I just watched the first half of
Lawrence of Arabia. and something stood out to me which I just have to share.
It ties into both this film and to Tolkien, and ultimately to characters/stories which are incredible because they resonate, are realistic, are inspiring to a world much in need of a ceertain type of character:
I once heard a discussion (on I believe the Tolkien Lore Podcast years ago) called “Why we need more characters like
Faramir”.
In other words, we need more characters who are good/heroic, not because they always makes the right decision (an unrealistic, and thus admired but discouraging character) but because they take the time to think, discuss, weigh wisely, and then follow the right way no matter the cost. Particularly important decisions 1) Either in the future or 2) to the present and decisions which are unclear.
This character type is in opposition to two other characters 1) The stupid, must work through major flaws character (i. e. Faramir in Peter Jackson's movie) Or 2) The character who always seems to do everything right (unrealistically)
Book Faramir, for instance once he captures
Frodo and
Sam, is unsure of what to do. He talks calmly to them, he treats them kindly and he tells Frodo
he must think about the matter. Then he is able to choose wisely. Rather than immediately acting, he is not simply a good character because he does the right thing but he is realistic and encouraging to the reader because he takes the time to find the right way. (Take note -
talking to others, seeking advice, in this decision making is majorly important too)
And this stood out to me in
Lawrence of Arabia in Lawrence’s character. I do not know if it was historically accurate but, for the sake of storytelling, it was incredible. That is, how much effort they put into the scene as he makes the turning point decision. I believe good stories and characters should be realistic partly for the purpose of being applicable to our lives. And vice versa - by being applicable/realistic it is incredible storytelling.
We need the character that is neither goody-good for no reason or horridly without self-control, seemingly stupid. We need them for they are applicable. we need them for mankind. They are the kinds of characters for role models, for inspiring
real people to do good in this world. we need characters who the audience can see are good because they intentionally walk through life, they talk with others, they think, they choice the right paths with intention. Am I not right - does not your spirit soar when you encounter this?
Do you see what I am getting at? I love this conversation.
P.S. I Love
the Lord of the Rings film trilogy but this is why I cannot stand Faramir’s portrayal (also Tolkien said if there was anyone in the
books he thought he was like it was Faramir. So yes, I could go on a rant
)
This could be an excellent discussion for the "What are the signs of a good writer or book for you" thread!
https://thetolkien.forum/threads/what-are-the-signs-of-a-good-writer-or-book-for-you.31265/
And now I will go watch the rest of the film. So far, spectacular!!!
thetolkien.forum
