NetherDemon
Champion of Morgoth
- Joined
- Jan 2, 2003
- Messages
- 224
To add to what NetherDemon said
Originally posted by Melko Belcha
Middle-earth is the world of Tolkien's imagination, it is not a shared world like Dungeons & Dragons or Star Wars. During the process of writing LOTR Tolkien took the time to learn how to stew rabbit, the phases of the moon, how fast storms move, and much more. It upsets me that Tolkien spent fifteen years writing the story to have some guy come along and rewrite the characters and key elements of the story that Tolkien worked so hard on. Anybody who has read HoME Volumes VI-IX know the labor and hard work he put into every detail, and to have PJ disregard it just is not right. I was just as mad a Romeo and Juliet for the same reasons. People want to say, 'What about PJ's poetic rights?', I ask, 'What about Tolkien's rights to the story he wrote?'. If some band was to go in and rerecord The Beatles White Album (or any album you like) and rewrote some of the songs, like turning Blackbird into the Big Bang Boog-a-loo, I would be just as mad. I believe in the rights and respect of the people who create books, music, artwork, or anything that comes from their own imagination, not getting famous because you rip someone else's work off.
How on earth can you reconcile those two statements?Originally posted by NetherDemon
(I'm an English Major BTW)
I love the movies. I have no issues with anything except the....Orc....
Originally posted by The Wookie
I am in no way shape or form disagreeing with the fact that P.J. owns the movie rights for LOTR. I was simply stating my oppinion about the innaccuracies. I'm entitled to my oppinion just as you are entitled to yours. In short, please recieve my sincerest apalogies for any offensive material that I may have posted that hurt your ego.
P.S. It was just a question. You didn't have to bite my head off. (sob..sob..sniff) And poeple call me melodramatic. Gee, I wonder why?
P.S.S. Don't answer that last question.
You said it, PJ respects Tolkien's work. But as me and gondorian45 have said, PJ did not respect Tolkien himself. It is no secret that Tolkien never wanted LOTR turned into a film, and he clearly stated his beliefs of how it should be done. PJ did exactually the stuff Tolkien wished would not happen. And Tolkien sold his rights because his wife was extremely sick in the hospital and he needed money to pay for the bills.Originally posted by The Wookie
We should all realize that we are greatly priviliged to have a movie director that greatly respects Tolkien's works.
Originally posted by gondorian45
Ahh, this I now remember I thought I had read that somewhere but I was not sure, but that brings up another thing that makes me angry how much money has New line cinemas, Peter jackson, etc made off these movies millions and how much of that goes to Tolkien or his family none, now you could say none should go to them cause he sold his rights but you gotta think it was this man's genious that created it and the people who reap the most off it are some movie directors that outrage Tolkien lovers and create millions of Orlando Bloom cults and fan clubs.
"And Tolkien sold his rights because his wife was extremely sick in the hospital and he needed money to pay for the bills.
Surely Tolkien would have been intelligent enough to maintain atleast Royalty Rights to the movie. We're not talking 19th Century Here. I know Christopher Tolkien has written forewords for a few books about his father and surely he's getting his fair share of cash. Then there are the college lectures and speaking engagments that Christopher cashes in on on his father's expense. I don't begrudge him for that. I would too!
As for benefactors of the movie.... Sorry to sound harsh, but get over it. This is life. Life sucks. You can say the same things about great painters who got barely anything for their works during their lives, yet years after they die, people buy, sell and trade their works over and over again for TONS of money. How many painters fans are screaming about it? Most of them bought the paintings!
For the hundreds that want Tolkien's book to stay on paper, there are probably millions who wanted them converted to movies. Where was the backlash for the animated version of the Hobbitt, Return of the King or Bakshi's LOTR? There was none! Why? Because those versions were unsuccessful, therefore noone cared.
I think LOTR has transcended the author too. Much the same way Einstein's Atomic Theory led to the creation of the Atmoic Bomb, which he was totally regretfull about of when it was finally made into a bomb. Einstein was looking to make an alternative form of energy - the US government wanted to Nuke Japan!
There are no "moral rules" when it comes to literature and Movies. Hell, many people hate Tolkien for abandoning his trench during the war and going AWOL until the war ended. I don't care about that at all. I hate war. But some people refuse to accept Tolkien for just that fact.
EDIT - Man, maybe I should write some papers! Of course, I used Napster to download MP3s, so I guess my copyright respect is rather shakey...
For your information he came down with a severe case of trench fever, like many soilders during WW I, and he was hosptialised.Hell, many people hate Tolkien for abandoning his trench during the war and going AWOL until the war ended. I don't care about that at all. I hate war. But some people refuse to accept Tolkien for just that fact.
Where? Where?Originally posted by The Wookie
....we are greatly privileged to have a movie director that greatly respects Tolkien's works.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?