The New Stuff
The following is a long excerpt from an even longer article by Scott Chitwood (there are spoilers ahead, but after December 14th [tomorrow as of this writing], all spoiler lists become forever irrelevant):
===============================
For this DVD review I'm only going to concentrate on the 50 minutes of bonus footage that's included in this special edition. If you'd like to see my review of the rest of the film, click
here.
Like the previous special editions of
the Lord of the Rings DVD's, there is a ton of extra footage included. Some of it is quite extensive and expands on the characters. Some of it goes by so fast that you hardly notice it. Thankfully, a booklet included with the DVD tells you exactly where all the changes are. If you just want to see those additions, it's easy to find them.
A few of the additions are quite dramatic. One of the most noteworthy is a scene showing a confrontation between
Saruman and
Gandalf in the flooded
ruins of
Isengard. We see Saruman talking trash with our heroes and smacking
Wormtongue down. But as Gandalf offers Saruman his life in exchange for information,
Theoden talks trash right back. The war of words eventually escalates until Gandalf shatters Saruman's staff, Wormtongue stabs Saruman,
Legolas shoots Wormtongue, and Saruman falls to his rather dramatic death. It's an exciting scene that ties up a lot of loose ends about Christopher Lee's character even if it does depart from the book. I would have liked to see it included in the movie. (The death of Saruman, of course, eliminates any need to show the
scouring of the Shire at the end of the film like in the book.)
Another dramatic scene occurs when
Aragorn attempts to recruit the ghosts in the cave. Rather than immediately rallying to his cause, they disappear. Then a literal avalanche of skulls falls on our heroes and threatens to knock them into the abyss. Aragorn, Legolas, and
Gimli escape from the cave and fall into despair until the ghost king reappears and agrees to help them. We then are treated to the sight of Aragorn commandeering the Corsair's
ships along with the ghosts. Again, this helps explain how they all ended up on boats in the first place and where they came from. This scene also includes a ton of humor between Gimli and Legolas as well as a cameo by Peter Jackson and a number of the other crew as the Corsairs. Their fans will love it.
There are also a few more scenes establishing the blossoming romance between
Faramir and
Eowyn. They are shown in the "House of Healing" together and they are also shown comforting each other as their friends ride into battle. (These scenes are accompanied by a song sung by Liv Tyler.) It's a piece of the book that wasn't really covered in the theatrical version, but it helps wrap up the Aragorn / Eowyn romance.
Late in the film we see
Frodo and
Sam in disguise and getting accidentally caught up among a troop of
Orcs moving towards the front of the battle. After causing a distraction, they are eventually able to give the orcs the slip despite almost being caught. It's a tense scene even if you know what's going to happen.
One of the final and most dramatic additions is Aragorn facing off with
Sauron. Aragorn gazes into the
Palantir (aka glowing bowling ball) and threatens the
evil eye. We then see him marching into battle and facing off with The
Mouth of Sauron played by an unrecognizable Bruce Spence (from Mad Max, Matrix, Star
Wars, etc.). The hideous creature proceeds to tell our heroes that Frodo was captured, tortured, and killed. He offers up Frodo's mail shirt as proof. So how does Aragorn respond? He lops his head off, of course. It's quite a dramatic scene that really adds tension to the climax and gives a face and personality to Sauron. It's another one I would have liked to have seen included in the theatrical release.
There are a lot of shorter but no less significant scenes included in the film. The potential romance between Eowyn and Aragorn is shown a lot more. In one scene she describes a dream that she had of impending doom to Aragorn. There's more of Eowyn and
Pippin preparing to ride into battle. A drinking game between Legolas and Gimli is also shown (which includes a cameo by composer Howard Shore). You see Frodo, Sam, and
Gollum traveling through ruins of
statues of
kings from the past. There's a bit more of the
Orc Captain (aka Sloth from the Goonies) leading his troops into battle. But my favorite of the "mini-additions" are those to the final battle scenes. There's more of a battle between Eowyn and the Orc Captain. I could be wrong but I think there's more of Legolas battling on top of the
Oliphaunt. Pippin is even shown viciously attacking Orcs and stabbing them repeatedly. It's surprisingly violent considering the character. Then there's a very exciting but brief confrontation between Gandalf and the
Witch King. The Witch King literally shatters Gandalf's staff and proves himself to be more than a match for the wizard. It makes Eowyn and Pippen's victory over him all the more impressive.
===============================
Entire article at
http://www.comingsoon.net/news/dvdreviewsnews.php?id=7561 (Well worth going there to read the section entitled "The Extras.")
Barley