Mrs. Maggott
Home is where the cat is
- Joined
- Oct 2, 2002
- Messages
- 3,463
But there is a scene when Elrond shows Arwen what will happen they marry, and it's put into the context of King Aragorn. Therefore the audience is given no alternative context. They can only marry if he's king. <quote chrischarlton>
But unlike the book, Jackson's Elrond makes no conditions under which his daughter may marry Aragorn. Indeed, he doesn't want that to happen! Also, the way Jackson at least introduces the Lady, one assumes that she is not all that obedient to the wishes of her father. Jackson wished her to appear strong and independent (and then he went and changed it back again). But still, there is nothing said about any caveats regarding a marriage between the two as existed in the book.
As for whether or not Aragorn had to be king for Arwen to marry him: yes, this is the fate that she is shown, but it is not written in stone. That would be predestination and I don't think even Jackson presented that in his message (such as it is). Furthermore, I don't think his targeted audience would give the matter much thought. Indeed, maybe even Jackson didn't give it much thought. Perhaps, in fact, we are agonizing over motives where none exist on the part of the Director. Maybe he just went with what he thought would work and hang the sense (or nonsense) of it. Your guess is as good as mine.
But unlike the book, Jackson's Elrond makes no conditions under which his daughter may marry Aragorn. Indeed, he doesn't want that to happen! Also, the way Jackson at least introduces the Lady, one assumes that she is not all that obedient to the wishes of her father. Jackson wished her to appear strong and independent (and then he went and changed it back again). But still, there is nothing said about any caveats regarding a marriage between the two as existed in the book.
As for whether or not Aragorn had to be king for Arwen to marry him: yes, this is the fate that she is shown, but it is not written in stone. That would be predestination and I don't think even Jackson presented that in his message (such as it is). Furthermore, I don't think his targeted audience would give the matter much thought. Indeed, maybe even Jackson didn't give it much thought. Perhaps, in fact, we are agonizing over motives where none exist on the part of the Director. Maybe he just went with what he thought would work and hang the sense (or nonsense) of it. Your guess is as good as mine.

