• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Why Didn't the ⛏️Dwarves fight in the ⚔️battle of the last alliance?

Well does anyone know what I am talking about? I know I read that somewhere but I can't remember now, I think it's in the Sil...........
 
Originally posted by redline2200
Well does anyone know what I am talking about? I know I read that somewhere but I can't remember now, I think it's in the Sil...........

You probably misunderstood me...I know which line you are referring to (can't remember where it's from right now), I'm just saying it's a bit out there you know. Hobbits and Eagles fighting on Sauron's side...? I dunno about that.
 
There have always been some form of 'evil' Dwarves: remember what the Dwarves did for the Nauglamír? Not exactly pretty stuff.
I think most of us do remember the line you're talking about, Redline, but I agree with Ithrynluin that Tolkien was only exaggerating. To actuallly think that there were Hobbits and Ents fighting for Sauron you would have to take what JRRT said pretty literally. :)
 
Originally posted by Lantarion
There have always been some form of 'evil' Dwarves: remember what the Dwarves did for the Nauglamír? Not exactly pretty stuff.

Lanty, I don't think that those Dwarves could be called "evil". They were just caught up in something too great for them (a Silmaril and the terrible oath that was associated with it). Similar to the Elves who are called "the Kinslayers" - what they did terribly wrong, but I wouldn't call them evil.

I guess the real evil Dwarves who fought on Sauron's side, were those of other houses, whose dwellings are further East (I guess). They would probably be alienated from their brethren in the West, and were more under the influence of the Shadow (both Morgoth's and Sauron's), which quite likely spread lies among them about the "Good peoples" and that's how they were persuaded to fight. But being sturdy and steadfast as only Dwarves can be, they couldn't be dominated by anyone.
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top