• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

The Return of the King Reviews Thread

What did you think of RotK?

  • I am completely speechless due to its glory

    Votes: 54 37.2%
  • Extremely Impressive

    Votes: 48 33.1%
  • Great movie

    Votes: 23 15.9%
  • Alright, but not the best movie I've seen

    Votes: 14 9.7%
  • Boring

    Votes: 1 0.7%
  • Complete waste of my time and money

    Votes: 5 3.4%

  • Total voters
    145
Narya said:
Oh I totally agree, I mean if you see the magnificence of the entire trilogy all in one sitting you'd see how incredible this project was. To think that it only took PJ what 3 years to finish this? .

One irksome point - Why release a version of a movie at the theatre you know is not as good as the EE you plan on releasing later?
Not from the point of view of being closer to the books, but the sequences gel together better.

I would think the movie versions should be the best versions.

My opinion extends to all EEs and Directors Cuts etc.

If the EE version is better.........show IT at the theatre. We shouldn't be made to pay to see movies the producers know are sub-standard just so more sessions can be shown in a day.
 
They do show the EE at the theatre, but I think its like almost a year later.
 
chrischarlton said:
If the EE version is better.........show IT at the theatre. We shouldn't be made to pay to see movies the producers know are sub-standard just so more sessions can be shown in a day.
I think you are confusing directors/producers and studios here. The three-hour time limit for the first two movies was not a Peter Jackson decision, it was a Studio decision. Directors can make all the director's cuts they want- if the studios don't like it, it will never reach a theater, no matter how much its target audience might rave about it. As far as I know New Line's decision had nothing to do with the number of sessions in a day, and everything to do with how many audience members they thought would sit through a 4 hour movie. Judging by how many people complain about the length of RotK vs. the other two (a matter of 20 minutes), I'd say that the studio folks are better off than if they had listened to your idea on how to spend their money.

As far as making us pay, I don't think anyone can do that. People offer us a product, and if we think it is interesting we will pay for it. You can't say "they didn't show us their best product, I want my money back"- otherwise theaters would have to refund every ticket for 'the Hulk' and 'Charlie's Angels 2' that was sold this past summer.
Wait a moment, that might not be such a bad idea ...
 

I'm sure the studio folks are much better off.


But I didn't say "they didn't show us their best product, I want my money back" at all.

My problem is that if "the studio folks" know the future EE will be fundamentally better (eg EE of T2T), release it at the movies.
 
chrischarlton said:
My problem is that if "the studio folks" know the future EE will be fundamentally better (eg EE of T2T), release it at the movies.

VERY interesting point!

I suspect that the likely primary reasons that there were two versions of each movie (theatrical and extended), were possibly that (1) three hours is about the max people will sit in a theater. Three hours means not drinking anything (thereby losing drink profits at the theater's candy concession) so you don't have to get up to go to the bathroom and miss some of the action, and (2) you can get the whole movie burned onto one DVD. (3) There was one helluva lotta money to be made by selling the first version on DVD and later the second version on DVD.

Lotho
 
Last edited:
Lotho_Pimple said:
VERY interesting point!

I suspect that the likely primary reasons that there were two versions of each movie (theatrical and extended), were possibly that (1) three hours is about the max people will sit in a theater.
Lotho

Yeah, and if it was more than that they prolly wont be able to get up! their ass would go numb from sitting that long (its more enjoyable on the couch and more comfy!) and people who cant control their bladder and are stupid enought to drink alot before they come to watch it and dont go to the toilets before hand disturb other people by getting up half way through the movie!
 
One thing for sure: the next poor slob who does the next film version of LOTR is going to get PLENTY of advice from people all over the world (and especially this forum) consisting mainly of "DON'T SCREW WITH THE BOOK THE WAY PETER JACKSON DID!"

Lotho
 
I post my review after my forth watchin of the movie.I am a FAD and i really like the movie,but(there always have to have a but) there were some moments that make a strange face thats says:"What the hell..."

1.Sam and Frodo scene,its a perfect scene from the PJ point of view but still the JRR Tolkien Frodo will never do that and i think that the one of the most immportant things of an adaptaion is the characters.
2.The Arwen thing,i like the idea about going to Valinor and the coming back but i didnt like this thing with her hate bound with the Ring
3.Who did Aragorn,Legolas and Gimli get to the ships when their horses get away?
4.Where was the darkness,when Faramir exit Minas Tirith to "take over" Osgiliath we see the darkness when the doors are open but after then its just gone(btw awesome scene,Billy Boyd done great job)
5.How Sam found his way out of the Shelob's lair?Yes,he found Galadriel's gift but before that?

Inspite of this,the movie is one of a time experiance.Awesome end,awesome trilogy.I cant wait the EE to see the three films on a roll once again .
 
Not posted anything for a long time, but I have to express my feelings about ROTK.

The only way I can explain how it affected me was to say that I came out of the cinema feeling exhausted. I, like many other contributors to the Forum, have been waiting for a film version of LOTR for over 20 years. (Yes, I am an old ****.) The emotions I felt upon leaving were a combination of elation and sadness; elation because I felt that the film was superb entertainment, sadness because there will be no LOTR release to look forward to next Christmas.

I would consider myself a purist in the sense that I don't think anyone is capable of telling the story better than Tolkien does, but that surely goes for most works of literature that make the journey from novel to silver screen. There were loads of things that I wish had been left in the film; Prince Imrahil, Ghan buri Ghan, Gandalf standing up to the Lord of the Nazgul, to name but a few. However, I will not allow any of this to get in the way of the fact that ROTK was an exceptionally well made, well directed, well photographed, well acted film with a superb score. Not enough has been said of Howard Shore's work but in my opinion the score is a vital contributor towards the emotions one feels when watching the film.

Anyway, to cut a long reply short, I loved it. I will buy it the day it is released on DVD and watch it over and over again. Theoden's speech, the Rohirrim charging the Orcs........fantastic. I could go on all day about what I enjoyed, whereas my complaints would be over in a few seconds. I think that Tolkien fans (myself included) should be mindful of the fact that thousands more people will go out and read the book as a result of watching the trilogy. Surely that's a good thing.
 

As the geologist said, "My sediments exactly!"

I especially agree with you about Howard Shore's music: indispensable and gorgeous incidental music to a great play. Can you imagine these films without the music? I can't. Thanks for your post!

Lotho
 

Back to my original point being - More money to be made by releasing a shorter version of a movie.

But knowingly releasing a poorer version I think raises some questions in relation to the studios integrity.
 
chrischarlton said:
But knowingly releasing a poorer version I think raises some questions in relation to the studios integrity.
Poorer is purely subjective. What the studios (I imagine) thought is that the majority of people would be upset if the movie was longer- in their opinion the longer movie would be poorer.

IMO the fact that the studios bankrolled 3 movies instead of the 2 that PJ was asking for, combined with the fact that they agreed to 3-hour movies, after stipulating 2-hour movies in the contract speaks volumes about their integrity. Or perhaps you are unaware of the financial risk they were taking?
 
Finally making a complete review.

After seeing ROTK for a second time I did enjoy it more. Although I was most dissapointed with the deviations from the book that was really only the complant I still hold. And though it is a big one I still enjoyed the movie, but I do think they could have done a better job keeping to the book.
 

Do you really believe that after the success of the first movie which more than paid for the cost of production of all three, they would be worried people might be upset at the length of following 2 movies?

Give me a break.

I've heard justifications of this nature before.
 
chrischarlton said:
Do you really believe that after the success of the first movie which more than paid for the cost of production of all three, they would be worried people might be upset at the length of following 2 movies?
Did youe expect New Line Cinema to release the 2nd and 3rd films as a public service merely because they had already made a profit? Perhaps you expected free admission to TTT and ROTK?
 
Last edited:
How about this for a break: the studios allowed PJ to make RotK 20 minutes longer than the other two theatrical releases, and the result has been an endless stream of "it was a great movie, but it was too long".
If you are unfamiliar with this type of criticism, I can point you to hundreds of such reviews, both by professional critics and by "average" movie-goers alike. And, just as a reminder, the EEs of Fellowship and TT were both over 30 minutes of extended material, i.e. longer than the theatrical release of RotK.

In terms of integrity, what evidence do you have that New Line lacks it? Are you aware that New Line allowed PJ to make each film a full hour longer than they had originally agreed on? Does that not show some integrity?
 
chrischarlton said:
Back to my original point being - More money to be made by releasing a shorter version of a movie.

But knowingly releasing a poorer version I think raises some questions in relation to the studios integrity.

I'm not quite sure what the word "poorer" is supposed to mean here. IMHO, the first and third theatrical versions have enough content in them to stand on their own. The second movie hardly made sense to me (and I wondered what those who'd never read the book would make of it) until I saw the extended version at home, where enough stuff was put back in to make more sensible fill-in. So in that sense and that sense only, I would say that the second movie was somewhat "poorer" than the others. In fact I recall someone (whether a poster here or a critic) saying "You haven't seen this movie [TTT] until you've seen the extended version." And they were right.

Lotho
 
Greenwood said:
Did youe expect New Line Cinema to release the 2nd and 3rd films as a public service merely because they had already made a profit? Perhaps you expected free admission to TTT and ROTK?

No but I do expect to see the best they can do. Not second best
 

I would prefer the best not second best, rather than have it compromised by the profit aspect. Their justifications are really only that.........their motives on the other appear to profit driven rather than quality driven.
 

So basically you've gone and spent more money (as have I) either hiring or buying the EE version of TTT. And you've found the EE version better.

So as I said originally why not release the EE edition if it is fundamentally better? Instead they released a movie that was second best.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…