Mrs. Maggott
Home is where the cat is
- Joined
- Oct 2, 2002
- Messages
- 3,463
Mrs. Maggott said:Perhaps, in fact, we are agonizing over motives where none exist on the part of the Director. Maybe he just went with what he thought would work and hang the sense (or nonsense) of it.
Actually, I think he finally admitted that he had read the book once when he was much younger. In my opinion, Jackson's "fondness" for Tolkien is the sort of "fondness" many people have for Shakespeare: they love thechrischarlton said:Probably.
My opinion is in efforts to help the audience relate to the characters and add drama to their stories PJ failed in accurately representing the true majesty of the characters from the books.
I don't know if he has or not, but judging only from my perspective of the movie adaptations PJ doesn't seem to have read some of Tolkiens other works (Silmarillion, Book of Lost Tales, Unfinished Tales etc). If he had I think he may have had a clearer understanding of Tolkien's characters in LOTR.
Hey, I enjoyed the movies. In their own right they were very entertaining. Best Picture material..........no. Too many fundamental flaws (just movie making ones). Visually fantastic though.
Are you watching, Foe-Hammer?!?!?!?!chrischarlton said:Too many fundamental flaws (just movie making ones).
Mrs. Maggott said:I don't doubt that Jackson had a general idea of what Tolkien was all about, but many of his changes lead me to seriously doubt that he really knew or understood the man's writings. Had he really respected his source material, he would have made an effort to ennoble many of the characters in the films that are considerably less noble, Aragorn and Frodo (not to mention Faramir) among them!
Foe-Hammer said:For me, a regular fan of jrr, it changes nothing. I look at these films as being true to the spirit of jrr. I can accept aragorn in many ways as long as they are done well on film. Aragorn, as a film character was done very well. He portrayed what pj was trying to say and I saw no ambiguity or contradiction that didn't have a realistic basis that explained it.
chrischarlton said:True Spirit
Hmm...............In the book Elrond held great bitterness towards men, even though he is half man and over a thousand years old (surely not enough time to get over it).
Hmm................In the book Denethor was petty enought not to light the beacons. That would have demonstrated that at least for a time he was a good ruler.
Hmm................In the book Aragorn had given up all possibility of becoming king. Elrond talked him out of that nonsense.
Hmm................In the book Aragorn did flinch and almost faint from touching the Orthanc stone, even though it was rightfully his. Oh, that's right he'd given up on higher aspirations.
Hmm...............In the book the soldiers of Gondor didn't sally forth from the broken gates when the Riders of Rohan came to their succour. Only capable commanders would have done that and I didn't think any were left in Gondor. Who was that Prince Imrahil fella anyway?
Hmm...............In the book Aragorn seriously considered giving up on Arwen for Eowyn. Can't be king, so can't have the girl to go with it.
Hmm..............You're right, PJ definately captured the spirit of Tolkien.
joxy said:Are you watching, Foe-Hammer?!?!?!?!
Maybe you, chrisc, are as ignorant of the fine and intricate art or craft of film-making as I am, and therefore not worthy,
in Foe-Hammer's eyes, to comment on the superb professionalism of P Jackson Esq., but you sure do talk sense!
In the movie Elrond is never described as half-Elven, so it is understandable that he might be upset that the weakness of men has left Sauron around for another three thousand years. For that matter, book-Elrond speaks of the Last Alliance with a little bit of bitterness. And of course, in the movie Elrond harbors and raises Aragorn just as he does in the book. Take the good with the bad, please.chrischarlton said:
In the movie Denethor becomes quite mad the moment that he learns of Boromir's death. In the books he is able bear up until he willingly sends Faramir to his almost-death. What you may not notice is that in books and movie it is the same madness, it just happens relatively earlier in the one than in the other.chrischarlton said:
In the books Aragorn had a glittering opportunity for becoming King, and he let it pass right on by because he had a 'hunch' that the time was not yet right. In effect, he 'chose' to remain in exile in the North, not knowing if another opportunity to become King would ever come along.chrischarlton said:Hmm................In the book Aragorn had given up all possibility of becoming king. Elrond talked him out of that nonsense.
In the book Aragorn is nearly wasted by his confrontation with Sauron via the Palantir. He is described as looking "as if in one night many years had fallen on his head". He goes away for many hours to battle with Sauron via the Palantir- doubtless at some point he almost flinches, and judging by his appearance he does nearly faint- not that Movie-Aragorn seems overly troubled after the Palantir rolls beyond his grasp.chrischarlton said:Hmm................In the book Aragorn did flinch and almost faint from touching the Orthanc stone, even though it was rightfully his. Oh, that's right he'd given up on higher aspirations.
In the books the enemy has not broken through to the second level of the city, so they are able to sally forth. This is what is known as a difference in circumstance, not a change to the spirit of Tolkien.chrischarlton said:
There is absolutely no indication in the movie that Aragorn ever considered giving up Arwen for Eowyn. In fact, he gives up Arwen because of concern for her mortality, but even then he makes no move for Eowyn.chrischarlton said:
I found quite enough tension in the books wondering if he would manage to stay alive!Parrot said:I have always felt that Jackson's goal with the changes to Aragorn was to try and build dramatic tension in the audience by introducing some real doubt about whether or not he would assume the throne if the chance arose
"Will he or won't he make it" with the character Tolkien invented would have been better. He still doubted his own wisdom (eg at Rauros) but he was always the coming King.Maybe they also wanted to humanize (and/or modernize) Aragorn somewhat, but I really don't think there was any intent to turn him into Doug Christie. I think mainly they did it to introduce another subplot - "Will he or won't he?"
He replaced Tolkien's tension with his own brand of modernised, hollywood style tension.Did he succeed in creating any real tension?
Parrot said:I have always felt that Jackson's goal with the changes to Aragorn was to try and build dramatic tension in the audience by introducing some real doubt about whether or not he would assume the throne if the chance arose. Towards this end, he instilled some personal doubts in the character to create an atmosphere where the audience could reasonably envision a scenario where Aragorn might refuse the throne.
Maybe they also wanted to humanize (and/or modernize) Aragorn somewhat, but I really don't think there was any intent to turn him into Doug Christie. I think mainly they did it to introduce another subplot - "Will he or won't he?".
Did he succeed in creating any real tension? Debatable, as always.
Which article?Foe-Hammer said:The words used in this article are "less than polite"
joxy said:Radagast, that's a really interesting reaction to the product as it stands now, and it reflects a lot of what has been said here.
You say one very surprising thing though, that it is FOTR that disintegrates after the first hour, and that TTT is much better than FOTR. There has been a lot of agreement here that it is TTT that begins superbly and continues that way, again for about an hour - maybe longer in the DVD EE - and then falls apart into a strange mixture of mangled characterisation and confusing action. Can you say more about the way that you found FOTR to fall apart?
You've given examples that many of us here have tried before, only to be consigned to outer darkness because we don't appreciate the full glory of PJ's masterpiece.Radagast said:all the Tolkien characters became PJ characters.
failed attempt at dwarf humour in Moria
Sam's remark to the camera of "I'm getting the hang of this"
the teetering rock thing etc
the whole mix up of character actions at the falls
"let's go hunt some orc" with a smirk thing.
I think PJ just dropped the tolkien vase here and it shattered I think he glued it back okay in TTT....
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?