• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Why didn't Frodo use Sting on Gollum at the Crack of Doom?

Joined
Feb 19, 2018
Messages
267
I know they ditched the cooking gear and all and had lost their armor and had stolen orc armor (which I think they might have ditched as well to lighten the load.). But I could have sworn that in Frodo's confrontation with Gollum outside the Crack of Doom that he threatened Smeagol with his sword Sting. However, when attacked, while having the advantage of being invisible, somehow he doesn't use it to stab at Gollum to try and keep his finger from being bitten off.
 
At this point Sting is with Sam, as can be seen in this paragraph from the chapter Mount Doom where they're tossing stuff away so they don't have to pack it any more.

"He came back to Frodo, and then of his elven-rope he cut a short piece to serve his master as a girdle and bind the grey cloak close about his waist. The rest he carefully coiled and put back in his pack. Beside that he kept only the remnants of their waybread and the water-bottle, and Sting still hanging by his belt; and hidden away in a pocket of his tunic next his breast the phial of Galadriel and the little box that she gave him for his own."

So Sam is packing Frodo's stuff as well as his own now.

The question might be asked why Sam did not rush forward and help Frodo when he was tussling with Gollum at the brink of the chasm's edge.

But we get the sense that Sam, having been knocked down, getting up 'dazed and with blood streaming down his head', saw all that was transpiring in a very short span of time, and did not have presence of mind nor time to either react, or act, given what he was seeing.

Thus ends Gollum... not by the thrust of Sting into the murk and mire of his innards, but by his own glee and lust at fulfilling at last his desire to repossess the Ring, and get betrayed by it. (Or by an even wiser and greater power, as it were, the ring not 'willing' itself to be destroyed.)

To Ent, a much more satisfactory ending than simply being gutted into the bargain.
 
Last edited:

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top