• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Aragorn Warns 🧙Gandalf

I believe you are refering to the film there spirit?
And it was Saruman that warned Gandalf that he knew what the dwarves awoke in Khaxad-dum, not Sauron.

But this thread is discussing the book, not the film. Saruman did not warn Gandalf in the book like he did in the film.
 
i guess that's the only logical answer we can come up with, Merabella. so foresight it is, then!
reem
 
I agree that they also knew something big and evil had killed all the dwarves there and quite possibly still lived there. This was a risk that they shouldn't take unnecessarily but they were forced into it having no other options. And foresight played a role as well i believe.
 
Originally posted by Mithlond
I believe you are refering to the film there spirit?
And it was Saruman that warned Gandalf that he knew what the dwarves awoke in Khaxad-dum, not Sauron.

But this thread is discussing the book, not the film. Saruman did not warn Gandalf in the book like he did in the film.


sorry. should have read the thread start properly. my mistake.
*goes red*.
 
Hmmm even Eomer makes a point about Aragorn's "Foresight"

When Aragorn leaves for the "Paths of the Dead" he tells Eomer "We will meet again though all the hosts of mordor stand between"

When they meet on the Feild of Pelennor Eomer and aragorn ahve exchange.

"Didnt I tell you We would meet thought all the host of Mordor stand between ?"

To which eomer replies "I knew not that you were gifted with foresight"
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top