Who are we in Tolkien's Middle-Earth?

[BlackCaptain]

"Obviously, BC, you're Ioreth. . .the nurse in the House of Healing. "

Hahahahaha Naw.

I'm probly like Bill Ferny... mischevious and lovin it

or is that Merry?

 

[Ol'gaffer]

This is a toughie, I can imagine Lanty as Legolas, but I can't for the life in me think of anything for me.

I guess I'm not very third ageish.

 

[Inderjit S]

Beleg=Goblin King
Nom=Grishnakh
Nenya=Mahur
Maedhros=Gorbag
Lantarion=Shagrat
Hurin Thalion=Snaga
ithrynluin=Ugluk
Anamatar=Bolg
Beorn=Azog
Gil-galad=Boldog
Arvedui=Radbug
Lhun=Lagduf
Eriol=Muzgash
Aule=Ufthak
YayGollum=Golfimbul
Ancalagon=Othrod
gate7ole=Balcmeg
Turgon=Lug
Finduilas=Orobal
Luthien=Inderjit. (Note: I've just named anyone that has come into my pretty head.) p.s=you are ALL Orks.

 

[HLGStrider]

I'm not!
I'm one of the cats!

 

[Inderjit S]

HLG=Evil White Cat of Queen Beruthiel.

 

[HLGStrider]

Ooooh. . .I can accept that

 

[Ithrynluin]

Bringing this thread back to light...I think we could come up with many more, especially since we have so many new members.

For starters, Inderjit S is a cut out Ghan-Buri-Ghan. Do you not think so?

 

[elvesrock]

are there any mentions of members being goldberry? im very goldberry-ish except i look nothing like her

 

[Rhiannon]

I'm easy Beleg already pegged who I am *pleased that she didn't have to do it herself*

Eriol is definitely Faramir.

I'm not sure about Elgee, but I think a Goldberry/Eowyn mix works, varying with her mood. I've seen her be both.

Tal is Eowyn mixed with one of the hobbits...Pippin, maybe? Or maybe mixed with Gandalf, since she leads projects (Rillewen!)

The-Elf-Herself is...mm. Tough one. I think Galadriel, maybe.

Thol is a hobbit. Merry or Pippin...I'll have to think about which.

Mm...who else can I come up with off the top of my head?

I can't think of a character sweet enough for Kailita.

 

[Ithrynluin]

Rhiannon = a dead-ringer for Arwen

All agree?

 

[Rhiannon]

Ahem.

I'm not even dignifying that with a response.

(This is not a response)

 

[Ithrynluin]

Interesting.

But which female character could you be then?

Galadriel?

Celebrian?

Aredhel?

Dis, the only dwarf woman ever named?

Shelob? Ungoliant? Lobelia Sackville-Baggins?

However, you are quite close to being Erendis, the willful mariner's wife.

Did I miss anyone?

 

[Inderjit S]

For starters, Inderjit S is a cut out Ghan-Buri-Ghan. Do you not think so

Hm...I am Faramir. I have all his good qualties and none of his bad ones. In fact I don't have any bad qualities. If there ever was a defintion of perfection it'd be me Inderjit Sanghera-King of the world.

No really I am most like hmm...Pippin? Faramir? Fëanor? Fëppamir?

Rhiannon=Crazy, homicidal Easterling woman who Grima is secretly married to. He keeps her locked up in his tower, feeding her fish-heads and lembas three times a day, with a copy of Death, Murder and Pringles, Éowyn's weekly newsletter, which has sent her into a murderous anti-Éowyn rage.

ithrynluin=Grima

Éowyn (Grima's other love intrest)=Gil-Galad with a blonde wig on. (And of course shaved legs and armpits, unless Éowyn had hairy legs and armpits. We are never told.

 

[Beleg]

Inder is the movie Faramir. Always sucking up to his daddy!

 

[Ithrynluin]

You hear that, Rhiannon? Our cover has been blown! Run away!

Now let us retreat deep into the East where the stars are strange, and plot our revenge.

Originally posted by Beleg
Inder is the movie Faramir. Always sucking up to his daddy!

Yeah, Inder. Stop sucking up to me already.

 

[Rhiannon]

*cough* I'm so totally not speaking to any of you...

 

[Inderjit S]

Oh guys! I thought immature behaviour and cheap jokes were my forte! Go get your own acts!

*cough* I'm so totally not speaking to any of you...

Oh! What happened to the wild, untameable shield-maiden? Rupture some spleens, stab us in the back and buy some cough syrup!

 

[Rhiannon]

Shhh, I'm at a babyshower! I'll deal with you later!

 

[Elbereth]

I guess Elgee is correct when she says that I'm most like Melian.

I may also be like Galadriel. She is likes power...but she knows when to stay out of a fight. And she has an air of mystery about her...and mystery is something I pride myself in keeping.

Elgee: I see her either as Goldberry or Rosie Cotton.
Tal: she is like Yavanna..
Aerin or Rhiannon: These two both personify Eowen perfectly
Dain: he is cross between Gimli and Legolas...if you can imagine that!
Galdor: Faramir
Cir: Boromir or Eomer
Grond: Gandalf
Anc: Sauruman
Beorn: Aragorn or Ulmo
WM: Illuvatar or Manwe
RD: Definately Tom B.
Narya: Arwen
Eriol: Beren

I may come up with more...but that is all for now.

 

[HLGStrider]

Elgee: I see her either as Goldberry or Rosie Cotton.

Just don't see the second half. . .and both of those girls married the type of guy I'm not really attracted too. . .