getting nearer and nearer. Lauder and lauder. Like an avalanche in the mountains, heading from afar, starting with silence, but reaching the spot with an enourmous rumble. Fate has come upon me. I can feel it. I felt it long ago. I foresaw it...

There is no time left. I must gather all strength to me... all power that is left in me... all "shards" of life that flows in my vains... must... break these... bonds...

...and he wrestled with the werewolf, and slew it with his hands and teeth; yet he himself was wounded to the death. He died then in the dark, in Tol-in-Gaurhoth, whose great tower he himself had built. Thus King Finrod Felagund, fairest and most beloved of the house of Finwe, redeemed his oath...

--------
color emphasis - original text of Tolkien's "The Silmarillion"
 
Last edited:
Now I post this delayed essay about Gil-Galad's last thoughts and I wish it is not judged too. I devote it to GG with all my love!Enjoy, brother. :)

* * *

My Final Breath is immortal, for I am the last High King of the Noldor!

'I fulfilled my nature duty, my moral obligation... I am now useful no more, needed no more... Alas, i wilt be sorrowed...'

"V..."

' Nay! I wish not to hear the happiness and glory of my home, for I wilt be tempted to live! I wish not to find the peace of the mortal for my destiny is my death!'

"Vi..."

'Wilt I not let this words flow into my mind! I am immortal and doomed to die! I wilt proudly meet my faith, my Lords, my Creators!'

"Vic..."

'Ereinion my people named me, Gil-Galad as well; the last High King I am...for a glance more...a breath more...'

"Vict..."

'...for I wilt die! I beared the Vilya, indeed; I foed the dark Lord and allied the Great Kings Elrond, Elendil for Great Kings of Hearts and Admiration they are...'

"Victo..."

'But what words are enemying my mind; poisoning and distracting my last thoughts and desires...Only the sorrow is worth enough, might enough to dry my concious, but the sorrow is over, isn't it? Were I not the one to fight against the Foe of All and see his inevitable death, his invisible leathal grief...?'

"Victor..."

'From now on only peace wilt rule, peace and happiness for my people, my friends, my home! I die for their lives, I die for I love them! I die because I am calm and certain in their bright future!'

"Victory..."

'Oh, I am happy now! I hear my desires redeeming, my deeds repaying! My life is this victory; my death is this victory; I lived for this victory! This victory, my friends, is for thee!'

"Victory is..."

'Flow, flow words and please my dying soul...I fought for you, words, for your echo in my mind, for you are most precious! I made you with my dearest Aeglos, unvaluable more than wife and children! I fought with the One created to die with me in this battle! I shall now pass away... I shall give my self to the glorious Valar... I shall forget the grief for I see the v...vi...vic...vict...victo...victor...VICTORY!'

Gil-Galad's eyes shutted, his last breath 'screamed' with pain his last desire! he was glad, he was at peace.

"Victory is lost!'
This was the roar of a warrior. His words echoed in the mountains, his despair flooded the valley.
Gil-Galad flickered in his dream...

Isildur had betrayed...
 
This is a copy of Eol's writing that by mistake went to the archieved thread . :eek:

* * *

The Confessions of Turin Turambar

The spring of 485, First Age

Indeed today was indeed a terrible one for the heir of Hurin Thalion! The fool Saeros has fallen to his death, and I am blamed for it. The fool thought to slay me, and lay in wait after out quarrel last night. No harm did I wish to come to him, and even though he was disarmed, I slew him not. Nay, instead I stripped him of all his clothing, and bade him run through the woods like a deer, for so his words turned on him. I pursued him through the woods, until the Deer’s Leap. There, in fright, he leapt, but his footing failed on the far shore. Indeed, even yestereve he said that ‘If the men are thus unkempt, then how must the women be? Do they run naked through the forest like wild deer?’ At this I took up my cup, and cast it at his head, leaving the halls. Thus mine was an appropriate judgment, and not worthy of exile as has been given me. Even Mablung, he who was once my friend, has doubted me. For though he said it not, I could see distrust in his eyes. Thus I am cast into the wild in exile, and tomorrow I head south of the river Teiglin. May Hurin’s heir find better luck there!

The summer of 485, First Age

Whether by fortune or fate, I encountered a band of outlaws this afternoon. Charged with death for intrusion on their territory, I bent to pick a stone and slay any who came near. At that very moment, one of the outlaws let loose a shaft. It passed over my head, but I stood and cast the stone, killing the man. The poor fools! They have accepted me, but perhaps it is best they do not know my true identity. I name myself now Neithan, the Wronged, for so I was in Doriath.

The winter of 581, First Age

This eve Glaurung has fallen at my hand, but the evil tidings outweigh the good ones. Niniel, my fair wife is none other than Nienor, the sister I had not seen. As Glaurung died, his lies were revealed to me. In a flash I saw all that had befallen as it truly was, without the distorted sight of Morgoth Bauglir. Today is the last of my life, for now there are none who will take Turin Turambar, and there are none who would seek companionship with him. I have only one possession left, that is Gurthang, the fell blade carried with me since exile from Doriath. This also I will take with me in death, for nothing of mine should remain with the free peoples of Middle Earth. I say farewell to cares of the world, and cast myself upon my blade. Sweet darkness, take me now…
 
Um..wow i feel so weird in here. I'm not used to people who acctually are talking about major Topics. I don't even know if I'm in the right place, but I'll give it a try. So anyway, I had to do a speach of my choice for a class I'm taking and I chose to talk about where Tolkien got all his idea for the names he put into Lord of the Rings. After finishing it I though that maybe you guys would enjoy it more than my Public Speaking teach so here it is...

**********************************************************

I am going to be telling to you about how JRR Tolkien came up with all of the names he put into Lord of the Rings. Where did they all come from? Hundreds of names were put into these epic tales and not one name, neither good nor evil, was without meaning. This includes people, countries, river, creatures, and cultures. Before I go directly into the specific names I want to give you a little background on where Tolkien got his ideas.
JRR Tolkien was a professor at Oxford University in England from the late 1920’s to the late 1960’s. He had been fascinated by languages from the time he was a boy and before the end of his life he was fluent in sixteen different languages which did not include the tongues he created for his beloved Middle Earth. These languages spanned from French to Norwegian to Ancient Greek. If it was out there, he spoke it. All of this knowledge was compiled to create some of the most complex languages the world knows today. This was the beginning of the names.
Where did Professor Tolkien start? He read books, including Oxford Dictionary of Place-Names, E.Ekwall’s English River Names, and P.H. Reaney’s Dictionary of British Surnames. If you were to spend ten minutes in any of those books you would know the origin of two dozen middle earth names. Tolkien also pulled out of history and legends from Europe’s past. Now I will give you some examples and explanations for a few of the better known Lord of the Rings names.
Let’s start with Frodo, the main character and hero of the story. Frodo’s name came from the epic Beowulf. The original form was Fródi, and he was a Norse king who desired peace.
Now Frodo wouldn’t have gotten very far without Samwise the Brave, so let’s have a look at him. Sam Gamgee was named for Tolkien’s neighbor, Samson Gamgee. This is one of the few characters named for an actual person.
Another great character is Gandalf. His name came out of an Old Norse poem along with quite a few Dwarves names that are seen in Tolkien’s book The Hobbit. His name means “sorcerer elf” in Old English.
It would be a shame to leave out a personal favorite of mine. What meaning does the name Aragorn have? Well, I was unable to come up with an answer to that, save an interesting fact about one of Aragorn’s other names, the name the hobbits were first given when they met him in Bree. Where did Strider come from? The name strider came out of Tolkien’s first name for this character, a mysterious hobbit called Trotter. It is hard to imaging that this King of Gondor started life out as a hobbit, but that is how it was. When writing the Lord of the Rings, Tolkien pretty much made it up as he went along.
Up till this point, I’ve only looked at good characters. Let’s have a look at the dark lords Sauron and Saruman. Sauron, the Lord of the Black Land, got his name from the Norse language, the word meaning abominable or detestable. Saruman, the White Wizard, got his name from the Old English word “searu” meaning “tricky” or “cunning”.
Now I’m going to move on to Creatures of Tolkien’s Middle Earth. Let’s start with Shelob, the great spider. Her name came quite easily. The Old English word “lob” means spider, put together with “she”, creates a female spider. It was really that simple.
Another creature worth mentioning is the Nazgul. This name came after Tolkien created one of his own languages. In Black Speech, the tongue of Mordor, the work “Nazg” means ring, added to the word “ghoul” brings together “ring ghoul” of “ring wraith”. On a funnier note, the word “Nazg” also means ring in Gaelic, a fact that Tolkien forgot until after the books were published!
So that now we’ve covered the people and creatures of Middle Earth, let’s have a look at the places. First we’ll look at Frodo’s home; Bag End. This was one of the other few, named for an actual person, or in this case, place. One of Tolkien’s aunts lived and the end of a cul-de-sac that locals referred to as Bag End
Our Next stop will be the Misty Mountains. This title was borrowed from Norse Legends that refer to the Misty Mountains as “full of dangers and hidden in the half darkness.
Another name that was taken from Tolkien’s surroundings was Rohan. Rohan was the name of a wealthy family in France, though Tolkien only used it because he liked the word, not to make any kind of point. The Mark, which is the area surrounding Rohan also came from Tolkien’s surroundings. It came from the word Mercia, which was the Anglo-Saxon Kingdom that borders Birmingham and Oxford.
I have now covered various spectrums of Tolkien’s Middle Earth names. My goal of this speech was to show you how great a scholar and writer JRR Tolkien was. There are many ways I could have gone about that, this is just an area I found interesting yet little known. I hope that each of you learned something new today, and that you now have more appreciation for the man who made Middle Earth.


**********************************************************

It's a bit rough, I only had a week to prepare, not to mention that's not the only thing I had to do, but it gets the point across. Any feed back would be great! Thanks!

Lady Sabeen
 
Hi Sabeen, there's no need to feel weird around here. The denizens of this corner of the forum are plain folks who put their pants on one leg at a time just like anybody else. :)

Anyhow, here are some thoughts on your presentation. Please take them with a grain of salt as I don't know my way around Tolkien's etymologies as well as a lot of folks around here. For the most part, my input revolves around how your speech is set up:

*It's strikes me as difficult to discuss how Tolkien arrived at his names for things without also talking about the various languages he created. You may want to give a summary of the languages he created (I think there are seven) and link your selected names to those languages as well as the Real World languages you referenced. As written, your speech sounds a little like a simple listing of words that Tolkien randomly selected from other languages or from people and things around him. You need to describe how he was much more systematic than that.

*You may want to discuss how many of Tolkien's names are actually constructed of word elements he created for his languages. For instance, the 'ar' in Aragorn means "high, noble, royal" in Quenya and Sindarin. It is also the Adunaic prefix of the names of the kings of Numenor. There are pretty extensive appendices in both LOTR and the Silmarillion that go into Tolkien's word elements if you need more examples.

One thing that works well for me when I give oral presentations is to organize my talk in the following way:

1. Tell your audience what you're going to tell them.
2. Tell them your message.
3. Tell them what you just told them.

Sounds strange I know, but having an introduction will 'prepare' your audience and put them in a better mind set to really hear what you're going to say. Likewise, a conclusion will send your audience on their way with the single most important idea you want to get across to them fresh in their heads, and more likely to retain it.

Oh yes. PLAN your talk to fit the time allotted. College courses have been taught about Tolkien's languages. If you only have three minutes, you need to distill a gigantic amount of information into the most important elements to fit your allotted time.

Hope this helps. Good luck on your speech and be sure to let us know how it turns out! :)
 
Ha! Your advise sound much like what my Public Speaking teacher would say. :D

The speach went as well as possable, for me. I get so nervous my hands shake. :eek: Oh well.

According to the teach, it went very well. I beg to differ! ;)
 
From Thought, Through Love, Till Reality


A perfunctiory study of the "Silmarillion" might suggest that there is an immense gap between the initial intentions, when the world was created with much love, and the upcoming results. I don't share this opinion. It seems to me that Thought, Love and Reality were basically the same thing, or the essense of the World Creator. There is no contradiction between the original idea and what happened later; there's no even need to oppose Eru's Love to the 'cruel' Reality.

All the events in Tolkien's epics happen because they are meant to be by a transcendental supernatural force. The "Silmarillion" reveals a profound monistic philosophy--i.e. a belief that everything--good and bad--derives from one source of origin,one creator. From Eru, the infinite intellect, comes all.

Concerning Eru's Thought, it is rather far-fetched to see only ideas of a peaceful existence and regard Melkor's twist as a surprising rebellion. You cannot possibly say that Eru, mighty enough to contrive the earth, was blind to let this Ainur walk around and do his misdeeds. Evil had been rooted in Eru. It did not spoil any plans, for it was part of them.
Malice did not come from outside, Melkor was just not that great enough to think up Evil by himself. Eru needed a Dark Lord or a Dark Lady for his purpose. Evil is the force that makes good things go. Someone had to play 'the fallen angel' and a talented Vala was up to it. Melkor was simply the necessary embodiment of that force. Don't overestimate his personal qualities--he was no different than Varda. Do you think she couldn't be corrupted? I don't.
Eru wanted to weave into the world dark and light, bad and good. He did so, even into the characters of all his Children (Vala,Maia,Men,Elves...). There was a lurking villain even in the fairest Elf; and that was the smartest point of his Thought. For evil is a vital thing. If there was only Good or only Evil, who could make any difference? What's the point in definitions at all? Eru wanted his children to tell the two sides apart, appreciate one of them and struggle with the other. There's no better way to teach them that tjhan giving them a piece of malice.

Was it only Love that He bestowed on his children? I daresay not. In order to keep them fit for improvement, he made them imperfect. There was pride and envy as well. Everyone was prone to temptation and that was a process triggered and expected. someone would deviate from the conventional 'good' thus contributing to the perfection of the rest.

Regarding Reality, I'd rather call it ' just' than 'cruel'. Did you think that the Good Lord only wanted his children to 'live happily ever after'? But that would have lessened the value of life itself! Just fancy--everyone flawless: no sufferings, but no appreciation of the fact as well. Without a threat to it, beauty cannot be treasured. Eru didn't want his people to live idly in bliss: his creation would have withered in nothingness. life would have been futile.
Reality was what he expected it to be. You may say the Curse of Mandos contradicts this idea. But mind you, that was Vala point of view. You can interpret it in 2 different ways: 1)that was the awe-inspiring way to say 'that's life'; or 2) you might assume (too naively, meseems), that the Vala seemed to believe in the utopia of eternal joy.
Someone had to cross the line and determine the 'downfall'. But it was nobody's fault in specific. If it hadn't been Feanor, it could have been a converted Vala.

The infinite supernatural power of Eru was beyond anybody's reach. A life of suffering actually turned out a benefit for his children--otherwise there wouldn't have been heroes, sacrifice for love,Beren and Luthien...Just how many great things were caused by Evil! There was a subtle balance--Eru would never have let any of the sides--good or evil--dominate over the other. Else it would diminish.
PRIDE--CONSTRUCTIVE OR RUINOUS?

As the saying goes, 'pride is a foolishman's burden'. But another saying heads in a different direction, moralizing that 'there are no great feats without pride'. Obviuosly, a fine-line separates two contrast aspects of pride.( And it is so with most human emotions: love becomes obsession and ambiton becomes recklessness...) Those fine-lines...they hide the secret of the human psyche. With pride, especially, this problem is very itchy. To me pride is like fire--you know fire that warms and saves lives, but you surely know fire that devastates homes. Therefore,pride is an elemental,dramatic force that is BOTH constructive and ruinous.

Pride is such a great issue, that has become a favourite Biblical and mythological motif. And Tolkien, a creator of a mythology (and probably a religion?) himself, has inevitably engaged his thought in figuring out this knot. And as a master of psychological exploration, he has reached to the conclusion of the two types pride--positive and negative.

Pride can build. As long as it is a feeling of respect and appreciation of certain values such as past, honour, family, skill, friendship, vallour....You cannot blame those brave people who would rather break before they bend in the name of something worthier than their own sufferings and lives. Such heroes include Hurin who never gave in to Morgoth's tortures; Beren who never doubted sacrifising his life for love...and many more. Yes, pride builds, and it builds heroism and eternal admiration.

Pride can destruct. In a moment that same very pride that drove a person to utmost feats can turn around. In a moment pride makes this person blind. And those ideals which seemed worthy before diminish for pride becomes self-centred. And this is how Feanor, the greatest craftsman, knislays for three sparkling jewels! The pride of a creator can turn into a devastating hatred for anything but the creation. And remember how Numenorians fell too, blinded by their own might and skill!...

The fire of pride hides too much. It is an ambivalent feature. And dangerous...one should always beware of the fine-lines.
I, MAEGLIN
/Or The Treason And The Void/

They say that once a spirit arrives at the palace of Mandos, he finds tranquillity and peace. It is a deceipt. Restless shadows and wretched creatures never find repose, even in the afterlife of promised stillness. These halls of eternal silence are a prison to me, Maeglin, a discorned souls among those wandering here.

My mind was always like burning coal, my heart one of molten steel, my desires--like a scalding flare that tortured ne acutely. I burnt out like a torch...in my own zest for life. I have been unhealthily scorched by this flame for so long and it never ceased. No, I cannot find peace here! I shall ever suffer in despair and remorse..yes, remorse!

For all, I am the despised trairor of Gondolin, the bitter disappointment of anyone who met me! Maeglin, the fair noble Maeglin, skilful and magnificent...Ha! How empty was it all...they did not suspect my fall had begun. And could it be prevented? And when it started?

Maybe when I set my eyes on her, Idril Celebrindal. In that instant I desired to be close to her, to have her, to OWN her...I struggled, but not too hard. I despised myself, but not too much. And she was scared of my thoughts and my passion. I hated myself, nay, i desired my own death..and still, her fright pleased me! The flames of my forbidden affection dominated...I had to bend her will with power!

And Tuor! What hilarious irony! She couldn't have hurt me more than choosing this mortal worm, this pawn that would have withered before long! And I had proved to Gondolin I was worthy and he was no better than me! Ever since my own father had restrained me from the world in my childhood, I had felt a desire to receive recognition of my quality. And lo! Tuor outdid me! I loathed him and his son and a poisonous thought obsessed me. Therafter I thought of nothing but of my wish that realm to fall. Oh, how I wished to smite Tuor!...and revenge Idril!And all was distorted then...

It was only inevitable that the Dark Lord sensed my frailty and called out for me...I do not even recall his tortures, for they were so weak in comparison to the trial of my own burning feelings. It was so easy to betray, it was so sweet to succumb! I did not realise that the most frightening only followed. Since the only person who could have stopped me then, my beloved mother,had died, I felt relieved and free and lonely...

I will never forget Idril's stare on the day of Gondolin's destruction. that stare was my true death. Tuor's sword killed me not---it was Idril's eyes. All I wanted was to hurt. And kill myself with this pain I gave her.

I still exist, though. and the shadows of Gondolin's victims I see are the worst imaginable punishment. The Hall of mandos are no bliss, it is eternal horror! And my only hope is the day that She will come. Oh,yes,she will...
Alienated. That's how Melian always felt in Middle-earth. You know her as tender,occasionally giving good advice lady... But what was beneath?...
------
I came here seeking for love, I was young and full of hopes...and there was a Thingol. Indeed, Thingol! I was so ready to give my all in this love, but too soon it came to me we spoke in different languages. A lessening marriage, some called it. Lessening it was not, and yet it was incompatible. He never fully understood what thrilled my heart, always demanding for me to change up to his expectations...And so I did! I built up a Girdle to create my own reality and to deceive myself I was happy. The truth is that all this time with him
I
Was
Not Myself.
Everyone knows the end of trhe story---how he left me ,how he passed to another world, how my grief ruined me...

What you don't know yet is that I am back! I'm back to life, back to Middle-earth, back to love, back to myself. i exist in a different form now...
I need to belive there's somebody out there, i need to believe that I'm not all alone.
I need to believe there's someone else in these skies I dream of. a guarding angel.
One day, we'll be freer than the birds.
To where the Zephyr would take us.

Was reading through some of these essays, and a fond memory of reading Melian's writing and talking with her back in the day was rekindled. I especially liked her writing of Melian! Hoping all is well with her!
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top