What about Pippin? You can't leave him out:
Pippin.
1: a crisp tart apple having usually yellow or greenish-yellow skin strongly flushed with red and used especially for cooking
2: a highly admired or very admirable person or thing.
I wonder which one Tolkien had in mind when he gave Pippin his nickname.
'Zactly. Try not to over analyze it....
(I've always found it difficult to get a firm handle on what's really happening with Frodo's final journey. It's probably meant to be fuzzy and ethereal and not something that's meant to be perfectly clear.)
The engineering part of my brain really wants to convert your statement into an equation. So, just for fun, what you're saying is...It isn't universally true, but it is true for some of us (moi included) : loss of enjoyment of Tolkien's works increases in direct proportion to the effort expended in analyzing them.
First , I like your equation as it 'zactly represents what I said..... Bravo! ... *polite applause*The engineering part of my brain really wants to convert your statement into an equation. So, just for fun, what you're saying is...
ΔE = -kA
where,
ΔE is the change in enjoyment of Tolkien’s works
A is the effort spent in analysis of Tolkien’s works
and k is the proportionality constant
For me, the opposite of your statement is true. This thread represents a substantial effort on my part toward analyzing Tolkien's work. And, so far, it has only enhanced my enjoyment of the stories. My equation is the same as yours except for the minus sign:
ΔE = kA
Edit: Of course, I do take your point (I think as you intended): trying to nail down with certainty whether Frodo's ship sailed off into outer space, or did it fade away into another realm, or what would a ship of men sailing alongside Frodo's ship have observed along the way: these would be fruitless analyses. It's best left as a mysterious event.
A most-excellent reply. Many thanks.First , I like your equation as it 'zactly represents what I said..... Bravo! ... *polite applause*
However... “I know that you believe you understand what you think I said, but I’m not sure you realize that what you heard is not what I meant.”
What you are doing is NOT analyzing Tolkien. You are "looking up words" (as we always phrased it in grade school) for which you do not know the definitions. It is very important to know the meanings of words, to fully appreciate a story, any story.
A very wise man (my mentor, now residing on the far side of eternity) told me to "always have a dictionary at hand when sitting down to read, regardless of the genre of the material. It should be right there next to your cup of tea."
I *ahem* 😇 already knew the definitions of about 95% of the words in your list.
But there is still that 5% which I did not know. And had you not chased down the meanings I would have had to do it.
To be fair, I had more or less accurately guessed meanings of those few from context and/or by familiarity with the root of the word.
But there will always be words to look up and, tho' he is gone, I would not disappoint my mentor, so the dictionary is on the side table by my cup of tea.
(The 20 vol OED is in another room )
Analyzing Tolkien is the activity on this forum and other JRRT related sites in which members ( I do not exempt myself) discuss, argue, question (at times not quite coming to blows) about how many Maiar can dance on the head of a wizard's staff.
Sometimes I enjoy it (I really enjoy it bunches when I win the argument😁) but I often come away drained by it.
"...Of making many books there is no end; and much study is a weariness of the flesh."
Rather, I should just sit back and simply enjoy the journey through his enchanting world of Middle Earth that the Professor has so kindly made possible.
Apparently, the phrase "my liege" can be spoken from the subject to the lord or from the lord to the subject (as in Denethor's usage). In the movies, as far as I can remember, it seems like it's always spoken by the subject.
I've also heard "liege lord" used to describe the superior. To me it sounds like 'the lord to whom I owe allegiance'.liege Minas Tirith: "’Now tell me your tale, my liege,’ said Denethor, half kindly, half mockingly. ‘For the words of one whom my son so befriended will be welcome indeed.’”, [Definitions: 1. a loyal subject, or 2. a feudal superior to whom allegiance and service are due.]
From the OED....(excerpted)I added only one word to the list today but included a little of my charred speculation regarding its use:
brand The Siege of Gondor: "Denethor laughed bitterly. ‘…why should I sit here in my tower and think, and watch, and wait, spending even my sons? For I can still wield a brand.’ He stood up and cast open his long black cloak, and behold! he was clad in mail beneath, and girt with a long sword, great-hilted in a sheath of black and silver.", [Meanings: a sword, a piece of burning wood, or a piece of charred wood.]
Why would Denethor be the only character in the story (I think) to refer to his sword as a brand?
Three thoughts:
So, in summary: Denethor is dressed like a brand, girt with a brand, about to grab a brand, and about to be on fire like a brand. It’s almost too much! Is Tolkien’s use of brand a bit of dark foreshadowing or just a coincidence?
- He’s covered in a long black cloak. The same color as a charred piece of wood, perhaps? (One meaning of brand.)
- Very soon Denethor is going to grab a torch and “thrust the brand amid the fuel”.
- He’s about to be on fire becoming a brand himself.
Edit: At minimum, I think it's a great example of a double entendre; he says he can still wield a brand (sword), but he's going to be wielding a brand of a different sort.
"Liege", "my liege", "Liege lord" when used as a direct address is always directed upward; that is, from an inferior (or subordinate) to one's superior.Today I added three words to the list.
Apparently, the phrase "my liege" can be spoken from the subject to the lord or from the lord to the subject (as in Denethor's usage). In the movies, as far as I can remember, it seems like it's always spoken by the subject.
....
liege Minas Tirith: "’Now tell me your tale, my liege,’ said Denethor, half kindly, half mockingly. ‘For the words of one whom my son so befriended will be welcome indeed.’”, [Definitions: 1. a loyal subject, or 2. a feudal superior to whom allegiance and service are due.]
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?