• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

The Return of the King Reviews Thread

What did you think of RotK?

  • I am completely speechless due to its glory

    Votes: 54 37.2%
  • Extremely Impressive

    Votes: 48 33.1%
  • Great movie

    Votes: 23 15.9%
  • Alright, but not the best movie I've seen

    Votes: 14 9.7%
  • Boring

    Votes: 1 0.7%
  • Complete waste of my time and money

    Votes: 5 3.4%

  • Total voters
    145
ROTK was nan awesome movie. The music, the actors, the soun effects, the story, evderything about it was awesome!.
 
Narsil said:
I really enjoy reading the stuff that Barley posts. If he didn't post the links I'd never think to delve in and discover this stuff for myself. Thanks for your time and effort! :cool: :)

Thank you, itza plezhaaaa!:D

Barley
 
Return of the King Rates "A+"

The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King (Extended Edition)

"A day may come when the courage of men fails, when we forsake our friends and break all bonds of fellowship, but it is not this day. An hour of wolves and shattered shields, when the age of men comes crashing down, but it is not this day. This day we fight!"
- Aragorn (Viggo Mortensen)

Review By: Rich Rosell
Published: December 13, 2004

Stars: Elijah Wood, Ian McKellen, Liv Tyler, Viggo Mortensen, Sean Astin
Other Stars: Cate Blanchett, John Rhys-Davies, Bernard Hill, Billy Boyd, Dominic Monaghan, Orlando Bloom, Hugo Weaving, Miranda Otto, David Wenham, Karl Urban, John Noble, Andy Serkis, Ian Holm, Sean Bean, Brad Dourif, Christopher Lee, Lawrence Makaore, Bruce Spence
Director: Peter Jackson

Style A+
Grade Substance A+
Grade Image Transfer A-
Grade Audio Transfer A+
Grade Extras A+
Grade Member A+

DVD Review

Author J.R.R. Tolkien once referred to his mammoth and sprawling The Lord of the Rings series as being "unfilmmable," but that statement was obviously made decades ago, long before technology and writer/director Peter Jackson got a hold of the project. Jackson's equally mammoth and sprawling film trilogy is simply epic on every scale, creating a believable and tactile Middle-Earth while carefully morphing and compressing Tolkien's story into a manageable package that would not only please the legions of Rings fans, but make for marketable movie entertainment for regular joes.

Thankfully, Jackson seems to have tilted the scales in favor of Tolkienites, creating his own fairly faithful version of the story, an intricately written trilogy that doesn't pander to audiences. With the release of this four-disc extended edition, as was done with The Fellowship of the Ring and The Two Towers, Jackson has once again been given the opportunity to reinstate scenes (14 new and 22 extended) back into The Return of The King that were not part of the original theatrical run. In this case it's just over fifty minutes of footage, melded seamlessly into the finished product, which expands the runtime well past the four-hour mark.

There is no "previously on The Lord of the Rings" primer at the beginning, just as there wasn't in The Two Towers, though Jackson does go backwards just a bit by opening The Return of the King with a flashback sequence showing the origin/transformation of hobbit Smeagol (Andy Serkis) into duplicitous Gollum after being eternally corrupted and controlled by the power of the One Ring. From then on, it picks up where The Two Towers left off, and the evil goes into the red and the battles become even more grandly violent and expansive. I get chills everytime I watch the Battle of Pelennor Fields sequence, from the heroic arrival of Theoden (Bernard Hill) and the Rohirrim to their weary face-off against an onslaught of Haradrim and mumakils.

There are five separate stories going on at once in this final chapter—spread across the breadth of magical Middle-Earth—all building and interconnecting with sweeping high drama and spectacular action sequences, and if you haven't seen the first two films you're going to be hopelessly lost. The One Ring is on the final leg of its journey, and must be destroyed in the fires of Mount Doom by Frodo (Elijah Wood), with no help from bug-eyed Gollum (Serkis), despite the adoring faithfulness of fellow hobbit Samwise (Sean Astin). Aragorn (Viggo Mortensen), the rightful heir to the throne of Gondor, must make his way on his own treacherous journey, eventually leading to Mordor, accompanied by elf Legolas (Orlando Bloom) and dwarf Gimli (John Rhys-Davies), while the other members of the original fellowship—Gandalf (Ian McKellen), Pippin (Billy Boyd), and Merry (Dominic Monaghan)—find their destinies just as intertwined as the ever-expanding reach of Mordor stretches across Middle-Earth.

Entire article at http://www.digitallyobsessed.com/showreview.php3?ID=6791

Barley
 
Oscar winner is even better in new DVD version

BRUCE KIRKLAND, SUN MEDIA

This is it: the Holy Grail, the ultimate triumphant march into film history: The Lord of The Rings is now in its complete and final form as the greatest trilogy ever. The coronation is scheduled for tomorrow when The Return Of The King - New Zealand director Peter Jackson's third film in his historic rendering of the epic novel by J.R.R. Tolkien - is released on DVD in the Special Extended Edition, a spectacular four-disc set.

The film itself [ROTK] is now four hours 12 minutes and 28 seconds long. Slightly more than 50 minutes of new footage, some of it crucial for the storytelling, all of it intriguing, has been added to the theatrical release version of last December.

There are 15 new scenes and 24 existing scenes that have been extended by seconds or even minutes in a few cases. The result is a rich, deeper, denser, more emotional, more intellectual and more involving film experience.

Paradoxically, yet exactly as it was with the special extended editions of The Fellowship of the Ring and The Two Towers, the much longer running time feels shorter because the flow of the film is smoother. The story unfolds more logically. More material from Tolkien's novel is embedded in the new version, even with the many changes that Jackson & Co. invoked to adapt the book to the screen.

This is the version that should have won those Oscars when The Return of the King devastated the competition and won 11 Academy Awards, including best picture. The February sweep meant The Return of the King tied both Ben-Hur (1959) and Titanic (1997) as the biggest winners in Oscar's 76 years. Now the film really deserves its honours.

The four-disc set also offers the most authoritive and interesting bonus materials of any Lord of the Rings DVD release to date (and I fully expect more variations in the future - perhaps a mega set with the extended versions of all three films, with their 11-hour-plus running time).

As for the new scenes in The Return of the King, the most interesting is Chapter 4, The Voice of Saruman. The seven-minute sequence finally reveals the fate of the corrupted white wizard and his startling encounter with Gandalf when he realizes his one-time pupil is now more powerful as well as more noble. Christopher Lee was reportedly upset that this sequence was missing from the theatrical version.

The best of the rest are two scenes also involving Gandalf. One comes when the Witch King challenges the Wizard's authority and shatters his staff in a thrilling scene on the battlements of Minas Tirith; the other, the Mouth of Sauron, comes when Gandalf joins Aragorn and others to ride out to meet Sauron's terrifying emissary outside the gates of Mordor near the climax of the film.

It's a scene that would have made the theatrical release even better because it sets up the good vs. evil struggle in stark detail.

As for the bonus materials, there are four separate commentaries involving, in total, more than 40 members of the cast and crew from Jackson to stars Elijah Wood, Ian McKellen, Liv Tyler, Sean Astin, Andy Serkis and Christopher Lee - who once told the Sun he was skeptical he would even be alive when The Return of the King was released. The commentaries are packaged with the film over two discs.

Disc #3, operating under the title the War of the Ring, is an outstanding collection of documentaries recounting the origins of The Lord of the Rings as a book and its realization as a movie series. The most important passages here involve a critical analysis of how Tolkien channelled his own education and experiences into his life's work.

Disc #4, operating under the title the Passing of an Age, includes a host of extras related to the making of The Return of the King.

More than anything else on the DVD set, this documentary demonstrates the emotional depth of Jackson and others involved in The Lord of the Rings - and that is the key to understanding their triumph.

Source: http://www.canoe.ca/NewsStand/EdmontonSun/Entertainment/2004/12/13/780267.html

Barley
 
The New Stuff

The following is a long excerpt from an even longer article by Scott Chitwood (there are spoilers ahead, but after December 14th [tomorrow as of this writing], all spoiler lists become forever irrelevant):

===============================

For this DVD review I'm only going to concentrate on the 50 minutes of bonus footage that's included in this special edition. If you'd like to see my review of the rest of the film, click here.

Like the previous special editions of the Lord of the Rings DVD's, there is a ton of extra footage included. Some of it is quite extensive and expands on the characters. Some of it goes by so fast that you hardly notice it. Thankfully, a booklet included with the DVD tells you exactly where all the changes are. If you just want to see those additions, it's easy to find them.

A few of the additions are quite dramatic. One of the most noteworthy is a scene showing a confrontation between Saruman and Gandalf in the flooded ruins of Isengard. We see Saruman talking trash with our heroes and smacking Wormtongue down. But as Gandalf offers Saruman his life in exchange for information, Theoden talks trash right back. The war of words eventually escalates until Gandalf shatters Saruman's staff, Wormtongue stabs Saruman, Legolas shoots Wormtongue, and Saruman falls to his rather dramatic death. It's an exciting scene that ties up a lot of loose ends about Christopher Lee's character even if it does depart from the book. I would have liked to see it included in the movie. (The death of Saruman, of course, eliminates any need to show the scouring of the Shire at the end of the film like in the book.)

Another dramatic scene occurs when Aragorn attempts to recruit the ghosts in the cave. Rather than immediately rallying to his cause, they disappear. Then a literal avalanche of skulls falls on our heroes and threatens to knock them into the abyss. Aragorn, Legolas, and Gimli escape from the cave and fall into despair until the ghost king reappears and agrees to help them. We then are treated to the sight of Aragorn commandeering the Corsair's ships along with the ghosts. Again, this helps explain how they all ended up on boats in the first place and where they came from. This scene also includes a ton of humor between Gimli and Legolas as well as a cameo by Peter Jackson and a number of the other crew as the Corsairs. Their fans will love it.

There are also a few more scenes establishing the blossoming romance between Faramir and Eowyn. They are shown in the "House of Healing" together and they are also shown comforting each other as their friends ride into battle. (These scenes are accompanied by a song sung by Liv Tyler.) It's a piece of the book that wasn't really covered in the theatrical version, but it helps wrap up the Aragorn / Eowyn romance.

Late in the film we see Frodo and Sam in disguise and getting accidentally caught up among a troop of Orcs moving towards the front of the battle. After causing a distraction, they are eventually able to give the orcs the slip despite almost being caught. It's a tense scene even if you know what's going to happen.

One of the final and most dramatic additions is Aragorn facing off with Sauron. Aragorn gazes into the Palantir (aka glowing bowling ball) and threatens the evil eye. We then see him marching into battle and facing off with The Mouth of Sauron played by an unrecognizable Bruce Spence (from Mad Max, Matrix, Star Wars, etc.). The hideous creature proceeds to tell our heroes that Frodo was captured, tortured, and killed. He offers up Frodo's mail shirt as proof. So how does Aragorn respond? He lops his head off, of course. It's quite a dramatic scene that really adds tension to the climax and gives a face and personality to Sauron. It's another one I would have liked to have seen included in the theatrical release.

There are a lot of shorter but no less significant scenes included in the film. The potential romance between Eowyn and Aragorn is shown a lot more. In one scene she describes a dream that she had of impending doom to Aragorn. There's more of Eowyn and Pippin preparing to ride into battle. A drinking game between Legolas and Gimli is also shown (which includes a cameo by composer Howard Shore). You see Frodo, Sam, and Gollum traveling through ruins of statues of kings from the past. There's a bit more of the Orc Captain (aka Sloth from the Goonies) leading his troops into battle. But my favorite of the "mini-additions" are those to the final battle scenes. There's more of a battle between Eowyn and the Orc Captain. I could be wrong but I think there's more of Legolas battling on top of the Oliphaunt. Pippin is even shown viciously attacking Orcs and stabbing them repeatedly. It's surprisingly violent considering the character. Then there's a very exciting but brief confrontation between Gandalf and the Witch King. The Witch King literally shatters Gandalf's staff and proves himself to be more than a match for the wizard. It makes Eowyn and Pippen's victory over him all the more impressive.

===============================

Entire article at http://www.comingsoon.net/news/dvdreviewsnews.php?id=7561 (Well worth going there to read the section entitled "The Extras.")

Barley
 
Last edited:
'King' Gets Royal Treatment in Extended DVD

By Jen Chaney
washingtonpost.com Staff Writer
Tuesday, December 14, 2004;

"The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King Special Extended Edition" (Rated PG-13; List price: $39.99 or $79.92 for the gift set)
Release date: Dec. 14

With 50 minutes of new or elongated scenes, the extended version of "The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King" boasts a four-hour-plus running time. And that doesn't even count the more than six hours of bonus features included in this four-disc collection, which -- like the extended editions of "The Fellowship of the Ring" and "The Two Towers" -- provides days (literally) of viewing material. Honestly, I could probably walk from downtown Washington to Middle-earth before most people have even loaded disc two into their DVD players.

That's not meant as a criticism. The extended editions of the three "Rings" films, all of which were released as follow-ups to the less-comprehensive DVDs of the theatrical versions, easily count among the finest, most meticulously crafted DVD sets ever made. It might seem that only Tolkien freaks and hairy-footed Hobbit geeks would care about all of this Smeagol-study. But anyone who considers himself a student of cinema will be engrossed by the exhaustive documentaries included here. In fact, I find the making of these movies just as fascinating as the movies themselves. So what exactly is included?

Documentaries about practically every aspect of the production, including the screenplay's adaptation, visual effects, costume design, principal photography, sound and more; production photos; a profile of young filmmaker Cameron Duncan, a friend of director Peter Jackson's who inspired the Oscar-winning "King" song, "Into the West"; a documentary about "Rings" author J.R.R. Tolkien; and four full-length commentary tracks from the director and writers, design team, production team and members of the cast. Nary a moment of the filmmaking process has been left uncaptured, which means fans literally serve as flies on the wall for many private moments, from cast and crew parties to Elijah Wood's final take, after which Jackson steps from behind the camera to tearfully embrace his trusted Frodo.

Many DVDs feature documentaries, but few are created with as much care and class as these. It's clear that everyone involved in "The Lord of the Rings" -- from the actors to the producers to the prosthetics artists -- feels great love for these films. That's reflected in this DVD collection, which will make the unabashedly loyal fans of "King" feel like they're not the only ones who hold Hobbits dear to their hearts.

Complete review at http://www.washingtonpost.com/ac2/wp-dyn/A61269-2004Dec13?language=printer

Barley
 
'Return of the King' DVD completes Jackson's trilogy

Dec. 14, 2004, 9:12AM

By BRUCE WESTBROOK
Houston Chronicle

After earning $2.9 billion globally at theaters, after 30 Oscar nominations and 16 wins, after three theatrical and six video campaigns, Peter Jackson's quest is done. With today's extended-edition DVD of The Return of the King, the writer-director has put his final stamp on J.R.R. Tolkien's Lord of the Rings trilogy.

Or has he? Even after expanding each film for DVD, Jackson has still more footage, as he reveals in one of King's four commentary tracks. "We're saving it for the 25th-anniversary edition," he jokes.

Complete article at http://www.chron.com/cs/CDA/ssistory.mpl/headline/entertainment/2945148

(ALSO AT THIS SITE: Audio Clips from the Chronicle's interview with Billy Boyd:

• On the friendships he made during filming
• On wrapping the trilogy
• On souvenirs from the final film

Audio Clips from the Chronicle's interview with Dominic Monaghan:

• On filming all three films at the same time
• On response to the films
• On why the films are so loved

Requires the free RealPlayer)

Barley
 
For never having to say “the end”

…or so you’d think: Lord of the Rings: The Return of the Ring (Extended Edition) (2003)

The DVD Pick of the (last two) Week(s) is an obvious choice. Rarely has a highly acclaimed, blockbuster film (or trilogy, no less) delivered on DVD the way The Lord of the Rings trilogy has. In fact, I dare say that for a fan of the book and/or films, the extended edition DVD version of each film is the definitive version. The same can’t be said for, say, the Star Wars trilogy. Like The Lord of the Rings trilogy, the Star Wars films have been released on DVD in “new” versions. However, unlike the Lord of the Rings movies, which have also been released on DVD in the theatrical versions to the delight of no fans, the Star Wars films have not been released as originally presented, to the delight of no fans. It’s an interesting comparison. While personally, I would rather have the Star Wars trilogy in any form on DVD than not at all, I do still have a sense of something being taken from me when I see some of the “new” additions to the films. With The Fellowship of the Ring and The Two Towers, seeing the new additions was like watching the movie again for the first time.

So much has been written about the trilogy, it’s not really necessary to rehash the plot of the film except to point out that it’s basically about a war going on while midgets carry a ring around. That said, the film did win all 11 Academy Awards it was nominated for, including Best Picture. In rewatching the extended editions of The Fellowship of the Ring and The Two Towers over the past few days, it’s clear just what an amazing accomplishment the trilogy is and how deserving Peter Jackson was of the Best Director Oscar. Just an incredible accomplishment.

As with the two previous installments in the trilogy, the Extended Edition is just that, bringing the total running time of the film to more than four glorious hours. All that before an additional 24 hours or so of extra features. Included on the four-disc set are an audio commentary track with director (and co-screenwriter) Peter Jackson, screenwriters Fran Walsh and Philippa Boyens; another with the production designers; one with the post-production team, and finally, one with cast members Elijah Wood, Ian McKellen, Liv Tyler, Sean Astin, John Rhys-Davies, Bernard Hill, Christopher Lee, Billy Boyd, Dominic Monaghan, Orlando Bloom, Hugo Weaving, Miranda Otto, David Wenham, Karl Urban, John Noble, Andy Serkis, Lawrence Makoare, Smeagol and Gollum. That’s right, Smeagol and Gollum offer their comments on the film. Also included on the discs are; photo galleries; two short films: "DFK6498" and "Strike Zone"; and a massive number of documentaries and featurettes. I think it’s safe to say that the full trilogy of Extended Edition DVDs total the most impressive array of extra features and expository material ever put together for any film, let alone three. It’s an accomplishment that should stand along side the films in history and quite obviously the DVD Pick of the (past two) Week(s).

Source: http://www.boxofficeprophets.com/column/index.cfm?columnID=8719

Barley
 
"The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King" Movie Review

Your Guide, Rebecca Murray From Rebecca Murray,
Your Guide to Hollywood Movies.

The Crowning Glory, The Finishing Touch, The Perfect Ending

Can I just start this out by declaring upfront Peter Jackson is a genius? There, I’ve said it and I stand behind my opinion. He’s a genius for having the guts to film the entire trilogy at the same time, for choosing the perfect mix of new, rising, and established actors, and for creating a fantasy world so breathtakingly entrancing fans of Tolkien’s work were left with very little to gripe about. Jackson’s also one smart cookie for his use of the Internet and fan sites to spread the news (and hype) surrounding “The Lord of the Rings.” Instead of keeping fans at a distance, Jackson did a fantastic job of embracing the people who would ultimately buy tickets, buy the DVDs, and support “The Lord of the Rings” trilogy.

Jackson knew going in that Tolkien fans were going to scrutinize and analyze every detail, every nuance of his films. Despite what must have appeared at times an insurmountable task, Jackson remained committed to creating an epic adventure that would entertain while staying as close as possible, within the confines of time constraints and visual effects, to Tolkien’s literary vision.

There’s no denying parts of the novels were changed, omitted or reworked. Bringing every single page of “The Lord of the Kings” trilogy to the screen was/is simply not possible. And like “The Two Towers,” it’s absolutely necessary to have seen the previous two movies (not just have read the books) in order to quickly pick up on the story.

“The Return of the King” starts off with the fellowship split into different subgroups. Frodo (Elijah Wood) and Sam (Sean Astin) are being led by Gollum (still one of the coolest creatures ever created) to Mordor. As the One Ring gets closer to Sauron, its power over the ringbearer becomes increasingly intense. The friendship between the loyal Sam and his Frodo is put to the test, with Gollum weaseling his way into Frodo’s confidence and effectively pushing Sam out.

The larger group of fellowship members is split apart after a disturbing incident with a glass orb. For the first time on the journey, Merry and Pippin are separated, with Pippin (Billy Boyd) accompanying Gandalf (Ian McKellen) to Gondor’s capital, Minas Tirith. Merry (Dominic Monaghan) remains with Aragorn (Viggo Mortensen), Legolas (Orlando Bloom), Gimli (John Rhys-Davies), King Theodon (Bernard Hill) and the soldiers of Rohan as they strike out to assist the soldiers of Gondor who are led by the mentally imbalanced King Denethor (John Noble). The fellowship peels off even further as Aragorn, Legolas, and Gimli visit the Paths of the Dead where deceased soldiers haunt the mountains waiting to be released from their pledge to assist Isildur. While Aragorn and crew are calling on the ghost soldiers, Merry and Eowyn (Miranda Otto) secretly join the horse soldiers of Rohan to battle Sauron’s army at the Siege of Minas Tirith.

That’s basically the set-up, with the little groups facing formidable odds while on the final stretch of the journey. Almost three and half hours long, “The Return of the King” flows so smoothly it seems considerably less lengthy. And while the battle scenes, including the Siege of Minas Tirith and the Battle of Pelennor Fields, will be praised by audiences, Jackson did well in remembering the humanity of his characters, allowing each central figure to be fully fleshed out and not lost in the great battles.

The effects in “The Return of the King” are up to par with what we’ve come to expect from the trilogy. You’ll swear Gollum is a real flesh and blood character, and Frodo and Sam’s battle with Shelob the spider is incredibly well done. The only part of the movie that was a little distracting involved the giant elephants. Some of the effects were a little on the cheesy side, in particular a scene with Legolas fighting his way up the side of the elephant. It just looked exactly like what it was, a CG effect. But other than a few very minor aberrations, “The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King” is epic filmmaking and storytelling taken to the nth degree.

If you’re going to do a trilogy, there has to be a compelling reason for there to be a third movie. The third film has to be the big pay-off (take note “Matrix” filmmakers). With “The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King,” Jackson fulfilled all of his promises. The epic journey concludes on a masterful note, with this final film the most emotionally involving and, dare I say, entertaining of the three.

Bring on “The Hobbit” – with Peter Jackson at the helm, of course!

GRADE: A

"The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King" was directed by Peter Jackson (cast and crew list) and is rated PG-13 for intense epic battle sequences and frightening images.

Entire article at http://romanticmovies.about.com/cs/lordoftherings3/a/lotr3rv121603.htm

Barley
 
A royal wrap-up to 'Rings' trilogy

By SUSAN KING
Los Angeles Times

The two previous extended editions of Peter Jackson's "Lord of the Rings" films -- "The Fellowship of the Ring" and "The Two Towers" -- were sterling examples of what a special digital edition of a movie could and should be.

Each was filled with extended and deleted scenes and commentaries and tons of informative, well-produced featurettes. The trend continues with this four-disc set of the last installment of the J.R.R. Tolkien trilogy, the leading candidate for the best special-edition set of the year (Platinum Series Special Extended Edition, New Line, $40; Collector's Gift Set, $80).

Of course, you'll need hours and hours to experience the extended edition. With the deleted and extended scenes, the movie clocks in at a heady 4 hours, 10 minutes, and there are four commentary tracks and six hours of documentary featurettes. It's best to savor this edition over a couple of days. It may just be too much to watch in one sitting.

The new scenes: Perhaps the most important footage that has been reinstated for this special edition is a seven-minute sequence in which Christopher Lee's evil Saruman meets a very violent end. Originally the scene was filmed for "The Two Towers" but was omitted because it impeded the flow of that film. When the scene didn't seem to fit seamlessly into "Return of the King," either, Jackson tried everything to make it work and even called Lee back to the set for a series of reshoots. Still, Jackson wasn't satisfied and cut the scene from "Return of the King," much to the dismay of the veteran actor Lee. (In his audio commentary on "Return of the King," there is still a bit of rancor in Lee's voice about being left out of the film.)

So did Jackson make the right decision?

Yes and no. The Saruman sequence does slow the action in what is already a very long film, but it does bring closure to the character, and fans will enjoy the flamboyant way in which he meets his end.

Saruman's death isn't the only scene shot for "The Two Towers" that was repurposed for "Return of the King." The whole opening sequence of "Return of the King," which depicts how Smeagol found the ring and was transformed into the wretched Gollum, was originally supposed to be in "Two Towers," after the scene in which Sam tells Gollum about his real identity.

Jackson loved the scene but thought it interrupted the main story. So when it came time to plan the opening of "Return of the King," Jackson thought the Smeagol sequence would be the perfect bookend to the trilogy. Screenwriter and Jackson-significant-other Fran Walsh helmed most of that sequence.

And when she got sick, Andy Serkis, who plays Smeagol/Gollum, took over.

Complete story at http://www.southbendtribune.com/sto...20041217-sbt-MARS-D1-A_royal_wrap_up_to__.sto

Barley
 
Extra 50 minutes ring true on DVD boxed set

Friday, December 17, 2004
By John Serba
The Grand Rapids Press

Hear that noise? It's the sound of "Lord of the Rings" super-geeks blocking off an entire day for a trilogy marathon.

Now that "Return of the King Extended Edition" is in stores, the massive saga comes to its ultimate conclusion. Like the extended cuts of "Fellowship of the Ring" and "The Two Towers," "ROTK" boasts significant additions to the theatrical cut, which managed to win 11 Oscars last February, including for best picture.

A seamless fit

Where "director's cuts" of other films can be muddled or indulgent -- did anybody really need an extra 30 minutes of "Dardevil"? -- director Peter Jackson anages to enrich his exhaustive, exhausting film series with unseen footage, which is integrated seamlessly into the movies.

This new version of "ROTK" boasts the longest screen time of the trilogy: 50 minutes have been added, making the total run time clock in at a whopping four hours and 10 minutes. However, it never gets tedious or repetitive, proving more "Rings" is almost always a good thing.

The film picks up where "The Two Towers" left off. The wizard Gandalf (Ian McKellen), future king Aragorn (Viggo Mortensen), elf Legolas (Orlando Bloom) and dwarf Gimli (John Rhys-Davies) are preparing for the evil, all-seeing eye Sauron's siege on Gondor, the land of men.

Meanwhile, hobbits Frodo (Elijah Wood) and Samwise (Sean Astin) are trekking to the dark land of Mordor, with computer-animated beastie Gollum (voice of Andy Serkis) in tow, to destroy the ring that holds Middle Earth's evil power.

In fact, watching the "Extended Edition" is akin to watching an entirely different film. Characters are further fleshed out -- especially warrior maiden Eowyn (Miranda Otto) and Faramir (David Wenham), a knight from the city of Minas Tirith -- and any narrative holes from the theatrical cut are, for the most part, sewed up.

Complete article at http://www.mlive.com/entertainment/grpress/index.ssf?/base/entertainment-0/110329844148800.xml

Barley
 
Tolkien tale gets royal treatment

Posted on Fri, Dec. 17, 2004

''We've come to it now -- the great battle of our time,'' said a member of the fellowship in The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King. The new ''Platinum Series Special Edition'' four-disc DVD (New Line, $39.99) renders the battle even greater, adding 50 additional minutes to the movie, which originally ran 3 hours and 21 minutes.

It turns what was already an epic, exhaustive finale to the best movie trilogy ever into a stately, spectacular summation. There are extended sequences, additional explorations of characters and motivations, and restored scenes that were sacrificed (including the last stand of Christopher Lee's Saruman and a romantic interlude between Miranda Otto's Eowyn and David Wenham's Faramir). One of the scenes compels us to consider something we've already seen from a decidedly different perspective. But I won't ruin it by spelling it out here.

It would take a J.R.R. Tolkien scholar or someone obsessed with director Peter Jackson and his work to take this in one sitting, especially since New Line's user-friendly assembly invites us to stop at various points to explore the history and mythology that Tolkien integrated into his philosophical fantasy, most of it explored on other discs in the set. (Oddly, New Line has chosen not to apply its innovative InfiniFilm branching options for any of the extended DVD editions, though it has been deployed on lesser titles like Elf.)

A more considered option might be to set aside a post-holiday week and enjoy the package miniseries-style, an hour or so each evening, while saving another week to poke around in the documentaries and production footage that make up the third and fourth discs. They include comprehensive pieces on how the digital effects and production elements were fused, and how various creatures were imagined and brought to the screen. A month or so later, you might have recovered enough to listen to the scene-specific commentaries by Jackson, the producers, the designers and the cast members, who apparently became a band of brothers during the filming of this and its two predecessors.

Also available is The Motion Picture Trilogy ($119.97), a box that contains the special editions of all three films. You can be certain, however, that an even more elaborate collection of the three films will appear at some time in the future.

TERRY LAWSON

Knight Ridder News Service

Source: http://www.miami.com/mld/miamiherald/entertainment/weekend/10428697.htm?1c

Barley
 
Movies: One DVD to rule them all

07 January 2005
By PHILIP WAKEFIELD

For the third year running, The Lord of the Rings ruled supreme on DVD in 2004. The four-disc Special Extended Edition of The Return of the King faced fierce rivalry for its home video throne, including the 10-disc Matrix Collection and the four-disc Star Wars trilogy.

But the winner of 11 Oscars couldn't be matched for the brilliance of its audio and video, and the breadth, depth and architecture of its extras.

Director Peter Jackson was among the first film-makers to recognise DVD's potential for maximising revenue, promotion and creativity.

He added nearly an hour of footage to The Return of the King, along with 350 new visual effects, while the copious extras barely scratch the celluloid of the behind-the-scenes footage his Forgotten Silver collaborator, Costa Botes, shot for three new documentaries destined for yet more special-edition DVDs (Jackson will work on these after King Kong).

The marketing of Jackson's trilogy in multiple DVD packages is a textbook example of how Hollywood has learned to milk a movie or franchise beyond its box office run.

Full article at http://www.stuff.co.nz/stuff/0,2106,3149931a1860,00.html

Barley
 
Are this Costas guy and his 3 planned DVDs well known, or is the first time they've been mentioned? Who is he?!
 
joxy said:
Are this Costas guy and his 3 planned DVDs well known, or is the first time they've been mentioned? Who is he?!

After doing a bit of googlesearching, it appears that he is a so-called actor/writer/director who was in PJ's movie "Bad Taste," playing one of the aliens...

Barley
 
I loved the movie, yet the scene with Frodo falling when Sauron's eye comes upon him in Mordor with Sam is so tasteless. He throws his hands up and falls down like he is lighter than a fairy!. Come on, Tolkien would shudder!.

The Fellowship started a great imaginative vibe that cried for more from the writings, yet as each movie progressed i felt more removed from the purpose with sadness. The series is still amazing in my eyes, and capture is more difficult than reality....yet somehow I don't feel the feeling from the books when I watch the movies!
 
Aw, and I'm sure Jackson thought that was SO clever! A sort of slow--motion ballet move.... :D
 
I loved it!! To me is a masterpiece, and it really helps people to get into the books.

I saw it at the movies like 11 times, and I have the normal DVD and the Extended edition too.

The whole LOTR saga, the trilogy is my all-time favorite movie EVER!!
 

Today's events

Back
Top