Originally posted by Rhiannon
Not half as ridiculous as the Eowyn-bashing I'm forced to endure, thank-you. Funny how they shut up when I respond, though- and in such arguments I'm generally the only one backing myself up with the text.
I want to discuss feminism, but not in here...is there another thread, or does someone need to go start one? Arwen's passivity annoys me, and this is tied to my ideas about feminism, but I feel talking about that would pull this thread even more off-topic than it is already, because it goes in to gender roles and all of that. I kind of feel we need to move out of the book section and into S&B for this.
join me now...may all anti Arwen's unite?!!!
1.> she does nothing other then sit around and have "HOPE" that things work out!!!! if i was her, i'd be there fight along Aragorn's side.
2.>She is so forlorn, like really id be way happier then she is if i was a gazillion (exageration) yr's old and still looked that good
3.> Eowyn diserved aragorn WAY more but stupid arwen stood in her way!
i posted this in the book section because i felt this way about her when i read the books...but even in the movie i cant STAND her cause pj has taken her annoying hated qualities and multiplied them a gazillion times
My, these old threads keep popping up at the bottom of the page. I'm beginning to suspect there's some sort of Algorithm Troll at work, always trying to stir the pot; not to mention goad me into another necropost -- something I find as difficult to resist as the temptation of the Ring!
I'll surrender to temptation (again) to try to address the subject. Female characters in romance can have various roles, of course; one important one is to be the counterpart of "wise old man", the White Queen to his White King, to use a chess analogy. Their opposites, the Black King and Queen, are the Dark Magician and Evil Mother.
As the function of the senex is to set the action in motion, and then retreat to allow the protagonist to make his way, so hers is to watch over the action at a distance, as a benevolent mother-figure, sometimes in the role of sibyll, like Galadriel with her Mirror.
These female characters seem to be more connected to the natural cycle, especially the lunar cycle, than male characters, and often appear to open and close the "cycle" of the story. They can function at any level: on the mythical plane, for instance, we notice how Elbereth appears in the song sung by the first Elves Frodo encounters; she reappears in the episode that closes the story, as does her romance-mode counterpart, Galadriel.
Another form of this character is as a bride, a Solveig-figure, on whose behalf the quest is undertaken; she will normally be introduced at the beginning, then wait patiently for the hero's journey to be completed, when she will reappear to close the cycle.
Arwen is the most obvious character of this type, and whether you like her or not depends, I guess, on how willing you are to accept the convention.
Again, this figure can operate at any level. In the children's fairy tale of The Hobbit, for example, her role is taken by Bag End, the female attributes of which no one could miss. In fact, "she" combines the two aspects, appearing as mother at the beginning of the story, to which the rather infantile Bilbo is still attached by the symbolic umbilical cord of the pipe he sucks, and at the end, as the "bride" he saves from desecration by usurpers.
This is all very well in a children's story, but would seem out of place and disturbing, even somewhat perverse, in the far more adult world of LOTR; and in fact her role as bride-mother is almost immediately taken over, on the return to the Shire, by Rosie Cotton.
One problem in romance with making this figure the hero's potential or oath-sworn bride is that it severely limits his adventures with the other female characters he encounters on his quest, particularly the ones he rescues from "fates worse than death", who often seem to be tied naked to trees, for some reason.
One way of getting around this is shown by the 19th century wtiters whose work was influenced by romance. They commonly present two heroines, one dark, one light. The dark one, to use Northrope Frye's description, is "passionate, haughty ,plain, foreign, or Jewish, and in some way associated with the undesirable or with some kind of forbidden fruit like incest". When both are associated with the hero, the dark one must be gotten rid of, or converted into some other relationship, if the story is to end happily. Otherwise the story can become a tragedy, as it does in the tale of Turin, who chooses the dark one, who turns out to be his sister.
It is notable that Tolkien reverses this light/dark duality in Aragorn's story. The reason for this may have had to do with the fact that his wife was dark-haired, and as we know, he modelled Luthien, Arwen's forbear, on her. But in the context of the story, it was associated with redeeming the darkness and night.
I guess the significance of this breaking with long convention on the part of Tolkien is not as recognized as much as it should be. Which is not to say he was the first to do so: Dickens did it in David Copperfield, one of his most autobiographical novels. In that one, the light character dies.
In any event, Tolkien resolves the dilemma of the polarization of the "Lady of Duty" and the (at least potential) "Lady of Pleasure" by marrying off the latter. But it is notable that Aragorn has already repudiated her, refusing the temptation to break faith, though "temptation" is probably too strong a word. It is a resolution in the direction of the moral; a "Christian" resolution, you could say.
I could be both....CL, you're either a person of rarified and discerning judgment, or a glutton for punishment.
I'm not sure which.
But thanks for the compliment!
I agree with CL. I have really enjoyed the discussion on this forum of late, largely thanks to SES's posts (among others).
I hope I don't sound sexist or male chauvinistic here...
You misunderstand the nature of the Elves. The Elves are supposed to be stand-offish and secluded. They are the highest created beings. They were written to be mysterious, deep and old. The ways of man don't concern them to much anymore. Arwen is that 'put on a pedastal' type of woman. The whole point of Aragorn's quest to fulfill his destiny as king is to 'earn' Arwen. The fact is, is that Aragorn doesn't deserve Arwen. The Elves are far above any man. Arwen not involving herself is what makes her all the more desirable to a mortal man.
Eowyn is 'every woman'. She's mortal and more like Aragorn, no doubt. But she is not Elven and does not have the kinship that Aragorn has with the Elves. Aragorn and Arwen's love is a deep love, not a surface crush.
By involving Arwen in everything like PJ did, he made Arwen as 'every woman', rather than the 'unreachable prize'.
Sheesh, that really sounds piggish doesn't it?
Welcome to the Forum, St0rmb0rn!
Why I 'don't' hate Arwen:
She is the evenstar of the Edain, most beautiful but for Luthien, the morning star. The tale as told in Lord of the Rings and Appendix B is so heartwarming even as it is sad.
The PJ fanfic movies didn't do Arwen justice by casting Liv Tyler and bloating out the tale so much.
And being part of many a forum through the first two decades of this century, I have to say this one is showing the most activity.
well really i cant see what makes elves so great cause realy isnt everyone equal? and besides that how can pointy ers be attractive?
now Eowyn...aragorn doesnt deserve her, man should desire an independent women who will fight for what she believes in and is strong and will ful.
but i guess tolkien didnt agree with me there/
Wow... that really shines a whole other wavelength of light on The Scouring of the Shire for me in Lord or the Rings.Again, this figure can operate at any level. In the children's fairy tale of The Hobbit, for example, her role is taken by Bag End, the female attributes of which no one could miss. In fact, "she" combines the two aspects, appearing as mother at the beginning of the story, to which the rather infantile Bilbo is still attached by the symbolic umbilical cord of the pipe he sucks, and at the end, as the "bride" he saves from desecration by usurpers.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?