• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

The Return of the King Reviews Thread

What did you think of RotK?

  • I am completely speechless due to its glory

    Votes: 54 37.2%
  • Extremely Impressive

    Votes: 48 33.1%
  • Great movie

    Votes: 23 15.9%
  • Alright, but not the best movie I've seen

    Votes: 14 9.7%
  • Boring

    Votes: 1 0.7%
  • Complete waste of my time and money

    Votes: 5 3.4%

  • Total voters
    145
First off, let me say that I was very much in two minds about this film. I knew I had to see it, but I was really worried that the deviations from the book and the apparently illogical made up scenes would get worse and that this would be even more of a travesty that TTT was.

I WAS WRONG!

Sure, there were bits I wasn't keen on, Frodo telling Sam to go home was probably the biggest gripe I had. It really detracted from the closeness of those two, although I will admit that for non readers, it probably made the whole Shelob bit more exciting with Sam heroically coming in at the last moment, but for me it would have worked just as well with the proper storyline.
Denethor too was just not right, especially his death plunge, he was just too evil with no redeeming qualities at all.
I too dislike Sauron's Eye, but I suppose it must be extemely hard to portay something like that on film when in the books it is a mental impression rather that a physical manifestation.
I also missed some of the superb speeches tolkien gave to his characters, and would agree that for me the film would have been better in the original language, but again I suppose that PJ had to try and make it comprehensible to the uneducated as well. ( I know some people who wouldn't have had the foggiest notion what Eowyn meant by threatening to smite the Witch King!)

However, in general, despite sitting in the cinema for a large part of the time saying to myself 'get this bit right please!' in general, I found that it was and was pleasantly surprised. I had been wondering how the deviations from the books could be corrected in RoTK, or even if they would be, but they were, and as has been said before, with it being a trilogy, many things which seemed odd in film 2 show themselves more natually in 3.
Minas Tirith was simply breathtaking and the overhead view as Gandalf and Pippin ascended the circles of the city was superb. In the same way I loved Minas Morgul, although I'm not quite sure about the lightning going up the way it did.
I missed Aragorns speech at the stone of Erech, but in general felt that the Dead were reasonably well done, even if they did end up fighting in the wrong place.
The arrival of the Rohirrim and their charge was wonderful, although I felt that Eowyn's secret should have still been a secret, and her battle with the Witch King was almost exactly as I had imagined.
I also had a horrible feeling that PJ might have forgotten Grond which would have been a tragedy, but no there he was large as life and twice as ugly! (surely our own version is much nicer ;) )
Legolas and the oliphaunt-well it wasn't right but it was a good piece of cinema, and I actually rather liked the continuation of the orc killing contest between him and Gimli.
Frodo and Sam in Mordor, well again, a little disappointed that there wasn't more of that, but what there was, was great and all credit to both actors for making it believable. Frodo pushing Gollum over the edge and his almost fall, had me again thinking 'oh no!', but at least I suppose it gave Frodo back some of the heroism so lacking in the first two films, and the scene after the Ring is destroyed, with Frodo and Sam on the rock, was despite somewhat changed dialogue, so close in emotional feel to the books that I was in tears.

Oh, and I'm so glad that the Eagles came!

On the whole, the bits I really missed, I already knew wouldn't be there, ie Saruman and the scouring of the Shire, and so I was already hoping that they'd be on the EE, and for me at least, the changes in RoTK were far less obtrusive and falsified than TTT was, in fact most of them, as was the case in FoTR, I could at least see some sort of reasoning behind them, even if it wasn't imo a particulary good reason.
With this film, as with the first, I came away happy and wanting to see it again in the cinema, whereas with TTT, I couldn't be bothered until the dvd came out.

I think I can safely say I loved this film. It may not be 100% true to the books, but then I've never yet seen a film adaptation that was. At least it ended with the right line!
 
Pippin/Frodo said:
My best friend and I said that the third movie simply needed a new director because it seemed as though PJ just slacked off in some things. I'm still pretty furious over the scouring of the Shire.
If PJ added the SotS we would need a new director...

Having seen RotK, how can you say that the SotS would be anything other than anti-climactic, not to mention making it over-lengthy?
 
My wife and I will be seeing ROTK a second time tomorrow. I can't wait to get the TE DVD, and the subsequent EE DVD at home on our Tolkien Corner shelf, upon which resides all things Tolkien, between a pair of bookends — one of which shows Gandalf knocking on Bilbo's front door, the other showing Bilbo answering. We have one hardback copy of The Hobbitt, three hb copies of LOTR, the DVDs, all the Houghton Mifflin illustrated books about the movies, and some videotapes of stuff I caught on TV — teasers and features about LOTR.

By the way, can anyone help me with this: I'd like to get books containing the letters that Tolkien wrote. What are their titles, who wrote them, and who published them? Thanks in advance!:)

Lotho
 
Lotho_Pimple said:
By the way, can anyone help me with this: I'd like to get books containing the letters that Tolkien wrote. What are their titles, who wrote them, and who published them? Thanks in advance!:)

Lotho

The Letters of JRR Tolkien, edited by Humphrey Carpenter and published by Houghton Mifflin.
 
Dáin Ironfoot I said:
Well, I must say I am incredibly satisfied with the ROTK (saw it at midnight). I left the movies feeling complete and happy, I do not have any major complaints as with TTT.

Since there was no thread for those who have seen the movie, I made one. Please post your comments, I would post more but I have to go to class!

Dain I completely agree with you! I know I'm going to get a beating from the so-called "Purists" but I stand by my post everytime. I believe PJ has done the unexpected (like he did with FOTR), he amazed me, moved me to tears almost. I felt so touched by the heroism of Sam, and the majesty of the battle scenes is breathlessly intricate. It made me feel like I was there. The effects are staggering, I must bow down to the special effects team of PJ, they have done a marvelous job (Being acquainted with animation softwares myself- I study them right now - I know how hard it is to make these effects, believe me, it aint no joke!)


Plus it has dawned to me that most of the actors and actresses cast in this film are so GOOD-LOOKING! really the pick of the crop!!! I mean they did not settle for anything less not even for the extras.

And SEAN ASTIN, has again taken my breath away! Blown me away with his magnificent performance. It was incredible, he almost outshined Elijah Wood. Especially his scene against shelob! That was so dramatic, my brother who has not read a single book exclaimed, that little hobbit is using just PURE GUTS, PURE WILL fighting that menace, and it was really amazing how he was able to defeat Shelob. The way it was portrayed on the film made it even more special you can see the bravery, the courage in Sean Astin's eyes, few actors can do that without looking cheesy, but he did it.

Even the slight changes in the story were to me worth it, it was if for all intents and purposes just cinematic effect. It has not - again in my opinion - taken anything away from the sacredness of the stories in the book, in fact it made many non-tolkien readers want to read the book version. To understand it more.

I give it FIVE THUMBS UP!!! Though I only have two, it's so good, I am willing to grow more thumbs just to do this feat!!!!

CONGRATULATIONS TO PJ, WINGNUT, AND NEWLINE!!!! JOB WELL DONE!!!!!
 
Posted by Narya I believe PJ has done the unexpected (like he did with FOTR), he amazed me, moved me to tears almost. I felt so touched by the heroism of Sam, and the majesty of the battle scenes is breathlessly intricate. It made me feel like I was there. The effects are staggering, I must bow down to the special effects team of PJ, they have done a marvelous job
Yes, he has done an excellent job, the movies were the reason for me to read the books I already finished FotR and TTT. And with RotK im on it, yes the movie has a lot of changes, but I think that PJ made a great project, he gave us his version of the story, and i thing its good, not as good as the books but its good and I hope, please God, make him won the Golden Globes and the Oscars, he deserve them. Its not easy to portrait a book in a movie, specially a book with great magnificence and majesty like the LotR books. You have to cut a lot of material like PJ did( but...I really miss Tom Bombadil and other characters).
Well, some things that i like of the movie:
Oh Pippin singing to Denothor, almost make me cry. Well No, but I love That Scene.
Eowyn(the best) and Witch-King,(but why they change her lines :mad: )
The rohirrim screaming Death!!!!!! and Theoden Speech(Excellent)
Minas Tirith and Minas Morgul wow excellent. :D
and a lot of more thing that I cant remember
Things I dislike:
Smeagol opening sequence
Denothor falling down hahahahahaha
Legolas in the mumakil
Frodo saying to Sam to return to the Shire :confused: (stupid)
no voice of saruman, :(
Well, but I really like it, great movie, I cant wait to have the dvd, and the extended edition please I want it blue, Fotr is green, TTT red, Rotk needs to be blue. Well excellent movie the best of the 3, if i can give stars between 1 and 5 this would be my score Fotr(****) TTT (***) RotK(*****) Can someone can tell me how can I make an avatar?
 
heir_of_gondor said:
I can't belive people hated The Return of the King, That movie is the best i have ever seen. GO ARAGORN :)


Oh I totally agree, I mean if you see the magnificence of the entire trilogy all in one sitting you'd see how incredible this project was. To think that it only took PJ what 3 years to finish this?

Other things we should take note of would be the development of Aragorn into the King Elessar! I mean PJ slowly transformed this caterpillar into a beautiful butterfly before our very eyes. Few Directors could boast of such an achievement. To take one character who in the beginning looks like a rogue and turn him into a King - SUCCESSFULLY - Viggo Mortensen looked so kingly that he doesn't look bad beside LivTyler's Arwen no more. At the beginning I was like, what does she see in him??? But at the end of ROTK, I realize, he IS good looking - worth giving immortality to.
 
Narya said:
...Viggo Mortensen looked so kingly that he doesn't look bad beside LivTyler's Arwen no more. At the beginning I was like, what does she see in him??? But at the end of ROTK, I realize, he IS good looking - worth giving immortality to.

So you're saying — GOOD LOOKS is worth giving up immortality for???

Lotho
 
Lotho_Pimple said:
So you're saying — GOOD LOOKS is worth giving up immortality for???

Lotho


Ahhhh...let me think....YEAH! :D Plus his personality, actually I found Aragorn as portrayed by Viggo more lovable than Legolas (sorry legolas lovers :p ) as portrayed by Orlando. He was more endearing indeed. :D
 
aturina said:
-

Personally, I thought he was sexier as a rogue! ;)

I am not into the dirty-scrappy-look today, so, I like him as the armour-coated king thank you! :p
 
Morvran said:
I really do. I wish you could feel like I do. I am someone who has read the books too many times to count. I am someone who loved the cartoon-movie as a kid, and always wanted to see these books made into a real movie.

I love these movies. I am thankful for what Jackson did by bringing these to the silver screen. I don't think it could have been done better.

I think a literal translation of the books onto film would have been horrible (not to mention impossible).

I have plenty of issues with the movies as they pertain to characters and plot...but I am able to accept the issues as a difference in opinion and interpretation. And most of my issues lie within the TT to be honest.

For those of you who are fans of the books, or fans of Tolkien, who hate these movies, I truly do feel sorry for you. I am sorry that you cannot get the joy out of these movies that I do.

This is exactly how I feel. My only gripe was that it sometimes appeared rushed & a little over edited but I suppose PJ wouldn't have got away with the film being any longer.
 
Bullroarer said:
This is exactly how I feel. My only gripe was that it sometimes appeared rushed & a little over edited but I suppose PJ wouldn't have got away with the film being any longer.

Correct!

Even if PJ wanted to include some scenes, there wouldn't be enough time to put in. Well, we still have the extended DVD's to look forward to. :D
 
Rhiannon said:
Hear, hear. Mortensen was very blah as a king.


Sorry Rhi, but I must beg to differ, I thought he was ruggedky handsome in the first to and Kingly handsome in the last one.
 

Today's events

Back
Top