Madonna Baggins
New Member
- Joined
- Jul 25, 2003
- Messages
- 40
great! Seems like I got nothing to worry about...I´m gonna see it again hopefully tommorrow

If PJ added the SotS we would need a new director...Pippin/Frodo said:My best friend and I said that the third movie simply needed a new director because it seemed as though PJ just slacked off in some things. I'm still pretty furious over the scouring of the Shire.
Lotho_Pimple said:
My pleasure. I had it sitting right here next to me, after all...Lotho_Pimple said:
Dáin Ironfoot I said:Well, I must say I am incredibly satisfied with the ROTK (saw it at midnight). I left the movies feeling complete and happy, I do not have any major complaints as with TTT.
Since there was no thread for those who have seen the movie, I made one. Please post your comments, I would post more but I have to go to class!
Yes, he has done an excellent job, the movies were the reason for me to read the books I already finished FotR and TTT. And with RotK im on it, yes the movie has a lot of changes, but I think that PJ made a great project, he gave us his version of the story, and i thing its good, not as good as the books but its good and I hope, please God, make him won the Golden Globes and the Oscars, he deserve them. Its not easy to portrait a book in a movie, specially a book with great magnificence and majesty like the LotR books. You have to cut a lot of material like PJ did( but...I really miss Tom Bombadil and other characters).Posted by Narya I believe PJ has done the unexpected (like he did with FOTR), he amazed me, moved me to tears almost. I felt so touched by the heroism of Sam, and the majesty of the battle scenes is breathlessly intricate. It made me feel like I was there. The effects are staggering, I must bow down to the special effects team of PJ, they have done a marvelous job
heir_of_gondor said:I can't belive people hated The Return of the King, That movie is the best i have ever seen. GO ARAGORN![]()
Narya said:...Viggo Mortensen looked so kingly that he doesn't look bad beside LivTyler's Arwen no more. At the beginning I was like, what does she see in him??? But at the end of ROTK, I realize, he IS good looking - worth giving immortality to.
To take one character who in the beginning looks like a rogue and turn him into a King -
aturina said:-
Personally, I thought he was sexier as a rogue!![]()
aturina said:-
Personally, I thought he was sexier as a rogue!![]()
Morvran said:I really do. I wish you could feel like I do. I am someone who has read the books too many times to count. I am someone who loved the cartoon-movie as a kid, and always wanted to see these books made into a real movie.
I love these movies. I am thankful for what Jackson did by bringing these to the silver screen. I don't think it could have been done better.
I think a literal translation of the books onto film would have been horrible (not to mention impossible).
I have plenty of issues with the movies as they pertain to characters and plot...but I am able to accept the issues as a difference in opinion and interpretation. And most of my issues lie within the TT to be honest.
For those of you who are fans of the books, or fans of Tolkien, who hate these movies, I truly do feel sorry for you. I am sorry that you cannot get the joy out of these movies that I do.
Bullroarer said:This is exactly how I feel. My only gripe was that it sometimes appeared rushed & a little over edited but I suppose PJ wouldn't have got away with the film being any longer.
Rhiannon said:Hear, hear. Mortensen was very blah as a king.